CTV News | Pakistan says al Qaeda killed Benazir Bhutto

Top Stories -   

Pakistan says al Qaeda killed Benazir Bhutto

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Paul Workman with the new revelations
CTV News: Joy Malbon on how the assassination has impacted the Presidential race
CTV Newsnet: Pakistan Interior Ministry fields questions from reporters regarding the death
Canada AM: Murray Oliver at the Canadian base in Kandahar
Canada AM: Eric Margolis, author, 'War at the Top of the World' and P.J. Crowlet, director of homeland security, Center for American Progress
CTV Newsnet: John Bolton, former U.S. ambassador to the UN, comments on the death
Canada AM: Alan Bell from Globe Risk Holdings examines the security lapses surrounding the assassination
Canada AM: Wajid Khan, MP for Mississauga-Streetsville
Canada AM: Raheel Raza, author, 'Their Jihah... Not My Jihad'
Canada AM: Jamal Jeofry, president, Toronto Pakistan Association

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(66)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Fri. Dec. 28 2007 11:25 PM ET

Pakistan's government blamed al Qaeda on Friday for the assassination of opposition leader Benazir Bhutto, and released a conflicting report that claims she died from a skull fracture, not gunshot wounds.

At a press conference Friday, Interior Ministry spokesman Javed Iqbal Cheema said the Pakistani government recorded an "intelligence intercept" in which an al Qaeda leader "congratulated his people" for killing Bhutto.

Cheema identified the "al Qaeda leader" as Baitullah Mehsud.

Mehsud is a commander of pro-Taliban forces in the lawless Pakistani tribal region of South Waziristan -- where al Qaeda forces are also active.

Cheema also said Bhutto died when she was thrown by the force of an explosion and knocked her head into the sunroof of her SUV, moments after she spoke at a political rally.

"One of the levers of the sunroof hit her on the right side, which caused a fracture, and that is what caused her death," Cheema told reporters.

But on Thursday, just hours after the attack, a doctor had said Bhutto was fatally shot twice by a gunman who then detonated an explosive device as Bhutto's vehicle sped away from the scene. Twenty-seven others died in the blast.

Further confusing the issue, the surgeon who treated Bhutto at Rawalpindi General Hospital said she died from a shrapnel wound to the head.

Dr. Mussadiq Khan said Bhutto had shrapnel in the right side of her skull. Khan also said Bhutto had no heart beat or pulse when she arrived at the hospital.

Bhutto's medical report did show no bullet was found in her body, said Cheema.

Masses of mourners

Meanwhile, hundreds of thousands of mourners gathered outside Bhutto's family's mausoleum to pay their final respects.

The funeral procession began Friday afternoon at Bhutto's ancestral residence in the southern town of Naudero.

From there, her plain wood coffin -- wrapped in the red, green and black flag of her Pakistan Peoples Party -- was transported to the mausoleum in Garhi Khuda Baksh.

"This country is in deep shock as a result of what happened," CTV's Paul Workman reported from Islamabad.

"Even those people who did not support Benazir Bhutto really can't accept and can't understand what happened."

Bhutto, 54, was buried next to her father, former prime minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, who was removed from power by the military in 1977 and executed.

Rioting kills dozens

In several cities across Pakistan Friday, supporters of Bhutto continued to riot, setting fire to cars and stores as they blamed President Pervez Musharaf for Bhutto's death.

Many believe Musharaf did little to prevent the attack by refusing to boost security for Bhutto, despite constant death threats against her.

In Karachi, people looted banks and fired guns at the police, injuring at least three officers.

Thousands broke into banks in Multan and threw rocks at police, while in the capital of Islamabad, another 100 people set fire to tires.

The military has sent soldiers into the cities to quell the violence and paramilitary rangers in southern Pakistan have the authority to shoot anyone who damages property.

With files from The Associated Press

Please Add Comments( )

JoAnn West Williams
said
0 0

As a black female educator, I am so moved by the death of this pillar of strength. I recall watching her when she returned from exile and thinking what a "woman of conviction and determination." I have kept that picture of what a strong woman can and will do without fear. In death, she still speaks "strength."


syed
said
0 0

It was highly disorganized burial. As compared to BB, Gen. Zia Ulhaq burial was much more organized.
It leaves us with no choice except to support the army who only are capable of restoring peace and stability in Pakistan.


Jean Pierre Levesque
said
0 0

The Good do die young!-
God rest her soul and
may her ideas live on .
REST IN PEACE


Sam in NS
said
0 0

I would like to be able to believe that those responsible for her death are feeling remorse today but alas I would be dreaming of better days for Pakistan and I fear that it is only going to get worse as a result of her assassination.


Al
said
0 0

Nuclear Pakistan, where could this all lead! How far has the extremist movement infiltrated the government?

Kim Sokochoff
said
0 0

If Bhutto knew that she was in such danger she should have accepted the security that she was offered rather than being upset by it being there. She knew she was in danger and should have tried to accept that fact. But instead she wanted to be a martyr. I do not feel sorry for her at all she was a smart woman and should not have been leading the rally. She sould speak at such an event with her security yes but to be in the forground of this event was a mistake and she knew it.


Mohamed
said
0 0

All of us are destined to die. What matters is what whether we will leave a stamp that others will remember us for. Mrs. Bhutto will always be remembered as a brave woman who attempted to stand against both a merciless dictator and powers of backwardness and she paid her life as a price. May Allah accept her as a martyr in his paradise!.


disillusioned
said
0 0

With the passing of Bhutto, Pakistan has lost its best hope of a peaceful democracy. I am particularly saddened by the violent protests, I don't think Ms. Bhutto would approve. Why is it that in certain parts of the world, when a leader dies the first thing their supporters do is burn cars and shops? How does this advance the cause against Musharraf, Sharif, or the military? It only undermines the position of the Pakistan Peoples Party, not only in the eyes of their countrymen, but to their neighbors and the world.


Wade Ens
said
0 0

Musharaff did enough to protect her. Lets see first he imposed Marshall law for awhile. Then she had tons of people blown up at a rally. Then she was put under house arrest for her own saftey. She refused to heed the advice.
It looks to me like Osama has his fingers prints on this and to kill innocent women to stop advancement of democracy seems like Bin Laden alright.
This war is everybody's war.


Nancy
said
0 0

Musharaff might be next.
Several attempts have been made on his life.
The terrorists just move from country to country killing where ever the sofest targets are.
World war 3 has been on for a while now.


Bilal Abdullah
said
0 0

Pillar of strength? Ms. Bhutto was the daughter of a weatlthy land owner who kept thousands of poor people virtual slaves on his land holdings. Her father was a despot. When she was brought into power, she and her husband went about pillaging the country and filling their overseas accounts with the wealth of Pakistan. I feel for her children, but Ms. Bhutto is no hero, nor was she a help to her nation.


William
said
0 0

What of the many who died along with her? No one seems to cry for them. What of the many children who died due to inadequate nutrition and medical care on account of the funds taken from the Pakistani treasury by Benizir and her associate. No one is mentioning the rampant corruption during both her administration and during her father's time. When will the West allow a person of integrity rule this troubled land?


shamaro
said
0 0

I feel for the people of Pakitan who had their hope of a secure and peaceful future snuffed out yesterday with such a violent end. The extremists responsible for this should be hunted down like a pack of rabid wolves and brought to justice. As for any violent extremist group, they should be dealt with extreme prejudice and be put away in a prison where they'll never see the light of day again or removed from the face of this earth.


p
said
0 0

Seems Bilal and William are the only ones here who can see / remember that even Mrs Bhutto was a tyrant and a greedy dictator - Yes she was a woman and yes she was preaching about doing 'good' and 'bringing about democracy' but remember this lady was just as powerful and dangerous as the others in this country. I feel very sorry for ALL the people in Pakistan who will now have even more unrest and strife. Think of all the children and elderly who will suffer for this.

In death she is even more powerful and dangerous than when she was alive - for now she is a martyr. Such struggles and grief for such poor people because of the actions of rich and powerful.


Mark
said
0 0

What a surprise that the country that is the host to Islamic militancy, supports Al Qaeda and the unrest in Iraq and Afghanistan should murder a voice of reason.

Pakistan-a country on the precipice of collapse. Nuclear Pakistan, the home of fundamentalist Madrassas and an entirely ungovernable frontier.

Pakistan-incubator of disaster and exectioner of reason.




Scott
said
0 0

This is a tragedy for the entire world. Such a great woman! These religious fanatics will not stop until they get a hold of Pakistans nukes, and serve them out around the world. As far as I'm concerned this is a huge blow to women's rights in the region as well. I hope these leftist bleeding hearts we have in Canada nowadays who want to hide, end our involvment in Afganistan etc. and do nothing about these injustices will wake up soon and smell the coffee. These terrorist vermin need to be eradicated, and we need to put our heart and soul into the fight against this, otherwise it will continue to haunt us until these terrorists do in fact get a hold of the nukes etc., as there are plenty sympathizers in Pakistan. If we don't fight it now, it will be much bigger loss for us in the future as they hate everything we stand for, especially equal rights for women. I just can't fathom how these leftist types don't get it? Anyone who won't fight against this kind of extremism is a coward as far as I'm concerned. May Bhutto rest in peace, and her death not be in vain, but an example for us to stand up against injustice and extremism.


Lorne
said
0 0

These places in the world are like black holes that just suck in the best of us and leave nothing but death and destruction all around. I hope we can find a way to bring peace and democracy to these places, but like the American Civil rights movement, it will probably take a hundred years or so of brave people dying in order for the rest of them to get it.


Lisa
said
0 0

Now that the present dictator has his biggest opponent removed, he is free to continue his tyranny and I am sure with the acceptance of certain other powers! How lovely! and what a fabulous way but to blame "militants", "terrorists" and "Al Queda" hahahahahahahhaahahha...


Allan Eizinas
said
0 0

This is bad news for Canada. The Pakistani government will have to concentrate their troops in the cities and abandon their already porous border with Afghanistan. There are 15 million Pashtuns and tens of thousands of Taliban who will be able to move across at will. The Taliban are already gaining ground in Afghanistan and this will put even more pressure on our Canadian troops.

As to Bhutto and security, George Bush would not stick his head out through a sun roof of his limo as he drove through Washington nor would Stephen Harper on a trip through Ottawa. This was not a very smart move.


James in Edmonton
said
0 0

When will the west "allow" a leader???

When did it become our responsibility to elect a leader for these countries...Democracy has to be allowed in all parts of the world, to those who want it.

Sometimes that means that they will not want the democracy that we take for granted. And we are not the ones to determine what is right for them.

I hope that Pakistan, after 60 years of hate, killing, and bloodshed, will eventually realise that this is not good for her people, or the world. The world has lost a person who truly tried to stand up against the establishment, and bring some sort of calm to her people.


Forte
said
0 0

This was a political assassination whose sole intent was to maintain the status quo.For western leaders to suggest otherwise is pure hypocracy.Bhutto was athreat to the old boys' club.Without her there is no opposition.What a waste of another life.


mo kongo
said
0 0

Bilal Abdullah is right!you people make conclusions without knowing her past and most importantly her family.most of third world politicians are very corrupt and its been like that for centuries.she was not going to chance anything just get to the top and steal more,however she didn't deserve to die.


paul
said
0 0

While no one should be attacked in this way, Ms Bhutto was not a picture of democracy give her removal of power for corruption. She also fought against house arrest and marshall law that would have protected her. This was a bad situation that grew worse by her insistence to make appearances at rallies. Peace and order needed to be restored before campaigning, there was little common sense used here - and whether she was a good leader, poor leader, she walked into a waiting trap. And now the people of Pakistan pay, that is the unfortunate part.


Mohamed Bhimji
said
0 0

Why are the Western governments surprised? They knew it was going to happen. The "Bhuttos" have enormous land holdings outside Pakistan, in London, Dubai and else where - where did this wealth come from? What was promised to her that made her come back? It had to be something that she could not say no to - she made that choice for she knew exactly what was in store for her. I feel sory for the people who trusted her and believed in her.


MR
said
0 0

Ms. Bhutto fought for the same thing Gandhi fought for - Peace in her homeland. She was not afraid of her fellow countrymen despite the fact that in the end- it was her countrymen who were afraid of her - and her ideals for peace and democracy. This woman's power as a female leader was a reality Muslim extremists would never accept- a woman trying to lead in a "Man's world". The very fact that a Muslim man used a gun to kill his fellow Muslim woman show's the inherent weakness of that man and his fellow
Extremists that were and still are against peace and democracy.
This assassin has rid the Muslim world of a positive chance for stability...and most hurtful of all, the assassin has rid three young kids of their mother.



Genong el Ratanf
said
0 0

The blood of the 20 others killed in this attack is on Bhutto's hands.

Poking her head through the sunroof to wave to masses and celebrate her glory was more than a risk to herself, she risked the lives of those around her.


dennie h
said
0 0

Good Bye to a Great Lady and a real champion for the Pakistani People. May she rest in peace.


Debra Bannister
said
0 0

The assassination of opposition leader Benazir Bhutto on Thursday, December 29th has 4 important lessons in leadership to teach us.

Lesson #1: Leadership requires a courageous soul. Many resist taking on this role because of the unknown risks that it exposes us to. However, there are the courageous among us that have a vision that is greater than ourselves and which compels us to ignore the unknown risks and embrace the creation of the greater good. In this instance, creating a fundamental shift from totalitarianism and oppression towards freedom and democracy.

Lesson #2: Never under estimate your enemies. Beware that your enemies may come disguise in friendly form. However, your enemies may eventually expose themselves through their behaviors – excessive ingratiation, persistent coercion, passive resistance and other types of quiet manipulation that is meant to move you toward a position of vulnerability. Benazir Bhutto may have been convinced to forgo protection of the armored car and stand up through the sun roof to wave to her supporters. This one act provided the opportunities for her enemies to attack with fatal consequences.

Lesson #3: Never fall victim to the false belief that as a leader are invincible; that your power, position or the overwhelming support that appears before you is enough to protect you from the forces that oppose you. This is a fatal flaw in every way. As leaders we must believe in our ability to influence our followers otherwise we would not possess the confidence to transform society and the organizations that support the current status quo. However, when our confidence and beliefs fool us into thinking we achieve anything, good or bad, without the fear of consequences or failure, then we lead ourselves towards a pathway of self-destruction. Those followers around Benazir Bhutto’s vehicle may have appears friendly to her but one of those friendly faces had terror in their hearts and their actions proved fatal for a leader that may have taken Pakistan to a higher level of cultural and political state of being.
Lesson #4: Always prepare a second in command to continue your legacy. Benazir Bhutto’s death has created a leadership vacuum in her political party and societal chaos in her country. Vacuums are dangerous entities as they attract both loyal and deceitful opportunists. History has taught us that in a vacuum people’s fear of the unknown will motivate them to immediately seek order and direction in any form. Unfortunately this misguided judgment often results in the wrong type of leader being elected into power under the guise of promised democratic rule.
We have witnessed architecture of a treacherous act. It remains to be seen whether Benazir’s her party can find a strong and democrat leader to succession the visionary work of Benazir Bhutto. May all the positive forces of the world unit to make this happen.







Rod Loewen
said
0 0

The sudden death of Benazir Bhutto could have been averted by the Military giving her security as happens in nromal democracies for dignitaries like her as a twice-past Prime Minister.
I hope they get to the bottom of who did this dastardly deed.
This may be a good time for the President to lead before his country is destroyed.It seems like he played his trump card to insure his own position but now the world sits on the brink of disaster.

Faruk
said
0 0

Equating Benizir Bhutto with Ghandi would be funny if not for the circumstances. What 90% of the commenters fail to realize is that the Bhutto clan made their vast wealth on the backs of the rural poor. These rural poor are little more than serfs on their fuedal master's land. Becoming priminister of Pakistan was a means of amassing an even larger fortune for the Bhuttos. It was in the best interests of Mr. Bhutto that the masses remain poor and ignorant. She didn't care for her people. She was as power hungry and selfish as those who preceeded her to office and those who will foll. Pakistan is a failed state and Ms. Bhutto was yet another in a long line of wealthy despots.


Fatima
said
0 0

"All the kings horses and all the kings men couldn't put humpty together again"

No amount of security is sufficient to protect against the most deturmined assassin. Had Benazir truly wanted to make amends for years of stealing from the Pakistani people, she would has stayed in London or Dubai and spent her considerable ill-gotten fortune on building infrastructure and providing educational opportunities to Pakistan's vast underclass. Instead, her enormous ego got the best of her and lead her back into the lion's den of Pakistani politics. She was no Ghandi or savior to "her" people. She was just a child of privlege who used "her" people to her best advantage time and again. Her time finally ran out.


oleg
said
0 0

People don't realize that she was as corrupt as any politician in that country. She went on self-imposed exile because she didn't want to to face corruption charges, upon her return her husband didn't come back with her, there is a reason for that . As for people who say she was a pillar of strenght and even comparing her to Ghandi, let's not forget that it was when she was in office the taliban were born with the help of Pakistan, one of the most extreme regimes in that part of the world that treated women worse than dirt. She didn't deserve to die, but she doesn't deserve the praise people give her either.


mo kongo
said
0 0

to Debra Bannister:

you should edit lesson #1 like this:
there are the courageous among us that have a vision for power and greed that is greater than ourselves and which compels us to ignore the unknown risks and embrace the creation of the greater good.
think about the people that died with her.


Johnson Mapple
said
0 0

Tribal warfare at its worst.


David
said
0 0

Even in death this woman and her family are villified without proof. Ms. Bhutto was driven from power twice because #1, She's a woman and #2, She believed in secular, democratic goverment. A rich woman, she did not need to return to Pakistan again, she wanted to help her country.


Fred
said
0 0

Just another piece of groundword laid by the islam fundamentalist political movement. It's time to stop pretending that fundamentalist islam is 'religion', when it's obvious that it's 'politics'. Within 20 years the entire moslem world (and possibly parts of Europe given immigration rates and family sizes) will be fundamentalist, with a subvervient female population living in a medieval culture.

It's time for the world to adopt standards of freedom and human rights that trump so-called religious freedoms


Andy
said
0 0

Now India & the US are left with no choice but to launch a preemptive strike against the nuclear targets to ensure these weapons are either forcibly removed & or destroyed for the safety of everyone on this planet. Pakistan has proven time & time again it is an unstable state & should NOT be allowed to harbour nuclear weapons for fear it falls into the hands of lunatics!


Jen
said
0 0

Mrs Bhutto returned home to help her people fight for their FREEDOM and DEMOCRACY. But was murder for her efforts.
Nato forces went into Afghanistan to help innocent souls fight for their FREEDOM AND DEMOCRACY but many of Nato soldiers and innocent Afghans were murdered for the fight for FREEDOM AND DEMOCRACY.
Mrs. Bhutto said in an interview, that Canada must not leave Afghanistan to stay the course. She said that we must not allow terrorists extremism TO PREVAIL NOR MUST WE ALLOW TERRORISTS TO TAKE OVER OUR LIVES AND THE LIVES OF MANY.

FREEDOM AND DEMOCRACY IS OUR DAILY LIFE WITHOUT IT WE ARE NOTHING BUT PUPPETS TO BE USED BY THE FORCES OF EVIL.
God Bless Mrs. Bhutto, may she find comfort in the God's arms and may her people never give up her's and their fight for freedom and democracy


Lart from Above
said
0 0

It is unfortunate that the Pakistani government refused to both provide security for Ms. Bhutto and to allow her to pay for her own security.

Like Corazon Aquino, Bhutto was a member of the elite; that was the only way she could have been part of the political process at all. She didn't create the status quo; she was thrust into prominence by the murder of her father. She promoted an agenda of economic justice that Pakistan desperately needs. Blaming her for the ills of Pakistan's culture that she was trying to change is unreasonable and logically dishonest.

Pakistan has many educated people, and like in most countries, you can find a thousand Thomas Jeffersons on any university campus. Pakistan's democratic parties need to find new leadership, and the West needs to support democracy in Pakistan by using carrot-and-stick influences with the military dictatorship.


GLOBAL SLAVERY
said
0 0

Ok... sorry to burst everyone's bubble but Bhutto was EXTREMELY corrupt anyway. If Musharaf gave her power things would not be any better. Her arrival brought a bomb attack that killed 142 people even after she'd been warned to stay away... And now, people will use her death as a justification for more killing. Also, the notion of Al Queda is hilarious... When will you people realize that Al Queda is NOT an islamic extremist group but rather a means of creating global tension for economic and political reasons... The ones carrying out the attacks do it for Allah, the ones planning them do it for the new world order. Learn something from American politics here: The LEFT and the RIGHT all answer to the same master. Wake up.


Anne
said
0 0

To those who blame Bhutto for being born into a wealthy family....we have no control over whose family we are born into, to those who blame her family for hiring the poor to work their land....who are they going to hire? the rich?....to those who blame her for sticking her head through a sunroof or leaving the confines of her home....all of us should have the freedom to go wherever we want without fear of being killed. None of us have seen any proof of corruption during her years of prime minister and it seems to me a convenient way for others not in power to get rid of somebody they dont want in that position. Bhutto stood for freedom and democracy and was well aware of the risks of returning to Pakistan, a country she loved. Regardless of your political beliefs, you have to admire her courage.


Pete
said
0 0

Am I the only one who doesn't think Al Qaeda was responsible?

Pakstan is a huge draw card for recruits. Killing Bhutto would only turn thousands of potential recruits against them. They may be evil...but they are not stupid. I'm pretty sure they would know the consequences of assassinating her would far outweigh the benefits.

It seems to me the obvious person to gain from all of this is Musharaf. And how convenient to be able to blame Al Qaeda without any hard evidence


J-F (Ottawa)
said
0 0

Pakistan, Iraq, Iran, Israel, Palestine, Afghanistan..Anyonesee a trend here?

Are these not "Holy" lands? These regions have been fighting for thousands of years and it will NEVER end. How can some people be surprised at what happened to Ms. Bhutto? There is NO common goal or ground in any of these regions and advancement towards democracy (if that really is the answer) is but an idealistic dream. Someone will always oppose by violence. All of this brought by different religious beliefs. Just to show you what negative aspects RELIGION has on the world. The entire Middle East is corrupt by religious extremists and the rest of the world is now paying for it as they infiltrate our lands.


Sandra
said
0 0

Let's all take a deep breath and put the blame of who committed this heinous act behind us.
It will not bring her back, but just fuel more hatred.
The world will never find out the real truth.
I wish the populous in Pakistan my deepest sorrow and wish for them one day to live in a peaceful and prosperous country.
My prayer are with you all.



Laurel
said
0 0

She died from hitting her head on a sunroof? Sure she did. Just like Victor Yuschenko wasn't poisoned, he ate "bad sushi." And Zahra Kazemi wasn't beaten to death, she fell down and hit her head. These kinds of explanations are rarely believable.


Vic
said
0 0

I do not know and I do not care about her political ideas. But I deeply appreciate her braveness as a woman.

Whoever behind this bloody murder is a shame!

It is some cowards who dared not to face a woman but tried to solve their problems by killing her.

What a shame!


Noor Jahan
said
0 0

Benizir was forced from office because she was a crook. Plain and simple. Deomocracy for her and her ilk is an exercise performed every four years (ie: elections) for the benifit of the internatinal press. Those who think that the last Ms. Bhutto was some sort of selfless 'Mother Teresa' should do a search of the internet and learn about their 'fallen martyr'. She spat on her people and really held the masses in contempt. In her mind and in the minds of her fellow zamindars (land owners), the people were just so many animals for their service and amusement. I really wish that those who applaud her actually knew her.


Pray for Peace
said
0 0

I never really cared for Ms Bhutto much before this but now I've realized what an amazing woman she was and how much she meant to her people. The alquaida leader has congratulated his people for murdering her. When will we ever open our eyes and really try to defeat and humble this wicked enemy.


Dudeman
said
0 0

What I find interesting is that Bhutto's death is now being claimed to be caused by a skull fracture from hitting her head on the sunroof of the car. If this is the case, that she did not die from gunshots or from the shrapnel of the explosion, then can her death technically be called an assassination? Can it be said that the Taliban or AQ assassinated Bhutto? Yes, perhaps these groups are behind the assassination attempts, however if the attacks were not the direct cause of her death, then they did not assassinate her. In fact there was no political assassination. What happened, according to the offical Pakistani report, was that a politician had two attacks made on her life and in the chaos of these events she accidently hit her head while trying to seek cover inside her automobile. Of course this is assuming the official report is true and not some sort of coverup.


LD
said
0 0

Religious fanatics/extremists/terrorists/warlords?...seems to me it is the same religion time and again through history that has difficulties. And to thank our liberal gov't...we will get to see this first hand very soon!!


Nick T
said
0 0

To: Allan Eizinas


You said: "The Taliban are already gaining ground in Afghanistan ..."

Can you site your sources of information on this? I have never heard this from any news feed anywhere, so I am curious as to where you got this information

As for the Bhutto saga, it's unfortunate she died, but what is even sadder still is the way the people of Pakistan are handling it. The news calls them 'protesters', the way I see them, they are rioters. These are not demonstrations or protests, they are acts of utter violence and social chaos. The people of Pakistan should set an example for everyone else and mourn properly and in a civil manner, not by destroying your country men's/women's livelyhoods and belongings... They should be ashamed of themselves.


Mohamed please explain....
said
0 0

You said "May Allah accept her as a martyr in his paradise!"...

My understanding is that suicide bombers believe they are doing allah's work and go to paradise... please explain how this all works... a somewhat confused westerner. Thank you.



Raymond
said
0 0

Funny, the very same people screaming about Bhutto's death and lamenting the loss of a voice for democracy in Pakistan are the same bunch who so vehemently oppose Canada's role in Afghanistan as well as the Karzai government. You want to see real chaos? Let the Taliban reclaim Afghanistan & allow the fundamentalists to control Pakistan's nuclear capability. Perhaps a North American Missile Defense Shield isn't such a bad idea after all.


Lou
said
0 0

for Laurel

have you ever been in an explosion? I have and I can tell you that the force of an explosion will cause your body to do things that you would never expect.

I have personally been in the back of a vehicle hit by a roadside bomb...It is not good.

That fact is that she died. Lets not dwell on how she died...other than it was murder.


barry
said
0 0

I will try again to add a comment on this tragedy. Mrs Bhutto's killers have only given strength to her cause. Presidents Bush and Musharaaf are the cause of her death. Now they have the most to lose with her death. Maybe now the west will stop sticking it's big noses where it doesn't belong. Looking at the west and seeing the greed and the lust for power, who would want "democracy"? And to say something as stupid as now is the time to make a pre emptive strike, sounds too american to me.


Vince M.
said
0 0

Phone intercepts indicate al Qaeda is likely responsible? Who would have guessed?

I thought from reading this board yesterday that contributors were convinced it was George Bush! Or was he busy hand-melting the polar icecaps at the time?




Chris
said
0 0

Of course the Gov't of Pakistan is now going to try and cover up her cause of her death. The Prime Minister of Pakistan and the Gov't want to make it seem all unfortunate. There wasn't even a formal investigation into her initial assassination attempt in October upon her return to the country which killed 150+ people. The World should be very afraid of this current situation which is going to spin out of control..an potential extremist country with nuclear arms....


Lance
said
0 0

Yeah right, Al-qaeda.

Everything is to be blamed on them. More fear-mongering by those who create it.

just another excuse to extend this phony "war on terrorism".


mike
said
0 0

These murderers have only added strength to her movement, for it is always after the death of such leaders that their movements ultimately gain strength. One only has to look at Dr. Martin Luther King as proof.


RJT
said
0 0

Lance: That's exactly what I was going to say.

Al: Has Pakistan ever attacked any nation with nuclear weapons? Are you under the impression that nations store nuclear weapons in cookie jars where even a five year old can get a handful? Try using reason and facts to dispel your hysteria and fear, it will calm you.

disillusioned:People riot b/c they're alive and value their nations future, in N.America we are comotose and numb drones who go from work to home and barely register a pulse. Violence gave us democracy and anger means the people of Pakistan care; did you ever stop and ask yourself why we're so repressed and apathetic in N.America? The answers are disturbing and I wish people in Canada would show more passion and outrage.

It's a terrible way to die but, just b/c she's a woman doesnt make her a saint, heed Bilals post.

j
said
0 0

Phony war on terror? You mean no one has been killed in Bali, Spain, New York, London?? Maybe you can explain your wonderful theories to us simple folk who only read newspapers and watch cable news. Obviously we don't have all the answers.


Scott M
said
0 0

As an outsider to all of this, I think it behooves those of us without detailed knowledge of the political history of and administration by Ms. Bhutto and her party, to be cautious about holding her out as a saviour for Pakistan. Reading the comments, it is clear there were many sides to this woman, both good and bad. The media tends to forget these things in the early days of such a tragic event, but we are starting to hear information on her political past which is far from spotless as many may recall from those days.

No one in her situation deserves to die the way she did and as a woman, her death in this manner is more abhorrent to me. I also feel for her family but we must keep the concerns about the manner of her death and sympathies for her family, separate form the politics of which most of us without ties to Pakistan or academic study in such areas, know little.




Thomas P
said
0 0

She was not provided security? Of course she was! The country was under martial law, and she was even put under house arrest for her own protection.

I even went so far as to say, while the media was reporting on these with its usual liberal bias, that the moment the government eases up protecting her on its terms, something will happen.

And it did.


PW
said
0 0

I want to be careful and hopefully not disrespectful in what I have to say, but we need to recognize that what was assassinated here was an idealistic hope of peace and tolerance in a dangerous part of the world. I'm afraid it's only a matter of time until we read of al qaeda or the Taliban having control of Pakistani nukes.


rahsabum@yahoo.com
said
0 0

Another great leader died. She was a brave, educated woman. RIP Ms Bhutto.

People will forget her in couple of days ... But another hope has died.

JPL
said
0 0

It says in the article

"...she was thrown by the force of an explosion and knocked her head into the sunroof of her SUV..."

But in the video link to the right of this article labeled "Final Moments", clearly there is no vehicle roof where she is. She appears to be sitting in a completely open vehicle without a roof.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz