News Sections
'Conspiracy of silence' on tarsands, group says
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(27)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Fri. Feb. 15 2008 9:14 PM ET
A new report accuses the federal government of allowing Alberta's tarsands to become "the most destructive project on earth".
The study was commissioned by Environmental Defence, a health organization, and features satellite imagery of the vast project.
Alberta's tarsands are second only to Saudi Arabia as the world's largest oil reserve.
"The enormous toxics problems go hand-in-hand with massive global warming pollution and the impending destruction of a boreal forest the size of Florida," the report says in its introduction.
Group spokesperson Matt Price blames Ottawa for failing to enforce federal environmental laws.
"I think there's sort of a conspiracy of silence, especially on the part of the federal government, with regards to the tar sands," Price said, "because there's an agenda to expand it dramatically over the next 10 to 15 years."
The report says the federal government needs to address environmental concerns ranging from greenhouse gases and cancer levels, to polluted water.
It also estimates that greenhouse gas emissions from the tarsands are likely to grow enough by 2020 to completely offset Ontario's planned emissions cuts.
Effects the report says are already being noticed:
- Toxic pollution from the tarsands has created what amounts to a slow motion oil spill in the region's river systems, and could be worse than the Exxon Valdez oil spill.
- First Nations living downstream are already seeing deformed pickerel and walleye in Lake Athabasca.
- Game animals are being found covered with tumours and mutations.
- In humans, unusual cancers and autoimmune diseases have been cropping up in the community of Fort Chipewyan.
The report says that instead of properly managing the tarsands, government has "outsourced" monitoring to the industry, "creating a classic situation of the fox guarding the henhouse."
This isn't the first such report on the oilsands industry. In 2006, The World Wildlife Fund Canada's warned that the expansion of the industry was threatening Canadian freshwater reserves.
The report on water resources also warned that even a small amount of global warming could have a dire impact on flows in bodies such as the Great Lakes and Athabasca River.
User Tools
Related Websites
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(27)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I applaud the budget, even though Health Care and education may stay unscathed. Sadly this cannot last and I worry to later this year where cuts will become enviable. If anything, this provides the Wildrose Alliance plenty of ammo when an election is called.


Comments are now closed for this story
GG
said
True Motive?
said
So I ask then, which organization(s) would feel most threatened by tar sands development? OPEC?
Chris - Winnipeg
said
Darsh Ramrattan
said
garry
said
All great dead civilizations had one thing in common, they could not get rid of their garbage. This is apparently happening to us. I hope we can clean it up. G
Former Liberal
said
How could the former Liberal government allowed this to happen?
Thankfully, Canada now has a Government which has introduced the toughest plan in Canadian history to address these concerns.
Under the Conservatives' plan, all the major polluters will have to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions, and that includes the oilsands. The plan requires absolute reductions of 20 per cent by 2020.
Unfortunately Liberals will continue to hang on to unachievable and worthless Kyoto as their only idea, however fortunatley if a vote is required in Parliament Liberals will abstain, for fear of losing their seats, therefore Canada's New Green Plan will be passed, for the benefit of all Canadians including those who live in Alberta.
Gerald Skowronski
said
richie
said
Ton
said
I'm not surprised given the philosophy of a conservative government
that feels the most efficient way of running a country is to trust private industry to do what is best for every one.
My idea of an efficient government is one that protects us from the ruthlessness of the market place where profit is the only consideration - never mind the cost to our environment, the disgrace of relegating a large segment of our society to the fringes and conditions of poverty, sickness, homelessness, hopelessness, and crime.
One day the world will run out of fossil fuels. Why do we want to wait until that happens before we begin to invest significantly in alternatives?
This present government is so incredibly short-sighted.
What benefit is reducing GST by 2%? All this does is encourage us to buy and pollute more. Imagine if that 2%were put into efficient city transporation? Imagine if it went into lower rates for public transporation?
Fraz
said
Michael Le Couteur CD
said
JD in Alberta
said
Funny we never see any reports in the news about the polluters in the east. Look at the condition of the Great Lakes.
C
said
As someone who works in the oil sands industry and occasionally on projects related to tailings, I would love for the authors to inform me of how we can magically make "Dry Tailings". Through chemicals? That's already been tried. Through massive driers? Well, you'll end up burning more gas that way. Filters likely won't work either due to the extreme solids loading of the system.
Everybody in the industry would love to hear how to make these "Dry Tailings". Would the authors' care to enlighten us?
WC
said
Remember all that exists in the universe is truth and resistance to it. Truth is the power of the voice of the universe.
Snowbound in QC
said
The oilsands is as earth destructive as anything going on in the Amazon, Indonesia or China.
And Canadians are supposed to be smarter than that. Looks like our souls are sold too.
Graham
said
B. Gordon
said
Craig
said
Do you enjoy driving your car, flying, buying anything? Then you are using oil that is being produced from the oilsands. This resource is not only used for gasoline, it is incorporated into plastics, transport companies etc.
Most critics always do the same thing. They whine and moan that the government is doing too little but will not change their own lifestyle. What happened to personal responsibility?
Yes, the government should do their part, but you should also do yours.
Dan
said
Lyndon
said
Kevin - Alberta
said
Alex March
said
James
said
Canada has strict environmental policies and they do the best to enforce them, if you like your car and 21st Century travel methods then we must get the oil out of the ground.
Winnipegger
said
That statement left me asking "This is a problem, why?"
Any polultion released into rivers is oil that isn't captured to sell to customers. It's about efficiency. Just recycle all water used and you collect all oil without poluting. Duh!
BC
said
Mike
said
ian in BC
said