CTV News | Santa crucified to protest Christmas commercialism

Top Stories -   

Santa crucified to protest Christmas commercialism

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: Likeness of Santa nailed to a crucifix

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(53)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Sun. Dec. 23 2007 2:25 PM ET

A Bremerton, Wash. man has registered his protest of the commercialization of Christmas by crucifying Santa.

"Santa has been perverted from who he started out to be," said Art Conrad. "Now he's the person being used by corporations to get us to buy more stuff."

A likeness Santa is nailed to a five-metre-high crucifix outside Conrad's home.

On one of Conrad's Christmas cards, a photo of the crucified Santa carries the message, "Santa died for your MasterCard."

"I don't make a lot of money myself these days, and I definitely feel the expectation to keep up with the pressures of Christmas," he said.

The 52-year-old Conrad, who likes to poke fun at political correctness, is a newcomer to his neighbourhood.

Another of his cards says, "Have a slightly demented Christmas."

While many have stopped to take pictures, no one has told him they are offended, he said.

Others were upset that Conrad used to the head of his animated singing Santa to create the crucifix version, leaving a headless singing Santa to belt out seasonal classics.

Neighbour Jake Tally got a chuckle out of the display, but thought Conrad was putting out a mixed message.

"I don't really know what to think. I know it's about God but Santa has nothing to do with it," he told the Kitsap Sun newspaper.

Conrad told the Seattle Times his display has nothing to do with religion.

He is also unlikely to duplicate the display in the future.

"Like [environmental sculptor] Christo, once you do an installation you don't do it again," Conrad said. "This is my year for this. I don't see the need to do it again."

With files from The Associated Press

Comments are now closed for this story

D. Moore
said

Mr. Conrad gets a two-thumbs-up for his protest against the commercializing of Christmas. I, and many I know, have become sick and tired of "retail racketeering" every December.


cory
said

I am sick and tired of people complaining about christmas (we cannot have this and we cannot do that and sad displays like this.)Well enuff is enuff and get over it christmas is what you make it and if you want to listen to the big corporations then go ahead but donot mess it up for the kids.
P.S. Yes the cross is a symbol of religion


RDL
said

Funny that "Santa has been perverted from who he started out to be,"

Who did he start out to be?

What is perverted is how Christ is now out of Christmas. Where the people who get offended at the mention of it, want all references of it removed. No doubt that these will be the same people who hve no problem with seeing or agreeing with the crucified Sanata.

Yes I totally agree with Art, that Christmas has become far too commercialized but he (Santa)has absooultley nothing to do with our Mastercard or money.

That choice is yours. If we consider the real reason for the season. We will not feel pressure for the expectations of "the Christmas season."

Merry Christmas and may God bless you one and all.


DJC
said

way to go Mr. Conrad! 'Santa died for your mastercard'
what a great slogan. I find it interesting that on the same page I'm writing and reading this, during the season of WAY overspending, there is an ad for debt reduction!
Ah, Christmas! if it doesn't come again for a year it'll be too soon!


Good News!
said

Right on, Mr. Conrad!
Christmas, for many people, has degenerated into nothing more than fattening the bottom line of merchants.
Buy, Buy, Buy!
Must Have!

"A Savior has just been born in David’s town, a Savior who is Messiah and Master."
---The Message (Luke 2:11)


Cross
said

Told my adult kids...no presents...the money goes to food for the underpriveledged. No presents from them to me either...that was included in the kitty.
Funny thing...they, me included, felt so good doing it that next year we decided to walk the streets and go big time.

Wall-Mart and the rest of you box giants...bite my....!



Al
said

I'm sure you would feel differently if you had to explain his actions to a five year old mr. moore


G. Hollett
said

Every year I feel more pressure by retailers to buy, buy, buy. Christmas shopping is promoted after Halloween now, its just sickening. It has been turned into a commercial holiday and not a religious event. I tend to buy one moderate gift for christmas for each family member. I believe birthdays should be used to shower a person with gifts as it is "their day"


G. Hollett
said

Every year I feel more pressure by retailers to buy, buy, buy. Christmas shopping is promoted after Halloween now, its just sickening. It has been turned into a commercial holiday and not a religious event. I tend to buy one moderate gift for christmas for each family member. I believe birthdays should be used to shower a person with gifts as it is "their day"


David - still shopping
said

Christmas is no more commercial than any other aspect of consumer society. Think iPOD, HDTV, vehicles, clothes; this society consumes far in excess of need, such that the term 'needy' and 'poor' require definition. When the entire focus of an economic system is to consume, that religious or other occasions get co-opted is the norm.


Pam Muzeroll
said

The way to fight the commercialization of Christmas is to focus on the religious aspect: send religious Christmas cards, exchange inexpensive gifts, return the focus to the birth of Christ, which is what Christmas is about. This display is perverse.


Earl Robert
said

Did Mr. Conrad do that to make a point or to bring attention to himself?


parks
said

This is ridiculous. I think we need to remember that Christmas inspires children to behave and presents them with morale values. If parents are addicted to shopping, than thats a whole other perogitive.


James
said

I admire those who realize the real meaning of Christmas,althought Jesus wasn,t born on this date.It,s time that we teach our children that we give them a few gifts in memory of someone special and remember those who won,t have gifts.


Santa Bob
said

Warning - unrelated comments...

I guess I'm wondering how this made it as "news". To me it is, at best, an oddity or maybe human interest story.

Even more odd is that it is a "Top Story".

Oh how our journalists and news outlets have devolved in "newstainment"...

PS: Christmas, Xmas, whatever - it's all good !


Mike B
said

I agree that Christmas has become very commercialized.
But im sure that he could have protested in another way.
What a great thing for a young child to see.
A child that doesnt understand that it is not real and that santa will still come Christmas Eve.
A child that is too young to understand the true meaning of Christmas.
If you think Christmas if to commercialized then dont buy the gifts.
Take you family to church Christmas Eve.
Teach your kids the true meaning of Christmas by donating to the food bank or Salvation Army or another charity.
But in my opinion Art Conrad is an idiot with too much time on his hands.
Doesnt he have something better to protest about.
I can think of many things.
Merry Christmas Everyone
Happy New Year
May you find joy in this wonderful time of year.


Marcy
said

That display is outrageous. If I was a parent of a kid living on that street, I'd be extremely mad.
I agree that Christmas has been commercialized but I also know that we have free will . Walmart doesn't come knocking at your door with a gun to your head to buy stuff; we go into the stores and we decide what to do with our Mastercard.
I, for one, enjoy showering my kids with gifts. I am not one of those parents that spoil them rotten, I only buy what they need throughout the rest of the year and Christmas is a time to spoil them. However, we also make sure to remember the less fortunate and to respect the religious meaning of Christmas.
I think this guy is a little over-the-top.


Dan
said

I find it most sad to see this! Though I fully agree about the ridiculous commercialism of Christmas, the Crucifixion, mock or otherwise, of anyone other than Jesus Christ is blasphemy. God sent His Son to this earth to pay the price for the sin of all those who would choose to accept His gift. See John chapter 3 verse 16.

Though I stand to be corrected, to the best of my knowledge, the santa that we know in North America, was always a commercialized symbol........ a marketing concept of Coca-Cola. Santa therefore, was conceived, from the very beginning to maximize profits from the season.

Unfortunately, this world chooses to deviate from the truth, relying on its own flawed wisdom, driven by the greed and love of money.

There are two passages of Scripture which come to mind: "What does it profit a man to gain the whole world but lose his soul"., and, "The love of money is the root to all evil" Take a look around you, I dare anyone to disprove the latter quote.

"As for me and my family, We shall serve the Lord". Happy Birthday, my Saviour and Lord!


Steven
said

Both Santa and the Christ are victims of mass commercialization. The spirit of both characters has been greatly compromised - Mr. Condrad deserves full credit for his message and I only wish the world would listen and look deeper into this stark image - for the crucified Santa is yet another sacrifice at the hands of 21st century consumerism.


Tracy O
said

To RDL, who Santa "started out to be" could be a reference to St. Nicholas, who was a very early Christian from Turkey who was known to be extremely generous to the poor. This person evolved in folklore into a jolly fat guy who gives rich kids more stuff to entertain themselves.


Dan Wright
said

Just another wingnut with a bucket of nails and some wood. This is not a newsworthy story. Move on CTV.


Louise
said

Although i do agree with Mr. Conrad I would not want to be the one trying to explain to a 3 year old (by 5 they should already be in the loop).
I have quite decided that next year the money I have spent on as George Carlin would put "Stuff" will be used to better a little bit the lives of those much less fortunate than myself and my family


Alan
said

"I'm sure you would feel differently if you had to explain his actions to a five year old mr. moore"

Maybe if that five year-old hadn't been lied to by his parents, and pressured by banks and business to BUY BUY BUY, he wouldn't need any explanations! That's all kids (like Cory) see this season as, anyway... a season of GETTING and revelry.

The cross is a religious symbol, alright... the most heinous one there was, in those times, which is why Christ was hung on it. It symbolized paganism, the antithesis of everything Christ stood for, and which is why they (the pagans) hung Him on it - the ultimate insult! Maybe it's fitting that a pagan god (Santa) be hung on a pagan symbol! Of course, it takes away from what the season is SUPPOSED to represent... Christ and peace. Yeah... right.

All X-mas is to me, is yet another opportunity to see the suckers and their money parted in the culmination of a materialistic orgy of self-gratification that began at the cessation of the previous one, a year earlier.








Denise
said

I have to agree with cory, "Christmas is what you make it". Mr. Conrad says he is low income, but feels the "expectations of the Christmas season". Perhaps he should speak to his expectant family and friends about his financial situation? Maybe make them a small gift? It doesn't have to be all about rampant consumerism, but it sounds like maybe his family and friends have expectations that are beyond his means.

Oh, and for all those who say it's about the birth of Christ, don't forget that it's also Eid, Hannukah and Winter Solstice right now. Last time I checked, they had nothing to do with Jesus Christ.


island girl
said

This has been done before. If you want to make a statement, at least be original. *yawn*.


Nanook
said

A CBC documentary I watched said that Wally-World gets 30% of their yearly sales in December alone. Wow.


Josh
said

I guess I'll be one of the dissenting voices here and say that I like Christmas the way it is. It’s nice to have the religious aspect mixed in with the commercial, and we have to remember that it’s supposed to be centered around kids. I mean how many people over 13 sit on Santa's lap at the mall? As for the monetary element, well a lot of people get bonuses, and even if you don’t, you can choose to spend as you like. It’s good for the economy if nothing else.


Felicia
said

I agree with Conrad in a way. I am not offended by his "art". Christmas has become comercialized, but I do not think it is Santa's fault. I think we have all forgotten the meaning of Christmas. Everybody seems like they are trying to buy bigger and better gifts than everyone else. My parents even do it. They don't give gifts from the both of them. They buy individual gifts for everybody and it is like they are trying to out do the other one. That has nothing to do with Christmas. It is almost like people are trying to buy love. It has to stop.
Christmas is about CHRIST. Yes, you are meant to give gifts as a symbol of the wisemen bringing gifts to Christ at his birth and people have just gone crazy with it. A lot of people don't even know what the symbolism is about.
The ones that drive me crazy are the ones that want to ban the saying of Merry Christmas and take Christ out of the holiday. I think those people are the IDIOTS. Christmas is Christ's birthday. That is what we are supposed to be celebrating.


Mohamed
said

Merry Chrsitmas to everyone (with shopping or without shopping :)). I dedicate these verses from our holybook about the miraculous birth of Jesus to my Christian brothers and sisters:

"And make mention of Mary in the Scripture, when she had withdrawn from her people to a chamber looking East, (16) And had chosen seclusion from them. Then We sent unto her Our Spirit and it assumed for her the likeness of a perfect man. (17) She said: Lo! I seek refuge in the Beneficent One from thee, if thou art God-fearing. (18) He said: I am only a messenger of thy Lord, that I may bestow on thee a faultless son. (19) She said: How can I have a son when no mortal hath touched me, neither have I been unchaste? (20) He said: So (it will be). Thy Lord saith: It is easy for Me. And (it will be) that We may make of him a Protant for mankind and a mercy from Us, and it is a thing ordained. (21)" Quran Surah 19 verses 16-21


Gail
said

People scurrying around buying commercialized goods are a retailer's dream come true. But crucifying Santa, come on! He's just another example of how a child's icon of goodness and giving has been turned into a commercial nightmare. World Vision's slogan is worth repeating "Change a life. Change your own." It's time more people remembered it is a celebration of Christ's birth. Giving to those less fortunate is not only more rewarding for the soul, but to those who need a helping hand, it is a sign of a truly caring society.


Get With The Times
said

This is absolutely ridiculous. For all you religious types out there, you're strongly out numbered, and obviously there are more people that enjoy the "evolved" Christmas more than the "old school" one you are desperately trying to defend. Religion has become such a small part of today's society, because it has become practically irrelevant in the Western world. Within the next generation, the "real meaning" of Christmas will be totally lost, and that's something you're going to have to come to terms with. It's an uphill battle not worth fighting.


RS
said

I'm not Christian, nor do I celebrate Christmas but I do love the sales (which means really nothing since you don't save, that's not how business works). Christmas is good for the economy, why fight it? It's cause of Santa that you get your cushy paycheck and guess what SANTA AIN'T REAL!!! So no one died for the corporations to exploit and increase welfare in our country. So who is the loser in all of this? Not me, I stay in this time of year, too coold!


Kevin
said

Christmas is too commercial now a days, but I think a lot pf people still know where to draw the line. I couldnt believe it when somebody told me the other day that a lot of retailers no longer do exchanges on Boxing Day, they ask that the bodies in their stores be for purchases only. Isn't that how Boxing Day came to be, was for returns/exchanges? Now it's all about the almighty dollar!


Mark
said

The cross is not a symbol of religion in and of itself. It is a manner in which romans executed criminals. Christians use it as a symbol because it reminds them of how Christ died for them.


FMC
said

To Denise,
I just want to say that Christmas actually stands for Christ Mass. It has everything to do with Christ. I do realize that there are those that have Hannukah and other religious holidays, but Dec. 25 is Crist Mass. I just don't want to see the religious ideas behind these holidays taken away, whether it is Christmas or Hannukah.


Kelsey
said

While I agree that Christmas is commercialized, I think this display is a poor way of protesting it. Congratdulations, all the kids who believe in santa are thrilled he's dead. There are better ways to protest than to crucify a man who was considered a saint. If he felt as stongly as he claims, he should possibally just not buy gifts and encorage others, not make kids who see this cry.


Rose
said

Maybe Mr conrad should have done what I did with my children . Go to the local lions or chartiy and give gifts

example my children gave gifts and wrapped them for the needy
it became a family traditon ( they would gave one of the presents they wanted to someone else).I would also so wrap one for the parents of the needy children .
Instead of Christmas dinner at home why not go to a place where you can serve dinner to the homeless. This way my children learned what the real meaning of Christmas is .
Happy Birthday Christ child
Rose.


Dan
said

Boo Hoo! If you don't like the present buying and the like... don't. No one, including the Wal-mart staff, is holding a gun to your head.


Glenn C.
said

I agree with Cory and Island girl. Christmas is what you make of it, and I don't think your idea with this display is new! Mr. Conrad you need to be creative- not making a fool of yourself!
Let the kids enjoy Santa,you find a hobby.



Mike
said

Poor Santa, he's taking a beating this fall. First he's too fat, then he's condemned for saying "Ho, Ho, Ho," Now he's crucified.

Why don't the artistes go after Cupid and the Easter Bunny next?


Lance
said

I only have one word for this:

BRILLIANT

We need to bring back Christ into Christmas!!!




Mark
said

Retailers rub their hands in glee thinking of all the money they are going to make at Christmas and at every other holiday they can exploit.But it`s ok to exchange small gifts and to give our children some nice presentsl, However there is no need to go wild with spending.Christmas is not only a religious holiday, but is a celebration meant to bring people together at a time of year when the days are short and the temperatures are low.To warm our hearts and spirits with family and friends and co-workers.To remember what its like to be happy.


Tricia
said

Christ was already crucified, died and arose for all our sins....including the commercialism of Christmas!


Dave
said

Yes, we absolutely should remember what Christmas is about...

It is a combination of old, pagan winter solstice rituals (decorated trees, yule logs, mistletoe, holly feasting and so on), the celebration of the birth of Mithras (on the 25th of December) or Jesus Christ (your choice), essentially a perpetuation of early Christian compromises to convert Central and Northern European tribes.

This said, it is a worthy celebration, incorporating family gatherings, giving of presents (ideally matched to the receiver, rather than a crass commercial exercise) and a break from both work/school and winter worries.

Merry Christmas to all.




Catherine
said

Chrismas is what you make of it. Just like anything else. If you don't like the way things are then don't join in. But who gives you the right to ruin other peoples fun. If you have children I can't imagine the ridicule they are going to be exposed to. Birthdays are to be celebrated if you believe in doing that I don't always celebrate mine on the day of. So Christmas is just a chosen day for the celebration of Christs birth. And if I want to celebrate with elaborate gifts or gifts of a lesser Value. then that is my business, But I don't go around ruining others celebrations. We all have choices to make. And you have chosen to only want attention brought to you. Credit cards and spending is a choice, Live within your means. Christmas is about sharing the joy of love peace and hope. My family hope that you will some day feel that. From my family to everyone out there that has the spirit of Christmas in them we wish you all a blessed,and veryhappy, Christmas with health and happiness in the new year!


Shayna
said

I understand that the original meaning of Christmas has been slightly lost on some people and corperations, but this is a little rediculous. True, Christmas is originally about Jesus' birthday and the birth of Christianity, but it's also about spending time with loved ones and giving (I don't think Jesus would be too pissed off that his birthday is also a day for giving and happiness). If you want to protest the commericialism of Christmas, there are better ways to do it than just freaking out children. You could not buy presents from major corperations and make them instead, for example. If people are pissed off with Christmas, keep it to yourselves, because most people enjoy this time of year and see it as a time to spend with loved ones and just relax and have fun. If you choose to be cynical and hate this time of year, go ahead, but simmer in your own angryness. Don't ruin other people's fun. What good does that do?


Kelly
said

It's amazing how some peoples' ignorance is their excuse for laziness. If this guy cares that much he should be spending his energy helping out at the local food bank or raising money for kids who won't have a good Christmas instead of putting up a display which is clearly disturbing for any children that happen to view it.

He then blames society for his own lack of morality? Shame on you!

If you want to change the world DO something don't just whine and complain.


Mike Baker
said

I'm guessing that Mr. Conrad never got that base ball glove he wanted when he was 9 so he hated the Holiday ever since.


Anne
said

It is disgusting to see these adults acting like children. Santa is a symbol of Christmas and as an adult, you do not have to pull out your mastercard at Christmas or any other time of the year. Grow up and learn to manage your credit card or cut it up!


RJT
said

Felicia: Jesus was NOT born on Dec25, Christmas dates are symbolic only of an Arab Jew of came to save the world from itself.

None of us have to get sunk by all the lies that we're told by advertisers, we can chose to not participate then society will be forced to change it's message from CONSUME to CONNECT with the people you love.

I love this time of year and I chose to NOT participate in the buying madness that consumes this continent during this season. Im okay with mixing in religion or spirituality or just love, that beautiful too.

Finally, to those whining about some rumblings about removing 'Merry Xmas', lighten up, it's not a national movement, it's a handful of people who may feel religiously excluded or who don't want religion part of the national identity. It's not that big a deal.

I would ask that we all think of civilians in war zones who are suffering and offer a prayer or a peaceful thought for their safety and well being.

To Mohamed: You embody what Jesus and His message is about.

Merry Xmas. Happy Holidays and the most beautiful New Year.


Billy
said

quoting "I'm sure you would feel differently if you had to explain his actions to a five year old mr. moore"

What a fantastic opportunity to talk to your children about the over commercialization of Christmas, and tell them the real reason for the season!


Nick J Boragina
said

Santa himself is a symbol created by commercialism

NEXT!


Eric
said

Christmas Commercialized? You betcha! When the advertising starts the day after Halloween and they bombard you with all the commercials etc, its no wonder people are getting tired of it. I wish Christmas was more like it was when I was a kid back in the 60's. A gift each or so. Now days people buy items just for the sake of buying with very little thought behind the gifts they buy.

Also, then comes the Credit Card Blues that many suffer because they thought they had to buy but really could't afford to.

I feel that its just a shame the way Christmas has changed so much over the years.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz