CTV News | Pakistani ex-prime minister Bhutto assassinated

Top Stories -   

Pakistani ex-prime minister Bhutto assassinated

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Tom Kennedy on the spread of grief
CTV News: David Akin on reaction world-wide
CTV Newsnet: Prime Minister Stephen Harper comments on assassination from Calgary, Atla.
CTV Newsnet: Eric Margolis, Benazir Bhutto's friend and terrorism expert, reacts to the first reports of her death
CTV Newsnet: Editor Sadeed Minhas of the Daily Times Islamabad on the civil unrest around Pakistan's capital
CTV Newsnet: Dawn News Bureau Chief Mubasher Zaidi, in Rawalpindi, Pakistan, explains the scene outside the hospital where Bhutto was taken
CTV Newsnet: Omar Samad, Afghanistan ambassador to Canada, discusses Afghan and Pakistan relations
CTV Newsnet: Security analyst Sunil Ram explains what happens next after this destabilizing act
CTV Newsnet: Husain Haqqani, former adviser to Pakistan prime ministers, reacts to the assassination and what could have been done to prevent it
CTV Newsnet: Tanveer Ahmed, National Federation of Pakistani Canadians, reacts to the increasing instability in Pakistan
CTV Newsnet: Ibrahim Daniyal, Pakistan Peoples Party, expresses his dismay with the attack
CTV Toronto: Chris Eby with reaction from the worried Pakistani community in Toronto
CTV Montreal: Rob Lurie with reaction from Montreal's Pakistani community
CTV Newsnet: Joy Malbon with reaction from Washington to the assassination

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(142)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Thu. Dec. 27 2007 10:19 PM ET

Pakistani opposition leader Benazir Bhutto is dead following a shooting and a suicide bomb attack on her vehicle as she left a public rally in Rawalpindi. She was 54.

As Bhutto waved to supporters from a car's sunroof, an attacker rushed toward the vehicle and opened fire. Her security adviser, Rehman Malik, said the leader was shot in the neck and chest.

The gunman then detonated an explosive device, killing at least 22 other people.

Bhutto was rushed to Rawalpindi General Hospital for surgery but succumbed to her wounds. Wasif Ali Khan, a member of Bhutto's party, said "at 6:16 p.m. she expired."

On Friday, Bhutto's body was being flown to her ancestral cemetery in Garhi Khuda Baksh, a small village in Sindh province. Her coffin was accompanied by her husband and three children.

She's expected to be buried Friday next to the grave of her father, former prime minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, who was removed from power by the military in 1977 and executed.

A doctor who treated Bhutto said one bullet struck the back of her neck, hit her spinal column and exited through the side of her head. Another bullet went through the back of her shoulder and out her chest.

Moments before her death, she had told an ecstatic crowd of supporters that she would fight Islamic militants with Pakistan's own army, rather than depend on foreign soldiers.

"Why should foreign troops come in? We can take care of this, I can take care of this, you can take care of this," she said.

The FBI sent a bulletin to police agencies around the world that suggested al Qaeda had claimed responsibility for the attack, citing information from Islamist websites.

The bulletin also said al Qaeda's second-in-command, Ayman al-Zawahri, may have planned the attack, according to a law enforcement official who spoke to The Associated Press on condition of anonymity.

But Bhutto had several enemies in Pakistan, and had accused Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf's government of doing little to ensure her security at political rallies.

After her death, Bhutto's body was taken out of the hospital, her casket carried aloft by supporters.

Pakistan elections should go on: Harper

Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper offered condolences to Bhutto's family, to the families of the other victims of today's attack, and to the Pakistani people.

"We condemn this attack in the strongest possible terms. This was an abhorrent act of terror. We hope that the government of Pakistan will act to bring the perpetrators to justice."

Harper told reporters in Calgary that the Pakistan election scheduled for Jan. 8 should continue as planned.

"This cannot be allowed to permit any delay in the return of Pakistan to full democracy -- something the people of Pakistan have been waiting for, for far too long," he said.

U.S. President George Bush also condemned the attack.

"The United States strongly condemns this cowardly act by murderous extremists who are trying to undermine Pakistan's democracy," he said from Crawford, Tex.

"We stand with the people of Pakistan in their struggle against forces of terror and extremism. We urge them to honour Benazir Bhutto's memory by continuing the democratic process for which she so bravely gave her life."

United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon called the assassination an "assault on stability", while the UN Security Council went into consultations to discuss the killing.

Three days of mourning

Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf announced three days of mourning and appealed for calm amid word of violent protests erupting across the volatile South Asian nation.

"This is the work of those terrorists with whom we are engaged in war," he said in a nationally televised speech. "Today, after this tragic incident, I want to express my firm resolve ... we will not rest until we eliminate these terrorists and root them out."

Bhutto's supporters at the hospital in Rawalpindi smashed glass doors and stoned cars and many chanted slogans against Musharraf, accusing him of complicity in the assassination.

In Rawalpindi, the site of the attack, Bhutto's supporters burned election posters from the ruling party and attacked police, who fled from the scene. And in the northwestern city of Peshawar as well other areas, angry supporters have taken to the streets chanting slogans against Musharraf.

The death has also thrown the campaign for the Jan. 8 election into chaos. Musharraf has called a high-level emergency meeting to discuss the government's response.

Pakistani opposition leader and former prime minister Nawaz Sharif said on Thursday his party would boycott the election.

"The PML(N) is boycotting the election after the assassination of Benazir Bhutto," Sharif told a news conference in Islamabad, referring to his party.

"Free elections are not possible in the presence of Musharraf... Musharraf is the root cause of all problems."

'She was the party'

Terrorism expert Eric Margolis, who advised Bhutto on security and became friends with her, told CTV Newsnet that her death will throw her party's future into turmoil.

"Bhutto's party which was the largest party in Pakistan -- the Peoples Party -- has now been decapitated," said Margolis. "She dominated the party. She was the party. It was a very personalized party. She does not really have a strong No. 2."

The Pakistan Peoples Party was founded by Bhutto's father, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, who served as a president and prime minister of Pakistan in the 1970s.

Bhutto lost power in a 1977 coup to Gen. Zia Ul-Haq, then the chief of the army staff whom Bhutto himself had appointed. Bhutto was executed in 1979 for allegedly ordering the murder of a political opponent.

Benazir, the oldest of the Bhutto children, vowed to continue the work of her father and won a majority in parliamentary elections in November 1988, at the age of 35.

By 1990, President Gulam Ishaq Khan had dismissed her government on charges of corruption -- charges Bhutto denied. Three years later, Bhutto won the prime ministership once again.

Her government would be dismissed again on corruption allegations in 1996. That same year, her brother Murtaza, also politically active, was shot to death under murky circumstances.

Facing corruption charges that she claimed were politically motivated, Bhutto left Pakistan in 1999, the same year Musharraf deposed Sharif.

Bhutto returned to Pakistan from exile in October 2007 and was campaigning ahead of the January elections. At the rally celebrating her return last October, more than 140 people were killed in another suicide blast. Bhutto was not hurt and remained defiant despite the threats on her life.

Margolis says Bhutto was aware of the dangers she faced and knew that attending rallies was a risk.

"She always said to be a politician and to do her populace politics, she had to be seen, and to move, and to go into the streets. That's the Pakistani style," he told CTV Newsnet.

"She was taking extreme precautions to protect herself, but the point was if she didn't show herself and stayed in seclusion, she would have lost a lot of her popular appeal. She was a street politician, rallying huge numbers of people was her stock and trade."

At the rally in Rawalpindi on Thursday, Bhutto herself explained her motivations:

"I put my life in danger and came here because I feel this country is in danger. People are worried. We will bring the country out of this crisis."

Comments are now closed for this story

jaded
said

I got one word for you: Martyr.


Les
said

The death of Benazir Bhutto creates more political uncertainty in Pakistan. It's a very difficult country to govern. Hopefully a capable leader will be elected in January.


another wanna be dictator less
said

If only guns and bombs were banned this would have never happened.


Sunil
said

Another victim of dirty politics.No words can describe nor justify such evil acts.


jasim khan
said

I am absolutely shocked.
I had tears in my eyes as soon as I saw this news. Whether or not she was good - she was a human and was a strong woman! :(

She was bold and brave.

What a tragic event and tragedy in the family.
May God Bless her soul.


......
said

If guns and bombs were banned, the outcome would be no different... Murder already is, and that stops nothing.


Monty
said

"if only guns and bombs were banned..." ???

Yeah, and if frogs had wings, they wouldn't bump their hindquarters when they hop.

Any realistic suggestions?


Ava
said

What a frightening commentary on politics in Pakistan. We need to be conscious and aware of the hatred and treachery in that country. Why do they have to eliminate their opponents?


shamaro
said

A terrible blow to the attempt of democracy in a nation thwarted by extremists. This is a tragedy that has been waiting to happen since she returned to Pakistan. Civil unrest will now sweep across Pakistan as a result of this and I fear democracy is going to suffer an enormous set back because of these sensless extremists who wish to keep living in stone age standards of living. Shame, just a bloody shame.


Eric
said

Didn't Musharraf say that something like this was going to happen and thats why he took the measures he did? I'm not an expert on Pakistani affairs, by any stretch, but its very obvious they're in a very fractured and unstable situation right now. Maybe history will now look back and recognize that there are times where extreme situation might have to call for extreme measures.


Rob Smith
said

Same corruption, different country.


Erica
said

Brave woman,tragic.


Sophie, Ottawa
said

She represented the only glimpse of hope for democracy in Pakistan. I am completely speechless!



Eric
said

btw: Rest In Peace Benazir!!! The memory of your bravery, and devoution to your people will help them to unite and live in peace and prosperity.


sibliqu khan
said

She was the cause of her own death


JJ
said

Her death is tragic. It further reinforces my suspicion that Pakistan is fooling us in believing that they are on our side, for the sole purpose of providing a heaven for Bin Laden (the tribal lands). I greatly distrust Musharraf who claims to have a democratic approach to politics yet all his actions are one of a dictator. Nothing good will come of this.


ian
said

What a mess that country is.


Bil Surette
said

If you ban guns and bombs, we'd use sticks and stones!! We are inherently violent creatures. What needs to be banned is religion it truly is a scourge on mankind.


Tim
said

Who cares, this sort of thing will happen again and again. I don't think this is an issue that deserves our attention.



Cynthia
said

This is the tragic loss of a beautiful person who only wanted the best for her country. She is a loss not only to Pakistan but to the world.


anna
said

Pakistan cannot afford to let its voice die with Bhutto. The world cannot afford to ignore its voice.


Saddened
said

I am so saddened by this. She was silenced by Musharif - or so it would seem. I have admired her for many many years as one of the bravest and strongest woman on the world political scene.


Barbara
said

Sadly, this could have been and indeed was predicted. It is a horrific event which will have cascading effects in the whole region. We must remember to have compassion for all involved. The only way to end this is with forgivness and compassion. Pray!


Cary
said

and that country has the bomb??!!!! It's sad to think that people live in that kind of environment. The thing is there is no real answer to the issues in the middle east. Things will only change if the people want it. I know our intentions are good but it may be for nothing. We cannot will madmen into our view of humanity and democracy.


Doug
said

Animals!


Michael
said

"The cause of her own death" Hmmm How short-sighted. If there were more political leaders with her courage and convictions there would be fewer evil cowards out there that would commit such atrocities.

The world has lost a great leader.


Peter
said

I fear that the current government in Pakistan could have done more to protect her and "let this happen"


A threat to the west?
said

Is this the early stages of what is hoped will be an Islamic run government which has control over nuclear weapons? If it is get ready for some serious problems.


BK
said

Nothing New,

United States and other western Countries have always opposed any movement toward democracy on that region. This is another cowardly act to stop a country inching toward democracy


Leslie
said

This saddens me. She was a passionate woman who wanted democracy for her country. Now what?


Regulus
said

Homework for cultural relativists. What is the origin of the word 'assassin?'


RJT
said

"We need to be conscious and aware of the hatred and treachery in that country".

Ava it is American imperialism and treachery that killed Bhutto.Musharraf is most likely behind her assisination and Bush is his biggest and staunchest supporter, which makes the Americans complicit in her murder and terrorism. The Americans and Musharaf have just quashed any movement towards democracy in Pakistan, the ZioNeoCons will never allow democracy to take root in Muslim nations b/c then they will have to deal with the Muslim people on an even and transparent playing field. With corrupt dictators in power, the Americans can prop them up, support them financially, militarily, politically and diplomatically so that the Americans can run rough shod over the region and continue their expansionist imperialist wars.

There was nothing brave about Bhutto, she lost her governments twice to corruption and for all intents and purposes, was chased out of the country for her shady dealings. Her entire family died by assasination or mysterious circumstances; not the familial history of a honorable states woman.

So long as America and Israel continue their military and economic domination of the entire region, no Muslim nation will have democracy.

This is the sad and dangerous truth.

There are no good guys in the current global political environment.

Im sad the woman was killed but, her intentions were never honest so lets not make a hero out of her.


D.R. - Calgary
said

hey peter...
Mushariff had her in protective custody and she wanted nothing to do with it. I am no fan of him, by any means and think that Bhutto could have quite possibly been a great leader in that country. But I think we all realize that there is much more going on here than what is seen on the surface. Pakistan has only begun the chaos that is yet to come.


Allan Eizinas
said

Some nations appear to not be ready for a democracy. There is a fine line between bravery and foolishness. It appears that Bhutto crossed that line.

With the history of assassination attempts on her life, how was anyone allowed to get that close to his target?

The 15 million Pashtun who have been infiltrated by the Taliban on the Pakistan border will now be emboldened to support the 15 million Pashtun in Afghanistan.

This is bad news for Canada.



Bob
said

It is so sad to hear of her death. She was the only one who could save Pakistan.

In years to come you may just find it was caused by the CIA and G. W. Shrub. He cannot allow democracy come to Pakistan.




SAIFUL NIZAM ABDUL LATIP
said

She survived many suicide attacks before, now her time has come to leave this world.


Max Wedge
said

I recall that she promised to crack down on militants and extremeist in the tribal regions.

Apparently they took her at her word.

A shame...


Jake
said

While it is saddening to hear of her death, im amused that militants(govt or otherwise) believe they can remove a problem with force.Ideas are bulletproof and cannot die.Someone will step foward and replace her and continue to fight tyranny.


jd
said

To: another wanna be dictator less.

Guns and Bombs hae nothing to do with this. If they didn't use those weapons they would have found another way. This is about Corruption, greed and power. Something every political party in Pakistan desires, and is willing to do anything to obtain, or hold onto. The rest of the world has to wake up, and stop dealing with corrupt governments. Exclude them from trading, slap serious sanctions against them Leave these countries out in the cold for 10 or 15 years, with no support of any kind, let it be financial, humanitarian etc.. Western countries should stop everything including accepting immigrants and refugees from these countries. Things would change. Why would they, The people of the countries would make them change.


Josh from Vancouver
said

Watch who you call animals; the beasts in Washington have murdered over 650 000 innocent people in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Cary,it is utterly laughable that you think 'our intentions are good'. If you had even one ounce of knowledge of the geopolitical situation in the region and the necessity for the Americans to maintain the status quo in Pakistan to continue their endless wars for global domination via military control (PNAC), you would know that no one in the west has a single good intention towards any people of color, particularily Muslims. Pakistan is not in the Middle East; however there are very clear solutions to the issues in the ME,starting with a fair and final resolution to Israels militarism in Palestine and Lebanon, withdraw American troops from Saudi Arabia and engage the UN to resolve the American created humanitarian disaster in Iraq. Oh! And don't invade Iran.

The mad men you blather about are in Washington.


James
said

Martyr? Ok. Bad for Canada? Bad for the world.
As long as instability reigns over there, it will affect the whole world.


David H
said

A huge loss for the region and the world. I'm deeply saddened.


Peter
said

Hey D.R.-
Bhutto had recently expressed concern about a lack of security for her safety.


Nat
said

I was also absolutely shocked to read this... I was worried that this would happen. My heart goes out to her family and to Pakistan. She has become a martyr of democracy in Pakistan. I pray that this will only do what she would have wanted, that this will further push democracy in her country. She wouldn't have wanted that push to stop with her. May God Bless her soul, and bring peace to her family and country.


Richard
said

My first reaction was, "sure is easier to run a country with less opposition..."


Andre
said

sibliqu khan
She was the cause of her own death???
What kind of logic you live by sibliqu? Cowards use suicide bombers, the brave use elections to define their destinies.




Dixie from Alberta
said

I just don't understand the culture of death that absorbs some in this world. Too many embrace death so easily that they do not know how to live. There is something fundamentally backward & wrong with those that don't want their children to actually grow up and prosper - that they would sacrifice peace and tranquility for war and turmoil. It so against the basic human instinct to survive. I just don't get it? The mess that this country is in really worries me because of their nuclear capabilities.
Its a very sad day when the fanatics kill someone whose only wish for their country was peace and prosperity. Will it ever end??


PW
said

this is sad and terrible news. we in the west need to keep a close eye on this as Pakistan is another powderkeg just waiting to go off.

where are our world leaders in all of this???


Bilal Abdullah
said

Martyr? Martyr for what? She was a child of a corrupt prime minister. (Zulfikar Ali Bhutto) and tyrant landlord who kept thousands of slave laborers on their properties. Benizir was both corrupt and incompetant as prime minister. She really did not care about the people of Pakistan. She just wanted to get her hands on the country's purse strings yet again. Her husband, Ali Zardari, was 'Mr. 10 %'. I feel sorry for her children. Sadly, Pakistan is a ship without a rudder. There are not selfless, honest potential leaders in this country. Sad.


Marcy
said

Another blow to democracy. This region of the Earth is lost, it seems that more people desire war than peace. I wonder if the western world should just give up on imposing democracy on them and let them live the way they want to live.


PBW
said

I wonder why sibliqu khan says:
She was the cause of her own death.

Is it because he believes women should be kept in their place and denied the right to even show their face? Attitudes like that belong in the 8th century, not the 21st.

Ms. Bhutto may have been a corrupt politician - who knows what the case truly was? - but SHE was a politician in a country where to be female is to be marginalized to a greater or lesser extent.

One can only hope that the group that organized her murder identifies itself, so that the military government can at least pretend to be democratic, by locating the group and bringing all know members to trial for conspiracy to murder. To do otherwise would be to support her assassination and the continued oppression of women in Pakistan.


Some guy in Ottawa
said

It's really only a matter of time before this mindless violence reaches our own shores. We'll be equally unprepared, and equally powerless to prevent it.


Ian C
said

Just tragic.


nbjess
said

I am totally shocked. She was the best thing that Pakistan had going for them. I was afraid for her since she returned. Pray to GOD that the country can recover.


Glenn
said

Benazir's life over? Perhaps. Then again, in 3 days, might we witness a miracle ressurrecton or the deification of another prophet?


Jindy Khan
said

I cannot believe it. Just a few days ago Pakistan was in the news regarding governmental issues and now we learn that Bhutto is presumed dead? Time has flown faster than expected.


Scott
said

Josh, The UN you say? If only you understood how useless they are. What did they do for Yugoslavia during the war? NOTHING!! What did they do when US wanted to go into Afghanistan and Iraq? NOTHING!!! Why? Because where does most of the money come from? All the UN is, is a 3rd world run US supported organization!!!


Elizabeth, Toronto
said

If she was a man, would we bat an eye-lash? Just putting that out there.



Andrew
said

We're all missing the major point here. And it's that, Al-Qaeda has taken Pakistan under seige in hopes of acquiring their nuclear arsenal.

Her death is another footstep for the enemy.

Their vision of world domination will be ever more clear unless this world wakes up!


M. Cameron
said

I have heard reaction from officials of many countries but where is our country's reaction? Is Harper still sleeping?


Lart from Above
said

Dictatorship and terrorism are two sides of the same coin; the lack of freedom breeds terrorists, and the lack of security is used to justify the dictators. Musharraf has been using US military aid to suppress democratic movements while tolerating Islamic extremists in the Northwest Province and elsewhere.

Democracy is the long-term solution. The challenge for the people of Pakistan is to channel their voice through other leaders now. Pakistan's democratic leaders need to work to solve Pakistan's core problems of poverty and inequality.

The West, and particularly the United States, need to scale back support for Pakistan's military caste and realize that long-term peace and security can only be built on a foundation of democratic government. The Taliban have grown in power on Musharraf's watch. Musharraf is the problem, not the solution to the issues of peace and security in Pakistan.


Kiranprit
said

This is such a sad tragedy....She was a strong woman and she could of saved Pakistan....I always wondered if all these bombers were animals..I guess they are. What I mean is that god gave them a brain..and they still don't know how to use it...What a shame..I would say one thing to them...They have no LIFE!!


Nick T
said

I am not surprised this happened. Religion + Political instability = chaos/bad outcome.

People wonder why the west has become less religious as time passes...


Cary
said

Josh,

MY intentions and the intentions of most Canadians are good when it comes to oppressed people and countries, although we have no real involvement in Pakistan other than possible want of a responsible democratic government. Not sure how "our intentions" infers that I go along with U.S. asperations? Bit of a stretch my friend.Just to clarify, I am Canadian. I understand how you are linking the Western world with US foriegn policy, but I was speaking as a Canadian citizen, and as a individual.

BC
said

And we complain in Canada about our partisan politics, leaders and opposition leaders in all levels of government. Canada is certainly far from perfect but in comparison to almost all countries in the world we are still envied. We must continue to respect our democratic process regardless as to which party is in power and ensure that our checks and balances allow for a level playing field for all.


Barry C.
said

It's sad but some realism is needed. She wasn't going 'to save' Pakistan. She was an integral part of what was wrong with Pakistan....corruption, violence and ingrained division.


Ahmed, Toronto
said

As cold as it may sound, returning from 'self-imposed' exile was her own decision.


Roger
said

After her return from exile it seemed only a matter of time before another attempt on her life would be made. There are many suspects ranging from elements within Musharraf's government to the Pakistani Taliban to al Qaeda; all had reasons to want her out of the way. Pakistan is a fractured tribal state, not a nation state, only the army holds it together. The future does not look overly rosey.


oleg
said

So she heavily guarded in her home and she didn't like it so they gave her what she wanted. Now people are surprised she was killed? Some people are trying to blame the US for some reason, she was speaking out against extremists who are present everywhere in that country. If anyone's to blame, it's them. And to people who claim she should have been better protected, have you actually seen twenty thousand people in person? It is impossible to stop one suicide bomber in that kind of situation.


Al Tees
said

Regardless of what your personal viewpoints are let us just hope that Pakistan does not disolve into civil war. This would have an incredibly disasterous impact on the region and consequently the world.


claude
said

Did anyone expect a different outcome?


Sherry from Ottawa
said

First of all Bhutto knew what could easily happen before she ever returned to Pakistan but still had such a strong belief in herself that she still went back. She was a smart woman - don't tell me she didn't think of this each day. Also, with the way terrorists and especially the Taliban work, the likely hood that they committed this murder is I believe 100%. That is their way -to create instability, kill as many as they can and inflict as much terror as possible. Not to mention hopefully those that are shall we say "uninformed" will most likely blame Musarraf and take to the streets - all coreograffed nicely by the terrorists. You can ban all the guns, missiles etc in the world - it would never stop terrorists, murderers etc - and to think otherwise is horribly naive.


Denis
said

What an outrage. The world needs to ban the use of terrorism for political gains.


Martin Crawley
said

I think this is a sad day for Pakistan and the world, because democracy is failing. It is the western nations duty to enforce democracy, and put pressure on Pakistan's Government to bring these criminals to justice.


Wm.
said

A terrible, tragic turn of events to snuff out opposition in a country torn apart politically, emotionall, religiously, and so many ways. Watch out Canada and the rest of the civilised world, . . . because we will now see an absolute flood of refugees from Pakistan infesting our free countries with their demands as they move in and take over our country. Don't think it possible ??? Get back to me in 5, 10 or 15 years.

Global village ? But global strife, anarchy, and death comes with the package.


Daniel
said

Doesn't surprise me from these types of countries. If they could prosper from an honest days work, they'd be too busy to devise evil.


Johann Flores -Vancouver
said

This smells like Al Qaeda (or other extremist faction) as much as it might be a plot by Musharaf. Both do stand to gain.

But you saw how the world reacted when Musharaf declared marshal law. Everybody turned on him. Now with the death of Bhutto the fingers are all pointed his way again. Unless it can be proven that Musharaf had nothing to do with it, the western world will not sit quietly as he seeks re-election in January. And even IF it were proven that Musharaf was not part of this plot who would believe it anyways?

You have a large chunk of the population that's anti-western and that's on top of the extremists in that country. And with a national literacy rate of 54% you're looking at a lot of people that can be swayed (by suggestion or threat) to vote a certain way during election time. And we aren't even speaking about blatant cheating yet, either.

You're looking at another country in the East on the brink of destabilization.

We got a reprieve when the U.S. national intelligence estimate came back saying Iran had stopped nuclear weapons research back in 2003. But Pakistan DOES have nuclear weapons.


P
said

Hmmmm, well, I just wonder how many of you remember why she was booted out of the country in the first place... just because she is a woman doesn't mean she is above treachery, greed, corruption and violence... (thanks Bilal for reminding everyone).

As for her being a martyr - Yep you bet...
I was waiting for this. and I wonder if she did not know that this would eventually happen and set herself up as a Martyr - out in a blaze of glory - what a way to go down in history...

Makes me feel very unsecure sitting here working across the road from the pakistan consolate... all it takes is one crazy @$$ to do something stupid.... Yep I feel real secure here in my safe secure country...


Sarah
said

Very Tragic.


mo kongo
said

The problem is not that she was a woman but a corrupt person coming from a family with a lot of tradition for corruption and indiference,same as aquino from the philipines if you remember.but still she didn't deserve to die.


Richard S
said

We're at war people. We must go into Pakistan with the U.S. and restore order and rid the country of the islamist militants who deny freedom and our way of life. We must protect Pakistan before it's too late.


Br
said

It's a very sad time. I feel for the people of Pakistan. Regardless of what kind of a leader she was, I believe she was killed by the Bush and his puppet Musharaf. her death will certainly cause a civil war which is what's behind this killing in the first place. I believe the real terrorists who sit in Washington won't rest until they create a civil in every muslim country.


J-F (Ottawa)
said

To Shamaro and Some Guy in Ottawa:

Although I have thoughts of my own on this matter, you both summed up my thoughts exactly, the chance of democracy has been halted by this occasion and I agree it's just a matter of time before we deal with the same extremist activities on our own turf.


Mark
said

The world loses another leader. Wonder what role the current regime had in her death? Seems to coincidental to blame it on a lone homicide-bomber, especially this close to an election.


larry
said

The West, including the U.S.A. supported Bhutto as a voice of moderation due to concerns with the extremists obtaining nuclear weapons and instability in general.
Linking the U.S.A. with her assination is at best incongruous with common sense. Of course those that blame this on the U.S.A. are often of the same ilk that likely blame the latest snow fall on Stephen Harper or sun spots on George W. Looking to score political points, when this is really a story of deep mourning.


Nancy
said

We need to maintain the fight on Terror.

My thoughts and prayers are with the Pakistani People, who lost a beautiful woman.


Aarij
said

The western world (USA to be specific) don't want democracy in Pakistan. The current president is America's puppet and they can control Pakistan. This is either Musharraf, America or both.


Lou
said

Why are people so shocked to hear about this? Have your heads been in the sand for the past few months? I am only surprised that it did not happen sooner.

A great leader - NO.
A corrupt leader - YES.

Good for democracy - YES
Good for Pakistan - NO.

The Middle East and South East Asia is not yet ready for Western style democracy. After all, who is to say that our way of life is best for those in troubled parts of the world.


al
said

She has done so much for Pakistan. It's sad to see her die in this fashion.
It's a huge tragedy for the country since partition. She being a Shia Muslim with Pakistan having a Sunni majority, and the factor of male dominance to it would have made it harder for her to govern the country.
Hope Pakistan goes under right direction of Musharraf and does not become a failed state like Iraq or Somalia.



Carol & Lydia in Toronto
said

Benazir Bhutto was passionate about her people and said she would do more to help fight and get rid of the terrorists if elected President when she met the leader of Afganistan last week.
We lost a good partner in the fight against terrorism.


Adele - Help Stop violence against women
said

As a woman I feel one of my sisters has fallen to violent brutal men.
We need to stand with all our sisters over there and stop the violence against women.


MJ
said

Just Pray for the departed soul and also for that country. It is in a mess.


Minna
said

Larry: You are dead wrong. Bush supported Musharaff over Bhutto and the entire world for several weeks while Musharaff declared a State of Emergency and began cracking down on 'democratic' demands; exactly what pile of sand do conservatives stick their head into?

Democracy in any Muslim nation will never work for American foreign policy towards Muslims. Your comment is incongruous with the facts.

Also, this fabricated fearmongering about 'extremists getting nukes' is beyond RIDICULOUS. Conservatives watch too much television. America has the largest nuclear stash of any nation and is the only nation to ever use nuclear weapons. Also, in several years America has invaded two nations and is preparing to invade a third: the agressors and religious extremists are the Americans.


Fergie
said

Monty wins for BEST COMMENT EVER!!!

I even added it to my favorite quotes on facebook


GB
said

Another tragic moment for democracy and for the victims and their families. I read with interest the comments above. We can accuse if we want a number of people and/or organizations. Will we ever truly know the truth behind this tragedy? Likely not. I disagree with the comments on the banning of "terrorism, guns and bombs...". That's like saying to a whole bunch of addicts "All right, no more drugs guys..." No matter what you try to ban, it takes a concerted effort to stop the trade of weapons you seek to ban and a lot of cooperation from like-minded people.

Can we prevent this? Not completely, at least not overnight. Changing the mindset of a people is a long and slow process that has lots of bumps in the roads. But it is a road we must nevertheless embark upon. As limited as the UN is as a world organization, it is probably still one of the best avenues from which one can start a movement of democratization and liberalization of countries around the world. I still hope and yearn for peace and equality for people but mankind has not reached that level of maturity yet. As a Canadian citizen, I hope and actually work for peace and pray for the souls of the victims as well as for those of the perpetrators of this act.


David
said

Perhaps her death will be the catalyst which forces Pakistan to finally crack down seriously on Islamic Extremists. If Musharraf would cooperate NATO and Pakistan could pin these extremists in the mountains from both sides and annihilate them.


Katherine Hoffman
said

She was the great hope for Pakistan. What will happen now? Let us hope that this will somehow rally the people of Pakistan for good.


nell
said

How wrong ,how sad. This woman who only wanted to see the seeds of freedom and democracy for her people.Who subjected to herself to being alienated from her children in order that she could bring her country forward into the twenty first century!I weep for their loss of a loved one and I say to them their mothers courage and strength also runs through them be proud.


MrD
said

to Bil Surette: Religion is not the issue. Greed or lust of Power, maybe in the name of religion, is the issue. Look at what the USSR was. Anti-religion yet the lust for power was huge and the corruption...?! It's what's in mens heart that matters and no one can force a change but that person. However, thru loving action, we somehow effect change in others. Inspiring others to make a change within.


Ken
said

Let's see... In recent history, the U.S. supported the Shah of Iran, Saddam Hussein of Iraq, Pervez Musharraf of Pakistan.

Can't it just be assumed now that if the U.S. supports your Middle East rule, that corruption and dictatorship, and instability will follow?

Who here actually believes that Musharraf had nothing to do with this assassination, directly or indirectly?? And who here actually believes it won't just get swept under a rug and forgotten?


Rob
said

I think that we are in for troubled times when your so called "TERRORISM" can be used as an excuse or disguise for everything from invading a country to assassinating an opposition leader. I think that "V for Vendetta" is a good warning of what the new political landscape will be and how "TERRORISM" can be used as a tool by politicians (from the west and east) who have NO REAL interest in creating a true democracy and are only concerned with creating a one world government. WAKE UP PEOPLE


Allan K. from Vancouver, B.C.
said

Gah... people... if you are thinking of saying very rude comments about the life of Bhutto, I suggest that you do not say them HERE.

It is very heartless to say that:
- democracy should not be in Pakistan or in the Middle East (right... when the people already want democracy in Pakistan, and who said democracy can't reach new places?)
- she deserved her own death (if she was helping Pakistan reach democracy, how did she deserve it then?)
- we do not need to care (ahem... would you not care if your family got murdered?)
- the US, the west, Israel, and Musharraf are complicit or playing a role in the murders (remember, you are innocent until proven guilty, and the US only weakly supported Musharraf after the emergency rule and did not say anything about killing Bhutto. It is also absurd to think that Israel and other Western countries are behind this.)

I am shocked and saddened by the assassination of Bhutto. This is a tragic blow to the relative stability which, although weaker than before Musharraf imposed the emergency rule, kept Pakistan from going into total chaos and unrest.

- Allan K.


Ken
said

Unfortunately Pakistan is not likely to be governed under a democracy for a very long time. I'm not sure this society is capable of supporting a democracy for an extended period of time given it's radical and highly emotional nature.


PA
said

I'm very upset that in Canada we have so many supporters for Pakistan that are in Canada and wanting leaders in Canada to help there country if you want to support your country go back home and support it but do not ask Canada to help in any way and dictate to Canadians on what should be done now to help that country. In Canada we have problems also and if you want to take up a cause and help people in Canada that are living in the streets and starving in this Country called Canada. We should just let them solve there own problems and not get involved it's the best thing..


Pete
said

Ok people get a grip here, don't forget that this was a women who twice fled her country amid allegations of corruption, bribery and murder.

Her father was hanged for corruption after which she swore to carry on his work.

After a falling out with members of her family her brother is murdered during a robbery and his wife "mysteriously" dies in London of food poisoning.

She returns now to Pakistan and her husband who is still facing corruption chooses not to.

An attempt on her life several weeks ago that killed over 150 people didn't slow down her lust for power. Oh no out she goes and who cares how many die as long as she gets power.

And the crap from Prime Minister Brown and President Bush calling the assassins "cowardly" is a bit over the top as both represent countries have a long and proud history of using assassination when it suits their own purposes.

If you look at her honestly she was just another self serving oily politician on par with the worst of them


Ahmad/ Calgary
said

Barry C.
"It's sad but some realism is needed. She wasn't going 'to save' Pakistan. She was an integral part of what was wrong with Pakistan....corruption, violence and ingrained division."

One of the few rational comments



Chris
said

What a shame...senseless violence.


VancouverDave
said

All those who are recalling how wonderful Bhutto was appear to have forgotten why she was exiled in the first place - extreme corruption while in power led to her being banned from politics in her own country.
She only returned because her ill-gotten gains were running low, and she needed to top up her fortune.


Lou
said

To Allan K

How can you be shocked about her assassination?

If you had any idea of what goes on in that region this should be of no surprise.

Democracy will never work in countries that still live by tribalism and where religion is not separated from state.

Having just returned from Afghanistan I can tell you how western culture and middle eastern culture do not mix.

Democracy is possible but it will take hundreds of years.

I revert to my original comment that who are we to say that our way of life is best.


Iqbal
said

Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was executed after a military coup just a few kilometers from this assassination. Politics is a dangerous business.


siyanga
said

This is a sad development. The women or so called gender activists should support the cause of Bhutto. A lot of uncertainty has now been created in Pakistan Politics.


Don Taylor
said

This brave woman was clearly a gem in a corrupt political system.

These stupid people have zero sense as they kill everything that is good and a benefit to them.

jeffy
said

She should never have returned to Pakistan. She chose exile over facing all the charges brought against here there. That is not a sign of a Martyr in my eyes. She came back to regain power solely. Her father was crooked as she was also it very likely appears. Loss of life is always extremely sad, but I don't think she was the answer to Pakistan's problems. The U.S.A should play this situation very carefully....their friends/allies are dwindling down to almost solely self justification for the so called War on Terror. The War on Terror ranks maybe top 25 in my list of World problems, but for 6-7 years the President of the U.S.A has been blood/oil hungry. Mark my word 2008 won't mean a new President for the U.S.A, provisions to bypass that have been taken care of.


Mike R.
said

Truly a tragic loss, my sincerest wishes for her family and her country who needed her.

As for the people who demand "banning" this, that, and the other: It is truly the dullard who believes problems can be solved by trying to control others in what they can see, speak, possess, think, feel. Dictators throughout history have tried - and failed. People who are into Banning are no better than the people they seek to restrict.


Roshanali
said

One might argue that was it not that the Emergency Law needed more time to continue? However, the pressure from the West and Opposition Parties themselves, it was lifted immaturely! Moreover, President Musharraf himself had (warned) mentioned that Bhutto should delay her returen (from exile) to Pakistan! Anyhow, in religious term it is said that her death drew her closer and faster.


j
said

What a tragic day. For all the cynical naysayers of Bhutto/US/Musharraf;
What are your solutions?? You have none except rehashing old tired Chomsky diatribes. Keeping looking for solutions from behind those textbooks while the rest of the world keeps on looking for real solutions to the real problems that exist today.



Photo Editor
said

OWP has gained exclusive evidence and undeniable proof that President Musharraf, with the help of an outside faction, was directly involved in the assassination of Benazir Bhutto. Designed to look like a suicide attack by a terrorist network, she actually died from the result of a gunshot just before the suicide bomber detonated his bomb on her charade. Further details are still unraveling, but OWP has confirmed that a gunman hired by President Musharraf fired the single shot that killed her. Unfortunately, with the support of the US as well as controlled US and Pakistan media networks, this involvement by President Musharraf is and will continue to be concealed.

Those that are interested in the truth and not big-nation cover ups, through our network of localized photographers and photojournalists already based across our worlds developing nations, One World Photography (OWP) has some of the only photos and video footage on Benazir Bhutto, the Bhutto Family and other relative images out of Pakistan and the region. www.oneworldphoto.org




Trudy
said

She went back there and she must have known she was a target. They were probably taking bets in Vegas on how long before this happened to her. In a way, she asked for it. The UN, Canada, the US should just stay out of it. Trudy


Melli
said

Sorry to hear of her passing...senseless violence. What really scares me is the NUKES they have..chaos in Pakistan is a recipe for disaster.



Bill in Seattle
said

In addition to my earlier comment, anyone who thinks that women should have a separate roll from men is just promoting another form of slavery. Rules and traditions based religious dogma belongs back in the stone age.


me
said

Pakistan has been run under military rule so often in the past, I'm afraid any commentary about Bhutto being corrupt etc can only be taken with a grain of salt, it's convenient to accuse the deposed in this matter.

Pakistan will never be a democratic state, the people at the top don't want it, her assassination, probably indirectly at the hands of Musharraf just drives that home.


Steve V
said

It was meant to happen!
So many attacks against her and still did not get the message and went around like nothing happened. She was brave, admired but also very naive!

Musharaf failed to protect her and her security guards screwed up. This could've easily been prevented.




Dale
said

Who can honestly say they were shocked that this happened?


Bob
said

Get all westeners, including our armed forces, out of that region. The whole area will descend into chaos as extremists use this incident to further their cause.


marshall
said

Her death is a blow to stability in the region.With elections days away, the country in turmoil, it is the prime breeding ground for alqueda and the taliban. They will not control the goverment, but most likely they will have influence.
Pakistan has nuclear weapons and the ability to produce more.
God help us if Pakistan loses control.


Bob
said

This smells like Al Qaeda (or other extremist faction).

The other extremest faction here is the CIA led by George W. Bush.

There is nothing that he would not do in order to preserve Pakistan the way it is.

He is the greatest terrorist in the world.


disappointed
said

Oh really, Mr. Harper and Mr. Bush! Do you seriously expect any of us to believe this is an act of "terrorism" behind which there was no nefarious shadow of Musharraf? Can our political leaders not call the little general on this one at least?


Angela
said

I would like to say that whatever opinions people have about Benazir Bhutto, the fact is that she was a mother & wife as well as someone who brought hope to a very unstable country!!
I like what Josh from Vancouver and a few others had to say about all of this...as for all of you that only spew your bitterness try taking notes & educate yourselves.

Then we wonder why we have no Peace!!

Wake up people, it affects all of us, more than you think!

God bless her & her family.

Angela


Kevin
said

The peoples first reaction is to burn, destroy, loot and fight the police. This is why there will never be democracy in that region. The people don't have the mindset. If a political leader in Canada were assassinated there would be no violence or looting in the streets because we think differently.


Miriam
said

It was just a matter of time, but what a tragedy for the Pakistani people and blow for democracy in the region.



Johan i Kanada
said

Bhutto once said:
"America symbolizes modernity, diversity and democracy, and it is these three things which are the fanatics´ worst fears"

More here:
http://www.johannorberg.net/?page=displayblog&month=12&year=2007#2496

No wonder she was targeted by the islamists.


Maeve
said

How are we to know the true reasons behind these allegations of corruption? Politics is a game. A game in which some pieces have more power than others in order to weild power and force. Bhutto may have come from a history of so-called 'corruption' but how is that defined in this sense, in this political game? It could very well be a fabrication launched against her in order to alter her image, her message, her goal. However she may have been 'corrupted', this is not the underlining issue. Corruption in this country has obviously been embroiled deep down for centuries and it was only a matter of time for someone to go against it and be penalized the way she was.
Enough is enough. There has to be some rest of civilty as we know it will end.


Hank
said

Disappoint...I am sick of you using this incident for more partisan attacks..
The Harper Governement took a strong stance and booted Musharraf out of Commonwealth and our PM has been a vocal critic of the regime.

Tom
said

Anyone with a potical interest could see this coming when Bhutto returned to Pakistan.

Realistically speaking in the political arena with little to no rules and given the location of this event, comes as no surprise.

Death might seem tragic initially, however sometimes good comes out of it, hopefully this will open the Pakistani public's eyes to senseless violence.

Is there any hope for Pakistan?


Alex
said

Thats horrible i cant believe the only leader with a heart for the people was killed.


j
said

Conspiracy theorists:
-Bhutto had stated that she would allow American troops into Pakistan to hunt Al Qaeda
- Al Qaeda or groups linked to Al Qaeda were behind the assassination attempts on Musharraf and the first unsuccessful attack on Bhutto
So Bush is behind this why??? Oh please, bring up the history of the CIA in Iran, Chile, etc. because we have never heard it before!!
If Al Qaeda and/or affiliated groups release a statement that they were behind this, will the conspiracy theorists believe them?? I think we all know the answer to that question, don't we…



Eric
said

Dissapointed -
"Oh really, Mr. Harper and Mr. Bush! Do you seriously expect any of us to believe this is an act of "terrorism" behind which there was no nefarious shadow of Musharraf? Can our political leaders not call the little general on this one at least?"

Does anyone who's pointing fingers have a shred of evidence supporting their conspiracy theories and name calling? Seriously. One piece? And saying "Well Bush wants Oil!" or "Bush wants Pakistan the way it is!" isn't evidence, it's assumptions made off biased opinions. Until someone can produce evidence of Western involvement in this, lay off the conspiracy rhetoric, it doesn't help the situation and only makes you look paranoid and/or partisan. Involving Harper in this assumption just makes you look even more ridiculous.

You all sit around decrying Bush because he acted without evidence, yet when these conspiracy theorists come up with their innane ideas without evidence it's called 'critical thinking'


Al
said

Ms. Bhutto didn't have a chance. Her enemies were many and her return to Pakistan was suicidal. Everyone knew this day would happen soon.

Pakistan is a deeply divided country, much like Iraq and other Mid-East territories.

Tribal hatred is increasingly untethered. And just as it was in Iraq under Saddam the only thing that has been able to keep any semblance of unity and normalcy has been military domination. But even IT is corrupted to the core, and probably at least partly responsible for today's event.

The grand plan for democracy will come at a terrible price, and will likely take at least two generations before true peace is achieved.

I hope it happens, but there will be many more days like today before we see any kind of true peace in the Middle East. The hatred and mistrust is just too deep.




Earl Robert
said

It is sad to read some of the comments. Far too many to list but I must respond to the one regarding Prime Minister Harper. He sent his regrets, what more do you want?


steve
said

Being a Bhutto in Pakistan is about as healthy as being a Gandhi in India. Any odds on which family provides the first third generation martyr.


SA
said

To Richard,
Your views are highly misguided. As a Pakistani I can tell you that there is nothing the West can do by going into Pakistan. What makes you think that if they cannot contain Afghanistan, how can they control Pakistan? I can tell you my countrymen will not tolerate the presence of any outside troops. If we cannot sort out our mess no one else can.


Dwayne M
said

This assassination is a statement of what all is wrong with the world. There is no longer compassion nor tolerance for one another. This is so tragic. I'm not sure what the solution is. It seems hopeless. She was just a person trying to bring democracy to her country, I'm sure she was not without her faults, I don't think she killed anyone. When a mother is killed in this way it just shows how sad the state of affairs is over there. I wish all Pakistan people and particularly the present government can re-examine things and make their country a great place in time. Rest in Peace Ms. Bhutto.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

In Pictures

Pakistani's and their supporters hold candles near photos of Pakistan's former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto at an impromptu rally in a Pakistani neighborhood in New York, Thursday, Dec. 27, 2007. (AP / Seth Wenig)

Life and Death of Benazir Bhutto

Looking at the life and death of Benazir Bhutto. (Warning: graphic content)

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz

Most Talked about Stories

I certainly don't blame him. He wants to at least have a fair shot at a World Series ring -- and it is highky unlikely that would be in Toronto, in his lifetime.
Even the "Beast and Pat team" won't be able to pull off that miracle!
Thanks Doc, for the memories. It was great to have you here this long.
Best wishes for that Ring wherever you land.

Alan

Report: Halladay 'not inclined' to re-sign with Jays