CTV News | Fall fiscal update expected to include GST cut

Top Stories -   

Fall fiscal update expected to include GST cut

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Ottawa Bureau Chief Robert Fife reports
CTV Newsnet: Flaherty makes the announcement
Mike Duffy Live: Party whips debate what the economic update will mean
CTV Newsnet: David Akin explains Flaherty's announcement

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(74)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Mon. Oct. 29 2007 10:41 PM ET

Finance Minister Jim Flaherty's fall fiscal update is expected to fulfill an election promise to cut the GST to five per cent, CTV News has learned.

Flaherty has said he'll give the update at 4 p.m. ET after the markets close, perhaps indicating that it contains several major tax reductions.

"Well, we certainly feel that Canadians pay too much tax," he told reporters.

Analysts said the GST cut could be timed for the holiday season, and would also be aimed at keeping Canadians from shopping in the U.S. to take advantage of a strong loonie.

After the GST cut, a $30,000 car would cost $300 less, and Canadians would save 50 cents on a $50 Christmas tree.

"It's one percentage point less in taxes than you would otherwise pay, and you see it up immediately the minute the rate comes off," Jeff Rubin, chief economist for CIBC World Markets, told CTV News.

Liberal Leader Stephane Dion said Monday he would prefer income tax cuts rather than reducing the GST.

"Compared with income tax cuts, a GST cut does nothing to improve our competitiveness in the world economy and does little to improve the fairness of our tax system, improve our productivity and move our economy forward," he said in a statement.

"The experts are united against a GST cut and we Liberals agree with them. It seems there is only one person who studied economics that wants to cut the GST -- and his name is Stephen Harper."

The government promised in its Oct. 16 throne speech that it would reduce the GST, and likely has the spending room to cut income taxes as well.

Last week, the department announced it had built up an $8.7 billion budgetary surplus in the first five months of this fiscal year.

"The government can easily afford it," said Rubin. "They are probably looking at another $15-billion-plus surplus. The GST cut is somewhere around $5 billion.

Dion has suggested he wouldn't topple the government over a GST cut, although he hasn't given a firm answer, while the NDP would likely oppose any major business tax reductions.

Flaherty wanted to present the fiscal update in the House of Commons -- another possible hint it will include major tax cuts -- but the NDP hasn't given its consent.

"If I can't do it in the House of Commons because of the NDP, then I'll do it somewhere else," Flaherty told reporters.

When former prime minister Paul Martin was a Liberal finance minister, he presented his fiscal updates in front of the government's finance committee.

Liberal whip Karen Redman dismissed the government's move to deliver the update on the floor of the House as a publicity stunt.

"We see Mr. Harper looking for maximum media coverage, and to ratchet up the expectations of Canadians to create some drama that isn't necessarily there," she told CTV's Mike Duffy Live.

Along with shaving another percentage point from the GST, Flaherty is also considering income splitting for all Canadian couple. The move would likely cost the government $5 billion.

He may also scrap the mid-range 26 per cent tax bracket and trim the lowest bracket to 15 per cent.

With a report by CTV's Robert Fife and files from The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Roch
said

I am very anxious to hear how prosperous Canada has become, and our government's plans for future prosperity and success.

Canada has never looked so good.



Scott
said

I wonder if it will also include raising taxes on the poor to pay for their stupid GST cut, like they did in the first budget. It's unfortunate that Canadians just let that slide.

Greg
said

Spending LIBERAL money again! The people will know this so he had better be careful for the Conservatives NOT to take the credit! They spend, they do not save!

Michael
said

Increase in personal taxes??

Given the surplus from OVERTAXATION of Canadians it wouldn't be prudent to increase any taxes to individuals at this time. Governments act as if it is THEIR money in the budget surplus... it BELONGS TO CANADIANS not the politicians nor bureaucrats and they would be wise to regard it in that light.


Richard
said

Myself, I'd rather see increased debt payments than tax cuts. I am in my mid-20's and had no conscious decision with economic policy during the years that the debt was accumulated. Yet, my generation and I are going to pay for it. The previous generation(s) should take some responsibility for the debt their children are inheriting.

Ron
said

Canada is on top of the world. We have become bigger and better leaders through our fiscal health, quality of jobs and lifestyle, Good job Harper. Good to see the Liberal party in the rear view mirror where I hope they'll stay.

J. L.
said

Time to give us taxpayers an income tax break, "Conservatives." So sick of hearing about multi-billion dollar budget surplus. We are over taxed!

Annie
said

The news from this government can only get better. My husband and I look forward to across the board cuts, as well as another 1% from the GST, being announced tomorrow in the economic statement.

Goodness knows we all could use some tax relief.


Micheal
said

I am expecting that the government will cut income taxes for our working families. The income splitting is also good for all working Canadians.

SaskDave
said

I am only a simple wage earner, but I like the idea of a cut to the GST and do not support Mr. Dion's preference for 'general' tax cuts. That being said, I believe we can afford the GST rate cut, and further general tax cuts, too.

D.R. - Calgary
said

To all those who were whining that they couldn't wait a few weeks to get tax cuts. Here it comes. But for some reason, I think that whatever tax cuts there are. There will be those who will whine and whine and whine. Count your blessings that you live where you do.


Dean
said

Not only have taxes been reduced in every single way that the government collects taxes, the country's economic performance has never been better. Canadians can take great pride in tomorrow's economic update as can Prime Minister Harper and Minster Flaherty.

Ken
said

The GST cut is a thinly veiled tax cut for the rich, plain and simple. It means you need to spend money to save money. What about those of us who are just sick to death of the government with their hands in our pockets? What about those of us who want to SAVE money? Income tax cuts are the only real tax cuts that will benefit families, but like all of Harper's foolish policies, the Conservative sheep are just lapping up every last drop of Harper's propaganda instead of truly looking at the big picture and realizing that Harper just needed the score popularity points with those who aren't educated in economics.

Kevin
said

One thing to keep in mind is that a budget has to prepare for worse case scenarios so when people get upset about a surplus at the end of the year please keep in mind that the budget was developed 14-15 months prior to the surplus being obtained and at the time the price of oil was a lot lower.


Terry
said

Hey Greg

They aren't spending LIBERAL money. They are spending Canadians' money.

PJ
said

These messages that praise our leaders for the state of the nation are somewhat creepy. We're the ones responsible--and it's taken decades to get here--the most our government can do is not screw up too badly...




Mark K
said

I read the article carefully twice and what the Conservatives are intending in terms of tax cuts.

I am looking for a volunteer to help Dion remove his foot from his mouth :-)

John
said

FYI, it was the previous LIBERAL government who partially lowered income taxes. It was under Mr. Harper that income taxes were RAISED to pay for his GST cut. Whoever denies that the Conservatives are business oriented, needs to look at the big picture. A GST cut will only make people want to BUY more products, which will benefit businesses. An income tax cut will actually put money in our pockets.

janet
said

"CANADA NEVER LOOKED SO GOOD"

this is all the work of the previous government,
NOT the current year old conservative govt

...in fact we may not look so good anymore if we continue to spend on overseas military missions, cut the (does-nothing-for-the-economy)GST, slash funding to social programs that keep communities prosperous and safe, slash funding to environmental programs, and spend millions on jail sentences that are already proven not to work in the U.S.

Mike
said

I as a young Canadian would like all GST, and interest saved from debt reduction locked in to pay for our debt. Wasn't that the original purpose?

I think econmically and taxation wise, Canada will be a stronger country with no debt rather than a couple thousand saved in taxes and us wasting billions in interest.


LM
said

What dark corner do these liberals hide in that they think martin or cretien are responsible for this surplus. They are the ones that were stealing it remember! GST cuts help every Canadian, that is why Mr Harper thinks it is responsible to do so. OOPPs, that is not selve serving so I guess the liberals and npd would not recognize it!

Bryant Wood
said

You know. Everybody is arguing about what? Taxes going down. What's to argue about. Only a few short years ago budgets were constantly in the red. Whether you're Conservative or Liberal this is good news. Sure Martin and Chretien started the process by gutting the military, EI benefits, bracket creep and massive increases to CPP, but it was needed. Now that the problem has been solved we can start to repair those areas, pay back debt and give some much needed tax relief. We are the only G8 country doing this. Don't complain. Ride the wave. Canada is the place to be for the forseeable future. Harper is doing a bang up job and deserves plenty of credit. He said he'd cut the GST to 5% and he's following through. Unlike Chretien who said it would be "gone". What happened there? Just be happy to be in such a prosperous nation. God bless Canada.

Sean Calder
said

Stephane Dion can argue as much as he likes. The Conservatives PROMISED that they would reduce the GST to 5% over the course of their mandate. They immediately shaved off the first percentage point after being elected. Shaving off the second point is fulfilling that promise. And that's something this government has been doing. Keeping promises.

It seems the Liberals have a problem with people keeping promises. That promises are a thing to compromise in favor of something more popular. But then they have an obvious track record on breaking promises.

And don't kidd yourself. If the Conservatives failed to keep that promise before the next election, the Liberals would showcase it as a promise broken. Can't win with those darned Liberals eh? Damned if you do, damned if you don't.

And while yes, in order to benefit from that tax cut, you need to spend money, but the last time I checked, I HAVE to spend money every single month through bills and services and a whole variety of other spending I'm required to do. I'll be saving money there for certain, and will enjoy it!


Andrew MacKendrick
said

I would much rather have that 1% of the GST dedicated solely to health care or education than it be reduced. That 1% only helps rich people who are making larger purchases. Lower incomes will not see the benefits, and on many of the necessities they buy (like food and clothing) to not even get taxed GST. Do what's socially responsible, not just economical!

Steve
said

Seems some believe that only wealthy folks would benefit from a GST cut. Incorrect. The poor pay GST, and every percentage cut makes a proportionately larger difference to them than to the wealthy. Besides, most poor folks don't make enough income to even need to pay income tax. Therefore, unless the GST is cut, the poor will not have any tax relief whatsoever!

So to cut personal, corporate and GST taxes will benefit everyone... and stimulate the economy, all at the same time. I wish the doubting-Thomases would open their minds to this plain truth.

Couver
said

I'm mostly for decreasing personal income tax rates instead of the GST. But I do realize the GST reduction was a tory promise and Harper will make sure he keeps that one. And when you look at it at least we are getting some tax cuts. After the tories decrease the GST one more point I think they will start focusing on personal income tax cuts.

Income splitting acrss the board!
said

The Finance Minister would do well to start by providing a break affordable to all through income splitting as well as other forms of tax reduction.

MR. MINISTER, BE A HERO - SIMPLIFY OUR TAX SYSTEM. Reduce the paper burden, eliminate the oppressive tax regime. Save $$.



Raymond
said

Ken: A tax cut is a tax cut. If these surpluses continue, I wouldn't be surprised to see a personal income tax cut as well.

Bill from NS
said

I hate to say it but I think I'd rather see the debt paid down some more then tax cuts. As much as I dislike the huge percentage taken off my pay check every week the government would actually save Canadians quite a bit in interest on the debt by doing so.


Mark
said

With the infrastructure needs we have, no GST cut, instead give it to the provinces for sewer, water, bridges, rec complexes, roads. Those are our biggest changes for today. Don't waste the opportunities.

debbie
said

Reduce personal income taxes, and get the government out of the bedrooms of the nation! There is too much government involvement in every aspect of our lives...thats how fascist dictatorships arise!

Al
said

OK I admit it, I am greedy, I want my tax cut and frankly I'll take it any way the government wants to hand it to me. I look at it this way: Better in my pocket than in theirs to piddle away...


David
said

Sean Calder - The Conservatives have been keeping promises? Kind of like how they "kept their promise" about income trusts? "Kept their promise" about lowering taxes for all Canadians, when they actually RAISED them on all of us? "Kept their promise" on solving the softwood lumber deal while giving the US a backout clause? "Kept their promise" about allowing MPs to vote with their conscience then firing Bill Casey when he did exactly that?

And you say the Liberals have trouble keeping promises?? I think you need to open your eyes here, pal. Harper has lied more in 2 years than the Liberals ever did.

Roch
said

"this is all the work of the previous government,
NOT the current year old conservative govt"

No, this has nothing to do with AdScam illegal advertising making Liberals rich or billion dollar boondoggles, this has everything to do with our New Clean Canadian Government!

It is very nice to once again be Proud to be Canadian! Look at our mighty Conservative looney soar....

Hopeful
said

By all means cut the GST. By all means pay down the debt. How about using some of that budgetary surplus to increase the capital investment in the CPP and OAS? That way, today's earners will will have more confidence in being able to recieve CPP and OAS, when fewer and fewer workers have to pay into a system that has more and more people drawing from it.


Fredh
said

Some of the many reasons our government is flush with cash is the GST and the Free Trade Agreement (Now NAFTA) implemented during the Mulroney years. The Liberals had promised to scrap the GST but did not do it once they realized what a good tool it would be to fight the deficit. Let's give credit where credit is due, to the Mulroney government for the tough choices it made while were were drowning in red ink. Let's also give credit to the previous government for having eliminated the deficit using both the GST and NAFTA. And finally, let's give credit to the current government for paying down the debt and passing down the interest savings.
Let's all enjoy this while commodities prices are so high because what goes up must come down (the question is when and how low)
In view of all this, let's enjoy any tax break we get tomorrow on the next budget, we deserve it.


Richard
said

Is anyone not concerned or embarrased that Canada has a ~$500 billion debt? Doesn't that sound a little scary? Sound it out, count the number of zero's ... its pretty scary to me as a young Canadian. Instead of cutting taxes now, we should pay off the debt. Imagine the tax savings of not having to pay ~$30billion of interest annually. I feel tax cuts are short-sighted gains that are irresponsible. Debt payments are not built into the buget. The only time there are debt payments is when there are supluses.

Anyone who complains that a few billion surplus is robbery is not very money wise. As Kevin mentioned, the budget was desgined many months in advance. Second, the only time we make payments on the debt is when there is a surplus. Finally, any responsible budgeting would have a 'cushion' for unforseen negative events. Canada has been experiencing massive 'good times' and therefore is producing surpluses because of responsible budgeting.

P.S. Dean; compare the lowest federal tax bracket for 2005 to 2007. You'll quickly observe that the rates were raised by 0.5% to 15.5% (or 0.25% per year - which is a 3.3% overall increase in that bracket!). That is the tax bracket that hurts our country's poorest the most. How can you claim that the Conservatives have reduced the tax burden?

Steve
said

Harper has lied more in 2 years than the Liberals ever did. -David

-Oh, really?

I recall the Liberals promised to "scrap, kill, abolish" the GST... and didn't. A Big Lie if ever they told one, which they didn't, for they told many.

The Tories promised to cut the GST twice, by one point at a time... and have already gone halfway there and appear poised to fulfil the other half of the promise very soon. Big contrast!

And, come on... what lies? I can't think of any Tory lies at all. Liberal lies, however... where to start, eh? Oh, I started with the GST lie!


james
said

A federal reduction in taxes, regardless of whether they are GST, personnel or corporate; will result in provincial governments raising their taxes to keep Canadians at the tax threshold. The difference is, when it comes to blaming politicians for the failute to fund education, health, or infrastructure; the blame will be properly placed at the provinces doorstep.

Well done Mr Harper. The federal government has more than enough money to take care of federal spending priorities (defence, public safety, prisons, fisheries) and there is going to be a proper funding base for the provinces to manage their responsibilities: welfare, health, education, and infrastructure.

A final reversal of the Trudeau "federalist dream".


Rob
said

Andrew MacKendrick said:"
I would much rather have that 1% of the GST dedicated solely to health care or education than it be reduced. That 1% only helps rich people who are making larger purchases. Lower incomes will not see the benefits, and on many of the necessities they buy (like food and clothing) to not even get taxed GST. Do what's socially responsible, not just economical!"

Hello McFly, again for the millionth time, Health and Education are provincial responsibilities. Get your facts straight


Deepthinker
said

"when they actually RAISED them on all of us?"

A Liberal election promise is far differnt from a tax cut. The GST cut gave mroe to everyone than the 0.5% on $10 000 anyways.

"solving the softwood lumber deal while giving the US a backout clause?"

You see it is funny because I remember Paul Martin demanding that a deal could be reached is the Americans gave 3.4 Billion, which he did not get back and the Conservatives got 4 Billion so I think that we got a pretty good deal.

"allowing MPs to vote with their conscience"

I know you probably are not all up on parliamentry tradition but the party has said all the way back to reform that there should be free votes *EXCEPT* on the budget for obvious reasons. The Conservatives have had many free votes including on SSM which I believe the Liberals whipped and lost 7-8 MP's from their party for.

"pay down the debt"

To put some things in perspective the Conservative government has paid down half as much of the debt as the Liberals did in 18 months then the liberals did in 13 years.

So the moral of this story is that our Conservative Government is Responsible, Honourable and Strong. Thats a heck of a lot more than we can say about the sinking Liberal ship with "Not A Leader" Dion!


Bob G
said

David
Sean is bang on.
The conservatives never promised not to change "Income Trusts". They simply said they had no "plans" to change it. It was never a major part of their platform and was hardly discussed during the campaign. Several major companies decided to try and take advantage of this by switching to Income Trusts drastically altering the playing field.Because of this the government was forced to act and did so in a timely and responsible even though they had no "plans" to do so before these companies forced them. Broken promise....No..responsible action.
"Raised taxes" ...again no...my taxes did not go up from the previous year. They eliminated a proposed minor Liberal tax decrease which would have benefited a few Canadians and replaced it with a 1% reduction in the GST (as they promised) which at least benefited all Canadians. Plus the other targeted tax reductions they promised and delivered.
I seem to recall the Liberals vowing to eliminate the GST. After 13 years I was still waiting.
"Soft Wood Lumber Deal"...They promised action and they did it. It may not be perfect but they accomplished more in a few short month than the Liberals did in years.
"MPs allowed to vote with their conscious"...They have also done this but anyone with an ounce of brains must realize this does not apply to confidence bills which could bring down the government.
Now shall we go into a few other promises kept eg. tougher on crime...Legislation tabled but not yet passed....promise kept....improve our military...increasing manpower, improved equipment, improved infrastructure...promise kept.....Arctic sovereinty....new deep water port announced...new patrol boats announced ( sorry not the icebreakers), increase in the Rangers...promise basically kept.

Now shall we look look at the Liberals record after 13 years? Promise to eliminate the GST...hmmm....promise to replace the Sea King helicopters faster and cheaper than the Conservative programme they cancelled at a cost of $500 million to the Canadian taxpayer. I haven't seen one yet have you? And when they finally do arrive they will be more expensive.

Heck there isn't enough space here to go on.


Frank
said

The Harper government pays more attention to propaganda - instead of poor people. They cut the GST for its max media coverage effect, yet quietly raised the personal income tax last year (reduced by Liberals before the election), and made tax return more of a pain.


DAP
said

Canadians should be asking why the NDP will not allow the Finance Minister to give his economic update in the HOC.
Are afraid of something?
Why is Dion against the cutting of the GST?
Chretien was all set to eliminate the GST altogether, and his back room boys are running the show in the Liberal Party now.
Oh, I forgot, Chretien never kept his word, he only wrote a red covered book about it.
Pathetic!!


freadadviser
said

i would like to remind people who are complaining about the cut in the gst that they pay it everytime they buy toilet paper, kleenex, hydro bill, gas, prepared food, diappers,so for people who are too poor to pay taxes on their pay check, the gst is a big cut for them.


Andy in Cambridge
said

Richard:

"Myself, I'd rather see increased debt payments than tax cuts."

The government is making debt payments. Since the Harper government took office they've paid down over 15 billion dollars on the debt. And if they feel they can continue doing that, and cut my taxes at the same time, then I'm all for it!


Doug
said

HaHa.It never ceases to amaze me how Fiberals try to take credit for this.The only reason the money is there is because of NAFTA and the GST.Liberal policies?I don't think so.
Having said that,I am concerned about increses in government spending also.THis economy and the high dollar will not go on forever.
And,as I pointed out in aother posting,the last time we saw a dollar this high,Canada had virtually no debt, budgets were almost always balanced,and "tax freedom day" was somewhere near the end of March. Not early July.
We have a long ways to go,my friends.


BW
said

To John,

Mr. Martin had proposed lowering the rate from 16 to 15.5. The Cons. in their first budget kept the rate to were it was previously and instead lowered the G.S.T. Quite frankly this reduction benefits everyone even low income earners. Or do they not spend any money?


Lance
said

Hey Greg. Spoken like a true blue LIBERAL referring to CANADIAN citizens money as LIBERAL money. Some things never change!


Rob
said

Frank said:
"The Harper government pays more attention to propaganda - instead of poor people. They cut the GST for its max media coverage effect, yet quietly raised the personal income tax last year (reduced by Liberals before the election), and made tax return more of a pain."


Really? Do you think that was an honest reduction by Martin or a way to try to buy votes to salvage a pathetic campaign mined with scandals and thievery? do the math. Tax cuts are on their way.



Richard
said

To Andy in Cambridge,

As you correctly noted, I said increase.

In 2005-2006, only budget surpluses went to paying the debt.http://www.fin.gc.ca/taxdollar06/text/html/taxdollar06_e.html

Chapter 5 of budget 2007 (http://www.budget.gc.ca/2007/bp/bpc5ae.html) states that debt payments of $3 billion should be planned annually. At that rate, it will take 167 years to pay down the ~$500 billion debt. Budget surpluses, are extra payments that help to pay it down further, and more quickly. The nature of supluses are that they are not planned.

If we can avoid tax cuts now in order to pay down more of the debt, the result will be much, much bigger tax cuts in the future.

An amoritization period of 167years is downright irresponsible.

P.S. For all the political yahoo's out there ... I do not care which goverment did what. Paying down the debt is the responsible thing to do. Tax cuts are short sighted. And please do not tell me that our economy needs a boost; unemployment is currently very low and our dollar is flying high. The economy is doing great and therefore we should use our current prosperity to pay back/prepare for those hard times, both past and future.


Kathy
said

Greg. The Liberal Party of Canada accumulated their surplus by cutting funding to the Military, RCMP, freezing Federal Gov't employee salaries, cutting transfer payments to the Provinces (ie for Health care) etc, etc. the Liberal suplus was not a result of fiscal thriftiness.


steve
said

GST cuts does nothing for me or anyone I know. I would like this money put to better use like funding out health care system that took many cuts under the Liberals.


James
said

I've never voted Conservative in my life, but might have to consider it if he finally gave a break to the most abused (and thereby deserving) segment of the Canadian tax paying population - the middle class.


Andy In Cambridge
said

"Hey Greg. Spoken like a true blue LIBERAL referring to CANADIAN citizens money as LIBERAL money. Some things never change!"

I agree Lance, smacks of Liberal entitlement to me!



shayne
said

Richard... So you are in your mid twenties and are not party to the fiscal policies that have caused our debt hey. So tell me, did you pay the FULL cost of your education? How about your health cae? Full price for that? Canada Pension when you retire? The fiscal policies of the past have made your life affordable whether you were a willing participant in those decisions or not. We all share responsibility for the debt. Taking responsibility is part of being a grown up.


Joseph
said

Re: John and
"It was under Mr. Harper that income taxes were RAISED to pay for his GST cut."

That is a complete fallacy, sorry. The Government cancelled a 0.5 percent decrease in income tax for one particular tax bracket, a decrease that had not even come into effect at the time of it's cancellation. That hardly counts as raising income taxes.

I've also heard someone else on here stating that the GST cut is a tax cut for the rich; this is rubbish. Those in the poorest tax bracket spend most of their money on items taxed by the GST and therefore end up benefitting from it the most.

David in Ontario
said

Any tax cut would be welcome. I find it ironic that some 14 years after Jean Chretien vowed to "Axe the tax", the incumbent leader of that same political party is criticising its reduction. The Libs under J. Chretien did wonders on the budget. They simply carried on with Mr. Mulroney's job. Then P. Martin went further, and now S. Harper carries it on. Let's all hope that it keeps going this way.


John K
said

A reduction in the GST would affect all Canadians proportionally to their spending. In spite of what Dion and the opposition claims, the 1% reduction in the GST is fair in the sense that it treats all Canadians equally in proportion to their spending. Of course, the opposition knows this, but they say that the GST cut favours the wealthy - saying this just to raise some weak sort of hullabaloo since that is all they can muster - in hopes that some of us are dumb enough to buy that line from them.

And to those who think 1% doesn't make a difference, well actually it does.


Marc
said

What has become quite apparent in Canadian politics is that most of the anti-Harperites, pro-Liberals are people who don't do their homework when it comes to politics. They are quick to criticize, when if they would actually take time to examine the situation, they'd see the tremendous progress that's going on.


Bill Gerdson
said

Correct me if I'm wrong; but if the Feds give people a tax-cut, doesn't that apply pressure on the Provinces bottom line giving them no choice but to rise taxes on their end of the big picture? If this is correct, isn't it just another "Paul gives and Peter takes leaving you no better off? I would appreciate an answer ti this question if possible.


D Daigle
said

Why can't we just pay our National Debt. If it is the good times, then clear our debt for our kids. It saves a fortune of interest every year for a long time. If we can't pay the debt in good times, then when??


Scott Buckshot
said

Lets see, the Liberals stole our money and the Conservatives put more money back into our pockets. Greg must not work for a living.


Jon
said

It always makes me laugh when people complain about this tax cut or that tax cut by saying that it only benefits those who are actually paying the tax in the first place. Big surprise? Maybe they should realize that those who are paying the taxes in the first place are the ones who have been carrying more than their fair share of the burden all along.


Moe
said

I have been a Harper supporter from day 1, just believed that he was different and would do the tough and right things to strengthen our country. He is a proud and determined Canadian. I see that his support is growing and growing and this heartens me. I can't wait to see where we are in another 5 years with him at the helm. Trust me, we will be in great shape and the future will reflect this.


tony
said

People, we're living in 2007, not 1993. "For 13 years....". We're living life right now. It's not 13 years ago. Cut income taxes, it'll actually give us money.


Mark
said

Most seniors on pensions and such usually favor the GST cut. They pay no income taxes now so any cuts don't effect them.

Also some working poor people (earning less than 18000) pay no income taxes so for them any cuts are pointless.

I'm not in either boat but just pointing it out that it does not "favour only the rich."


Joyce Conley
said

Seems to me at last count the Federal debt was 467 Billion not 500 Billion, so as far as the Conservative Government is concerned, they have paid off more on the debt each year,and have not held back like the lIBERALS did a 3 billion dollar slush fund to come out before an election to reward their own constituants.
We have been overtaxed and it is good to see the GST being pared down, incidently Chretien campaigned on getting rid of the GST remember, but he knew it was too good a haul, and so Chretien did break his promise.



retep
said

Tax cuts: yes, but try and give the lower income a real break. The Liberals, NDP shouldn't be afraid to support a tax cut. Give the PC what they are asking for. There is nothing wrong with supporting a cut in tax, in fact I think voters will give you the support you need . . . and that will really blow the PC bubble.


Voice of Reason
said

It is truly disgusting to have to wade through the political hacks and halfwits in order to find the voice of reason. In this case Richard is that solitary voice. The only responsible thing to do with the surplus is to pay down the debt (which Richard has eloquently explained above), and revist and redress the criminal cuts that were made to the environmental and social programs. Anything else is miopic and self-serving. And yes, the tax system needs to be simplified and more forgiving.


R.G. Browne
said

I suppose this means the lowest wage earners will be getting another raise i n taxes. It astounds me how this government is still blaming the Liberals for everything and taking credit for everything they did at the same time. It still hasn't sunk in that our economy is doing well in spite of Harper, not because of him.


Danny
said

I must take exception to the people who want 1% of the GST to be put towards health or education. That is the worst thing they could do. I live in Alberta. We don't need any more money from the Feds for health or education. We do need new roads, power transmission lines, etc. I'm sure some other provinces have many roads and no schools. My point is the Feds shouldn't be poking their noses in provincial areas. Cut the taxes and let the provinces/individuals spend it as they need it, not how people in Ottawa want them too.


Mark Embree
said

I'm curious, with the comment about scrapping rhe 26% bracket, what will fill this void. Will the government increase the lower bracket limit or move the higher bracket down so all middle class pay more


Blair
said

He won't scrap the 26% tax bracket,thats the middle income people,if any thing they'l raise it.the feds have been milking us dry for years.Why is it that people below the poverty line pay taxes at all?Canadiens need to shake their heads & wake up........


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz