CTV News | Quebec moves to ban cellphone use while driving

Top Stories -   

Quebec moves to ban cellphone use while driving

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Jed Kahane covers the new driving laws
CTV Montreal: Tania Krywiak looks at the deadly connection between cell phones and driving

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(18)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Wed. Nov. 14 2007 6:33 PM ET

Quebec Transport Minister Julie Boulet tabled new legislation Wednesday aimed at cracking down on dangerous drivers, including a ban on cellphone use while behind the wheel.

Drivers caught talking on their phones would be given three demerit points and fined between $80 to $100, although so-called "hands free" devices would still be allowed.

If the bill is passed by the National Assembly, it would make Quebec the second province in Canada to institute such a ban, following Newfoundland and Labrador.

Other measures in the bill include:

  • Lowering the blood-alcohol limit from 0.08 per cent to 0.05 per cent;
  • Photo radar and red-light cameras in 15 easily identifiable zones, with municipalities given the power to add more;
  • Mandatory driving lessons for all new drivers;
  • Banning hand-held cellphone use while driving; and,
  • Installing devices to prevent truckers from travelling more than 105 kilometres per hour.

If drivers are caught with a blood-alcohol level above 0.05 per cent, their license would automatically be suspended for 24 hours. Further penalties for drunk-driving would also be increased significantly.

The proposed legislation is based on a study by the province's road-safety task force, chaired by Jean-Marie De Koninck.

He told CTV Montreal that he would like even further steps taken against intoxicated drivers.

"We want Transport Canada to implement, as soon as possible and in an all new vehicles, an alcohol ignition interlock device," he said. "So no cars would be in motion if you have an impaired driver at the wheel."

Boulet discussed several details of the legislation this past weekend, and even came under fire late Tuesday when opposition parties accused her of being in contempt for revealing too many details before the bill was tabled.

Public pressure over the death of Quebec toddler Bianca Leduc likely fast-tracked the legislation.

Hundreds in Ile Perrot, Que., took to the streets over the weekend in a march to remember the three-year-old girl who died earlier this month, when an out-of-control car struck her as she played in the yard of her babysitter's home.

Cellphone ban

Newfoundland and Labrador is the only province in Canada to have successfully banned the use of cellphones in vehicles, passing legislation in 2003. Fines range from $45 to $180.

Road safety expert Etienne Blais told CTV Montreal that the added distraction leads to an increase in collision risk.

"You are less likely to keep distance between you and the other vehicle and you are less likely to stay in the middle of the line," Blais said

Records at the Quebec coroner's office state that between 2000 and 2005 there were 20 fatal crashes on the province's roads linked to mobile phone use.

"It's quite the same as driving while intoxicated by alcohol or even speeding," Blais told CTV Montreal.

Blais said driving while on the phone poses more risk than talking to a passenger because a passenger will lower their voice or speak slower depending on the level of distraction for the driver.

He also said there is little difference in distraction between hand-held and hand-free devices.

Cellphone use while driving is on the rise according to an August 2007 survey conducted by the Canadian Traffic Injury Research Foundation.

  • 37 per cent of drivers admitted to using their cellphones while behind the wheel in 2007.
  • In 2001, only 20.5 per cent of Canadian drivers admitted to using their phones while on the road.

With reports from CTV Montreal's John Grant and Tania Krywiak

Comments are now closed for this story

JTJ
said

Good ideas BUT with the lack of patrols from officers, who's going to enforce these new measures...

What we need is for ALL police agencies to start working together and stop thinking about who's going to take the credit for X number of impaired drivers caught in one month. The only stat they shoud worry about is protecting the public...


Sherry
said

It's about time. They should have been banned when they first came into the market! Clearly the big telecommunications companies are funding the governments with some big money. EVERYONE knows the dangers of cell phones and driving, just like EVERYONE knows the dangers of speeding. Its going to be about policing as JTJ said.

I only hope legislation will spread across the country!


Yew Wish
said

They should make the "cell phone" law nationwide! When I'm driving, I notice that a lot of people that are talking on their cell phones are not watching what they're doing when driving. The next time you get cut off in traffic, watch to see if the person who did it is talking on their cell phone... nine times out of ten they'll be yacking away on the phone and not even realize what they did.


Gerald Skowronski
said

First they take our cell phones then they'll take our Tim Horton's coffee. After that our choice to smoke inside of our vehicles. Then it's no talking to our fellow passengers - too distracting. I may as well stay home from work tomorrow. Some people have too much time on their hands and noses too big for their own business.


Scott
said

I dislike the use of cell phone use while driving. Go back to the days of pulling over and using a pay phone. Hmm what next a cell jammer for cars that cells will only work if the car is not running? Actually I love cell jammers, my wife keeps one in her purse when we eat out. Gotta love Israeli technology.

2nd thought on cell use, in my are reading the newspaper and applying lipstick and combing the hair out number cell users.


CT
said

This should be a Canada wide model. People have to understand that while at the wheel of a 1000kg vehicle, a mere moment of inattention can cause the death of another human being. You cannot take that back and you have to live with the question of was that cell caller that much more important? Think about it, let's say one of your kids or friend is the victim?

Now, take a young driver talking on his cell, add the extreme DBs coming out of his/her car radio and you just doubled the potential for disaster.

The same goes for the "Oh so important executive who holds the balance of the universe with that phone call"

Enforcement will also play a huge part has JTJ mentionned above; and the rule will also apply to our law enforcement folks who are often seen talking on their cell while driving. It's all about setting the correct example.


Sparky
said

When I see a vehicle waiting to turn across my path at an intersection/driveway I will leave them room to do so--if they are not on a cell phone--if I can see that they are on the phone I will pull up as I normally would and block them from going in front of me. My rationale? They are not paying attention anyway and won't notice. Want to make a phone call? PULL OVER!!


Paul Connolly
said

Good Going Quebec, Excellent Plan!

Isn't it sad we have to legislate responsibility. We tend to be selfish beings with no regards for others and the lives of others so laws have to be passed.

I've seen too many incidences of distracted drivers, far too many.

Come on Canada, cell phone use while driving should be banned across the country!


Mike
said

Thats a start! Then they can ban passing on the median on the Laurentian Autoroute as I have seen. After that they can nab QC drivers coming back from Toronto in convoys doing 140kms as they cross the Ont/QC border. Once that is in hand they can catch those who pass on a single lane on curved overpasses in zupped up BMW's on the West Island who burn rubber on their front tires just SLOWING down to make the turn so they wont slam into you BEFORE they pass you!! See it all in QC. Scary place to drive really!. These are welcomed measures.


Raymond
said

And what about the police/emergency services drivers talking on their radios/telephones? How about airline pilots keying the mike while shooting an approach? Maybe some people shouldn't drive. Period.


Ian
said

Go for it. Banning cell phone use is long overdue. TOOOOOOOO many drivers talk on their phone while writing on a pad, putting on make up and whatever. How many people have to get killed or seriously injured before the offender realizes they have a weapon in their hands.

sk GVRD
said

Just look around as you drive. Everyone is attached to the phone. Frightening! This is a great initiative. Kudos as well to companies like Finning who have mandated their employees must pull over to use a cell phone! The technology is there to suggest every car sold in Canada should have bluetooth/ hands-free phones built in just like they must have daytime running lights. Probably only adds $100'ish to the price when mass produced.


Al
said

One thing not mentioned by Etienne Blais is that a driver needs two hands to drive. The controls of a car are designed for the driver to use both hands.

I wish that Etienne Blais and Québec legislature would challenge other provinces, like mine (Manitoba, who wants to raise speed limits) to do the same.

Québec is the only province with any sense in making laws to protect their habitants and the environment.


-Brian-
said

The biggest objection that I have to cell phone use (with hand holding cellphone) is the lack of signalling by these drivers. They seem to feel, because their hand (usually left) is busy holding the cellphone, that they cannot be bothered to signal either their lane changes or their turns. If this practice continues, signalling, itself, would be up for question. Even today, many police officers and others don't seem to care if they signal or not.

As far as the "studies" about the use of cellphones while driving being equivalent to impaired driving, the medical doctors have being saying this since people started to use cellphones in vehicles.


Ryan
said

Ban cell phones while driving good idea. Photo radar bad idea. It's time to re-evaluate our speed limits. We now have safer more responsive cars. We should finally reap the rewards of technology rather than be punished for it.


Uwe Warkholdt, Elliot Lake, Northern Ontario
said

I firmly believe in banning cell phones while driving.

I have been a licensed driver for over 35 years and until recently have driven thousands of miles in Northern Ontario every year without incident.

However, one day I was talking on my cell phone while driving and nearly hit a deer. I was truly distracted. This has never ever happened to me before. Now when I need to use my cell phone, I pull over first.

I see many people using a cell phone while driving. I truly hope that Ontario takes Quebec as a good example and does the same.

Regan
said

well, I thought i heard it all...one of the biggest users of cell phones in cars are the RCMP when they stop using there phones so would I...how on earth would you enforce such a stupid law everywhere in the country the RCMP are crying for bigger budgets for what they're dealing with now, never mind cell phone users why can't politicians think before they open their mouths?


It's about time!
said

This is the first time that I've seen any province looking at lowering the blood-alcohol limit and it's about time. Alcohol-related accidents are the number 1 killer and they are 100% preventable. They don't get much dumber than a person who thinks that he/she can drive after having a few drinks.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz