CTV News | Prime minister announces $1-billion relief package

Canada -   

Prime minister announces $1-billion relief package

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: David Akin explains the recession fears
CTV Atlantic: Andy Campbell on the big bail out
CTV Newsnet: Dave Coles, Communications, Energy and Paperworkers Union of Canada

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(35)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Thu. Jan. 10 2008 6:16 PM ET

The federal government has announced a $1-billion investment into single-industry communities stung by economic hardship and plagued by high unemployment.

The announcement comes after increasing pressure to help workers in traditional industries such as forestry, fishing and manufacturing. Such industries have been hurt by the strong Canadian dollar and less demand from the United States.

Prime Minister Stephen Harper said the "community development trust fund" will provide money to create new opportunities for vulnerable communities and laid-off workers.

"The program is aimed at one-industry towns facing, or communities plagued by chronic high unemployment, or regions hit by layoffs across a range of sectors," Harper said at a press conference held at a New Brunswick lumber mill on Thursday.

Each province will be given a base one-time payment of $10 million, and each territory will be given $3 million. The rest of the fund will be shared on a per capita basis.

Harper said the program will support job training, create opportunities for workers and help communities form plans to create economic development. Specific plans will be decided on by each provincial government, he said.

"Our government has been prudently taking steps to prepare Canada for the uncertain times ahead," Harper told the news conference. "This fund will help vulnerable communities and their workers to adjust to these changes and to prosper."

The money for the fund will come from the federal surplus and will be announced as part of the next budget. If opposition parties vote against the budget and trigger an election, the fund will not proceed.

Liberal intergovernmental affairs critic Dominic LeBlanc said Thursday that the announcement was one big political ploy, ahead of an inevitable election.

"By tying this package to his next budget, Mr. Harper is engaging in a purely cynical political ploy -- designed so he can blame the woes of the forestry and manufacturing sectors on the opposition if they were to refuse to pass his entire budget," Mr. LeBlanc said in a released statement.

LeBlanc said Harper's government caused the problems by cancelling a Liberal forest strategy and negotiating a bad softwood lumber deal with the U.S.

Provincial reaction

The announcement was made with New Brunswick Premier Shawn Graham in attendance. His province will receive $30 million through the Community Development Trust.

"These are indeed difficult times for the forest industry, workers and communities right across Canada. Forestry has long been the engine that drives the New Brunswick economy and the recent downturn has hurt our province," Graham said on Thursday.

"We must find ways to diversify our economy and move away from the concept of one-industry towns."

Other premiers reacted skeptically on the heels of the announcement. Ontario's Dalton McGuinty and Quebec's Jean Charest both questioned the validity of the announcement.

"I don't think forestry workers in Quebec deserve to be part of the election campaign," Charest told a press conference.

Charest also said the announcement -- worth about $200 million for Quebec -- equals about 10 per cent of what his province has already done for its forestry and manufacturing sectors.

While McGuinty thanked the prime minister for the funding, he said the announcement -- worth about $350 million for Ontario -- pales in comparison to the $3 billion Ontario has already invested in its ailing industries. He was also skeptical about the announcement's dependence to the passing of the budget.

"Either we agree as Canadians and as political leaders that the situation before us is somewhat urgent, or we don't," McGuinty told CTV's Mike Duffy Live.

"We're appreciative of the funding, but we'd like that to flow sooner, rather than later. And it should not be made conditional on the passage of a budget and possibly a subsequent election."

Both McGuinty and Charest said on Mike Duffy Live that the money can, and should, flow without attaching it to the budget.

The premiers of every province and territory will meet with Harper in Ottawa, to discuss the economy on Friday.

The location for the announcement, a mill south of Fredericton, focused the announcement on the forestry industry -- a sector particularly hard hit by exchange rate fluctuation and turmoil in the U.S. housing market.

Forestry employs about 300,000 people in 300 communities across Canada, according to the Forest Products Association of Canada.

Dave Coles, president of the Communications, Energy and Paperworkers Union, said the announcement was an insulting game Harper was "playing on the backs of unemployed forestry workers."

"Mr. Harper's announcement has nothing to do with saving the forest industry. It's not a Band-Aid for the industry, it's not even a stitch on the wound," Coles told CTV Newsnet.

He said the union had met with government officials to discuss what must be done to save the industry, but no one was interested in hearing their advice.

He said it will take closer to $10 billion in federal money to do any real good. That money should target research and development, develop new products, and invest in communities and workers hurt by the economic turndown.

"We're going ahead without the government, and they'd best get on board," he said.

Buzz Hargrove, president of the Canadian Auto Workers union, said Ontario's share of the $1-billion investment wouldn't be enough to help struggling manufacturers.

Hargrove said on Thursday that the money wouldn't even be enough to upgrade a single parts plant in Ontario.

The auto industry directly employs 150,000 people in Ontario, as well as 500,000 directly or indirectly across Canada.

Comments are now closed for this story

MHR
said

Uh oh, I guess this meant that Canadian's economy is not good as "Canada's New Government" been bragging about.


Greg from Kitchener
said

Buzz will never be happy with Harper.. we all know that. How about getting rid of the unions who are killing the industry... take a look at Toyota Buzz, no union, great company making lots of money...
nions were good at one time, but these days, they are hurting Canada.


Allan Eizinas
said

What about the tobacco industry in Southern Ontario?

Leaf tobacco sales have dropped by 70% in the last 6 years, farmers are going bankrupt, related industries going out of business and local communities are suffering with no end in sight.


Jali
said

All I can say is - It's about time!

And thank you.


Roch
said

Leave it to the CAW of Ontario to be asking for other Canadian province's share.

This is an excellent investment by our government, to help Canadians in trying times. Isn't this what a Government SHOULD be doing, helping Canadians in their time of need?

Within reason of course, we do have limited funds and we have to be fiscally responsible.





Ken
said

OK Buzz how about this, The PM announces that the entire surplus will be given to the CAW immediately. Buzz responds, this is totally inadequate because this is a conservative govt. Give me a break. If the auto industry in Canada was to produce vehicles that Canadians wanted to drive, maybe there wouldn't be so many Hondas etc on the road in this country.


Help is welcomed !!
said

Our Prime Minister is doing the right thing and I applaud his efforts to cushion the east from hardship. A government can only do so much but at least they are trying to do what is good for Canadians.


W.G.
said

I really expected Hargrove's name to be in there complaining about not enough funding for the Auto Sector. Yep it's been hit really hard, and it will only get worse in the years to come. Does the government, any government do A) Give 100 Billion towards it? B) Let it adjust and correct itself?

The problem I have always seen with the Auto Industry are the Union's themselves. At some point people must accept that the generally high wages, high overtime, and all those other goodies the unions demand on their behalf ultimately cost them their jobs. The auto makers offload the high wages and benefits to the consumers, and eventually consumers go by the imports, because they don't feel like getting another $25000 loan for a new car.

Think I'm wrong here? Perhaps, but it's odd that Toyota can turn a profit in North America, but the big guys (union guys) all loose money in this market...

Soo long story short, is it the Government's responsibility to bail out plauged business, or is it best to leave it to free competition?


FreakAlert
said

Money, wealth, jobs, and overall prosperity is created by debt with the system we live in. Now, debt has passed the point where debt and credit can't be balanced any longer; hence, an economic collapse.


Jason Stephenson (Fredericton)
said

The thing that caught my eye was that he has tagged this with the next budget.

Strong move by the government that really backs the Opposition to either support the budget, or sink the aid package to force an election

I live in NB, so this is welcome news, albeit late


SM
said

This appears to be aimed at rural Canada - it is about time that someone took notice of the dying rural communities. Thankyou,


JD
said

After reading this article and many others on this website, only one thing can be said. It doesn't matter what the Conservative Government does, they will be trashed by certain people and groups.

This government is providing this money to avoid mass unemployment, future job loss, to keep the economy stable and to provide re-training for people that need it. 1 BILLION dollars, thats a lot of cash, but still it's not enough. Maybe what people like Buzz needs an ATM card to access Government funds, would he be happy then?
Plain and simple.. Unions have outlived their usefullness all they do is hold employees back and put the money in the pockets of the people who run the union.


Marc
said

Greg from Kitchener

Who cares about tobacco farmers. Maybe their customers are dying of cancer and not buying as much tobacco anymore. Must be hard to feel sorry for these people growing cancer causing, addictive, products.


BK in Europe
said

To Allan in S.Ontario

If you're still in the tobacco industry in this day and age who exactly do you believe your market is? Duh.

Doesn't take a brain surgeon to realize those days are gone and you should be thinking about what else you need to get into - Canola perhaps?

But then again look where the comment came from, never could figure it out for itself...always looking for handouts.


Lillian
said

Perhaps Buzz and the unions shouldn't have demanded such outrageous wages over the years from GM etc. Many people have bought and are buying foreign vehicles because they are just better quality. I see no reason why taxpayers should have to bail out these highly paid auto workers and companies such as GM, Ford and Chrysler.

Doug
said

This band aid could be of some help. It seems to be getting a generally warm response from the BC government. I'm not really a fan of this governement. But then again,the previous one was at least as bad. Their answer was to de-value the dollar so we all paid more for everything. I have to think that the idustry has to do all it can to become as efficient as possible. Adjusting to a higher dollar will be a challenge to many industries.

JS
said

Hey Buzz, what's the UAW doing to help the autoworkers? Sucking even more out of the auto manufacterers till they have to lay people off to be competitive with the Toyotas and Hondas. Mr. Harper announced a helping hand for the industries, not a welfare system for them. If the opposition party doesn't like the plan, they can always get off their hands and vote the budget down. We can then see what plan they will come up with during the next election then. This Canadian does want an election now, so that the Liberals can get voted into non political party status.

Mr. Coles also wants the federal government to fix the HUGE problem his union has made out of the forest industry. The US is the biggest buyer of Canadian lumber, and if the US isn't building new homes, they won't be buying our lumber. Mr. Coles can always get into the tooth pick or even better the chop stick business and sell them to China.


Mike from Canmore
said

And why aren't these industries trying to be innovative and create value-added products when times are good? And maybe the workers should have stayed in school, but why bother when there's big union pay at the mill? This whole country, workers AND corporations have developed this lazy attitude that we're doing "good enough". Unlike a Japan, we've had the luxury of abundant raw materials. But look, the government is bailing us out again, so we wallow in our mediocrity, and loathe the Americans for being rich.


BOB, Calgary
said

A Conservative government can never please Buzzie. The American auto industry produces autos that no one really wants. The quality and consequent trade in value of big 3 autos is lower that Honda/Toyota. The Big 3 have been slow to get on the Hybrid bandwagon. This is not the autoworkers fault but more an indication of mediocre management. However the CAW nust realize that it is not the job of the government or Canadian taxpayers to bail out the autoworkers. Some help is positive but an open checkbook is not the solution.


larry
said

Sorry to hear the Unions complaining, once again, even though they are getting a free hand-out ( 1 billion is huge) and they are most certainly a big part of the problem. No class at all.
I guess no matter what a conservative government does, they will complain anyway.
I wonder if it was an NDP or liberal announcement, they would be so shortsighted.


Josh
said

If you know about the situation in Hamilton, ON, you will know that the unionized Stelco is falling on hard times because the union is doing what most unions do and obstructing business. Defasco, on the other hand, right next door, is not unionized however, and, although they employ less people, their employees take home more pay and they have working conditions which are superior to Stelco’s. Unions create unneeded hostility, and have outlived their purpose. Unions have a special status in the New Democratic Party, they are more powerful than the average NDP member, they cannot be trusted to give fair political commentary. The Liberal Party was the worst at “political ploys”, but the Harper government has been disciplined and focused on priorities, not been irresponsible like Stephan Dion wants the government to be with out of control spending. Not everyone should rely on the government all the time!


Steve G
said

I'm not surprised to read the anti-union comments from some of the usual corporate cheerleaders who post here. Here's some enlightenment for you-GM's Oshawa plants are the most productive in all of North America (including your beloved non-union Toyota and Honda plants).

As far as the tired old "unions have outlived their usefulness" comments-unionized workers earn, on average, 30% more in wages and benefits than non-union workers, so until non-union workers catch up, your point is moot.


CORPORATE WELFARE - Broken Promises Again
said

CORPORATE WELFARE

Yet another broken promise by this regime. Maybe Harper should not have sold us out to the US in negotiating the lumber deals. Now the taxpayers pick up the bill for poor leadship and non-existent diplomacy.

Ya, thanks to Steve and his naive supporters.

So which is it in Canada a booming economy or struggling industry? Ah, the hypocrisy of the spin doctors.


eskiefan
said

I think this is a great move by the Government. The advantage we have today is PM Harper's background is in Economics rather than law as with many politicians. He's very aware of the bottom line and of the fact that money talks and he speaks the language. Instead of unions today I'm in favour of profit-sharing by employees. This is a winning approach for both companies and workers.


MikeN
said

I used to work in a sawmill in Thunder Bay. After all the gov't initiatives and offers of loans to mills they've all shut down here and I've been laid off for nine months. The lumber industry is not dying here - it is DEAD. It's time now for the government to step in and have my former employer pay out his severance packages to all his unemployed workers.


Prognosticator
said

My, cry me a river, Buzz!

Last time I looked, Toyota was outselling the unionized Big Three. To add to the costs incurred by the Big Three because of inflated union rates, the auto manufacturers still have not grasped that higher fuel prices mean that people want fuel efficient vehicles, not gas guzzlers

Maybe the auto industry should NOT be part of this aid package until they get their act together. If European and Japanese manufacturers can produce gas and diesl engines that get 60 miles per gallon, then the Big Three can too, as they own - or are owned by - those same European manufacturers.

As for the other industries, maybe they do need a little help. But our dollar is high because our economy is strong and our debt load is decreasing, unlike the USA. When Washington gets its act together and spends money to pay dopwn debt instead of running a constant deficit, the greenback will appreciate and our dollar will be reasonably under par with it. A 90 cent loonie would be good.

But until the US economy turns round, look for weaker manufacturing exports here, especially in the over-priced and over-paid unionized auto sector.


Norm
said

"Each province will be given a base one-time payment of $10 million, and each territory will be given $3 million. The rest of the fund will be shared on a per capita basis.
Harper said the program will support job training, create opportunities for workers and help communities form plans to create economic development. Specific plans will be decided on by each provincial government, he said."
I like what is being done here. Money going to good use hopefully. Federal Gov't making funds available for a local solution. It is now up to the provincial gov't to make sure the programs are set up properly. I strongly believe Canadians are good at adapting to changing times. This program is a great example of taking care of our fellow Canadians and allowing them to adapt in changing economic times.Now the pressure would be on the provincial gov't s to make sure Canadians are taken care of. As far as being tied to the upcoming budget isn't this what a Federal Gov't supposed to do, make decisions for the benefit of all Canadians.Tell me who is excluded from this those of you who don't like the proposed program. At least it is not going to be another sponsorship scandal or HRDC fiasco.


Lance
said

Can somebody spell,...RECESSION?


Couver
said

I think the federal government should stay completely out of this business. Government cannot pick and choose which corporations should receive welfare and which ones don't. So either you help every corporation that is having trouble in any sector (which would be very hard to do) or don't do anything and keep taxes low (which would keep every corporation on an even playing ground). Secondly, why do we need federal money to retrain laid off workers? Especially since when you get a job they are the ones that train you. If people were employed in one town industries out east maybe they should consider moving out west where we are short of workers.


Ken
said

I think it would be in the CAW's best interest to replace Buzz with a leader who would take a "partnership" approach in their strategy. Buzz's negative and outdated attitude only plays into Toyota's favor.


Matt
said

Funny story the Harper government lost more than 1 billion in the forestry "deal" and thinks that's all it will take to fix it??? Not to mention the other industries. Thanks again Conservatives, thumbs up on a terrible job, hopefully the opposition will keep them honest on this one.


David in Que.
said

Tie it to the budget and turn it into an election issue instead of standing up and giving the people hurting the help now. Just another my way or no way from Comrade Harper. What a control freak.


Paul
said

Any economist knows that government intervening to prop up failing industries simply lowers everyone else's standard of living. Wealth is redistributed to non-viable economic entities when it should be invested in areas with growth potential.

I am sure that PM Harper does not believe in this policy but realizes that it is necessary to win a majority.


Brenda
said

Steve G, 30% more of nothing because you have been laid off, is not better. When will unions understand that their high wages are causing their own people to be laid off? Buzz doesn't care he has seniority.


Greg
said

This is a no sense announcement, a mere campaign speech in whcih Harper has sucke din the Premiers to say it is a good announcement. The Budget has to be passed first!


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz