CTV News | Saskatchewan's election a non-ideological affair

Top Stories -   

Saskatchewan's election a non-ideological affair

From left, Saskatchewan Party Leader Brad Wall, Liberal Leader David Karwacki and NDP Leader Lorne Calvert get ready for their leader's debate on Tuesday, Oct. 30, 2007 in Regina, Sask. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Troy Fleece)

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(16)

By: Bill Doskoch, CTV.ca News

Date: Sat. Nov. 3 2007 7:40 AM ET

After coming close in 1999 and 2003, this appears to be the year the Saskatchewan Party pushes the NDP from power in a provincial election.

Two polls released publicly indicate the mildly centre-right party has a substantial lead over the mildly centre-left party that has ruled Saskatchewan since 1991 -- with Lorne Calvert as party leader and premier since 2001.

However, 'mild' is the operative word when describing the two parties' ideological differences.

"There's a bit of polarization, but it's tactical more than ideological, like: 'Who's going to look after my interests better?'" Ken Rasmussen, a University of Regina political scientist, told CTV.ca.

About 15 seats are in play in urban Saskatchewan, and both the main contenders are trying to reach those voters in time for the Nov. 7 election, he said.

The Saskatchewan Party is likely to pick up seven or eight seats in the wealthier suburbs of Regina and Saskatoon. With the NDP unlikely to make gains in rural Saskatchewan, that's enough to change the government, Rasmussen said.

If Saskatchewanians do change their government, they will do so at a time of almost unparalleled prosperity in the prairie province.

The province is raking in the bucks from the same energy boom that has lifted Alberta's economy to dizzying heights.

Prices are good for major commodities like uranium and potash. Even agriculture, long a depressed part of the economy, is seeing buoyant prices for grains and oilseeds.

But the NDP has a problem, Rasmussen said: People are tired of them.

This has happened before. The 11-year-old government of NDP Premier Allan Blakeney got swept out of office in 1982 by a Progressive Conservative tidal wave.

A brash young agricultural economist named Grant Devine led the Tories to victory, telling the province, "there's so much more we can be" -- and turning the NDP's "tried and trusted" slogan into "tired and rusted."

This time, the Saskatchewan Party is led by Brad Wall, who took over in 2004 but who has been involved in conservative provincial politics for much of his life. For much of the campaign, he's been calling the current NDP government "tired and old."

Fear factor

While the Saskatchewan Party can offer fresh faces, it made itself look "scary" in 2003 when then-leader Elwin Hermanson -- a one-time federal Reform Party MP -- refused to promise his party wouldn't privatize Crown corporations. The NDP clung to power with a two-seat margin, taking 30 of 58 seats.

Wall, 41, has stressed that no wholesale privatizations will take place under his leadership -- and has attacked the NDP for fear-mongering.

In one pre-election ad filmed at a football practice, Wall calmly tells the camera: "They might say anything ... maybe that I'm a secret Calgary Stampeders fan."

Over at the NDP's website, they don't accuse Wall of being a Stampeders fan, which if true, would be political death in the Saskatchewan Roughriders-mad province. But you can see a graphic there labelled "The same old Sask Party." An image shows a wolf in sheep's clothing -- with a red 'no' line superimposed.

"What lies behind the friendly new image?" the NDP asks, urging people to say 'no' to the Sask Party's "hidden agenda."

The NDP talks up the Saskatchewan Party's inexperience and "recklessness," and calls its opponent an apologist for Prime Minister Stephen Harper.

Calvert got into a fight with the feds over equalization earlier this year.

However, scrapping with Ottawa and trying to link Wall and the Saskatchewan Party to the bad memories of the Devine years don't appear to be paying dividends.

"It's all they've got left," Rasmussen said of the NDP's campaign, adding that it worked in 2003.

Neither the NDP nor the Sask Party are wasting any time attacking the Liberals. Party Leader David Karwacki has the unenviable task of trying to capture attention in a province that often splits between a left and right-wing choice.

Karwacki's party got shut out in 2003. If the polls are correct, that might happen again on Wednesday. If Karwacki doesn't win his own seat this time, he's likely done as leader, Rasmussen said.

Fighting for the centre

While the province has historically been split between left and right, the ideological distances on policies have never been smaller as the three main parties fight for the centre.

The two main contenders are using the province's current prosperity as an opportunity to make spending promises. The NDP has promised to cap drug subscription costs at $15. The Sask Party promises farm families they will save thousands on education property tax.

Calvert in turn has talked about property tax relief for everyone -- including renters. (As an FYI, the NDP is strongest in cities.)

"This a low-key, non-ideological election," Rasmussen said. "It's really about changing the elite in the province as changing the policy direction."

Ultimately, the Saskatchewan public likes NDP policies -- they're just tired of the NDP, he said.

The Sask Party recognizes that and has shed the old Reform Party tinge that coloured its early days, Rasmussen said. "They have reinvented themselves as a mainstream conservative party, and that seems to be enough to make people think they're okay."

If the Sask Party does form the government, Rasmussen said don't expect the Saskatchewan version of the Mike Harris "Common Sense Revolution" in Ontario.

But from a province that has seen pitched political battles in the past over things like medicare, nationalization and privatization, that sounds somewhat dull.

"This has been a terribly boring election," Rasmussen said.

Share with your social Network:

Comments are now closed for this story

Alberta Cam
said

Over the years the NDP have pushed all the right leaning people out of the province. Scare tactics have worked well for them.

David
said

So, who else can picture laughing in the PMO?

Around June the Sask. Party held a 17 point lead over the incumbent Dippers. Now, it seems that for the most part those numbers have held up.

With Calvert gone in a matter of days, I suppose that's one less premier to oppose Harper in a Federal election.


Mike
said

As the people of Sask begin to prosper a little they realize that the NDP offer nothing of interest for them nor will the NDP protect the prosperity machine. NDP have a way of killing prosperity and hurting "...working Canadians".


Rob
said

Go Saskatchewan!!! I almost took a job in Swift Current years ago... but I decided to stay in Alberta because I couldn't see any future for NDP's Saskatchewan. Maybe things will get better there with the Sask. Party.


Ash from MJ
said

What a well written article, I think it captures the mood here in Saskatchewan very well, especially the "terribly boring election" comment. No real push by the Sask Party to win, I think they realized all they needed to do was not screw it up. The NDP's scare tactics have failed and although it doesn't look like an overwhelming victory, it should easily be a majority for Brad Wall.

It would be nice to see Karwacki get his seat though...

It'll be nice to see the end of this equalization fight with Ottawa, it was just silly, how can you say we're entitled to more money from Ottawa while cutting the PST by two per cent, ridiculous.


Jim
said

I genuinely fear for my province if the Sask Party gets in. I do not believe that they have forsaken their cherised desire to sell our Crown Corps.

I also hope the Liberals turf Karwacki. He had a real chance to form the government, but lacked the vision and courage necessary to try. He is by far the biggest disappointment in this entire campaign.


Bill
said

Jim, they have committed to not selling the crown corporations. I wish people would open their eyes and listen to what is really being said instead of taking the NDP scare tactics and thinking they are true. Surely Saskatchewan people are not so weak minded.


Shane Prpich
said

I am a University student in Saskatoon and I may be forced to drop out if the Sask Party wins. I will face a dramatic tuition increase along with a substantial increase in living expenses. The flood gates are about to be opened to private business by Brad Wall and the vast majority of Saskatchewan residents are going to be the losers.


Dale
said

It doesn't matter who wins, it'll still be same ball game, different players. If the NDP wins,nothing changes. If the SK wins,a bunch of people will be replaced to bring in workers that follow the party line. And most promises won't be kept because they'll probably say something like they didn't realize the province was in such bad shape and that it can't afford to


Ryan
said

I find this sad and unfortunate. Provincial NDP parties on the praries seem to be the only New Democrats left who stick to their roots, and follow the traditional principles the party was founded on. The poor performance of the federal party in the same places such as Saskatchewan and Manitoba where the NDP regularly forms government is testament to that. I wish the Sask NDP luck, but I know that the values of the provinces people will be held to, no matter which party forms the government.


tam
said

If you don't believe the SK party will just cave into the feds on the equalization challenge I have a bridge in Saskatoon to sell you.

This, despite being a fed/prov issue is one that irks me and why I won't vote SK party this time around.

Though Wall has said otherwise, like Harper I suspect he will ultimately support Sask remaining on the "dole" from the feds who will tell us in Sask what we may or may not do with our money and how we may or may not do it.

Given that other features of the prov. party platforms are essentially the same this is the tipping point issue for me.

What mystifies me even more is how our PC parlimentarians can with a "straight face" suggest that Harper's dealing with SK is just or fair in light of the deals cut with other provinces. And even more mystifying is that people would consider voting on a fed level for these same people again.

But that's another story.
Should be fun watching the prov. results on TV.

regards,







Ishmael N. Daro
said

Although I'm an NDP supporter, it seems inevitable that the SaskParty will win and I'm not scared. As the article states, all the parties are ideologically similar. I wish the Liberals would become a stronger force in the province's politics though. It always helps to have a strong centrist party.


Keith P
said

Glad to see the baseless allegations that the Sask party will privatize the crowns etc. Shows the incredible lack of originality and thought on the part of the NDP sheep out there!


Marco Funk
said

I spent five years in rural Saskatchewan, and I can't wait to move back. Personally, I enjoyed the NDP party. I volunteered as a visitor at the PA penitentiary once a month and found that many of the programs that helped the inmate I was visiting were initiated by the NDP government. Now, when my friend was let out on parole, he is no longer looking for the next hit of drugs or the next bottle of whiskey. For myself, I can look after myself and my own; I expect my government to help look after people that can't look after themselves (the sick, the underprivileged, the weak). The NDP were doing a good job at this. However, there are numerous ways they could do a lot better. Reforms in the justice system are needed. Also, Saskatchewan should really think carefully about allowing oil companies to rape our lands and soils, just so they can make a quick buck. Also, we should think carefully about whether its good that we mine so much uranium - we should at least specify the companies we sell it to, so that our products are never used to make Weapons of Mass Destruction. Anyways... just some thoughts. I look forward to living in Saskatchewan again. I hope that voters think of more than themselves and their own pocketbooks when they go to the polls, and think also of what party will do a good job of fulfilling the role God requires of governments: that is, to encourage goodness, justice, to help the needy - and to discourage/punish/limit/curb violence, crime, injustice, 'evil'.


Jeff
said

Finally the scare tactic's of the NDP are failing to sway voters who realise that their is a bright future ahead for this province. People are now seeing that we should have responsible government but government open to people who are not afraid to invest in themselves without being told what they can and cannot do. Go Sask Party.


Ted
said

The Sask NDP likes to boast about all the things that have become better while they have been in gov't but if you look in to those things they include it's not hard to see that they have only happened out of coincidence and not from anything they have done.


 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz

Most Talked about Stories

The chance of the destruction of our planet is very very small with this collider, but who are these people to decide what risks are acceptable for all of mankind? It puts me at unease and adds to my anxiety. CERN acknowledges that there are miniscule risks -- they admit to it so please spare the convoluted retorts.

kc-bby

Hadron Collider back in action after year of repairs