News Sections
Ontario returning Ipperwash park to natives
CTV News Video
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(53)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Thu. Dec. 20 2007 10:24 PM ET
The Ipperwash Provincial Park where native protester Dudley George was shot and killed in 1995 will be returned to the Chippewas of Kettle and Stony Point First Nation, the Ontario government announced today.
"I think he would be pleased. He paid the ultimate price and is not here to enjoy," George's brother, Sam, said Thursday.
George was killed during a police raid to remove protesters from the park on Sept. 6, 1995.
The protesters had wanted the federal government to return nearby Camp Ipperwash, formerly the Stony Point reserve, to Kettle and Stony Point descendants.
At the time, the protesters also claimed that the Ipperwash Provincial Park, owned by the provincial government, was the site of a sacred burial ground.
Justice Sydney Linden, the commissioner of the Ipperwash Inquiry which probed the death of George, said in his May 2007 report that the most urgent priority was that both the federal and provincial lands be returned.
Sam George welcomed the announcement Thursday.
"By returning these 109 acres, by keeping a treaty promise, and by honouring the memory of my brother Dudley, we are respecting each other," he told reporters. "It shows that we can be friends. For these things, I and my family would like to again thank the people of Ontario."
Aboriginal Affairs Minister Michael Bryant said Thursday the move showed how determined the McGuinty government is to move forward with the recommendations.
"Returning Ipperwash Park and acting on Justice Linden's recommendations is the clearest and most powerful expression of the intention of the McGuinty government to move forward in a concrete, practical and deliberate way to forge a stronger, more positive relationship with all Aboriginal peoples in Ontario," he said.
He also warned the government against letting tensions escalate to that level again, possibly making a veiled reference to the heated stand off in Caledonia.
"That where there is conflict and violence and death, it does not in fact provide for a more expeditious result. In fact, it leads to complete entrenchment and tragedy," he said. "Bitterness on both sides you have to see to believe."
Mark Simpson, a counsellor in nearby Lambton Shores, said the transfer set a dangerous precedent.
"I've talked to a lot of people in my community and they're livid. They're absolutely livid with what's happening -- that they've been excluded from the process," Simpson said Thursday.
Julian Falconer, legal counsel for Aboriginal Legal Services, said the decision was an important one.
"The Minister of Aboriginal Affairs deserves a lot of credit for bringing this to what is an important first step in healing," he told CTV Newsnet Thursday afternoon. "Today is a great day."
George's death left an important legacy for the Aboriginal community, he said.
"The First Nations are proud of the community member who gave his life to ensure the return of lands," said Falconer, who was involved in the Ipperwash inquiry.
Easing the transition
He said while the news is cause to celebrate, preparations also have to be made to help ease the transition of the land transfer.
"There would be no way to simply, like a car, turn over the keys, so there's land management issues here," he said.
"It is important to understand that there are issues amongst the communities on how to manage the land. The fact of the matter is that the Kettle and Stoney Point Band has accountability issues with its people as well, in particular Stoney Pointers who have also laid interest in the lands."
Natural Resources Minister Donna Cansfield said the province plans to work with local communities during the transfer phase.
"As the first step in the process to transfer Ipperwash Provincial Park from the province to the Chippewas of Kettle and Stony Point First Nation, both parties will work together with the local communities to develop an interim co-management plan," she said.
"Through these discussions we will determine how the park lands will be used and managed until the transfer is completed."
Falconer said there are other recommendations in the Ipperwash report that should be followed immediately, namely a personal and public apology by the commissioner of the OPP to Cecil Bernard George who was also beaten.
Justice Linden said he'd like to see the federal government get more involved.
"I mean the people on the ground don't care if it's federal or provincial, they just want to see it work," he said. "Somehow, the federal and provincial governments have to get together to solve this problem."
Land history
Various sections of the Kettle and Stony Point lands were sold in the 1920s and 1930s. In 1928, the Stony Point Reserve surrendered its entire beachfront for sale to private interests.
In 1932, the Province of Ontario bought a portion of the beach front and established Ipperwash Provincial Park.
In 1937, park authorities were notified by the native chief and council that a sacred burial ground existed on the land. They asked officials to protect the site but no evidence suggests that they did.
During the Second World War, the Department of National Defence (DND) wanted to use the remaining 2,211 acres of the Stony Point Reserve as a military training camp.
In 1942, a government representative asked the natives to surrender the land voluntarily but they refused. Using the War Measures Act, the DND took over the land and named it Camp Ipperwash. They paid $15 per acre for the land and never returned it.
Stony Point descendants had occupied and protested at Camp Ipperwash since 1993 but stalled negotiations prompted the move into the government park on Sept. 4, 1995, two days before the shooting of George.
He was the first native in modern Canadian history to be killed in a government conflict over land.
In 1998, an agreement-in-principle was finally reached between the federal government and the Kettle and Stony Point peoples to return Camp Ipperwash to the natives.
Despite the agreement, since it was used for military purposes, the land is currently being investigated for unexploded ordnance (UXO) and environmental contamination. As a result, a final settlement has not yet been reached to return the land.
Linden's report recommends that the federal government "return the former army camp to the Kettle and Stony Point First Nation immediately with an apology and appropriate compensation."
With a report from CTV's Lisa LaFlamme and CTV Toronto's Paul Bliss
User Tools
Related Stories
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(53)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I applaud the budget, even though Health Care and education may stay unscathed. Sadly this cannot last and I worry to later this year where cuts will become enviable. If anything, this provides the Wildrose Alliance plenty of ammo when an election is called.


Comments are now closed for this story
Steve
said
I'm in total agreement with the recommendation...name the park after Dudley. If not the entire park at least partially.
Fiona
said
Ken Leland
said
Bill Stewart
said
Many Canadians are probably wondering when the governments will return all the surrounding land that rightfully belongs to the 1st Nations. If evidence (of the claims) are present, let's get the cases over & done with -- return what was taken!
BOB
said
barry
said
Gwen
said
Kris
said
What a nice change in native/non-native relations.
Federal government: Take note.
Keith
said
Regardless this is a great victory for the Canadian First Nations Movement.
Oh, BTW, I'm white!
Harvey
said
steve I. C.
said
JM
said
RJT
said
Lart from Above
said
J-F (Ottawa)
said
To Bill Stewart:
If we were to return what was taken (generally speaking) the entire country would be handed back to the 1st Nations. I agree with your comments though.
I am also of the opinion that the 1st Nations have been awfully abused and taken for granted and they should receive compensation and retrobution of some kind. However, in some cases, it's awful to see how these pieces of land and territories are being treated. I understand what goes on within the reserves is nobody's business but their own, but it is very sad to see the abuse, addiction problems, children out of school, lack of employment, deterioration of properties etc...It would be nice to see a much brighter and advanced future for the Natives, but I doubt the Feds would soon agree to help them along.
Dave Hayward
said
We, the descendants of Canada’s Aboriginal, French and English founders,
and of all others who later arrived to help build this nation,
stand in unity as witness to this pledge.
Remembering that Canada’s provinces and territories have been settled
by peoples whose mother tongues, heritage and values differed,
we pledge to one another:
To recognize, to respect, and to celebrate Canada’s diversity,
lest a loss of identity suffers unto our descendants;
To embrace tolerance, equality, sharing and compassion
as the moral cornerstones of our great nation;
To bond together as one in the pursuit of dignity, health,
prosperity and happiness for all Canadians;
To forever preserve and promote this mission
that we so proudly share.
____________________
Reference: http://twenty-twenty.ca/forum/viewtopic.php?t=89
Sean
said
The Indians lost the war hundreds of years ago.
The Government should not be handing them all the choice pieces of waterfront property to the detriment of the general population who would love the opportunity to enjoy that land as well.I know my views are not popular but Aboriginals would be far better off to join our multicultural society rather than continue to live outside of it.
BJ
said
Anne
said
Adrian
said
At that time, will the people living with the settlement that is decided upon now, believe it was fair or unfair? Will they believe one group took advantage of another? Will a new settlement be negotiated then in order to fair-for-the-day? Is there such a thing as fair-forever?
Pam
said
Thank you First Nations for your wonderful help in WWII.
Fred Bloggs
said
"Canada has far too many illegal immigrants....ask any Indian"
karyn
said
Kevin
said
Kamil
said
Doug
said
I do,however,reject the use of force as a legitimat way to resolve these disputes.
It's the obligation of all of those of us who are not part of the First Nations community to get our governments moving to resolve these issues.However,for First Nations people who use force,violence.or blockades as a means to an end,I suggest those efforts are counter productive.Rather than speed up the process,they in fact,harden peoples attitudes towards all First Nations communities.
There has to be a recognition that we are going to have to find mutual accomodation for all people in Canada.We don't have the technology to return to the 17th century.So,let's get busy and see how we can make better lives for the children and grand-children who will surely look back,and wonder about this period of our history.
Complex issues will require complex solutions.But only with good will can any dispute be resolved.
We must ALL,First Nations,and non First Nations,be more accomodating,and show more determination to find solutions without resorting to extremist posturing or violence.
Murray
said
Mark G.
said
Randy
said
Concerned UWO student
said
Natives already get far more than they deserve from hard working tax payers in this country.
This is yet another example of Liberal incompetence.
How long before they turn over the Caledonia sight? Perhaps the other 100 billion dollars in land that natives lay claim to.
Even if the billions of dollars of lands being claimed by natives did at one point belong to their ancestors... IT WAS THEIR ANCESTORS ... not them ... get over it already.
Abby U
said
Gordon
said
Well and governments wonder why the public distrusts them.
HA
Francois
said
They lost the land... that's too bad...
I say that they reserves should be removed completely... and that they should become normal Canadians like the rest of us, and pay taxes! This is simply ridiculous
Rob
said
Rob
said
Mark G.
said
dana
said
jerry
said
Greg from Kitchener
said
Giev them back their land?
Well come to think about it, my great great great Grandfather sold his farm land to the government to build... I think he was ripped off, I want it back now....
They don't pay taxes, live of my and other Canadians money, disrespect the law, practically get away with murder, and we bend over backwards for them... great, lets start selling off Canada bit by bit!
All the liberal softies, you will be the death of Canada.
Mike
said
RICKJ
said
Sometimes, "the ends justifies the means".
Dan J
said
The fact being overlooked is the government PAID them for the land, even if it was a forced expropriation it happens all the time. Not to mention, most of these natives were not even alive at the time time, so they deserve nothing.
Josh from Vancouver
said
What would you do Randy if the government confiscated your home, threw you and your family onto the streets and promised to return it but never did? Would you go away or would you fight for your rights and against he tyranny of that government? I think you would fight.
Thanking Aboriginals Across Canada
said
JFJ
said
It's time do do way with the apartheid that ensures one group of Canadians stay forever victims.
Liberals have been good at creating dependencies. Look at what they (and Red Tories) have done to make dependents out of Canadians living in Atlantic provinces.
What's the point of going to Afghanistan to establish democracy and equality of teh sexses there when McGuinty and his cronies encourage racism, corruption, nepotism and male domination in reserved parts of Ontario?
The quicker we start treating all Canadians as equals the better, and depart from this idiotic white liberal ideal of the noble Indian living off the land. It's a myth that belongs in the dustbin of history.
Mike B
said
We are all going to pay for this lack of thought on the governments behalf.
I know lets just hand over the whole province.
Welcome to the Province of Ontario Indian Reserve.
Pat_Pending
said
Paul
said
Kanatian
said
Kanatian
said
All of which are present in Canadian law in some form or another and make for great reading when one can not sleep.
Never stop learning.
Ever wonder why it is "our home and Native land" in the anthem? That was no accident.
And thanks to the editors for the butchery of good posts.
christine
said
Some people really disgust me. Do some research, learn a thing or two before formulating an opinion. If you're still an intolerant, racist and selfish person after that, at least we'll all know that is just who you truly are and that it is not caused by a lack of knowledge.
I bet a lot of you would do well at the so-called "reasonable accomodation hearings" (aka: "Open Forum for Racist and Ignorant People") in Quebec.
M
said
Vi
said