CTV News | Extended cellphone use causes hearing loss: study

Health -   

Extended cellphone use causes hearing loss: study

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Avis Favaro on avoiding hearing loss
CTV Toronto: Monica Matys on the risks of using a cell

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(12)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Wed. Sep. 19 2007 12:29 PM ET

For years, there have been worries that cellphones can cause anything from cancer to brain tumours. Now, a study is sounding a new warning for cellphone users.

The small study is being presented Wednesday at a meeting of the American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck and Surgery Foundation in Washington, D.C. It suggests that long term cellphone use, particularly using the phone primarily on one ear, may cause inner ear damage.

The study comes at a time when even young children are carrying cellphones and using them for everything from gossip sessions to listening to music with the built-in MP3 players.

Dr. Naresh Panda from Chandigarh, India studied 100 young cellphone users and 50 people who had never used a cellphone. He found no significant difference of hearing abnormalities between those who regularly used the phones and those who didn't. But those who used the phone for more than 60 minutes a day for over four years had noticeable losses in high frequency hearing.

The hearing loss was greatest in the dominant ear -- the ear usually used for their cellphone conversations.

Panda admits he uses a cellphone himself but says he tries to keep it to a minimum.

"We should educate the public to only use them when necessary," he told CTV News.

Panda suspects microwave emissions from the phone may be damaging tissue in the ear.

"These microwaves may do harm because of the proximity to the ear," he says.

The problem with hearing loss is that it's slow and gradual and people may not hear the difference until it's serious. Panda says there appear to be warning signals that a cellphone is damaging hearing:

  • Feeling warmth in the ear after a cell conversation
  • A sense of fullness in the ear
  • Or a ringing in the ear

Panda found that who experienced any of the above symptoms during cellphone use seemed to have more hearing loss than those who had no complaints.

He says follow-up studies are needed to see if the hearing changes noticed in the study are reversible after making changes to cellphone habits.

Toronto-based audiologist Marshall Chasin says listening to sounds at 85 decibels or higher, over many years, can cause some hearing loss. That is the reason any phone use can be potentially more damaging than face-to-face conversations, even though the conversations don't sound any louder than face-to-face.

"Listening to a cellphone for 60 minutes or longer can potentially be damaging," believes Chasin. "The reason I say that is we know the loudness coming out of a cellphone is about 85 decibels. If you listen to that long enough, over a week, over a year, or 10, it can cause hearing loss."

Whether it's the magnetic emissions that are damaging the ear, as Panda speculates, or simply the volume level, researchers say cellphone users can lessen the risk of hearing problems by:

  • Switching ears regularly
  • Using an ear piece, which would eliminate the risk of magnetic waves from the phones themselves
  • Or better yet, using a speaker phone.

"If you listen to a speaker phone or hands-free system as opposed to using the cell phone in one ear, that essentially means the potential damage is one-quarter of what it would have been," says Chasin.

"My rule of thumb is moderation -- if you listen to anything loud enough, long enough, it can cause hearing loss."

Please Add Comments( )

Jonathan Avery
said
0 0

I would love to read this study. The tricky thing about these studies is attributing causation. There are so many other factors that can cause hearing loss such as ipods or other music listening devices, live music concerts and even urban living. Have you ever stood on street corner waiting for a bus and it screetches to a stop causing your ears to ring? I wonder if they controlled for these factors.

For all we know this sample could be young city dwellers who listen to their iPods on a daily basis and go to live concerts on a regualr basis. So of course they would have hearing loss..but would that be caused by their life style of their cell phone, or all of the above? I am sure you get my point

Jon

I


Bob
said
0 0

There are far too many people who think they can't do without these things. How did we all get along before they were invented? I was in Marathon, Ontario last fall and there was a woman registering in the hotel who was shocked that there was no service in the area. She asked the desk clerk "What am I supposed to do now?" He answered, "We have these" and showed her the desk phone. She couldn't believe it!

johnn
said
0 0

Oh well, like Tennessee Ernie Ford sang: If the right one doesnt get you then the left one will . . .
We'll all go because of something.



Susana C
said
0 0

Blah Blah Blah - if phone usage does that then all of us who have made(make) a living working on the phone all day would be stone deaf - I have been working on phones for 41 years - as a Bell Operator, Receptionist and Call Centre CSR I ain't deaf yet! Pardon what did you say?


richie
said
0 0

Yes I totally know what you mean Bob. The sad part is that if you don't want to play ball you have to pay 50 cents per call at the dwindling number of payphones in urban canada today... even in spite of a class action lawsuit against the gouging by cellphone monopolies of canada.


miles
said
0 0

Maybe you're not deaf Susana but you sure have eye problems if you missed the fact that this article is about cellphones, not conventional ones.


Mau
said
0 0

Strange. I figured commentors here would have denied their is a problem and if there were its because of the Liberals or some left wing conspiracy.


DF
said
0 0

Someone's waste of time Ph.D. thesis. These days they will run a study on anything - i bet it all can be explained by that.


Thomas Chan
said
0 0

Not only the cellphones might lead to hearing loss, but also the MP3 players. It is a norm that younsters or music lovers turn the volume of their MP3 way too loud and making their calls so frequently, please don't expect your hearing ability lasts long.


wc
said
0 0

Sorry... what? I can't hear you.... you're breaking up.... it's a right wing plot?


Aaron
said
0 0

It's pathetic nowadays what these studies come up with.

Pretty soon toilet paper is going to be the leading cause of cancer or watches are going to be known to have a direct link to carpel tunnel syndrome.

What a waste of time and money.....



o'donnell
said
0 0

Could working in a call centre hurt your hearing also?


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

Subscribe!

CTV MedNews Express

CTV MedNews Express

Sign up for our weekly medical newsletter, delivered for free to your inbox.

CTV.ca Blogs

Health Blog Avis Favaro Marla Shapiro

Health Blog

Check out what our guest medical experts and CTV health reporters are writing about.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz