News Sections
Tories introduce Tax-Free Savings Account
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(62)
Philip Stavrou, CTV.ca News
Date: Tue. Feb. 26 2008 4:58 PM ET
OTTAWA Canadians are being encouraged to save for life's big events, not just retirement, with the introduction of the Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) in the 2008 Budget.
Starting in 2009, Canadians aged 18 and older can contribute up to $5,000 annually (from their taxable income) to a TFSA.
The investment income, including capital gains, earned in a TFSA will not be taxed -- even when withdrawn.
The plan also allows an investor to withdraw funds from the TFSA at any time and for any purpose.
The withdrawal amount can then be put back at a later date without reducing contribution room.
Additionally, if an investor puts less than $5,000 into a TFSA in a given year, the unused room can be carried forward to future years.
"It's the first account of its kind in Canadian history," Finance Minister Jim Flaherty said in his 2008 Budget Speech.
Don Scott, a tax partner at Welch LLP, told CTV.ca that the TFSA will benefit lower and middle-income taxpayers that are looking for a way to save money.
"You can use the plan to save for a special purpose -- a down payment on a house or to buy a car," said Scott. "It provides an incentive to put money away for that purpose (and) you get the tax break of not having to pay tax on the income that's earned on it while you're saving."
As an example, an individual contributing $200 a month to a TFSA for 20 years, at a 5.5 per cent rate of return, will earn about $11,045 more in savings than if the investment had been made in a taxable savings vehicle (unregistered account).
Seniors will also benefit because they will be able save funds once their age restricts them from contributing to an RRSP, said Scott.
Income or capital gains earned in a TFSA will also not affect eligibility for federal income-tested benefits such as the Guaranteed Income Supplement for low income seniors. The same applies to withdrawals from a TFSA account.
For example, a modest or low-income retired couple, earning $2,000 a year in interest income on an unregistered basis, would see their GIS benefits reduced by $1,000.
If the interest was being earned in a TFSA account, there would be no reduction to their GIS.
Based on current savings patterns, seniors are expected to receive one-half of the total benefits provided by the TFSA, says the 2008 Budget.
The budget estimates that the introduction of TFSAs will reduce federal revenues by $5 million in 2008-09 and $50 million in 2009-10. By 2012-13, the estimated tax savings from TFSAs will be $385 million.
Over the next 20 years, the annual tax savings is estimated to grow to over $3 billion annually.
However, the new account may draw people away from contributing to an RRSP, said Scott.
"It might for the lower and middle-income earner that's wanted to save some money... with the concern that when they took the money out they might pay more tax then the savings they got when they put it in."
Overall, because of the nature of the new plan there will most likely be a better encouragement to put savings away instead of spending it.
"Will savings reduce? Probably not," said Scott. "It's now just a question of which type of plan are you putting your money into."
How the Tax-Free Savings Account Will Work
- Starting in 2009, Canadian residents age 18 or older will be eligible to contribute up to $5,000 annually to a TFSA, with unused room being carried forward.
- Contributions will not be deductible.
- Capital gains and other investment income earned in a TFSA will not be taxed.
- Withdrawals will be tax-free.
- Neither income earned within a TFSA nor withdrawals from it will affect eligibility for federal income-tested benefits and credits.
- Withdrawals will create contribution room for future savings.
- Contributions to a spouse's or common-law partner's TFSA will be allowed, and TFSA assets will be transferable to the TFSA of a spouse or common-law partner upon death.
- Qualified investments include all arm's-length Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) qualified investments.
- The $5,000 annual contribution limit will be indexed to inflation in $500 increments.
(Source: 2008 Budget)
User Tools
Related Stories
Related Websites
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(62)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
The chance of the destruction of our planet is very very small with this collider, but who are these people to decide what risks are acceptable for all of mankind? It puts me at unease and adds to my anxiety. CERN acknowledges that there are miniscule risks -- they admit to it so please spare the convoluted retorts.

Comments are now closed for this story
Kim
said
Dave, Ottawa
said
Kelly
said
As the lower income earner I would rather save my money this way than RRSPs.
Alan Browe
said
JP
said
Mark
said
Paul
said
I wonder, though, if the provinces will want to tax it like ordinary income.
Still, half a loaf is better than none.
Cal in Ottawa
said
Michael
said
Paul
said
Krista
said
Rich
said
Chuck
said
I like this idea, though I doubt many could reach the $5000 limit. Anyhow...its much smarter than a stupid GST cut.
Angela
said
So this TFSA could be ANY account so your interest will vary.
I don't think this means that it has to be a traditional savings account earning 4% or whatever.
Gord Smith
said
Sue
said
Just lower the income tax rate! Keep it simple!
Jen
said
This is great - I love that withdrawing frees up more contribution space!
D-
said
Kim, the savings are better on this than just increasing your basic tax-free income amount because not only is the $5000 tax-free but also all money that you make on the investments in your account. That is HUGE because it allows you to grow funds in your account without being taxed annually, so you're basically compounding and making a lot more long-term than you would by having $5000 more basic tax-free income.
Mark
said
With this new account, saving for a mortgage will be a much more feasible option. Especially since I already have to contribute to RRSP's to lower my taxes...
I should be able to put away 3k/year and as my income goes up I will be able to use more of what I didn't use. How is that a bad thing?
kriss
said
Geoffrey
said
John
said
you put into an RRSP , depending what Tax bracket you fall under, you get a substantial refund to do with what you want. If you put $2000 dollars in this year and you make $30,000a year then you will get a $500-$600. refund. On $5000.it would be around$1400.
This doesn't happen with this new PLan but it's a good plan though. I like it
Tax Ponderer
said
Denise
said
Roger
said
JF
said
bshelt
said
Gordon Hughes CFP
said
Jim O'Brien
said
Stop manking excuses and start saving even a little.
Bernard Romanycia
said
Is everyone happy? I don't think so.
Gary
said
Peter
said
calvin
said
Withdrawing frees up contribution space - Is this dollar for dollar? What if I but a stock and get a huge return in one year. What if I buy $5,000 of something and next year it's worth $20,000. If I take it all out, do I now have $20,000 of contribution room?
Chuck made a comment about why would anyone ever use an RRSP now. These accounts are totally different, I think most people would still benefit from an RRSP. If you're earning a decent income and are in a fairly high tax bracket, the RRSP contribution gives a tax deduction. The after tax account has no associated deduction. Also, at $5,000 the limit is much lower than the RRSP limit. I think for those who have the means, it would be beneficial to maximize contributions to both savings vehicles.
My 2 cents anyway... Cheers!
D-
said
Why are people complaining that this isn't as good as getting a tax deferral. It's better than a tax deferral, you never pay the tax in the first place and you don't pay it upon withdrawal either. In many ways it's better than an RRSP, assuming people actually start to learn how to stop living above their means and start doing some good, old fashioned saving.
I'm not a fan of the tories in any way, by the way, but I'm loving this idea. And I'm not rich, I'm a poor 20-something student who happens to work in the financial industry.
Calvin Broady
said
People saying they can't afford to save... well that's just foolishness. The government offers new programs like this to help citizens save effectively. If you can't do it, that's a personal issue, and perhaps a course in creating a basic personal budget would help, which has nothing to do the mechanics of an RRSP or TFSA. This kind of statement seems to be deeply rooted in the 1960's type logic - get a job and work hard and at the end of the day, the employer/the government/the union will take care of you. That's not the case anymore. Canadians need to take charge of their own finances. The government offers programs (like this new one) to encourage exactly that. So what are you waiting for??
D-
said
Kelly
said
Trent
said
William
said
FB
Kim
said
Rob
said
Narin
said
Why should be have to put back the withdrew money? Or we don't have to put it back?
Calvin
said
Bob
said
hjo
said
i like that plan. so simple and rewarding for me.
nice easter egg.
thanks' cons.gouvernement.
George D. - Toronto
said
adam
said
"Contributions will not be deductible".
That means the money you put in is not deducted from your income as an rrsp contribution is. This account can not be used to lower your income for the purposes of getting a bigger income tax refund. Therefore, it only makes sense to contribute if you have already contributed the maximum to your rrsp.
Calvin and D-, that's why people are saying it's only beneficial to the wealthy.
Jac
said
Nick
said
Carol
said
TECH
said
If you are DISCIPLINED, the TFSA can become your main income! It all depends on you. Good luck!
Dave in Surrey
said
This really only helps those who have no more room on their RRSP and are saving money for retirement... The odds of any account making you 10% is slim, so basically you will be lucky to get $500 a year that is not tax deductable... This will die off in the near future once people start doing tax returns and their accountants eat up most of the money through processing fees... The average Canadian will never use this... Just fluff adding more buracracy to the picture...
Dan
said
skatepro
said
For a single person on a moderate (30-40k) income the measly 18% RRSP limit is rapidly reached.
I was hoping they would just put a flat $20,000 ceiling on the RRSP - no such luck.
But over the long haul protecting the interest from 5000 a year is a big help. Even if you only made 4% a year, you would come out 33k ahead after 25 years !
K.K.
said
Darla
said
Good idea bad timing I think. Good for seniors though and I am getting there soon!
Peter
said
Craig, Edmonton
said
Livign in Saskatchewan
said
I see that capital gains would be tax free etc so that looks like stock portfolios which is great for the upper and rich class as they can afford stocks. Some middle class people might be able to benefit from this, but for lower middle class families it's still going to be harder to scrounge up savings that will earn capital gains etc.
I work in a financial institution and understand that people like having income tax free including myself, but from what I can understand from this account is to help more so for the rich more, if you look at it lower income classes is not likely to invest in higher risk investments that are going to possibly have very big fluctuations in the principle amount so on a 5000 investment that lets say is in one of the banks high interest savings account if that qualifies so the interest rate would be about 3 - 4 %, that's a 200 savings on interest in a year. 200 divided by 12 is only $16.67/month. TELL ME HOW IS THAT HELPING THE LOWER CLASS and some LOWER MIDDLE CLASS FAMILY? Can anyone see how this might be skewed for the higher income class family? If anyone the lower middle class is going to be fooled by this then let this be a warning, it's a way to make the richer richer, and the poorer to stay where they are at.
Need further proof? $5000 of investments bought in shares that is $50.00/share, which works out to 100 shares, the share value grows to $60.00 so now the investment is worth $6000.00 an extra 1000.00 more if they sold it that income is tax free. better than 200 right? So case in point the upper middle and rich class would get this tax free if I understand this correct therefore they would get richer. Tell me how that is fair.
I am more apt to agree to cut income taxes more so towards the lower income class to the middle class as I would see that benefitting more people in the long run.
Also for those who are afraid of RSP's this is for down the road to retirement, even if it is in a lower investment earning account, your investments still grow tax free, you get the benefits at tax time. I encourage to have both non registerd savings for emergencies, and registered for your retirement planning, but this new account. I just can't see the benefits to the majority of people unless someone can point it out otherwhise.
Andrew
said
Craig, Alberta
said
If at retirement, your RRSP account was valued at $500K you now are FORCED to pull money out and pay taxes on EVERY dollar you pull out. On the other hand, if your savings had grown to $300k in your Savings Plan, you would actually have MORE CASH IN HAND because every dollar you withdraw is TAX FREE. Plus, you have the option of pulling it out whenever you want/need, and replacing it (unlike RRSPs).
Hopefully that simplifies it and helps you see that you are better off maxing out this Savings Plan FIRST, then move on to your RRSPs. This is a fantastic program.
Priscilla Laudon
said