News Sections
Chretien: Canada in tough spot over Kosovo
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(62)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Fri. Feb. 22 2008 11:18 PM ET
Never at a loss for words, former prime minister Jean Chretien says that Canada is in a "delicate" spot over the decision whether to recognize Kosovo's declaration of independence.
"Canada has to be careful because people want to separate from Canada," Chretien told reporters from Ottawa's Rideau Hall on Friday.
He said because of Canada's Clarity Act, which sets rules for legal separation from the country, the government should be careful of setting a dangerous precedent by recognizing Kosovo's unilateral separation from Serbia.
The U.S., U.K., Germany and France are among more than a dozen nations that have recognized Kosovo's independence. Canada has not yet taken a position.
Chretien noted that both the U.K. and France have their own problems with segments of their populations wishing to separate. Scotland and Wales in the U.K. have long had separatist parties and France has had issues with its Mediterranean island of Corsica.
"But I'm not the one who decides for the government," Chretien said. "I'm not the Monday morning quarterback."
Chretien was made a companion of The Order of Canada Friday in Ottawa and spoke about Kosovo when prompted by reporters.
On Friday, Liberal Leader Stephane Dion said it would be preferable that Canada join its European allies and recognize Kosovo.
A pair of former ambassadors agreed with Chretien that Canada should move cautiously.
James Bissett, Canada's former Ambassador to Yugoslavia, told CTV Newsnet's Mike Duffy Live Friday evening that he is concerned that Kosovo declared independence unilaterally and without a referendum.
Paul Heinbecker, a former Canadian Ambassador to the United Nations, noted, however, that the situation in Kosovo is very different from issues in Canada about Quebec.
"There has been -- between the Kosovars and the Serbs -- a lot of trouble," Heinbecker said.
"There was a war in 1999. NATO had to intervene to stop it. By the time NATO started, (the Serbs) had expelled nearly 500,000 people from their homes in Kosovo. In Canada, we haven't had a shot fired between the French and the English for about 200 years."
Many analysts have said Serbs engaged in ethnic cleansing and discrimination against minority populations in the former Yugoslavia. But Heinbecker pointed out that Canada is a strong state that has had many protections for minorities. He said Canada has historically welcomed full participation of Quebecers into the national life.
He added that Quebecers have held the Prime Minister's Office for significant periods, and they are at the top levels of the military, government, and other public offices.
The Serbian ambassador to Canada, Dusan Batakovic, told CTV Newsnet that he agreed with Chretien's comments, especially when the former Liberal prime minister said that it's hard to judge the escalating situation in Serbia without being there.
"Of course, Serbs remain defiant," Batakovic said of the recent outburst of violence in the capital of Belgrade. "(But) it's regrettable . . . an emotional outburst is obviously wrong."
Many Serbians see Kosovo as the ancient cradle of their state and religion.
Batakovic also expressed concern for the ethnic Serbians in Kosovo and added that Serbia would try to block any attempt by Kosovo to join the United Nations.
Kosovo is 90 per cent populated by ethnic Albanians. It has not been under Belgrade's control since 1999, when air strikes were launched by NATO to put an end to a Serbian crackdown on separatists.
Since then Kosovo has been governed by a United Nations mission.
User Tools
Related Stories
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(62)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I applaud the budget, even though Health Care and education may stay unscathed. Sadly this cannot last and I worry to later this year where cuts will become enviable. If anything, this provides the Wildrose Alliance plenty of ammo when an election is called.


Comments are now closed for this story
BOBT
said
John S.
said
Until the Separatist Movement is crushed in Quebec, the best the Prime Minister should do is we cannot recognize Kosovo due to doing so would ignite separatism back home
jill-ny
said
Mike - Toronto
said
FreakAlert
said
kathy
said
Eric
said
Louise Fribance
said
Gary
said
Dave out west
said
C
said
As for Quebec, if they choose to separate, then that is their decision alone to make. I wouldn't want them to stay a part of Canada if they truly don't want to be here.
Doug
said
With that in mind,I find it surprising when I look at the list of countries jumping in to recognize Kosovo.I have to assume they either know a lot of things we don't,or have just as much trouble finding good government as we do here.
Gerald Skowronski
said
Vancouver
said
ex-Canadian
said
rob
said
nathan
said
Michael Le Couteur MSCD, ret'd
said
Peter
said
D in Calgary
said
Nothing could be better for Alberta than to separate from Canada.
The west has been ignored for too long by Ottawa, and now even though Mr. Harper is the PM, The resentment towards Ottawa is just to deep. Just take a look at the Tranfer payments Ottawa gets in a year from Alberta, compare that to the east?? How much does Quebec pay? Nothing,at all. All because their french.
Ottawa would never let Alberta leave because Quebecs piggy bank would be gone
Linda
said
PC's were banished,NDP remains a joke,at best,and Reform were to close to the radical right.It has to be easy to win elections if all the opposition is so badly fractured.
And he takes way to much credit for balanced budgets.He really need to acknowledge Preston Manning and a host of others for pushing the issue.And the Free trade and GST deals that gave him the money to do it.
Really.I guess honesty in politics is to much to expect.I don't like Harper or Dion,but I'm sure glad Cretien is out of there.Even if he makes a good point on this issue.
I doubt there is any decision Harper can make here that would be approved by everyone.
ROCK--Harper--HARD PLACE
Dan
said
There are several major differences between Kosovo and Quebec:
1) Canada has never tried to exterminate French-speaking population in Quebec, while Serbia has been trying since the WWII. In the years after the WWII, special partisan units were formed for killing Albanian children in Kosovo, to fight Albanian high natality. In sixties and seventies, water wells in Albanian villages were poisoned with anti-fertility drugs for the same reason. Not to mention that Albanians were never allowed to learn Albanian language and culture in schools.
2) 92% of Kosovo population are Albanians. Quebec is not even close.
3) Unlike Serbs, Canadians are a peaceful nation and their culture is based on tolerance and multiculturalism. Check out B92 videos on YouTube and you will see that violence is deeply rooted in Serbian culture. No wonder no one in ex-Yugoslavia wanted to live with Serbs in the same country.
Chretien, your statement reflects either cowardice or ignorance!
Greg from Kitchener
said
Sophie, Ottawa
said
I am actually wondering if there is such a position as ''neutral''.
RS
said
Canada should recognize independence of Kosovo without delay, and join other western democracies that have done so.
Javid Radfar
said
What Jean Chretien did for this country includes eliminating the deficit, which was left for us by dear Conservatives. He also brought down the national debt, which was the second highest among G7. Furthermore, he made the Clarity Bill, so the separatist cannot have their "way" on a possible referendum. Jean Chretien is one of the greatest prime ministers this country has ever had and I am proud of his accomplishments.
PB
said
As for the difference in population - that's easy. Albanians have a MUCH higher birth rate than Serbs, which is why the population has shifted from the Serbs being in the majority in 1912, to them being a minority now.
Dave out west - Good point, but the reason this can't happen is tied into the REAL reason NATO invaded Serbia in the first place - it's vast mineral wealth. In the north of the country they estimate there is 15 BILLION tons of lignite, 15 BILLION tons of cobalt (which is great for the aerospace industry) and 20 BILLION tons of lead and zinc.
The great prize is the lignite/coal. With increasing industrialisation on a global scale, everyone is grabbing resources, hence the US invasion of Iraq for it's oil (which is why it never had a reconstruction plan - it never intended to leave), and then the invasion of Serbia for it's coal supplies and gas (newly discovered in southern Kosovo - TRILLIONS of cubic metres of gas).
Most of the mineral wealth is smack bang under Mitrovica, the Serb dominated part of Kosovo. This is why the US and EU are happy to recognise Kosovo, yet won't allow partition of the province - it would defy the whole reason for invading inthe first place if the Serbs still retain control of 75+ % of the mineral wealth !!!
Vancouver- you should stop talking a load of bull and tell the world what really happened, i.e the fact that the UK, US and German secret services trained and equipped the KLA to start a war of insurgency in the first place. They wanted Milosevic to respond so that they had the pretext to intervene. If any ethnic group has blood on it's hands, it's the Albanians. You conveniently forget you NAZI sympathies in WWII with your special albanian units, e.g SS Skanderberg.
Dino M
said
Bob
said
You are absolutley correct when you say,"the PQ is hoping that we foolishly join the US and EU and recognize Kosovo, so that they can use this as an excuse to continue their agenda to destroy Canada."
Check out the PQ's website where they are congratulting Kosovo:
http://www.pq.org/?menu=5&q=node/1617
AD
said
Valorie
said
Matt
said
I think the only way to split a country is by mutual agreement. Civil war is simply terrorism by those who aren't willing to accept the actions of their government.
As for Quebec and Alberta, they are both part of Canada, and I will not accept any unilateral declaration of independence.
Marijana
said
Flori Kooli
said
If we get the decision of Suprime court of Canada about Quebec Separation you will see that it applies 100% to Kosovo and gives Kosovo the right to secede. This is in the paragraph where it is written that only peoples that are suppressed and colonialsed has the rifght to secede. This is the case of Kosovo.
All what you are doing is much ado about nothing. Secesion of Kosovo is in total agreement with the Supreme Court Decision of Canada in legal terms.
John S.
said
And the Supreme Court ruled that Quebec separating is unconstitutional. Thus, the Clarity Act we see today.
Jerome
said
john lee
said
Mike
said
In case you dont know what it is, find out!
By breaking the International Law, the only law which will remain will be the law of brute force to protect Serbia's territorial integrity.
Why's is the only 10% Serbes currently living in Kosovo. It is because they have been cleansed by the Albanians for decades.
Bettina
said
Ed Lenarcic
said
Bobby
said
Milos
said
1) Canada has never tried to exterminate French-speaking population in Quebec, while Serbia has been trying since the WWII.
2) 92% of Kosovo population are Albanians. Quebec is not even close.
3) Unlike Serbs, Canadians are a peaceful nation and their culture is based on tolerance and multiculturalism.
Chretien, your statement reflects either cowardice or ignorance!..."
----------------------
Dear Dan, ignorance is a lousy thing, but a deliberate and constant lying,as you are, is more dangereous.
1. 300,000 Serbs were progrssively trough 1945-2008 expelled (cleansed) from its own land in KosovO. Kosova is an invented word, stolen from the Serbian word KosovO (land of blackbird). In fact the only nation that felt genicde were Serbs: Nazis, Austro-Hungarians, Albanians, Croatians, Muslims (Bosnia), 1914, 1945, 1991, 1995, 2004, 2008.
2. Quebec is populated with about 85% Francophones, read statistics.
3. Serbs are very friendly and peace-loving people, but react with a determination when attacked or when a justice hasn't been done, either to them or to somebody else. We love freedom and our land, and we will not exchange them for anything in the world. In Serbia live more than 60 different nations, and Belgrade was always known as a multicultural city. Serbs were allies to US, UK, France and all other progressive peace-loving nations, whereas Albania and Shiptars were always on agressors' side: Nazi side torturing and killing not only Serbs, but Albanians who were thinking differently
4. Mr. Chretien is very right. A wise nation should find truth for itself by consulting all nencessary resources possible. And, trust me, they will find it sooner or later.
Bernard Romanycia
said
ron
said
there was never ever any kind of suppresion crimes killings and mass expulsion done on Quebec people by any Canadian government.
There were a few referendums done in Quebec for independence were they voted to stay within Canada etc etc.
This is why Quebec and Kosova are two very different things. Please people understand this once and for all. I guess our politicians have to understand this too.
C
said
Dardane Shushka
said
Canadian Goverment has not slaughtered/massacred thousands of civilians and displaced and looted houses of million people like serbian Government did.Do not we forget thet Serbia started the war in former Yougoslavia, fist in Slovenia killing a number of people, subsequently started the war in Croatia and massacred thousands of civilians, then in Bosnia and massacred hundreds of thousands(remember Srebrenica) and then in KOsovo and slaughtered thousands of unprotected civilians and destroyed entire province.Albanians are happy today not because they got their occupied teritory back but more that they will not fear Serbian fashism in their own house. (or pretend not to know) the truth and tragedy about Balkans.
Ustasa
said
You think anybody can feel sorry for Serbs for your comment of "200000 serbs were kicked out of Croatia." Stop believing your own propaganda. It is a lie. What has Serbia done to Croatians, Slovenians, Bosnias, Albanians since god know when? Typical? Nobody feels sorry for Serbia as this has been brought upon themselves. All these countries have left because of Serbian oppresion and war crimes. Now everyone can see Serbia show their true colours. As for "Mr." Chretien. Zip it. Noone cares about your opinion.
Cufi
said
Read the HIstory of ILLYRIANS and their DARDANIAN TRIBE and then http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Illyrian_tribes
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dardanii
read the history of SLAVS.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serbs
freedom lover
said
Recognizing the rogue state of "Kosovo" will open up a can of worms Canada should avoid.
Neil
said
"Quebec and the french, along with the english, founded Canada. 2 different scenarios"
No Peter, Canada was already founded; the english and french migrated here and done just that, made it their own country.
So if the mexican migration leads to a majority in a US state and are mistreated by the US and decide to seperate, GREAT!!!
Pavel
said
When the federal government tried to crack down on terrorists, they had no choice but to move away a few families living along the border with Albania to prevent entrance and exit of bandits.
The rest is a fairy tale written by Americans who want to plant a Muslim terrorist country in the centre of Europe to destabilize their main economic competitor. The competitor itself has something on its mind -- like Germany that dreams about returning territories that were taken away after the WWII.
Just wait, Canada. If a hot francophone head starts killing federal servants in Quebec, the Kosovo scenario will be repeated exactly.
Josh
said
Roger Mills
said
Nate
said
mac
said
So, Quebec separatists have to commit lots of violence before the cause of separation can be condoned.
Well, that's the consequence of some your mindless maundering.
Dan
said
> 1. 300,000 Serbs were progrssively trough 1945-2008 expelled
> (cleansed)...
Yeah, sure... How come that Serbs fought a war with almost every other
nation in ex-Yugoslavia? Bosnians voluntary killed themselves in
Srebrenica? The problem with you guys is that you are always blaming
someone else for your atrocities and their consequences..
> 2. Quebec is populated with about 85% Francophones, read statistics.
Heh, less than 50% of people voted for independence of Quebec. Seems
like every single Albanian (92%) wants to part away from Serbia.
> 3. Serbs are very friendly and peace-loving people,
Sure... :) How come that Serbs fought a war with almost every single
nation in ex-Yugoslavia. This reminds me of a problematic kid in
elementary school, he would get in fights with other kids and always
blamed others.
Kevin - Calgary
said
Bob H
said
Tom M.
said
John
said
Quebec has the right to self-determination, Kosovo does not as stipulated in article 1244 of the UN Resolution which realigns Serbia's territorial integrity. Put differently, unless a new resolution is reached, the partition of Serbia is illegal under international law. Knowing this, Kosovo will never be allowed to be a member of the UN.
This will give precedent to instability. Regions are already bent on self-determination since Kosovo has separated: the Basque region of Spain, the Serbian part of Bosnia (Republic of Srpska), the Croatian part of Bosnia and Herzegovina, the Turkish part of Cypress, Chechnya, parts of Georgia.. etc. The list is endless.
The war in Kosovo is over, much the same as the war in Bosnia and Herzegovina is over. Looking at present statistics 100,000 people (both civilians and soldiers) were killed in Bosnia and Herzegovina. It was plunged through 4 years of bloody civil war (ethnic cleansing, genocide etc..). Presently, Bosnia and Herzegovina is one country with 2 entitities(a Bosniak-Croat Federation and the Republic of Srpska). Why doesn't the West look at Bosnia as an example? They were so vehemently opposed to the partition of Bosnia, but for Kosovo they do demand independence. Why the double-standard?
Richard S
said
Eric
said
Canada is way too late already in recognizing Kosovo as an independent state.