News Sections
PM: 'No discussion' about replacing Gen. Hillier
CTV News Video
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(112)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Wed. Oct. 3 2007 10:06 PM ET
The prime minister told the national press corps that he has held no talks about the possibility of replacing Canada's Chief of Defence Staff, Gen. Rick Hillier.
Prime Minister Stephen Harper said Wednesday he has held no talks with senior officials on the fate of Canada's top soldier in Afghanistan.
CTV News reported Tuesday night that the Conservative government won't extend Chief of Defence Staff Gen. Rick Hillier's term when it comes up for renewal in February. (The post is traditionally held for three year terms.)
But in a rare press conference at the National Press Theatre in Ottawa, Harper called Hillier an "outstanding soldier, who is bringing strong leadership for the Canadian forces."
"There has been no discussion in my office or with me with any senior officials about the possibility of changing the Chief of Defence Staff," said Harper.
He added, "As a matter of fact, I think I just approved a pretty good rating for (him)."
Robert Fife, CTV's Ottawa bureau chief who broke the story, told CTV Newsnet after Harper's press conference that the prime minister left the fate of Hillier's future ambiguous.
"He did offer great support for (Hillier), but he also said no decision had been made on whether his term is going to be extended," said Fife.
"If, in fact, he supported Gen. Hillier, he would have said, 'I'd like him to continue on for some time.' But he didn't say that."
Gen. Hillier Responds
Meanwhile, Gen. Hillier says he's 100 per cent focused on his job, has no plans to leave his post at this time, and that he's received no word the government is planning to end his term.
"Truthfully, I look at it this way," Hillier told reporters after a luncheon in Ottawa on Wednesday.
"I'm the chief of defence staff. We're into a pretty intense period of operations in our country right now, and for me to be focused on anything but looking after Canada's sons and daughters and meeting my responsibility to Canada's moms and dads, would be wrong. So I'm 100 per cent focused on that."
He pointed out that his position is not subject to a three-year term. Instead, he serves at the pleasure of the prime minister for as long as both parties feel it is appropriate.
Traditionally, however, that period is about three years.
"There is no fixed term that goes with that whatsoever, and so at some point in time the prime minister will ask me, or I will indicate to him the time has come, and that time will come sometime in the future," Hillier said.
"I indicated when I took the appointment I would serve at the pleasure of the government, and that continues."
He downplayed the suggestion that leaving his post now would endanger the mission to Afghanistan.
"No, I don't put it in those terms whatsoever," Hillier said.
"Because whether it's Afghanistan, whether it's Afghanistan continuing or whether it's other missions, the Canadian forces will always be involved in missions and I won't be the chief of defence staff always, obviously, so right now I'm focused 100 per cent on my job."
Hillier, appointed by the previous Liberal government in 2005, also denied he is seeking a position in the private sector.
MacKay: 'just speculation'
Earlier in the day, Defence Minister Peter MacKay said any talk of the Conservative government replacing Hillier is just speculation.
"There's no basis to this discussion. We're at war with respect to terrorism. Gen. Hillier has shown great leadership and we have tremendous confidence in his ability," MacKay told reporters in Halifax on Wednesday.
"He serves at the pleasure of the prime minister, and the prime minister is pleased with the work he is doing."
However, Hillier may have personally decided not to stay on as the Armed Forces' chief of defence staff when his term expires.
Fife said a source told him late Tuesday that Hillier had decided against an extension to his term.
"We'll see if that in fact is the case. All his office will say is that his reappointment is the prerogative of the prime minister," Fife told Canada AM on Wednesday.
He attended a private farewell ceremony on Tuesday for former defence minister Gordon O'Connor -- a ceremony for which Hillier turned up late.
He said Wednesday that media reports unfairly put a negative spin on the event, when there was no reason to do so.
However Scott Taylor, a military analyst and publisher of Esprit de Corps magazine, told Canada AM on Wednesday "there was no love lost between the two."
O'Connor and Hillier had clashing visions of the Armed Forces, he said, noting the Conservatives set Arctic sovereignty as a priority while Hillier pushed the Afghanistan mission.
"We saw very quickly that the Conservatives took Hillier's lead," Taylor said.
He noted that Hillier announced a transformation of the Armed Forces as the Liberals were leaving office but before the Conservatives were sworn in on Feb. 6, 2006.
"A very daring move on the part of a general as a civil servant to restructure his entire (service) ... basically daring the Conservatives to come in and change his transformation," Taylor said.
Hillier is central to completing that transformation, he said.
Fife said Hillier's large personality is part of the problem, according to Conservative insiders.
"They say he went out of his way to undermine O'Connor," he said.
"They also felt he was too large a presence, too powerful a personality for the role of chief of the defence staff. They wanted to bring in somebody who would not be such a strong personality. They want to reassert civilian control over the military."
Possible successors include Vice-Admiral Drew Robertson and Lt.-Gen. Andrew Leslie although insiders say Lt.-Gen. Walter Natynczyk is likely to get the top job because the prime minister likes him.
Taylor said replacing Hillier won't be a popular move with the troops.
"Gen. Rick Hillier has made it possible for soldiers to be proud again," he said.
User Tools
Related Stories
CTV.ca Blogs
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(112)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I applaud the budget, even though Health Care and education may stay unscathed. Sadly this cannot last and I worry to later this year where cuts will become enviable. If anything, this provides the Wildrose Alliance plenty of ammo when an election is called.



Please Add Comments( )
Sherry Hummell
0
said
0
Ray
0
said
0
Sheldon in NS
0
said
0
Louise Reid
0
said
0
Catherine Byers
0
said
0
David
0
said
0
Earl Robert
0
said
0
Michalina
0
said
0
Paul
0
said
0
Eric
0
said
0
Kevin Hamilton
0
said
0
Kevin Hamilton
Kingston, Ontario
Allan Eizinas
0
said
0
He undermined the civilian Minister of Defence, tried to direct government policy and has taken the spotlight from the Prime Minister.
I just hope that he remembers that “Old soldiers never die, they just fade away.”
Although I doubt it!
Jean
0
said
0
David
0
said
0
Peter Friesen
0
said
0
Rob petawawa
0
said
0
As a soldier to see what General Hillier has done to our forces it makes us all proud. He is a soldier's soldier and that's what we need, not a puppet to the politicians, he's army through and through and what we need he sees. I think the politicians should look at what he's trying to do, look at what the Liberals did and then say are we a military or a boy scout group with outdated weapons. The things that we need he is making sure we get, he has a motto: leave no man/woman behind and soldier on to the accomplishment of the mission. There are 10 principles to leadership and he shows them all, the respect he has for every man and woman in uniform is the same, to General Hillier Bravo Zulu keep up the excellent work we wont forget it.
Steven Rose
0
said
0
STEVEN LEBLANC
0
said
0
GOOD JOB SIR !!
Dave Norman
0
said
0
Afghanastan under terrible circumstances. Most Canadians are really proud of you.
cindy osborne
0
said
0
HNG
0
said
0
Robert C. Cross
0
said
0
If so, that would be great!
Bob Fenton
0
said
0
When he leaves he can leave knowing that he deserves a a "BRAVO ZULU" for a job well done.
Allan Eizinas
0
said
0
Mike Smith
0
said
0
As he knows his job might be coming to an end, and to try and save face, he would rather say he was thinking of quitting anyway rather than being fired from the job.
Bob
0
said
0
His problem is that he tries to play politics and that is not his place.
He is a Military man not a political man.
When he leaves the military then it is time to get into politics and try to change things. He will do very very well if he takes that road.
Good luck to him in the future and I hope he will not go with the little "c" party.
Tamouh
0
said
0
1) Separation of Religion and Politics
2) Separation of Army and Politics
An Army CO should have no job in making political decisions. His mission is to follow the orders of civilian elected parliament no matter how much he/she may disagree with it.
Michael Baker
0
said
0
Tim McDermott
0
said
0
General Hillier is the most effective spokesperson the Government has when it comes to Afghanistan. He speaks with authority and "street cred" when it comes to the war in Afghanistan. He has believability and credibility that Jack Layton, Gilles Duceppe, and Stephane Dion can never have when it comes to offering an opinion on the way ahead.
The only thing Sandra Buckler should fear more than the General's continued employment in the Canadian Forces, is having him free to voice his opinion as a private citizen. I can guarantee you that the media will beat a path to his door for many years to come.
If I were Stephane Dion, or Jack Layton, my worst nightmare would be having Mr Hillier run for Parliament as a Conservative candidate. It's in nobody's best interest to see General Hillier retire.
Karen
0
said
0
Louidr
0
said
0
Chris
0
said
0
Ghyslain
0
said
0
Nelly
0
said
0
We love you and we will greatly miss you as our top soldier.
It will be very hard for the next CDS to fill Rick's shoes. Let's hope he is as caring and strong, and not only a puppet to the government, because we know all too well that unfortunately, this is what the government wants.
Chris
0
said
0
Michael Nixon
0
said
0
Dennis
0
said
0
Lillian
0
said
0
Hugh
0
said
0
Stephane Dion is about to go out another door; what's to say General Hillier won't turn up as the next leader of the Liberal Party? that prospect should really worry the PM!
Curtis 366
0
said
0
Ed. in Beaconsfield
0
said
0
Speak up Canada!!
Al
0
said
0
Gary
0
said
0
Serving Soldier
0
said
0
Doug
0
said
0
Gen. Rick Hillier is a great leader, true, but he went out of his way to undermine the authority of the MOD. This was a grave mistake, and he should be ousted for it. He is under the thumb of the MOD and should always be. Nice guy maybe, caring guy yes... but he is no better than Gen. Louis MacKenzie was, and he will be replaced by another general worthy of being CDS.
Mike Williams
0
said
0
There is no denying Gen Hillier's impact on the CF. The fact that he is charismatic, dynamic and a natural leader should not distract from his other, considerable weaknesses. He has actively usurped two political parties by creating his own policies and priorities based largely on his experiences with the US Army. He is sharply focussed on anything Army, but has provided little to the other services.
I will glad to see the end of his career. He has done enough damage already.
Kirk
0
said
0
Laurie
0
said
0
Magnan
0
said
0
Marc Chassé
0
said
0
When I read rhetoric like “way to stand up against the politicians” and “stand up for the troops and not the politicians” it makes me very uncomfortable. That is the kind of thinking that created Myanmar, Iraq and the other military dictatorships."
You're absolutly right. The abuse of human rights and civil liberites of Canadians are comparable to those in the countries you mentioned. And to think that we Canadians live under the same dictatorships that they do.
Here $5, go buy yourself a clue please.
S.White
0
said
0
General Hillier is "adored" by the troops. Robert Fife's words. The last thing you want is low morale among the men and women fighting in Afghanistan.
Bet most Canadians can't name any other CDS's in recent history. Hillier has inspired both the military and the civilians.If it is his choice to go, THANKS for a job well done!
NEil
0
said
0
Gary
0
said
0
Ross
0
said
0
Doug
0
said
0
Having said that, I agree with the poster that said the man in this position cannot, and should not be a politician. He does need to advocate for the military and those who serve, but it is, in fact, not his job to determine government policy. It is a fine line to walk. I doubt any of us would want a country where anyone in the military can trump the elected government.
IF, and I think there is a big "IF" attached to this story, we can only hope his successor won't be a "lapdog" either.
I also think there was a tradition of rotating this position between the army,navy, and the air force. I don't know if this is still true.
And finally, if he decides to move on, I agree with a poster who imagined him running in a federal election. It's hard to imagine him getting beaten. He surely has become known and respected for his "straight talk".
Extremely refreshing in our political arena.
Chris
0
said
0
A military Wife
0
said
0
Veteran
0
said
0
Servant of Canada
0
said
0
Daniel Smith
0
said
0
Cary Baker
0
said
0
Tanya (CF member)
0
said
0
You say "why make the Air Force adhere to the same physical fitness standards as the Army?"
Because we are all wearing the same Cadpat Uniform, that's why. Last I recollect, we are called the Canadian Forces, not the Canadian Army, not the Canadian Navy or Canadian Air Force. When it comes down to it, we are all soldiers first, our trade second.
And, in case you are unaware, the new fitness test that is uniform across the board is a STEP-DOWN for the army.
Anyone in the military not on a medical exemption should be embarassed not to be able to pass this test. Gen Hillier has my FULL endorsement to increase physical fitness requirements in the CF.
If you're under the impression that a pilot should be able to be 20 lbs overweight and not be able to run for 10 minutes, maybe you should go work for Air Canada. Our pilots here in the Air Force have a bit more pride than that.
wc
0
said
0
Brian Cheney
0
said
0
Robert McCrea
0
said
0
Linda
0
said
0
I think he does a great job. And, I know the people in the forces are a little subdued in most political debates, but I had the impression he had a great deal of respect from the troops. I can say I certainly believe Mr. Hillier has opened the eyes of many of us who didn't give much thought to our military. I think many Canadians have found a new respect for all of these men and women.
As to Afganistan, I do believe in the mission. I don't know if the conclusion will be satisfactory to the people of Afghanistan, or to NATO. But I am sure of a couple of things. If it does not work out as well as we hope,it will not be Mr. Hillier's fault. Nor will it be the fault of Canada, or the men and women who serve us so well.
Canada, and every one of our brave men and women can leave with their heads held high after doing their very best to bring all the people of Afghanistan some semblance of peace and freedom.
But you are out of your mind if you think this will ever reflect poorly on Canada, its military, or the men and women who serve.
I am not sure I can say the same thing about the countries at the UN, and at NATO who voted for this mission, but failed to show up to do their part.
There is no disgrace in trying your best, even if you do not succeed. The real disgrace is seeing something that is not right, knowing you could perhaps help, and turning away, and not even trying.
Dave
0
said
0
cindy
0
said
0
From a very proud Canadian!!
Al Ferrie
0
said
0
Tony
0
said
0
No one in the military today could fill Rick's shoes as the CDS.
Rick along with the Conservatives made sure our soldier were the best trained and one of the best equipped militaries in the world.
He made sure that our soldiers and their families were cared for when tragedy of any form came around.
As for all you people that think Mr. Hillier's mission is to follow the orders of civilian elected parliament no matter how much he/she may disagree with it. You better think again he has a legal responsibility to do what is right and just because your elected parliament say to do it will not stand up in any court in our country.
For any of you that think Mr Hillier is over stepping his bounds you must be on very cheap drugs.
If the Conservatives were not happy with him he would be gone just like Mr O'Connor who said in parliament that Military families been taken care off when in fact they were not.
Mr Harpper would not even hesitate one second to replace Rick if he was not serving the best interest of Canada and the Government.
Al
0
said
0
Ed.
0
said
0
If the Prime Minister "The Decider" speaks out clearly in support of Rick then we can believe it. If there is silence then Canada will know where Stephen really stands!!
Now speak up Stephen!!
PG
0
said
0
Gene
0
said
0
Jim McB
0
said
0
This whole story is speculation; ...Now there is a storm of controversy brewing because the governments can't deal with this guy. That is highly unlikely because O'Connor and Hillier together did more for the military in the past year and a half than any Liberal government did in 30 years of power. These two put us back in the game and the cabinet knows it.
If he goes, he certainly has earned my respect and admiration.
Peter Friesen
0
said
0
Brad White
0
said
0
1. Transformation began long before the Liberals were out of power. In fact, it was the only good thing the Liberals started.
2. Gen Hillier's wonderful term is coming to an end that was planned for and is planned for with every CDS.
3. If he decides not to extend he will go with our best wishes.
4. The CF is used to the transferring of duties efficiently and effectively. We do it in times of war and in times of peace. We all do it every two years on average. The only troubles we'll have during a turnover will be trying to wade through the mess of a Liberal engineered spin.
Mike McInnis
0
said
0
Gen Hillier has done an excellent job and the troops respect him more than any other CDS before or one that will come after. The Conservatives are playing Russian Roulette with votes on this issue and if the troops think that Hillier is being forced out so too will the Conservatives be....from Ottawa next election day.
Finska
0
said
0
Liberals Rule
0
said
0
Ed Samson
0
said
0
Sarah
0
said
0
Proud Newf
0
said
0
EG
0
said
0
Katie McLaughlin
0
said
0
JTJ
0
said
0
Mason
0
said
0
Steve V
0
said
0
BobMGfls
0
said
0
"I also wonder if it's another slap to NL...we all know how much the PM likes our boy Danny and one wonders is this the PM's way of getting back at Danny Williams by getting rid of General Hillier?"
Food for thought.
Linda
0
said
0
I wonder a couple of things.Do we know when his term would expire? I believe it is a term of a soecified length.I am also a bit reluctant to judge the people who might be his successors.Who are we to say they might do en equally good job?
As to comments about the Governor General,I guess that's about the only thing the Liberals can laugh about these days.Whick leads me to my final point.As someone suggests we take out our displeasure at the ballot box.REALLY??? Like how??? Turn the country over to one of the pinhead parties on the opposition side.Now that would be like cutting off our noses to spite our faces.
Emmett
0
said
0
Audrey Pynn
0
said
0
Art Murphy
0
said
0
Mike in Ireland
0
said
0
Mark W....A proud Canadian
0
said
0
I can understand that if it’s the government that wants him out that is only because they fear that the head of the army is more popular to the public than the Prime Minister.
Mike
0
said
0
garhane
0
said
0
So it should be understood that the soldier has been chastised, but there is still a really useful task for him to perform. It has become crystal clear that there is occurring a tidal shift in the USA. A period of the American empire is being replaced by a period of Fortress America. That means the Afghan enterprise will be ended, probably in a messy, undignified and wasteful way. But as those days come toward us, we still do not have a good force of reliable helicopters, of our own, big troop carrying ones, to get out people out of combat areas. I would like to see the general left in place while he sticks it to the political leadership and sneers at O'Connor, that the only truly effective response to the roadside mine is to get off the road, get up in the air. That is what the Brits finally did in the Six Counties, to the point that all supplies moved by copter, while the fiction that Northern Ireland was part of Britain was still being maintained. If they can do that with a straight face, so can we. A bunch of copters will save lives of soldiers. No body can doubt that. And the fact they can also be useful later to get to hell out of Kandahar is beside the point. As tools of defense they are more important now, than a cluster of ice teasing patrol boats several years down the road. We can use them for firefighting later. They can be useful in Alberta. Meanwhile Hillier could beat the drums for them on the basis of present combat needs, and then we will have a least a few on hand for the day that is coming pretty quick.
When we are out of that bloody awful place,then Hillier can choose to retire and go become a consultant for an arms company, maybe one that sells helicopters, and enjoy his retirement, and O'Connor will have been useful, which he has not been to date.
Wolf
0
said
0
Gary
0
said
0
GP
0
said
0
Unfortunately the military still is in many respects dysfunctional because of those dark years, however this General has done more good and accomplished for the troops and their moral than anyone I have every seen, or hoped for.
General Hillier is the best of the best, he has gotten to his position he is through “action not words”. To replace him with a lesser person will be to roll back all the gains made for our selfless soldier…Airborne!
Pat Zagler
0
said
0
Do not let him go.
Pat
Thomas Puddicombe, Sgt. (ret'd) 3PPCLI
0
said
0
Andrew (Edmonton)
0
said
0
BomMGfls.
0
said
0
tell
0
said
0
military spouse
0
said
0
Jason
0
said
0
Al
0
said
0
Mark
0
said
0
Michelle from Trenton, On
0
said
0
Annonymous
0
said
0
eva fox
0
said
0