CTV News | Day promises 'consequences' for illegal refugees

Top Stories -   

Day promises 'consequences' for illegal refugees

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Graham Richardson on a refugee influx

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(16)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Fri. Sep. 28 2007 11:19 PM ET

Canada's Public Safety Minister Stockwell Day says there will be "consequences" for any illegal refugees who try to enter Canada without proper documentation.

"People cannot come into this country without proper documentation and consequences will follow if they do," he told reporters in Calgary.

His comments came on the heels of reports suggesting that busloads of illegal immigrants currently in the U.S. were on their way to Windsor, Ont.

In the past three weeks, nearly 300 people have crossed into Windsor from Detroit and applied for refugee status in Canada.

Day said Canada will take a zero-tolerance approach to anyone trying to enter the country illegally, but wanted to investigate specific claims in Windsor more closely.

"People who are coming across the border will face anything that anybody would face if they didn't have proper documentation and if they're not supposed to be here," he said.

On Friday, Windsor Mayor Eddie Francis met with a Florida man accused of being responsible for sending the wave of immigrants to Windsor. He told Francis there are more busloads of potential immigrants on the way.

"There are individuals or organizations that are now planning for these types of arrivals at the Detroit-Windsor gateway," Francis told A-Channel after his meeting with Jacques Sinjuste, founder of Jerusalem Haitian Community Centre in Naples, Florida.

"He gave specific reference as to one that will be coming the first week of October and they've already made accommodation arrangements on the Detroit side of the border," Francis said.

So far, almost 300 people originally from Haiti and Mexico have crossed into Canada from the United States over the last three weeks.

Most have arrived with the help of Florida-based groups who say Canada has special permits to provide Mexican and Haitian citizens claiming refugee status a quick turn around.

Another nine such people arrived in Windsor Thursday night.

Sinjuste told reporters that they help illegal Mexican workers in Florida fill out forms to make refugee claims in Canada.

"I understand that I fill out the form, but in reality I do not send them here," Sinjuste told reporters. He said his group connects Floridians with a company in Detroit that helps them apply for refugee status, for a cost.

"We do not force the person to pay."

Sinjuste told media after his meeting with Francis that another person, responsible for sending the latest group, was charging more than $1,000 a head to bring them to Canada.

Francis said he's concerned Sinjuste, who is staying in the Detroit area for the next few days, is making arrangements for future groups.

Francis has written the federal and provincial governments asking for funding to help cover the cost of keeping the refugees housed while they wait for their refugee claims to be heard.

Last week, he said it had so far cost the city $230,000, about 20 per cent of the annual budget for shelters.

Windsor's unemployment rate is currently pushing 10 per cent, making the influx of jobless refugees the last thing its economy needed.

Dozens of settlers have begun receiving welfare benefits from the government while they wait for their refugee claim cases to be processes. Most of the claims have little chance of success.

It has been reported that the immigrants may not be covered under Canadian refugee status, meant to be given to people with a well-founded fear of persecution in their home country.

According to the Geneva Convention, persecution must be based on reasons of race, nationality, membership of a specific social group or political opinion. Gender, in some cases, can also be a factor.

Also, those applying from a "safe third country," such as the U.S., are ineligible to make refugee claims at a Canadian border crossing by land.

If Mexicans come to Canada through the U.S., for example, they must make refugee claims there, and are not eligible here.

"You're not helping people by providing people false hope; you're not helping people by encouraging them to leave where they are at now only to be returned a year and a half or two years later," Francis said.

There are currently 30,891 cases awaiting adjudication across the country.

According to the Immigration and Refugee Board, refugee claims from Mexicans have exploded in the past 10 years, from fewer than 1,000 to 5,000. Canada has become the top country for Mexican claims in the past two years.

The recent migrant wave to Canada comes after U.S. President George Bush promised a crackdown on illegal immigration.

Minister of Citizenship and Immigration Diane Finley has said she is monitoring the situation, but no other help has been offered from the federal government to either the wave of immigrants claiming refugee status or the overwhelmed city.

The websites for the Ministry of Citizenship and Immigration , and the Canadian Council for Refugees both have notes warning people to avoid groups of individuals offering special programs.

"Canada Immigration has been very clear about posting everything that needs to be posted, that there is no special program," Day said.

Meanwhile, the Wednesday arrest of a Montreal human rights worker allegedly helping 12 Haitians seek asylum in Canada has sparked outrage from lawyers' and refugee's groups.

Janet Hinshaw-Thomas, stopped with a group of Haitians at a Quebec border crossing earlier this week, has been charged under the federal Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.

The Act says that "no person shall knowingly organize, induce, aid or abet the coming into Canada of one or more persons who are not in possession of a visa, passport or other document required by this Act."

Andrew Brouwer of the Refugee Lawyers' Association of Ontario says it may be the first time a refugee worker has been charged under the legislation.

Brouwer added that it could scare off groups helping refugees seek asylum in Canada.

Members of the Canadian Council for Refugees said the law should not impact people acting in humanitarian reasons.

"This is a very grim day for Canada. We are now criminalizing the act of assisting refugees," Vice-President Amy Casipullai announced Thursday. "By pressing charges against a person acting on purely humanitarian motives, the government is intimidating all those who assist refugees to seek the protection offered by Canadian laws."

She added that the decision to prosecute a humanitarian worker working out of compassion is all the more shocking considering the government has done little to crack down on smugglers who exploit refugee claimants by charging large sums of money.

With report from CTV's Graham Richardson and The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

New kids on the Canadian block
said

I don't disagree with Canadians who would like to apply checks and balances within our immigration system but I would like to point out another side to the story.
I am the oldest male sibling in a large family. Every time a new baby would come along I felt the pain of being back-burnered a little bit more. However after going through it I wouldn't have it any other way. Look, I understand the complaining that some Canadians are doing about new "kids" coming into the Canadian family. Perhaps we should start viewing them as useful people that we may eventually come to like and appreciate. (Sometimes I find that you are a lot better off "rolling with the punches".)


DAVE
said

This is a problem that needs to be fixed fast. These laws where you show up, get paid to stay before a hearing is non sense. Our homeless shelters are filled as it is just with Canadian citizens. I much rather see my taxes go to help a Canadian in need 1st and not being racist by all means. Yes we need skilled labour here but labour that comes in legally. As for the comments to send them to ALberta or Sask, let me tell you that if you come west to those 2 provinces, you will see we have taken in our share of immigrants, all with Ontario lic. plates on their cars. You have given us enough problems over the years and that's just MARTIN and TRUDEAU. Enough is enough. If you want to help them, put them to work in our auto industry, the word is they work cheaper and build a better vehicle.


Rob
said

What happened to the Third Safe country agreement? Whereby a person is required first to make a claim in the U.S. if they are coming from there. The Federal Government has to fix this refugee system considering the fact that a single refugee claim costs about $40,000. What a joke. Again Canada, the suckers.

shayne
said

Have we learned nothing from the U.S. problems. This is just a trickle, a taste of what's to come. It's simple. Don't let them in without a sponsor or a work visa. Once word gets around about how easy it is to get in here (and I assure you word is spreading quickly), and that they even don't have to worry about illegally crossing the border, the flood will start. We cannot afford it.

johnn
said

Pardon my ignorance, but since we are aware of this situation, is the Canadian Border Services Agency not able to stop this nonsense? Can a whole bus load of people without proper documentation just come into the country and then be accorded all the rights (or perhaps more rights and privileges) that even some Canadians do not have?
I fail to understand this.
Help me out, please!


Claude
said

Terrible, that we are not doing anything to prevent this. Nice to have immigrants but let's do it the right way and legally and not wind up like what is happening in the U.S.

C_C
said

Yes, how did they pass the border?
Can they get a work visa rather than staying on refugee status 40,000/year?? Let them work in Alberta or Sask. Fastfood chains are looking for help all the time.


Laurane
said

These people probably just come into the country as tourists on a bus....then they claim refugee status once through the border.
They need to show return tickets on the bus or plane with a date of departure. This might help catch the ones who will overstay.


Gerald Skowronski
said

The "quick turnaround" mentioned in the article should be Canada turning these people back to the United States, where they came from. This is blatant abuse of our laws. The porous border runs both ways.


Linda
said

Are we expected to pay them welfare until they get a hearing?? I hear that can be a year away. And even then they have little chance of success.
If we have an election I hope immigration is an issue. I will vote for the party that offers some fixes to this issue. And the one that makes it impossible to deport criminals and those who don't come here through legal channels.
We have enough Canadians living in poverty to spend this money on.

Steve
said

Having spoken to a friend of mine who works at customs, all these people have to do is go up to the border guard and announce they are seeking refugee status. Once they do that, the border guard has no recourse.


Phil VT
said

Nobody should have a free ride and that is what these people are looking for. The gravy train in the U.S. ran dry and now they are coming here -- not with my tax dollars, thank you.


JTR
said

For a long time now, I have read posts from Canadians who were bashing U.S. citizens for speaking out against illegal immigration. We have been called racist, bigots, imperialists, and heartless. Now that they are moving north and the Canadian people are starting to understand the problems with illegal immigration, I hope you will begin to support our fight. I wish that Canada did not have to become the second welfare system for Mexican citizens, after the U.S. I am sorry that you have to go through this.

My advice is to start the fight before it is too late.

JTR
Texas

Errol
said

Stop it now while there is still time, or maybe it's already too late. We will most likely become a "Trilingual society".


Rob
said

Anyone, no matter the source country, who arrives in Canada and claims refugee status is automatically in until a review takes place....read 1+ year(s).
That's the law ....we need to hop on politicians to get this stopped.


david
said

Oh stop whining! With the rise of the Canadian dollar being equal or even surpassing the US dollar this is just part and parcel. Where's your Canadian pride? You all wanted a high dollar equal to or more than the US. Now you can expect Mexicans and Haitians to go where the money is. Careful what you wish for (high dollar) because Canada has become an attractive place for refugees with a dollar that goes far. Share the wealth!


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz