CTV News | Marc Garneau says he wasn't part of Dion's vision

Politics -   

Marc Garneau says he wasn't part of Dion's vision

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV's Question Period: Marc Garneau dropping out
CTV's Question Period: Bryon Wilfert, Liberal MP

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(31)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Sun. Sep. 30 2007 1:32 PM ET

Former astronaut Marc Garneau confirmed on Sunday that Liberal Leader Stephane Dion's ambivalence was one of the main reasons he announced his departure from politics earlier this week.

Widely considered as a star candidate in Quebec, Garneau said during an interview on CTV's Question Period that Dion's refusal to endorse two nomination bids -- one in Westmount-Ville Marie in May and the other in the riding of Outremont last January -- was a major decision for his political departure.

Garneau resigned as head of the Canadian Space Agency in 2005 to run unsuccessfully for the Quebec Liberals in the 2006 federal election in the riding of Vaudreuil-Soulanges.

"You get very excited about politics. It's something that is almost a little bit addictive. I put in a lot of time during 2006 and I gave up a job in 2005 to run and I really did enjoy the time that I was involved with it," Garneau said Sunday.

"But the reality is that we have to get on with our lives too."

Garneau said Dion didn't contact him after he made the announcement earlier this week but said he didn't expect a call from the leader urging him to stay in politics.

"Sometimes between two people, it just doesn't work out and I'm not necessarily part of somebody's vision," Garneau said.

There has been speculation Dion is punishing Garneau for his support of Micheal Ignatieff's 2006 Liberal leadership bid.

Garneau said he expressed his interest in running again last January during a conversation with Dion, after former Outremont Liberal MP Jean Lapierre quit politics. He said he was told by the leader at that time that the riding was reserved for another candidate.

Last May, Garneau filed nomination papers when Liberal MP Lucienne Robillard announced she would not run again in the riding of Westmount-Ville Marie. Dion announced less than a week later that he had hand-picked someone else to run in the riding, further discouraging Garneau.

He made the decision to leave public life after his family summer holidays, citing a need to provide financially for his family as one of the reasons for his departure.

"I decided that well, since I don't know what the future holds for me its time for me to get back into private life," Garneau said.

Watchful eyes on Dion

Garneau said he will remain a "very committed Liberal" and will closely follow Dion's reaction to government's throne speech on Oct. 16. The embattled Dion has suffered several blows recently, including losses in three Quebec byelections and the withdrawal of Garneau and other key candidates.

"Dion, by his own admission, has work to do. He has come out and said very clearly that it's not sufficient to pass the messages, to have policies, to have ideas, to have vision," Garneau said.

Dion confidante and Liberal MP Bryon Wilfert told QP on Sunday that he will advise Dion against triggering an election when the throne speech is delivered, citing a lack of party preparation and no clear defining election issues to rally behind.

"We're never afraid of fight, but I think when you go into a fight you should pick the timing," Wilfert said.

"I don't see any rush. I believe that obviously there are issues with regard to money and organization," Wilfert said referring to organizational issues in the federal Liberal party.

Dion has maintained he will need to hear Prime Minister Stephen Harper's response to four key issues before deciding how to vote after the Oct. 16 speech.

Comments are now closed for this story

Gordie
said
0 0

"no clear defining election issues to rally behind"

Translation: The Conservatives are doing a fine job of running the country.


Heather
said
0 0

Quote - "There has been speculation Dion is punishing Garneau for his support of Micheal [sic] Ignatieff's 2006 Liberal leadership bid."

For heaven's sake, when did Dion punish anybody for backing Ignatieff? He appointed Ignatieff deputy leader (the job MI wanted). Marcel Proulx, an Ignatieff-supporter, is Dion's "Quebec lieutenant." Coderre got the defence critic job he reportedly wanted. Where's the punishment?

There's also "speculation" that "CTV.ca News Staff" base their stories on unfounded speculation, but that doesn't make it true. Necessarily.





Scott
said
0 0

I agree... clearly Garneau is seeing no real future for the Liberal Party under Dion. I think we are headed to a Conservative Majority soon. Might be nice to have some political stability for a few years. Actually I think PM Harper has done a pretty good job so far and I don't have a problem with him having another 4 years


Sammy
said
0 0

The Liberals are all out of corporate dollars and now have no idea how to get the ordinary party members they've been ignoring for years to give money to the party organizers who have alienated grassroots members time and time again.

Canada needs a hero, someone with a vision and that isn't Harper, or Dion and it certainly isn't Gilles Duceppe. We need a Tommy Douglas, an Alexander Mackenzie, a Pearson, even a Trudeau.


Riley W
said
0 0

Man does history repeat itself.

Mulroney = Chretien
Campbell = Dion

The Liberals are self-destructing as a party...which to me is not a bad thing.

Conservatives are moderate centrists and I think thats the perfect formula for Canada.

We need some more Libertarian stances on the economy and some more Capitalism to make all of Canada like Alberta....

Ryan
said
0 0

If Dion is punishing Garneau, a Canadian hero I might add, it shows Dion is a very petty man who should never lead this nation.

If Dion wanted to win, he would be begging people like Garneau to run and kissing their butts.


Steve
said
0 0

Garneau - someone who has a good shot at winning - tries to run in two different ridings and is told both times by Dion that he is hand-picking a different candidate? No wonder our party is in disarray. Don't know if Ignatieff could have done a better job, but it's hard to do much worse than Dion is doing right now.



Ashley
said
0 0

The Liberals just does not have any direction nor the necessary means to get there.

The Conservative knows how to play the game and they are playing it pretty well.

Agree with Gordie.




David Cahill
said
0 0

And another one bites the dust!

Mr. Dion can not hold his Quebec caucus together, failure to do so will cost him not only a mandate, but also any hopes of denying Harper a majority government. I'm by no means a strong Harper supporter, but considering the alternative, Harper looks pretty good come voting time.


Paul
said
0 0

Gordie, you should take up cheerleading.

Dion made a mistake here, for sure. Garneau should be running in Robillard's riding.


ED VIRTUAL
said
0 0

I get the impression that there are two types of Liberals in Canada. The one side being those that want to do the right thing for the country and the Dion Liberals that will do anything to trip up the other Liberals as well as anything that Harper wants to do for the country. It's apparent to me at least that Dion won't even give the time of day to a Canadian icon...one of our astronauts.

John
said
0 0

Right you are Gordie. And they are not prepared anyways. Who is the election for, the good of the Country or the Liberal Party? It's a classic Liberal statement


Ian
said
0 0

Hey maybe the reason Dion didn't take Garneau is because he knows full well that Liberal supporters would see Garneau, an ex astronaut aka pro military, as the type of "Hero" that a typical American would vote for. I'll bet you dollars to donuts that if Garneau was selected that's what the complaint would be.


Mike
said
0 0

This is what happens when a Party is so vindictive that it picks a lacklustre, third rate person for leader rather then all getting behind someone like Bob Wray or Michael Ignatieff. Instead they pick the third, and most useless dimwhit. The Liberals will never become government while Dion is the leader. Period


Brrent
said
0 0

I think the liberal ship is sinking and no amount of the little blue pill will make it rise for sometime. The Conservatives are here to stay and I agree with Gordie the Conservatives are doing a very good job of running the country


John T
said
0 0

As a Liberal, it is sad to see the party in such disarray.

It is sadder yet to see such suppport for Harper's Conservatives and their mean and shallow policies.

The only consolation is that at least 31% of Canadians are happy with this government.

I can only hope that the combined opposition can hold Harper to a minority until the Liberals can rebuild. It will be a black day for Canada if Harper ever gets a majority.


Andrea Timmons
said
0 0

I greatly admire Garneau's magnificent contribution to the Space Program but I think it's silly to presume his skills in that capacity are easily transferred to the complex program of politics, particulary in Quebec.
Dion's decision was never a personal one & Garneau should apologize for speaking against Dion's choice.
Garneau should have spoken to Dion & asked why he didn't get the job instead of jumping to his own conclusions.
This article is nothing but gossip because it's so one sided.


Anthony Salloum
said
0 0

WILFERT TO HOST GARNEAU ON PARLIAMENT HILL OCTOBER 4:

CTV, particularly Mr. Oliver and Ms. Taber may be interested to know that Mr. Wilfert is hosting Marc Garneau on Parliament Hill on October 4th for a luncheon briefing on space policy. The event is being organized with the Rideau Institute on International Affairs.


Don J
said
0 0

People who want to run for any party, don't get what they want or disagree with the party, then run to the press and air their dirt publicly before resolving it internally, would not be an asset to any party. Any party leader who is worth it would do the same as Dion in this matter.


Kevin
said
0 0

I agree with Ryan 'If Dion wanted to win, he would be begging people like Garneau to run and kissing their butts.'

Those that think that 'the conservatives are doing a fine job' should consider that a party in a minority position acts far differently than a majority. Just wait until they let Cheryl Gallant loose! Anne Coulter wanna-be's are scary stuff.

A fair number of the current conservative cabinet members were the ones that laid waste to Ontario's health program (firing nurses, closing hospitals, reducing medical school enrollments), waged war on schools and teachers, created dangerous policies that precipitated the Walkerton disaster, and actually BORROWED MONEY to fund a tax cut!

Yeah, that's great. Mortgage my kid's future so I have an extra $50 in my pocket. No thanks.


Joeseph
said
0 0

The continuing train wreck that is the Liberal Party just furthers my belief that we are headed towards a conservative majority in this country, which, in my opinion, can't happen any sooner. I think Harper's doing a good job, and I'm tired of the instability and political gamesmanship of minority parliaments.


Alex
said
0 0

I predicted that Dion was the wrong person to win the Liberal leadership. As a leader he is bland, and is living up to that perception. I would not support he nor his party in an election. I would never have expected to say that Harper isn't doing too bad a job - environmental issues excepted.


George
said
0 0

Kevin, my gosh! How can you bring up Anne Coulter's name? I will have nightmares, tonight.


Jane
said
0 0

I am a Liberal through and through but right now I would find it hard to vote for "Dion" who seems to be making mistake after mistake.
Why wouldn't he want someone like Marc Garneau working in the party. Who the heck is advising you Dion? Get with the program...think before you speak and leap.

His first mistake was to forget if it hadn't been for G. Kennedy, he wouldn't be the head of the Liberal Party. Rewarding Ignatieff was a poor decision on Dion's part. Get your act together or "heaven's forbid" we could end up with Stephen Harper again .....Canada's President.


James V
said
0 0

Dion - bland, without substance, poor precense, no charisma.

Liberals will lose again because of him.


Scott Isbister
said
0 0

It is interesting how Dion actually won the leadership campaign for the liberals. Essentially Chreitien's team made some deals to get him there. Dion has an image problem. It's ironic how it is turning out. Canadians have a hard time personally relating to him. Kind of like Joe Clark or Robert Stanfield. It will come apart at the polls for the Liberal party for this reason.


Tom C
said
0 0

"This article is nothing but gossip because it's so one sided."

I am sorry to inform you that the truth is one sided.

"Garneau should apologize for speaking"

How dare (!) he speak against his lord and master. How dare (!) he speak that damned thing, truth. Where are the marketers and why haven't they written a script to solve this truth problem?


Denis P
said
0 0

I think Dion goofed big-time on this one. He's still playing at party politics, while Harper is already on page two.

Linda
said
0 0

Marc is probably better off not joining that messed up bunch. Right now they can't figure out who,or what they are.
Of course, Mr.Harper is still on shakey ground. If he can't move the poll numbers in his favour now, I think it shows he is still not trusted.
I tend to be a "swing voter". I think loyalty to any party is a mistake. I voted for Mr. Harper the last time, but I'm still not sure I would vote for him if I thought he would get a majority.
I read what Ian said on another issue,and totally disagree.People who voted Conservative for the first time are the ones who put them in office after a decade in the wilderness.
If the next session of parliament sees accusations of "extreme right wing,neo cons,or religious right agenda" become a reality,I'm pretty sure I won't be the only one deserting the Conservative ship.
Back to the wilderness they go. To bad for Canada though. I would rather see more than one choice when I go to vote.


JohnY
said
0 0

Hi Kevin
Your comments lead me to believe that you are referring to the Ontario Provincial Conservative Party, not the Feds. They are not the same party and often are at odds with each other. Unfortunately from Trudeau on, Mulroney, Chretien, apparently Dion, all exhibited pettiness to the expense of their respective parties and the people who voted for them. I am not sure about Martin but he did not come across as being petty. Of them all Harper seems to be a reasonably good leader so far. Dion does not exhibit good leadership skills else he would not be having the problems he is having and in public at that.
Once again I feel I feel that my choice of who to vote for is pretty limited.
On passing, it was Trudeau and Chretian as his minister of finance who sold out your childrens future aided and abetted by Mulroney & Martin who, combined, put this country into horrible debt and mortgaged all our futures. Industry is fleeing Ontario and Canada and once gone it will never return. If the Oil Boom in Alberta drops out then we'd be in a sorry mess indeed.
Personal opinions only. Flames go here (______________). heh heh...
John Y.


Gary
said
0 0

"no clear defining election issues to rally behind"

Another translation: a minority government is working possibility that neither the Liberals or the Conservatives can exploit for their own 'power' purposes. So let's accept this culture of consensus over the culture of domination as the guiding principle in Canadian politics and reform the legislature so that parties can represent the whole of Canada and not fracture the legislature regionally.

Now there is an election issue for you.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz