CTV News | PM talks with Dalai Lama signal unprecedented push

Top Stories -   

PM talks with Dalai Lama signal unprecedented push

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: Peggy Nash, NDP MP

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(17)

Ashleigh Patterson, CTV.ca News

Date: Sun. Oct. 28 2007 4:02 PM ET

Prime Minister Stephen Harper will host the first-ever formal meeting between a Canadian prime minister and the Dalai Lama -- a controversial move that could signal an unprecedented push for Tibetan autonomy.

The 72-year-old exiled spiritual leader will visit Ottawa today and publicly meet with Harper in the Prime Minister's Office on Monday.

That meeting is expected to go further than former prime minister Paul Martin's informal private talk with the Tibetan leader in 2004 -- the first time the Dalai Lama had ever met with a Canadian prime minister.

"For us, no matter what they talk about in the meeting, the significance is that they are meeting," Norbu Tsering, president of the Canadian Tibetan Association of Ontario, told CTV.ca from Toronto.

October's visit will be the Dalai Lama's sixth trip to Canada and his third to Ottawa since he began travelling to the West in the 1970s:

  • The Dalai Lama first visited Canada in 1980 and was met by then-governor general Ed Schreyer.
  • In 1990, he visited Ottawa for the first time and met former secretary of state for multiculturalism Gerry Weiner on the government's behalf.
  • The Dalai Lama's 1990 visit prompted an amendment to Sino-Canadian diplomatic policy, which was officially established in 1970. Canada continued to recognize the People's Republic of China as the official government but would take no position on territorial claims.
  • In 2004, former prime minister Paul Martin courted controversy by becoming the first Canadian leader to meet the Dalai Lama. The one-hour talk on human rights took place at the home of the Roman Catholic Archbishop of Ottawa. Martin's predecessor, Jean Chrétien, refused such a meeting.
  • The Dalai Lama was personally recognized when he last visited Canada in 2006 and received an honorary Canadian citizenship -- a measure protested by Chinese officials. He joins Holocaust hero Raoul Wallenberg, Nelson Mandela and, most recently, Burmese democracy activist Aung San Suu Kyi in receiving the honour.

Currently, Canada's Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade recognizes China as the legitimate government of both China and Tibet -- but has "great respect" for the Dalai Lama.

Dermod Travis, executive director of Canada Tibet Committee, says western nations have made a distinct shift in recent years toward a negotiated solution for an autonomous Tibet within China.

Travis said the prime minister's meeting demonstrates Harper wants to see concrete change and not a continuation of the current record.

"Certainly we would hope that the prime minister will reflect what the House of Commons said this year when it passed a motion unanimously in February calling on the government of Canada to increase pressure on the government of China to enter into these negotiations with determination and resolve to reach a solution," Travis told CTV.ca from Montreal.

Over the past two years, the Conservative government has angered China on a number of issues prompting several high-profile visits to mend frayed relations.

Jacob Kovalio, an Asia-Pacific expert and professor at Carlton University, speculates that Harper's public meeting with Dalai Lama is a response to icy relations with the People's Republic of China.

"It's posturing and a display of Canadian foreign policy confidence, not against the People's Republic of China, but to reinforce our position as a nation proud of its democratic political traditions," Kovalio told CTV.ca from Ottawa.

Kovalio speculated that Harper has chosen this moment to resuscitate international interest in the Tibetan issue because of the 2008 Olympics in Beijing.

"He (Harper) knows China is not going to rock the boat too violently because of the concern the Chinese have with some nations or some important individuals boycotting the Olympics," Kovalio said.

Lhadon Tethong, Tibetan-Canadian and Executive Director of Students for a Free Tibet, said the meeting could equate to nothing more than a symbolic shift in diplomacy.

"It's a fantastic gesture and a very important one for the elected prime minister of the Canadian people to the Dalai Lama, who the Chinese government wants to paint as an extremist," Tethong told CTV.ca in an interview from New York.

"It's one thing to meet with the Dalai Lama but it's another to give a real expression of support for his attempts to resolve this threatening issue non-violently," Tethong said.

"We haven't seen, other than token gestures, any real substantive moves by the Canadian government or the Canadian corporate business community to help improve the situation on the ground inside Tibet."

In August, Tethong was detained in Beijing by Chinese officials for criticizing the government on her blog. Two other Canadians in her group were taken into custody after they unfurled a banner that said ''One World, One Dream, Free Tibet" at China's Great Wall.

The dispute's history

In 1949, China invaded the Himalayan nation killing more than 400,000 Tibetans, destroying 6,000 monastic communities and branding the Dalai Lama a separatist. The following year, at the age of 16, the Dalai Lama assumed full political power as Head of State and Government in Tibet.

After a failed uprising in 1959, the Dalai Lama fled to northern India where he continues his struggle for Tibetan autonomy and the preservation of Tibetan Buddhist culture.

China has been chastised for its human rights record inside Tibet where it is illegal to possess a photo of the Dalai Lama or a Tibetan flag. Ethnic tensions have heightened in recent months, prompting an escalation in police action.

"We would like to see a real effort by the Canadian leadership to address the situation and to push the Chinese for change," Tethong said.

"(We need) substantive measures and not just these backroom closed bilateral talks on human rights but to lead the international community in getting together and saying to the Chinese leadership that enough is enough."

Chinese leaders protest

Chinese officials are vehemently opposed to foreign leaders meeting with the Dalai Lama, claiming the Nobel laureate is a political figure who aims to fracture the People's Republic of China.

During this recent North American tour, the Dalai Lama met privately with U.S. President George Bush at the White House on Oct. 16 and received the Congressional Gold Medal at Capitol Hill -- the body's highest civilian honour.

Chinese officials protested the visit and responded by saying the "erroneous actions by the US have severely undermined China-US relations."

China cancelled a third consecutive round of Germany-China talks following a meeting between Chancellor Angela Merkel and the Dalai Lama in September.

As expected, the Chinese embassy in Ottawa issued a statement critical of Harper's public meeting with the Dalai Lama referring to him as a political figure engaged in "secessionist" activities.

Potential fallout

Despite China's continued threats, western supporters of the Dalai Lama continue to push for diplomatic talks between China and the exiled spiritual leader.

"We saw the outcry in 2004 when (Paul) Martin met the Dalai Lama," Travis said. "I think that China would be well advised to pull back on the knee-jerk reaction and instead focus on the benefits of building trust between the Tibetan people and the Chinese government,"

"Certainly there has been no demonstrable fallout from the Dalai Lama meeting with heads of state around the world."

According to a Canada Tibet Committee survey conducted last month, nearly nine out of 10 Canadians support the meeting despite the threat of consequences for Canada's trade relations with the communist country.

"I think Canadians are speaking with one voice and the West is speaking with one voice and China now has an obligation to hear the message that we are sending," Travis said.

Comments are now closed for this story

Reg
said

How can China accuse the Dalai Lama of being a seperatist, when China is the culprit who raided Tibet and annexed them to China?


Walter Turner
said

As far as I am concerned China is like a virus it invades and destroys all in in its way


Reg
said

I think Chinese now are speaking with one voice and the West will not change anthing. Actually nothing at all.


delford twain louis
said

As a member of the indigenous peoples and a past executive member of the International Buddhist Foundation, Calgary this is news that is absolute progress. One step ahead. I applaud this meeting between the Dalai Lama and this government!!!


Lorne Babcock Sr
said

The situation in Tibet is reminiscent of what Hitler did in Europe. The world is practicing a policy of appeasement in respect of China's moves in Tibet. Unfortunately this is but "a bitter cup that will be proferred to us again and again" China's rapid military build-up, rapidly escalating financial resources, and bellicosity will result in a clash sooner or later. We should confront China now while we still can.


Lauren
said

This is an answer to my prayers. For once, the Conservative government has done something right. By recognizing the Dalai Lama, our government has finally recognized the Tibetan people's the right to exist freely and without violence. I am proud to be Canadian.


Rakesh Kapila
said

Tibet has always existed as an independent country for centuries, with distict language culture and religion and even overseas diplomatic representations in the past. Physical claims based on armed invasion and occupations by China do not actually establish their rights over the lands of Tibet. Please read the history of Soviet Union, Truth Always Wins in the end ! My salutations to Dalai Lama his power of prayers is mightier & powerful than the brute force of all the guns, armies and the missiles of PR-China. No nation state has ever won over the powers of divinity which Dalai Lama represents today !


Steven Booth
said

What do you expect from a totalitarian Communist regime? Respect for human rights? Respect for the territorial integrity of a neighbour? And the Left claims the US is the evil empirical power! HA!


Tommer Lama
said

The Buddists should ask Jesus to help them!!!


A. Bica
said

How appropriate!

A news story of Stephen Harper recognizing the Dalai Lama but with a picture of him with George Bush.

A Freudian news slip perhaps or a true picture of just how intervhangeable Bush and Harper really are?


A. Bica
said

That didn't take long!

Now the photo is the same as the headline and shows Harper, instead of Bush, greeting the Dalai Lama.

That's just about how quickly our politicians change positions too.




Riley
said

A. Bica - its typical of the media. They slip in pictures of Bush in Harper /CPC stories.

Trying to tie the CPC to the Republicans when the CPC is actually a middleground between the U.S.'s Dems. and Reps.

Anyways I am proud Harper is in talks with the Dalai Lama.

For once I am proud as a Canadian again.


Marek
said

At the same time the chinese government paint dalai as a seperate seems ridiculous to you people, how funny is it that some of us are led to believe that china is run by hitler?

Tibet did exist as independent nation, but only for less than 50 years in the 19th century, and last time it was independent goes back a long time ago, after invaded by mongols they did not regain autonomous rights until the Manchus in 1700s decides to give more autonomous. Then the British invaded, resulting a power vacuum in Tibet. Complicated story.

Also, one cannot say truth wins in the end, instead, ask yourself, who defines the truth?


Trip McNeely
said

If we say to the world, "Tibet should be allowed to seperate" what is to prevent the world from saying, "Quebec should be allowed to seperate"?


Adam L
said

Remember how pissed Canada was when the French president came over in the 60s and said free Quebec?


Roger T
said

I guess we could compare our own country to the mass killings of the Native people which owns this land. How can our PM stir problems when in fact the Natives were killed and forced to give up their land? Hope this doesn't bring any backlash.

Until the Natives are handed back their land we have nothing to discuss. Oh, yeah we also have a Quebec separatist problem which one day will happen, should the Chinese leaders meet with the Quebecs separatist to stir problems for our Gov't?


Marek
said

we are only frowning at china because it is china, what ever happened to killing all the natives to for colonization? lets go kick the chinese out of tibet, while we are at it, should we try to reverse colonization?


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz