CTV News | Cement truck driver charged in crash that killed 5

Top Stories -   

Cement truck driver charged in crash that killed 5

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Kirk Heuser on the horrific scene
CTV Newsnet: Insp. Guy Slater, Calgary Police

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(25)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Sat. Dec. 8 2007 9:28 PM ET

A 50-year-old cement truck driver has been charged in connection with a horrific accident that killed five people -- including three children -- in Calgary Friday night.

The victims were crushed after the car they were in, which was stopped at a red light, was rear-ended by a Mack 700 Tri-Axel cement truck.

Police say the northbound Chrysler Intrepid was stopped at a red light located at the intersection of MacLeod Trail and 194 Avenue Southwest around 7 p.m. on Friday when it was struck from behind by a 2005 Mack 700 Tri-Axel cement truck.

"The force of the impact lodged the Intrepid under the front of the cement truck and the momentum of this truck pushed this vehicle nearly 300 metres northward where it finally came to rest in the east curb lane and shoulder," a statement from Calgary police said.

A male driver, 41, and a female passenger, 33, were pronounced dead at the scene.

A six-year-old girl, nine-year-old girl and 16-month-old baby boy were also killed in the crash. Police say all three children were properly restrained in the back seat of the vehicle at the time of the collision.

The cement truck driver, Daniel Tschetter of Cochrane, Alta., was uninjured in the crash. The identities of the deceased have not been released.

Police say the tangled wreckage of the vehicle has created problems for investigators. Only some of the next of kin have been notified.

"The wreckage of the vehicle made it extremely difficult for extrication and so the medical examiner's office has not been able to complete their work in order to confirm (identities) and do the notification of the next of kin," Duty Inspector Guy Slater told CTV.ca on Saturday.

Police have not said if those killed were members of the same family or Calgary residents.

Slater said excessive speed and alcohol are believed to be factors in the crash.

"Numerous witnesses plus the first assessment from the debris field would indicate that speed was a factor," he said.

The truck had a number listed at the back which people could call if they were concerned about the way it was being driven. CTV Calgary spoke to a call centre operator who said she was on the phone with a complainant who was behind the truck just before the crash.

He complained about the way the truck was being driven. Gina Wilke, the operator who took the call, said the sounds she next heard over the phone still haunt her.

There was a "scream and the crash of the actual (accident). It was that loud," she said.

On the other end of the line, Wilke said the complainant "screamed 'oh my God!' He has just gone through a red light and he has just hit a car, T-boned a car. Call 911. I have to hang up."

C and J Construction, the company which owns the truck involved in the crash, released a statement late Saturday: "At this time of great sorrow, we offer our deepest and sincerest condolences to the family and friends of the victims of this terrible accident (Friday) evening."

The statement went on to say that because of the on-going police investigation, the company will not comment further and will respect the privacy of all those affected.

MacLeod Trail, the site of the crash, is a major roadway that runs from the south of Calgary to downtown.

Slater said weather was not a factor and road conditions were not icy or slick at the time. "It's a tragic situation that reinforces that speed kills," he said.

Tschetter remains in jail and has been charged with the following:

  • Refusing to provide a breath sample;
  • Five counts of dangerous operation of a motor vehicle causing death.

He is expected to appear in court on Dec. 13.

With a report from CTV Calgary

Comments are now closed for this story

kristy voisin
said

This was my best friend's family. Her beautiful little cousins and her uncle who could always put a smile on everyone's face...

Steven Baker
said

The driver should be charged with 5 counts of 2nd degree murder or manslaughter...

Zoe
said

Horrific doesn't even come close to describing this totally preventable "accident". I live in Calgary, I moved here five years ago from New Brunswick, I have said since I got here that the worse drivers I have ever encountered drive here, or attempt to drive here.

I have been snarled at, yelled at, cussed out and sworn at and have been given the obligatory Trudeau salute on more than one occasion. I have been cut off, passed when I shouldn't have been and the list goes on.

Road rage is very much alive and well in Calgary. I have driven extensively in Canada and the US and I can honestly say that I have never seen such inattention to driving as I have in Calgary. There is no excuse for this type of behaviour. The roads belong to everyone. I abide by the rules of the road and the fact that I have had no traffic violations speaks for itself.
My heart breaks for the loved ones of this family. Who wants to hear this kind of story when you turn on the news?....

Sandi Sala
said

.... My prayers go out to the family and loved ones of those who so needlessly perished.

Leslie
said

I have lived in Calgary all my life and I totally agree with the comments about how horrible the drivers are here. I have a 16 year old son who just got his license and the fact that he is out there on these roads learning makes my blood run cold. If this kind of tragic, heartbreaking accident doesn't wake people up here in Calgary I don't know what will.


Marc
said

This is really sad to read. My condolences to the family and all who had the great pleasure of knowing these people.

Hopefully the family can get some sort of justice from the injustice system that we seem to have.




J Kay
said

A tragic event. The problem is, in Canada you can kill a person with a gun and you get charged with Murder (if you aimed the gun at the victim) or Manslaughter (if you accidentally discharged the gun, or were reckless and a death ensued), but if you point a car (or in this case a truck) at another car (intentional) or fail to stop or are just reckless, you aren't charged with Murder, but "Dangerous Operation of a Motor Vehicle Causing Death".

The difference in the charge says it all. Reckless operation of a motor vehicle, which by the way kills more people every year than guns do is just not viewed by our legislators (or the public) as a serious offense.

With respect to the "Failure to Provide a Sample", I think it's about time we started thinking about tipping our constitution rights away from the individual and more towards the good of society. I, for one, would be prepared to give up the right to refuse to provide a sample if it would get more impaired drivers of the road, or ensure they pay the penalty when an accident and death results.

Of course, we don't have all of the facts in this case, so we don't want to try the driver in the media. Perhaps the air brakes failed.

To Zoe, I have to disagree with your view of Calgary drivers. I was in Calgary last weekend and can say that Calgarians are amongst the most courteous drivers I have come across. Especially compared to Winnipeg, Toronto and Montreal.

J Kay
Winnipeg




BP
said

My thoughts and prayers are with the families of these 5 people. May wonderful memories give them strength to carry on during this incredibly sad and difficult period.




ed in Calgary
said

... Would it be so hard to mandate the use of sobriety ignition locks on large commercial vehicles? Insurance companies should demand it or at least give premium discounts to companies that install them. Why not a lifetime requirement to use such a device for anyone found guilty of DUI causing death?


Mark
said

How incredibly sad and how senseless for this to happen? ... My sympathy to all those bereaved by the death of this family.


Pat Hooisma
said

I am a good friend to the driver of the car, and my heart and soul goes out to them in this time of need. He brought a smile to my best friend and she is hurting so bad....

corrie lynn ferguson
said

rest in peace ... you're forever loved and missed



D.R. - Calgary
said

I also drive a concrete truck in Calgary. I moved to Calgary about five years ago from Manitoba. It is so very true some people in this city are completely oblivious to what is happening around them. Driving is incredibly hard when I have cars and trucks cutting me off constantly. I'm surprised that this doesn't happen more often. In this case though, the truck driver should be nailed to the wall if he was drinking. I can't even imagine operating one of those trucks under the influence. Ed is right! Sobriety tests in the truck before the ignition turns on. My heart, thoughts, and prayers go out to the families of those involved. I also lost my sister in a car accident where the other party was at fault. God bless those who perished and their families.


CD
said

This is so terrible but also a warning to everyone...always look behind you especially when you are the only vehicle stopped...I've had to discontinue my stop to fast and full speed ahead to prevent being rear-ended twice in my life. Had I not seen one truck fishtailing behind me on a slick highway and got out of the way I wouldn't be here also. Sad but true..you need eyes everywhere when driving.


Danny
said

.... On the comments of bad Calgary drivers, I only agree to the fact people here have not accepted the fact we are now a REAL BIG city and stop driving around like you used to on a Sunday afternoon when there used to be only 50 cars on Deerfoot Trail and people must also know and understand what the left lanes are for, not for casual Sunday strolls!


R. Lastra
said

The "right" to opt out of a breathalyzer must be changed. One too many individuals have pleaded guilty to lesser charges based primarily on the fact that they refused to provide a breathalyzer....

T Thibodeau
said

That Accident looked bad...i was traveling in the south bound lanes just shortly after emergency vehicles arrived...I agree totally agree with Ed...my thoughts on that is that all vehicles should be equipped with the interlock system...

Doug
said

This is such a sad and tragic incident. So many innocent lives that will not be lived.
I've recently retired from a long career as a commercial transport mechanic. My experiences, and observations while driving around in BC lead me to believe the bar has been seriously lowered in that industry.
I don't want to throw everyone in the same category. Absolutely there are many very good people doing very resposible work. But I see more and more operators acting like "cowboys" behind the wheels of the "big rigs". And far to amny people are not doing all that is needed to maintain this equipment.
In BC,the Motor Vehicle Inspectors have occassional check of trucks on the road, and an alarming number are found to be unfit,and outright dangerous. We have also seen privatized driving schools closed down for fraudulently testing and approving of new drivers.
These people should not have died. My advice to everyone is not to trust any of these trucks. Stay as far away as you can. The operator and those who maintain the truck may very well not be as "professional" as you think. And there is very little being done in BC to improve the situation.
There can be no excuse for this. I know accidents can happen even to the best of us. But if you are a professional,the public has a right to expect you to be held to a higher standard.
It's always better to get there late than not at all.
Rest in peace my friends. My deep sympathy to your friends and families.


ric
said

zoe said it best, i have lived here for 8 years and by far compared to the other major cities in this country, the drivers here are the worst!!! i have previously lived and driven in toronto for 12 years and montreal for 4 years and the drivers, although not always that great are pros compared to the locals here. no signal lights, speeding, following too close, cutting off, not knowing what the meaning of merge is and driving 130 kph when its snowing. come here and drive for 30 mins and you will see the cause of these deaths ....

Undy
said

I came to Calgary 15 years ago. The driving was very good, people stop for pedestrians to cross the road. But I think with the oil boom, people from BC and Ontario moved to here and thing started to change. Those behaviours mentioned in earliers are what I experienced on Hwy 407 when I visited my friend in Toronto few year ago.


Cody
said

One thing is better in Calgary is that the police will put charges against the driver immeditely, if in BC they would probably let the driver walk away. less work for them....

Fool
said

... I travel through that intersection everyday. It is 80 km/h about 200 meters before the intersection and there are warning lights that the traffic light is red or going to change. The roads are dry as a bone right now with no snow for the past several days. The road is also 3 lanes wide with lane wide shoulders on both sides, so he had room to swerve... I feel so sorry for this family.


Marc
said

I am not sure if it is nation wide or only in B.C. but if one was to refuse a requested breath sample in B.C. they will receive a mandatory 3 month driving prohibition. The driver who refuses will be taken to the police station and required to have a blood sample taken so refusing a breath sample is quite pointless as the driver will be found out either way.


Sandi
said

This is awful, so close to Christmas. My thoughts and prayers go out to the families. My husband is a transport driver in Ontario and he complains everyday about the stupidity of other drivers. ...

Suzy MTQ - BC
said

Firstly, our hearts, thoughts & prayers go out to all involved in this saddening, senseless & tragic event. Two years ago, I became a 'trucker' along with my current f/t position as a mommy. I had to go back to work and knew it would be a job I would enjoy. Safety has always been paramount to myself, my family & my fellow public, I felt I would be an asset to the trucking world. ... I believe it should be mandatory for ALL vehicles world wide to be built with sobriety starters....it just makes TOTAL SENSE. ... In closing, do unto others as you would have done unto you!! Take care and drive safe CANADA!!


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz