CTV News | Harper: It's up to opposition to trigger election

Top Stories -   

Harper: It's up to opposition to trigger election

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Roger Smith covers the surprise move
CTV Newsnet: Harper speaks from Press Theatre
CTV Newsnet: Harper speaks from the Press Theatre, part two
CTV Newsnet: Harper takes questions from reporters
CTV Newsnet: Harper takes questions from reporters, two
CTV Newsnet: Ottawa Bureau Chief Robert Fife on the reasons for Harper's press conference
NDP Leader Jack Layton reacts to Harper's speech
Mike Duffy Live: A panel of experts discuss whether Gen. Hillier has a future with the Canadian military
Canada AM: Jane Taber, co-host, CTV's Question Period

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(43)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Wed. Oct. 3 2007 8:29 PM ET

Prime Minister Stephen Harper said Wednesday he has no intention of calling a fall election, but will not bow to pressure from opposition parties who have demanded changes to the government's agenda.

"The choice is not an election or obstruction, the choice is an election or give the government the mandate to govern," Harper said in his first news conference at the National Press Theatre in Ottawa since taking office.

Bloc Quebecois Leader Gilles Duceppe has outlined five "non-negotiable" conditions he wants the government to meet in its Oct. 16 throne speech, including an end to Canada's combat mission in Afghanistan by February 2009.

Liberal Leader Stephane Dion has also made demands, including clarification over the Afghanistan mission and the support of Bill C-30 on climate change.

"We always listen very carefully to what the opposition says, and we will attempt, as far as the throne speech can, to address the issues that they have raised," said Harper.

"We always listen very carefully to what the opposition says, and we will attempt, as far as the throne speech can, to address the issues that they have raised," said Harper.

However, he went on to say: "We're going to ask Parliament for a mandate. Once we have that mandate, we're going to consider that basically gives us the right to consider those matters confidence going forward and to get results and get things done.

"Obviously, if we don't get approval, the opposition will force an election. That's not my preferred course of action, but if they force that, we'll be ready for it."

The National Press Theatre is operated by members of the parliamentary press gallery, meaning the prime minister has no control over who is asking questions.

Before Wednesday, Harper had never used the theatre since becoming elected 20 months ago.

Harper has had a sometimes frosty relationship with the national press corps, stemming from his staff's tight control over new conferences and lack of accessibility to MPs and cabinet ministers.

The prime minister said he was surprised when Duceppe listed his non-negotiable demands, following byelection results in Quebec where the Conservatives took a seat in the Bloc stronghold of Roberval--Lac-Saint-Jean.

The Liberals lost their longtime stronghold of Outremont to the NDP, while the Bloc held onto the remaining Saint-Hyacinthe-Bagot riding.

"I think it's been an unusual couple of weeks in Canadian politics," said Harper.

"We've had the byelection results in Quebec, and I know I'm not supposed to be an analyst, but as an analyst I wouldn't have predicted that the results of those byelections would be a message to Mr. Duceppe and Mr. Dion to make non-negotiable demands -- otherwise, to demand a general election."

He also reiterated previous comments that an election would likely result in another minority government.

"We're entering a period of minority government. We've had a couple in a row now," he said Wednesday.

He added that with four political parties securing a minimum of 20 seats each, it would be difficult for any side to win a majority of votes.

"I think the possibility of a minority government in a subsequent election is pretty high," he said. "At the same time, I don't think Canadians want an election and the government is not seeking an election."

Meanwhile, NDP Jack Layton said Wednesday he had a "one-on-one meeting" with the prime minister about the upcoming throne speech.

"I presented to him the direction that we in the NDP feel the prime minister should be following," Layton told reporters after Harper's press conference.

"We feel that he's off track with the majority of Canadians on key issues."

Among those issues, Layton said, was the "widening prosperity gap" in Canada and the Conservative government's weak record on the environment.

The NDP also wants troops pulled from Afghanistan earlier than February 2009.

Please Add Comments( )

bruno
said
0 0

I agree, there is no need for an election. The Conservatives have nothing to gain from it, nor does any other party. Polls consistently have shown that the Conservatives will not get a majority. If anything, they have actually slipped in support since the last election. With the exception of one poll after the last budget, we have seen this again and again. Most people (close to 70%) do not want them to be their government, let alone to be their government with a majority.


Evan J.
said
0 0

I'm glad that the PM restricted national media access, because some of the news reports were brutally one sided and totally unfair.

Rik
said
0 0

After his successful media interviews in NYC recently it would appear that Harper has decided upon a media approach that suits him and he's now bringing it to view at home. It's nice to have a PM who doesn't need the media and who isn't controlled by the media. Taking control of the message he wants out there is a sign of leadership and confidence in himself and the message. Not sucking up the media to get his message out is integrity. Finally, a PM we are not embarassed to watch and listen to.


Gary
said
0 0

I agree with the PM on this point. Canadians dont want an election right now. They seem comfortable with this minority government as long as work is being done. In a minority government no one party controls the agenda..only through compromises and consensus will a minority government work. That being said if the throne speech does not adequately address the high priorities, Canadians (not the other parties)have firmly expressed over the past 20 months (namely Afghanistan & the environment) then Canadians may want a new mandate from a different party. We'll have to wait for the throne speech. Given the recent polls that indicate a tie between the Conservatives and the Liberals, only a very distinct agenda should trigger an election. If the parties agree to the priorities Canadians have indicated then we'll set them back to work it out and provide Canadians solutions to our priorities. If they are unable to manage/execute this in the next few months Canadians will be ready for an election after the budget 2008. May the best party to address Canadians priorities/interests win.


Ken
said
0 0

The fact that CONservative support numbers are still tied with the Liberals, despite their negative press right now, must just be tearing Harper and his supporters apart. Harper will never get a majority in this country. The only party that has a chance of climbing in the polls now is the Liberal party, and climb they will, just as they have always done in the past. The Conservatives will continue to realize that this country does not suffer ultra-right wing governments for long. Liberal policy has always been, and will always be, closer to the values of the majority of Canadians. It will give me great joy to watch Harper lose the next election and lose his position as leader of the hardest right wing government this country has ever seen.


Take the shade off and look around
said
0 0

Ultra right wing? who are you kidding? you have no idea what left and right is if you think Harper is right wing!

Socialism doesn't work and Canada is a good example. No wonder there is East vs West your 'left' wing parties AKA liberal started that whole feud. Qc still wants out and I know NFLD is starting to wake up to just how backward this commy nation has become.

Wake up people!


Ryan
said
0 0

I think Canada is on the verge of a new political era. I think the days of majority governements are over for the Liberals and the Conservatives.
This is not a bad thing. I do not believe any party represents a majority of Canadians, and forcing them to find common ground it good for the country.
Harper is demonstrating he is fine with this new reality and acting mature by not forcing an election. Now if the other parties can grow up maybe Canadians can avoid the polls until 09 when it would be time for another election.
Minority governements work in Europe they can work in Canada to.
Welcome to the new Canadian political system!


Gerard
said
0 0

I'm glad to see that Mr. Harper now realizes he can not win a majority, But come on folks ! Enough with the games already. Let's get cracking here and actually do something meaningful in this session of parliament. I am not a Conservative by any means, but right now Harper is our only alternative as to who is actually fit to govern. Enough games gentlemen, lets get to work. That's what your paid to do right? Canada does not need or want another election in such a short time. We need a government who can govern as they were elected to do by the people of Canada.


Charles from Montreal
said
0 0

Actually, as a "CONservative" supporter and Harper fan, I can assure you that poll results don't cause me the slightest trouble. Were an election triggered because none of the opposition parties could support the Throne speech, I am not worried one bit about the outcome: a Tory majority. Just thought you'd like to know just how badly a typical Tory supporter is "tearing himself apart" over poll results.


Darryl
said
0 0

The Bloq, Libs and NDP have been believing their own slanted press for far too long. They think they will each win, knock yourselves out I say. Paint yourselves in corners or continue to circle the wagons...and keep firing inward. Harper and co, look far more professional than they did when first elected. NDP more radical, Dion and co, more cut throat and hapless. The Bloq? a separatist hapless bunch at best. The Conservatives will win another election except , this time a majority.


Clarke
said
0 0

I'm still not sure how Liberals come on here and say that this government is "ultra right-wing". I think this government has done a decent job so far and I have yet to see any extreme right wing politics. As a matter of fact, there is little difference between the old Liberals and Conservatives right now. It is always good to not leave one party in power too long like the Liberals were, and all parties need a time of renewal when they are not the governing party.


steve
said
0 0

What a leader, thanks for playing politics with us. Did the PM call the throne speech just to see what chance he would have in attaining a majority. Well, at least they got an extended holiday and nothing will be accomplished in Parlament and all the work that was in progress is now wasted. Let's pay these politicians for doing nothing and accomplishing nothing. Talk about wasted tax payers money, maybe the PM will learn that he is in a minority situation and the public wants to see that minority government work, not just to see the conservatives waiting fifteen years for their opportunity to squash the Liberals. Oh ego! We stand on guard for thee!


Matt
said
0 0

I definitely agree with the PM and am proud to say that we finally have a PM with some guts. He tells it how it is and isn't afraid to offend people. Everyone has different oppinions and the problem with previous governments is that they try and please everyone where it is not possible. Thanks to Mr. Harper for putting some integrity back into Canadian politics and doing what is best for the whole of Canada.


Ian
said
0 0

I have to agree with Ken, and I'm a Conservative. It's obvious that Canadians will only support the Liberals and that is a reason why we haven't been relevant on the world stage since the end of WW2. I spent many months working with people from over 20 countries recently, and they couldn't tell me anything about Canadians, except that we are nice polite people. We have done nothing of consequence. So yes, Canada very well may end up with YET ANOTHER Liberal government soon, but as far as I'm concerned that is nothing to be proud of. It just tells everyone that we don't want to really embrace democracy, but are content with a NEO AUTOCRATIC SYSTEM. How else can you explain the support for a party that is on the verge of mutiny!


Jason B
said
0 0

Ken-
"Ultra right wing", the "hardest right wing government has ever seen"?

The Conservatives may have a different view on certain subjects, no doubt there. But while they are right wing (for the most part), words like "ultra" are not really applicable, or fair. It's like calling the Liberals socialists.

Despite their rhetoric and disputes, there isn't a HUGE difference between the two parties. When the Liberals came to power in 1993, they didn't re-negotiate free trade, or scrap the GST (both they had promised to do).

The Liberals blew a great opportunity to set things right. I think Mr Harper and the Conservatives have, so far, done well. Cutting taxes, moving Canada to become a bigger player on the world stage.

They may be tied in the polls for now. But, as time goes on, more Canadians will remember how the Liberals blatantly lied to us, perpetuating the Mulroney era's excessive taxation, and deceit.


Greg
said
0 0

Harper has been PM for nearly two years, and yet he still cannot generate enough popularity to achieve the majority he so desperatly wants... This despite billions of dollars is spending announcements, millions of dollars spent on attack ads, and two cabinet shuffles. No one expects much from Dion, but wasn't Harper supposed to bring his party to the promised land?! Desperate times call for desperate measures I guess!


A_Canadian_In_Norway
said
0 0

When I read that this was his first press conference in national press gallery, i hontestly laughed. I mean, he must be the first P.M. in our history not to have a press conference there in the first 20 months of his reign. Subverting democracy he's good at that.


A. & J.
said
0 0

Tory supporter here. Not worried about the polls whatsoever. Time for the opposition to pull the plug. Yay! Let's give "Steve" a majority. Looking forward to it, actually.


Pedro in Windsor
said
0 0

There's nothing wrong with another minority government, be it Tory or Liberal. Happy Harper knows deep down he'll never get a majority. However, he is effective in a minority role.



Dale
said
0 0

It's funny, if Harper doesn't want an election then why did he prorogue parliament and essentially set his government up to fall?


Roch
said
0 0

Another excellent political strategic move by Prime Minister Stephen Harper.

By announcing that his Government does not wish a fall election, which is how most Canadians feel, then the onus is on the Liberals whether or not an election occurs!

Given the Liberals slapstick comedic leadership and internal problems of late, an election would only reduce their current status, as demonstrated in the Quebec by-elections.

The problem is, are the Liberals competent enough to know how to react, given the decision placed squarely in front of them?


Jim
said
0 0

I have to chuckle at some of the ... comments here.

To call the CPC ultra right wing shows a complete lack of political knowledge.

As well, keep in mind that 70% of Canadians don't want the Liberals to run this country either. The 30% that do must be on dope.

I don't think most people want an election this fall, but mark my words, if it does happen there will be a rude awakening for the political left.

Michael (Ottawa)
said
0 0

The Prime Minister conducts himself with more poise and class than any one of the wannabes who aspire to lead this country. Harper may not be perfect but he acts like a leader and knows how to lead unlike the turkeys who grovel in the dirt of smear politics.


Don L.
said
0 0

If Harper doesn't want an election then why did he prorogue parliament? There was no need for a new session and a new throne speach.

Harper is incredibly manipulative and every move he makes is aimed at getting a majority.

Even his stating that the best he can hope for is a minority is a ploy to make people vote conservative thinking that he won't get the whole shabang.

By the way, where is his right wing these days? Why is he keeping them gagged and locked up in the closet?


Craig
said
0 0

What ever Harper says, believe the opposite. If he says he doesn't want an election, then get ready folks -- he knows the Liberals are in trouble, so now is his only time to strike because, ya they are 'ultra-right wing' but they just can't stretch them right now. They get a majority and look out; it'll be back to grassroots Reform policy time.


Tim
said
0 0

Harper is the CON in conservative.

He does not have the balls to call an election because he knows that Canadian will penalize him for it. He will orchestrate his own defeat and blame it on the opposition parties.


Ian B
said
0 0

What a model for open and transparent governing - a model for the entire planet on how to run a country - he should be calling an election any time now


Mike "C" Conservative
said
0 0

After decades of trying to bend the Canadian psyche to accept all the political rhetoric the "Left could use to denounce the merits of Conservativism, Canadians are starting to realize they have been sold a bill of goods and recognize that Conservatives actually share their value system and that the "Left" are actually the ones who are "way out there".


Shawn
said
0 0

To: Canadian in Norway:

Subverting democracy? How? Because the PM chooses not to kowtow to the Parliamentary Press Gallery's whims?

Last I recalled, we didn't elect Journalists, but MPs. Our Prime Minister has the mandate from the people, not the PPG.


Confused Canadian
said
0 0

As a 19 year old I'm sure many of you will call me ignorant or uninformed...but honestly, I'm just confused. How can the Liberal party, who appears to be in shambles, be so popular ? The Conservatives seem to be doing a pretty good job and I can't see any real justification for them not to gain a majority other than the fact that Canadians (in Ontario specifically) are close minded and will only vote Liberal, because they've always voted that way. The Conservatives really aren't that "conservative" and in my mind are handling issues at home and abroad very well. I can't see the Liberals dealing with Afghanistan any differently if they were in power. Anyways, weren't they the party that put us there in the first place ? I just think people should be more open minded to every issue and how each party handles things as a whole, rather than burying their heads and towing the party line that they've always towed.

Wayne
said
0 0

Steven Harper is brilliant, perfect timing as well as poking the opposition parties in the eye. He has got my vote (and get this I am a former liberal)! Though I must agree with several of the posts when it comes to minority control gov'ts in that they never " Raise " taxes


Leslie
said
0 0

Then why was it when Harper was the opposition, he couldn't wait to pull the plug & topple the Liberal government? Now that the shoe is on the other foot, he don't want to be toppled, well wake up & smell democracy Harper! Unless you get your Majority (Heaven forbid) you got to take the lumps like every other minority!


Craig
said
0 0

I'm quite shocked that he finally allowed some control to slip out of his hands. To actually let journalists ask questions that he hasn't pre-approved and timed is new for him.

Harper wants a presidential type of governing system. His MPs aren't allowed to comment on anything without his say-so. Look at the cabinet shuffle. Something major like that, and only he was allowed to speak about it in Parliament. No other conservative MPs were allowed to talk.


DD
said
0 0

This is so typically Harper...say one thing, mean another.

We've seen it all before...with the Atlantic Accord, Income Trust, women's rights, the rapid reaction force for Goose Bay, climate change, openness and accountability.

So, get ready for an election. Dion may have his faults, but he is still a far better choice than Harper. Liberals distrust Harper more than they dislike Dion...so another minority is on the way...and I'm fine with that.


Garrett
said
0 0

I know that elections are expensive and affect the country greatly however getting input from the elctorate right now appears desireable to me. We as Canadians have much to be put on the political agenda that needs the clarification that only occurs during an election. Go for it.


Raymond
said
0 0

'Liberals distrust Harper more than they dislike Dion'...that's actually quite funny, DD. Dion has proven beyond a doubt that he is totally incapable of governing Canada, let alone the LPC. Those who know him best like him least (read: Quebec).


Norm
said
0 0

Prime Minister continues to amaze. In a country that had beed lacking in strong, determined, intelligent leadership, we now have someone who the critics had "written off" and who wants only to govern. A leader, who along with our soaring dollar is soaring in prestige on the world stage. Let's give credit where credit is due and avoid the petty politics of the nonsense that emits from the endless chatter that paints the Prime Minister as a "clone" of Bush and a "slave" to the U.S. leadership. In my view, this is utter nonsense.


Mark
said
0 0

Why does everyone look with disdain at Harper's prorogue of parliament?

Wasn't this a favorite technique of Mr. Chretien?

I believe it is common practice for any government to use when the agenda nedds to be re-started.


Gary B
said
0 0

I can see there will be problems. No matter what, if there is an election it will be caused by the opposition. It is their choice. Harper is prepaired and like it or not he is the best minority PM since Lester Person.



Bruce
said
0 0

If an election were called now, Dion wouldn't stand a chance. It would be a Tory majority. Dion is a very weak leader and an election campaign would only make it obvious to the average voter.


Emily
said
0 0

Harper is a right leader , but not Dion. but I don't like some of the policies of the Conservatives, so a minority government is OK.


Ryan
said
0 0

I think Harper knows he will be Lester Pearson Part II if he goes to the polls again. He will win, but with a slightly larger minority. This will lead to speculation that the Tories need someone else to make a breakthrough. If he holds still and waits it out, he has a better chance for a majority after governing for several years from the center.


Hunter
said
0 0

Well the media whines that the PM isn't following their rules, when he does, they still whine. I can't remember electing the media.

So far PM Harper has been very clear on his positions, and only changed them for the good of Canada. The same can not be said about the opposition parties who are being ruled by the polls.

Keep up the good work PM Harper, it's nice to finally have a leader who wants to make Canada a better and more relevant country on the world stage. If Canadians can't see that, then Canada is lost.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

CTV.ca Blogs

CTV.ca Politics Blog

Politics Blog

David Akin: Harper speaks at National Press Theatre for first time as prime minister.=

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz

Most Talked about Stories

I certainly don't blame him. He wants to at least have a fair shot at a World Series ring -- and it is highky unlikely that would be in Toronto, in his lifetime.
Even the "Beast and Pat team" won't be able to pull off that miracle!
Thanks Doc, for the memories. It was great to have you here this long.
Best wishes for that Ring wherever you land.

Alan

Report: Halladay 'not inclined' to re-sign with Jays