CTV News | Girl's writings opening new window on autism

Health -   

Girl's writings opening new window on autism

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Chief Anchor and Senior Editor Lloyd Robertson with the remarkable story of a 13-year-old named Carly
CTV News Extended: Avis Favaro on the autism milestone
CTV News Extended: Arthur Fleischmann, Carly's father

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(8)

Angela Mulholland, CTV.ca News

Date: Sun. Feb. 17 2008 10:12 PM ET

TORONTO — A 13-year-old named Carly is challenging the conventional notions of autism, demonstrating emotional skills that lay hidden for years, until one day, a computer helped her reveal to the world what it's like to have her condition.

From an early age, it was clear Carly had autism. As a young girl, she would often rock back and forth for minutes on end, flail her arms and hit herself repeatedly. Equally troubling, she never gained the ability to speak.

Her father, Arthur Fleishmann, says many people who didn't know her assumed she was intellectually challenged.

"Even professionals labelled her as moderately to severely cognitively impaired. In the old days you would way mentally retarded, which means low IQ and low promise and low potential," he says.

Arthur and Carly's mother Tammy were advised to place her in an institution. Instead, they opted for a therapy called ABA -- Applied Behaviour Analysis, the kind of therapy now recommended for kids with autism but because of the expense and the need for specially trained therapists, isn't available to all children.

While Carly made progress through the therapy, speech continued to elude her.

"We tried hard to get her to talk but it wasn't in the cards for Carly," says her speech pathologist Barbara Nash-Fenton.

Then, two years ago, Carly surprised everyone. Working with a computer equipped with pictures and symbols, she started typing and spelling words. At first it was just words -- help, hurt, head, teeth -- but soon she was assembling sentences.

She typed slowly, using only one finger, and the words she wrote stunned all who knew her.

"All of a sudden these words started to pour out of her," says Nash-Fenton. "And it was an exciting moment because we didn't realize she had all these words."

"It was one of those moments in my career that I'll never forget."

Writing reveals secrets of autism

As Carly learned to write better, she began describing what it was like to have autism and why she does what she does, such as making odd noises and hitting herself.

"It feels like my legs are on fire and a million ants are crawling up my arms," Carly has written about the urge to hit herself.

"I want to be like Taryn," she has written of her twin sister, who does not have autism.

With her single typing finger, Carly has been able to demonstrate her emotional intelligence and witty sense of humour to a family who says they were stunned by what she revealed.

"We realized that inside was an articulate, intelligent, emotive person that we had never met. She was 10 at the time, and we just met her for the first time at 10 or 11 years old," says her father Arthur. "This was unbelievable because it opened up a whole new way of looking at her."

Through her writings, Carly has joked about her "yucky" siblings, shown that she understands their jokes and revealed a curiosity about boys -- even asking when can she go on a date.

"Inside, she is a perfectly normal 13-year-old girl. She has crushes, she likes music, she wants to be treated like every other 13-year-old," says her father.

Carly also has expressed her frustration about her condition and about how the world misunderstands her.

"It is hard to be autistic because no one understands me," she writes. "People look at me and assume I am dumb because I can't talk, or I act differently than them... I think people get scared with things that look or seem different than them. It feels hard. It feels like being in a room with the stereo on full blast."

Autism specialist Dr. Wendy Roberts has read some of Carly's writing and watched her on video. She says Carly is certainly unique in her abilities and provides some fascinating insights into the condition of autism.

"I think the initial reaction is that it is incredibly remarkable," she says. "It is amazing to think that somebody who has not been able to put her thoughts into words now has a mechanism to get some of her ideas across."

Roberts says it's unclear whether Carly's unusual language abilities makes her a rare case or whether her new writing skills are the result of her intensive training.

She says it's rare for someone with autism to have apraxia -- the inability to speak despite an understanding of language -- as well as such an obvious command of written words. Roberts says it may be that Carly possesses unique abilities that make her a rare case, or it may be that her early and intensive training simply drew the skills out.

"What she does is quite uncommon but there hasn't been a really good look at kids with severe apraxia to see what could they be taught with intense teaching," says Roberts. "And that really begs the question of are we giving children enough intensive intervention to see if we are missing a fairly small percentage of kids who have this ability. There may be children being missed because they have not had access to therapy."

"From a broader perspective it puts pressure on us to develop interventions that will allow written language to develop... so that we can develop more effective interventions."

The benefits of ABA therapy

Carly's parents say they are so grateful that their daughter was able to discover this way to communicate because it has made them rethink autism and made them realize that they made the right decision to provide Carly with intensive therapy.

"If we had done what so many people told us to do years ago, we wouldn't have the child we have today. We would have written her off," says her father Arthur. "Then what would she be today?"

"We never would have seen she could write these things. Can you imagine? We would have never have gotten out of her how articulate she is how intelligent she is," he says. "Now, she tells us stories, she teases her brother. She just does it in a different way, she does it with her computer."

Carly's writing has progressed so far in the last two years, she's now starting to write a book. It's a take-off on herself and she's already come up with the title: "Elephant Princess."

Her writing has also helped her therapists help her more effectively.

"We've actually learned a lot about Carly," says her therapist Howard. "Since she has been able to type she has been telling us how it feels to be in her skin -- like ants are crawling up her arm. For us, this is very important. It helps with how we treat Carly, even how doctors treat Carly.

"I think Carly has a lot to teach us."

Carly has said she would like to tell the world about what it's like to have autism, so that others can understand what it's like.

"Autism is hard because you want to act one way but you can't always do that," she has written.

"It's sad that sometimes people don't know that sometimes I can't stop myself and they get mad at me. If I could tell people one thing about autism it would me that I don't want to be this way but I am. So don't be mad. Be understanding."

  • Read some of Carly's words.

From a report by CTV medical specialist Avis Favaro and producer Elizabeth St. Philip

CTV.ca readers with questions for Carly can send them to health@ctv.ca. She will do her best to respond later this week to some of them and we will post her comments.

Comments are now closed for this story

Patricia O'Brien
said

Fantastic story - she should have a column to write about anything and everything on your website. It would be an inspiration to everyone!


Gary
said

Just an abolutely amazing and beautifull story..Other then that I am at a loss for words.


mamie clary
said

I am a teacher to an 11 year old autistic student. His strongest reinforcer is the computer and is exellent at manipulating it. We have tried to teach him to type. Can Carley tell us what it took for her to learn. Is there an ABA guide or other source that may help me to structure typing lessons.
Thanks


Karen
said

The world could learn so much from Carly. It's great that a computer has given her a voice. I hope everyone stands up and takes notice. Her insights could help thousands of autistic children.


Glenn Emberley
said

This story holds great promise for future advances in therapy development for all those affected by autism.
However, judging from the number of comments posted here, it appears that most readers are not interested, and that is sad.


cathie
said

My daughter has autism and she is 22. I have know she knows and understand far more than she can communicate to the world. We need to stop listening to all the so called experts that simply did not exist when my child was even ten years old.

Take the time to get to know autism. Take the time Ontario to offer therapy in any form. My child had it in the US before we moved to Canada.

Therapy in school, free by the govt is great and it worked for us in the US. I hope to see it in all school for all special ed students in all of Canada.


George Frink
said

This is a story of surpassing triumph which is being celebrated in the U.S. as well as Canada. I applaud the remarkable young woman, her loving parents and her skilled therapists.


Kathy Deschenes
said

Carly is an inspiration to so many other children living with autism. Her parents are an inspiration to so many other parents of children with autism, hoping to tap into their child's potential. Together, they are an amazing example of the ability to rise above a disability!

Thank you Carly for sharing your thoughts. I am sure that you have enhanced the understanding of autism for those touched by it and those who are not affected. Thank you Tammy and Arthur for your unconditional love to an obviously very special young lady!

"While we try to teach our children all about life, our children teach us what life is all about."



Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest
Carly, uses a computer to communicate with her family, a rarity amongst those suffering from autism.

Carly's Writing

Read what a 13-year-old girl with autism has to say. 'I recently learned that dreams can come true.'

Vaccines

Autism Debate

Angela Mulholland explores the lasting controversy over whether vaccines cause autism.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz

Most Talked about Stories

This is a moral test for voters in the municipal election. Electing him will be a stamp of approval for his actions. I strongly believe that the first thoughts should be for the person he has publicly humiliated, his partner. By his conduct he has made of himself, merely, a footnote in the election.

Allan McLay

Giambrone drops out of T.O. mayor race, post scandal