CTV News | U.K. teacher sentenced to jail in teddy bear case

Top Stories -   

U.K. teacher sentenced to jail in teddy bear case

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: Tom Kennedy with details in London

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(45)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Thu. Nov. 29 2007 3:21 PM ET

A British schoolteacher was sentenced Thursday to 15 days in jail and will be deported from Sudan for allowing her students to name a teddy bear after the Muslim Prophet Muhammad.

Gillian Gibbons, 54, was convicted by a Sudanese court of inciting religious hatred. She will be deported after completion of her sentence.

The British teacher was arrested Sunday after a complaint was lodged with the Education Ministry that she insulted the Prophet Muhammad -- the most revered religious figure in Islam -- by applying his name to a stuffed animal.

She faced a maximum penalty of 40 lashes and six months in prison for the charge.

The British Foreign Ministry said it was "extremely disappointed" by the conviction.

"We are extremely disappointed that the charges against Gillian Gibbons were not dismissed," British Foreign Secretary David Miliband said in a statement.

"As I said this morning, our clear view is that this is an innocent misunderstanding by a dedicated teacher. Our priority now is to ensure Ms. Gibbons' welfare and we will continue to provide consular assistance to her," he said.

Sudanese Ambassador Omer Siddiq has been called to the Foreign Office to explain the decision.

CTV's London Bureau Chief Tom Kennedy told CTV Newsnet on Thursday that the identity of the original complainant was revealed in court.

It's reported a school staff member, someone who may have harboured a grudge with the school, lodged the original complaint with authorities.

"There were no complaints about the naming of this bear for several months. None of the parents complained and then suddenly, last Sunday, Ms. Gibbons was arrested," Kennedy said.

Swift trial

Riot police surrounded the building on Thursday as Gibbons approached. Dressed in a dark blue jacket and blue dress, she was not handcuffed when she entered the court in the Sudanese capital of Khartoum, media inside the courtroom said before being ordered out.

A statement from Gibbons, explaining that her seven-year-old students voted to name the stuffed animal Muhammad, was read to the court Thursday, British Embassy spokesman Omar Daair said.

Gibbons' chief defence lawyer, Kamal Djizouri, said ahead of the proceedings that he would show there was "absolutely no intention to insult religion, and for blasphemy to take place there must be an insult.''

"There is a very big difference between the holy character of Prophet Muhammad and the name Muhammad given to a person,'' he said, pointing out the name is commonly used throughout the Arab world.

"When somebody is named Muhammad by his parents and then turns out to be a thief, is it an insult to religion to say, 'That Muhammad is a thief'? Of course not.''

No consular representation was allowed in the courtroom during the proceedings.

Tensions ignited

The charges have sparked tensions between the Sudanese government and British officials; however, the British government maintains it is a consular matter, Kennedy reported.

The controversy erupted from a classroom lesson. Gibbons was teaching the elementary students about animals and asked one of the children to bring a teddy bear to class, Robert Boulos, a spokesman for Unity High School in Khartoum, has said.

The students were instructed to pick names for the stuffed animal and they voted in favour of naming the bear Muhammad.

The children were instructed to keep a diary of their time with the bear when they each took it home on weekends.

The diary entries were collected in a book with the bear's picture on the cover, labelled, "My Name is Muhammad," he said. The bear itself was never labelled with the name, he added.

Sudan's top Muslim clerics called for mass demonstrations in the streets of Khartoum after Friday prayers. Other hard-lined clerics are calling for Gibbons to face the full force of Shariah law, Kennedy said.

Sudanese religious leaders said Gibbons intentionally insulted the prophet and compared her to author Salman Rushdie, saying her actions were "blasphemies".

Rushdie's novel, "The Satanic Verses," prompted Iran's Ayatollah Khomeini to issue a fatwa -- a religious edict -- against the author for insulting Islam. The fatwa triggered death threats against Rushdie and inevitably forced him into exile.

With files from The Associated Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Roger T
said

Yes, under that country law she should be punished accordingly British or not. All violators in the country of orgin should be punished to what the law states, if they give special treatments it's leading a bad example. Surely, we wouldn't want other nations to tell us to bend our laws if they are here, if so will we?


Doug
said

Whether it's deliberate or not is question open to debate. This woman is going to jail for giving a name to a Teddy Bear and the best you can do is to cmaplain about giving "special treatments"?

Dean Grant Baker
said

It is time to stop ALL relief to the Sudan, full stop!
or it is time to esaclate the Crusade and eliminate Islamofascism from the face of the Earth once and for all!




Charles
said

This is about more than laws in Sudan. This is also politics. Muslim extremists want to discourage westerners from living there, and more of this garbage will do the trick. Long term it will create more solitudes in this world - not good.


Dan
said

Misplaced resentment, uneducated procedure.


William Bell
said

If the name Mohammed was not used as a first name by millions of Arabs, there might be a reason to be upset. The simple fact is that it is a very common first name and therefore using it to name a toy bear should not be a cause for offence. I would bet that lots of the children in the class have family members with the name Mohammed. I think that certain elements in the Muslim world use any excuse to prod people with more moderate views. I am also aware that
many moderate Muslims have spoken out in the teacher's defence


Jay Jonah
said

As is typical in the Muslim world, here is another example of taking an innocent event to encourage writing and turning it into something out of all proportion to reality. When will these extremists wake up!!


Duncan Efford
said

I agree with Roger T. in so far as everybody is subject to the laws of the country. But, can we please take a serious look at this situation. We are talking about children naming a toy. I think that the court realized that the whole thing was silly but in order to keep the peace and avoid violent demonstrations gave her a "token" sentence. Obviously religious extremism is a very dangerous thing. It should be kept separate from politics and law.


Bob H
said

The whole thing was a political move to bring attention to religous beliefs.This teacher should never have been subjected to this inhumane treatment.I think there will be a mass exodus of foreign teachers from Muslim countries,and rightly so.

Charlie
said

If this does not confirm the outrageous irrational treatment of innocents by religious fanatics looking for a way to shove their beliefs down the throats of others, then nothing does. A teddy bear for God's sake! Most likely much cutier and cuddlier than any human prophet. If they like they can use my name, Charles, and I would consider it an honour. It really brings their beliefs into disrespect when they are so afraid of any reason or logic to sustain it.


The Bet
said

Come on---what's wrong with those people to jail a teacher for such a petty thing that she did. I believe it was all innocent but I can tell you, I now know why people can't get along. There are those who take things way to seriously and to the extreme. Sure, if you visit another country you should educate yourself regarding their laws but people are not lawyers and innocent mistakes are made. There was nothing evil in the intent. I feel sorry for this lady. I know I would never visit that country.


Pat_pending
said

Oh aren't we so enlightened here in the west. How barbaric of the Sudanese to punish a woman for breaking one of their "crazy" laws with 15 days in prison. Not like us in the West at all. They could never be so "enlightened" as to fire cruise missiles into a pharmaceutical factory (Al-Shifa)making medicines to treat malaria and TB. The result of that missile attach by the US against Sudan in 1998 resulted in the deaths of thousands of sick people as a result of the unavailability of those drugs.

How barbaric of Sudan, and how hypocritical of us.


John
said

Yet another example of how religion divides.


Nick T
said

The weirdest part is that the teacher didn't name the bear, the students did. Why is it that they aren't being persecuted for this 'blasphemy'? And calling for demonstrations. I really think a lot of these clerics and 'holy people' need to take a good look at reality.


Michael Kelly
said

Why did the children not get punished? They decided to call the teddy bear Mohammad.

tony
said

I'm sorry Gillian that you have to go to jail.


Ray - London
said

She was convicted under Islamic Sharia, a group of laws that are not written, commonly misunderstood, and are not equally enforced or applied. It is mainly practiced using whatever standards are observed by the local justices, tribal elders, or mobs.

This incident has less to do with an insult to Islam and the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh), and more to do with a concerted effort by some ambitious Sudanese to strengthen their power base among the radical element.


kev
said

I heard somebody has already started a name that teddy bear Mohammad for Christmas campaign - sounds great.
As long as we don't make any cartoon we should be OK


G.Williams
said

To Nick T, this is reality as they perceive it.

When even members of the same family can have divisive differences of perception what hope is there for harmony between cultures?

Tyranny thrives in isolation, and I agree with those who see this as about discouraging foreigners. Whatever happens we must maintain contact with even the most obnoxious regimes. Not doing so has been the biggest error of US foreign policy.

The staff member at the school who pushed a personal grudge also has much to answer for.

Hopefully Sudan's obstruction of the Darfur deployment will now be ignored and forces sent in.


Shaun
said

Interesting to read the comments. First thing I thought was "you are a teacher going to an Islamic country and stupid enough to allow a stuffed bear (a.k.a. an idol) to be named for THE prophet?" Lucky she is not dead. Hey, I am not for religious fanaticism but I am for self-preservation.


Amber
said

The world will never be at peace until everyone is accepting of of all religions and beliefs. Events such as this will forever happen b/c people are of belief that the religion or beliefs they have/practice are the ONLY ones to have.


Dave
said

Many travellers don't realize that their government holds little sway over the laws of another country, and Roger T is correct in that point.

I think the bigger issue is to create legal systems that ARE just. Sharia is definitely not one of them. All this does is confirm the irrationalism and extremism of religious based judicial systems.


Cassandra
said

Unless you live in that country or practice that religion you have no business saying what they did is wrong. They live in a different culture so have different views and different laws. If you live in a country without understanding their beliefs, customs and laws and then break a law or go against a belief you deserve whatever punshiment they deem correct. You don't expect people who come to North America from other countries to be above the law so why should we expect that treament in their country?


Lex
said

If this were a case of someone disobeying the laws of another country, then yes, it would be understandable. However, this is a case of an -extremely- vague law being specifically misinterpreted to persecute a foreigner. What is "insulting" is impossible to define, and therefore if these people chose, they could arrest a foreigner for doing -anything-, by simply interpreting it to be an insult to Muhammed.


Jim
said

Wow. Is this the 21st or 11th Century?


Kathy
said

I have a question. If a foreign teacher can be sentenced to jail time for allowing her students to chose a name for a teddy bear; can the parents of these students be sentenced to jail time for neglecting their children's religious education? After all, it appears the students did not know they could not name the teddy bear after the Muslim Prophet Muhammad?


G.Williams
said

Cassandra seems to suggest that all rules should be rigidly applied without contextual considerations.

To quote W.S. Churchill, "Rules are for the guidance of wise men, and the blind obedience of fools".

Most cultures have had a principle that one gives a guest the benefit of any doubt.


J. Brown
said

As a professional working in a foreign country, it is not only common sense to have a basic understanding of cultural differences, but for your EMPLOYER to ensure that you understand these differences and are willing to accept the position under those terms. Clearly, in a tense region (or any for that matter), it is ludicrous, as a teacher, to assume that you are outside the rules, ESPECIALLY when you are considered a role model to those whom you have accepted the position to teach. Not only should this teacher be made aware of her error, but the consulate and the hiring officcials be held just as accountable. This could have easily blown up into a violent scene, affecting foreign relations all over the world. When are people going to accept that when in someone else's domain, you follow their rules, and if you don't like them, don't go there. And if you don't understand them, you'd better make sure you're asking questions.


Melanie
said

What I don't understand is how can someone defend these actions. I understand, no one is above the law in any country they visit, but to prosecute a teacher, who has given up their life to help a struggling country, for allowing her class to name a teddy bear what they like is riddiculous; no matter how you spin it.

This is not a hateful woman imposing threats to a religious group... this is a teacher sculpting the young minds of the future.

What impression will this leave on the students? A beloved teacher imprisioned over a stuffed teddy bear... they are impressionable youth and let's just hope they are not negatively influenced by this event.


Kathie
said

I agree that when you are travelling to foreign countries that you are subject to their laws but in this case everyone agrees that the children named the bear not the teacher. Shouldn't the children have know better since they live there. I don't see anything about the children all being thrown in jail because they named the bear. Another case of them twisting their laws to suit their needs.


janet
said

Roger T, it is not if she should be punished under which law, it's that she shouldn't be punished at all.

She allowed her student to name his teddy Muhammad, but she wasn't even thinking about THE prophet Muhammad. She was not insulting their prophet.

Furthermore, the student named the teddy after his own name, Muhammad , a common name among Muslims who pick it because it's the name of their prophet.

Also, I would want my country to defend me if I were charged for a crime I didn't do in another country. Wouldn't you?


Denise
said

Roger T and Pat - Pending: You are both assuming that a law was actually broken and that the terrible evil West is trying to assert its dominance and not respect another country's laws. There was no law broken unless you consider that every person bearing Mohammed's name should be imprisoned,tortured and possibly put to death - along with the parents who did the naming. This teacher's only crime is that she is a westerner. What happened to her is simply an expression of the hatred and fear that Sudan's religious extremists have for anyone who does not think, believe and behave as they do. (The fact that she is a woman would have only increased their anger.) This must have been an irresistable opportunity for the clerics to demonstrate the power and control that they wield in that country.


Ian
said

This is nothing more than politics, at its worst, at play here. The Sudan isn't seeing eye to eye with GB over the Darfur issue and is now using this poor woman as a pawn. Apparently the whole issue of the prophet being used in an inappropriate manner does not apply here, according to some Muslims I have spoken to. If this is political then GB should take political actions of its own.


Paul
said

It's noteworthy (in a bad way) how quick the term "Islamofascism" came up in the comments section here. Islamofascism is an utterly bogus term, it's a 100% American concept dreamt up in Washington by Neo-conservatives, like so much other military-aggression-propelling terminology and stupefying jingoistic catch phrases people are adopting without a second of logical or critical thought these days. It's sad and worrying to see how easily Karl Rove has extended his reach into the collective Canadian psyche...

That said, this punishment for this particular crime is absolutely ridiculous, but unfortunately this woman is bound by the laws of Sudan and really should have known better, or at least have been trained properly about perilous legal and social transgressions she might not be aware of while working there. I hope she gets through it okay...


M. Cameron
said

If only she had taken the responsibility of becoming familiar with the laws and customs of the country in which she lived. Now she is paying the price for her own ignorance.


Jason
said

Hey I don't agree with this but it's their law. You wouldn't want someone coming here and telling us growing opium shouldn't be a crime right? And the suggestion to stop aid is harsh as it's the people who would suffer, not the government.


Sean
said

Funny thing about it all is that it happend at a Christian School too...on a side note, don't put all Muslims in the same pot...all religions have extremist elements...


G.Williams
said

I want to thank Ray in London for clarifying the nature of "Sharia". I particularly liked his inclusion of "mobs" in his list of practitioners.

Obviously this is a system that is open to abuse of power and personal bias and doesn't constitute what we understand as "law".

There have been attempts to embed Sharia in the legal process of western countries. These must be resisted. We got past that point centuries ago.



Greg
said

Jason

As I recall, recently a number of Chinese imigrants were charged in Ontario with "cultivation" of an illeagal substance. As it turned out these unknowing persons were dupped into doing so by local Nationals. The court aquited them of the charges and rightfully so. The only persons convicted are the Nationals who dupped the imigrants in the first place.

The issue I have with this whole affair in Sudan is that why did the person who reported to authorities not go to the school officials first? This could have been diffused quietly right from the outset. I guess it was not in their self serving interests!


Ron J.
said

I.Q. of lettuce. Plain and simple. The whole incident shows the stupidity of others; proof that most people only make it in life on the backs of those much smarter. Most only have electricity because a few were smart enough to invent it. Most have medicine because a few were brilliant enough to make those discoveries. Most people on the planet couldn't survive if it wasn't for the intelligence of a few.

It comes down to who the leaders are as to where the sheep will end up.

In this case, the leaders are as dumb as the sheep.




Tamouh
said

Definitely there is a group behind this story. If the parents didn't complain, the kids picked the name by themselves and the name Muhammad is common name anyway. It is not reserved just for the prophet. In fact, name Muhammad was commonly used before and after his message. So what is the fuss about? I think as a Muslim It'd make an emotional attachment with the child to name his teddy bear a name that he loves and respect. The clergy is out of order on this one, and the courts are screwed. But it is their country and they can do whatever the hell they want.

I just think there is absolutely nothing wrong in what she did and this is no way account for an insult.


Po
said

I'm not against Islam in any way but it seems to me some branches are extremely intolerant of others. In no way was there a reference to the prophet when they named the teddy bear, only the name Muhammad, which is a very common arabic name.

The simple fact that the clerics demanded demonstrations speaks loads about the way these guys get public support... through hate and discrimination. Had the front of the book said "Hi, I am the prophet Muhammad", then they could have said what they wanted but this was completely innocent and it appears to me that they're just going after a foreigner that is promoting a religion other then theirs.


Marlene
said

Paul, the term Islamofascist was termed by a practicing Canadian Sufi in Toronto whose been targeted by Islamofascists. He admitted to it on either a Michael Coren show or a TVO show. MANY Muslims also use this term.

Stop blaming the term on the U.S. Your political rhetoric is loosely veiled and so typical of Canadian bigotry.


Peaceful Religion
said

I encourage people to check out http://www.thereligionofpeace.com for a better understanding of Islam and its place in the world today.


C
said

I read in another article that the teddy bear was named after a popular classmate named Muhammad and not the prophet. No one has said there was a law against naming a bear after another person.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz