CTV News | Dion takes responsibility for loss, vows to do better

Top Stories -   

Dion takes responsibility for loss, vows to do better

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Robert Fife on the alleged infighting
CTV News: Roger Smith on how Dion can move on
CTV Montreal: Rob Lurie on the desire for change
CTV Newsnet: Stephane Dion speaks in Crosby, Ont.
CTV Newsnet: Denis Coderre, Liberal defence critic
CTV Newsnet: Richard Marceau, political commentator
CTV Newsnet: Strategists debate what the election results mean for their party
CTV Newsnet: Liberal strategist Gerard Kennedy on lessons learned from the byelection
Canada AM: Jack Layton, leader of the NDP
Canada AM: Antonia Maioni, director, McGill Institute for the Study of Canada
CTV Newsnet: Liza Frulla, former Liberal cabinet minister discusses the rebuilding challenges in Quebec

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(105)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Tue. Sep. 18 2007 7:16 PM ET

Liberal Leader Stephane Dion said he takes full responsibility for a key byelection loss to the NDP in Quebec on Monday, and vowed the party will perform better next time.

"It's my responsibility to win the byelection and I take the responsibility for what happened and the responsibility to be sure that next time we'll be stronger," Dion said during a news conference on Tuesday.

"We may have a national election -- a general election, or a byelection in Saskatchewan, Ontario, and British Columbia. We intend to win these byelections or a general election."

The Liberals came up empty-handed in three byelections held Monday, while the Tories and NDP gained ground.

The Conservatives managed to take a seat in the Bloc Quebecois stronghold of Roberval--Lac-Saint-Jean, while NDP challenger Thomas Mulcair took the longtime Liberal stronghold of Outremont from Jocelyn Coulon.

The Bloc held onto the remaining Saint-Hyacinthe-Bagot east of Montreal, fending off a strong challenge from the Tories.

Dion denied that the losses in Quebec have led to a leadership crisis. He said the Liberal Party now knows it must work harder if it is to build support in the next election.

"We will ask a lot of questions about how can we improve the situation to make sure we win the next election," Dion said.

"We have a burden of responsibilities on our shoulders. We really think that this government is bringing Canada in the wrong direction and we need to win for the good sake of Canada."

Dion, a Quebecer, was elected as leader partly on his promise to gain ground for the Liberal Party in Quebec.

He said Monday's loss was a reflection of the fact the Liberal Party faces challenges in Quebec, and he intends to have an "intense dialogue" with people in the province in the coming weeks and months to get the Liberal message across.

Mulcair, a former Liberal environment minister in Quebec, told CTV Montreal he sees his victory as a major milestone for the NDP, which has only ever held one seat in the province.

"I think what you're going to see as we head into the next general election, there are a lot more people like me who are household names in Quebec who realize the NDP is the way of the future, for our kids, for Canada getting back to its pre-eminent role on the world stage that we've lost with the Harper Conservatives."

Speaking on Tuesday, Mulcair said the victory came down to hard work by his campaign team, the NDP's position on the war in Afghanistan and the party's strong environmental stance.

NDP Leader Jack Layton said Mulcair's win in Outremont, a riding held by the Liberals since 1935 with only one exception, represents a "very significant change, a new era in politics in Quebec and therefore perhaps in Canada."

"It's the beginning of a process," Layton told CTV's Canada AM on Tuesday morning.

"With a voice of such integrity and capacity as Thomas Mulcair, speaking out against the Harper policies on the war, speaking out so strongly on the environment where he's so well known, and for the priorities of working and middle-class families which are really feeling squeezed out there."

One analyst said Mulcair's victory in what has historically been considered a safe Liberal riding, to a candidate hand-picked by Dion, will undoubtedly trigger questions about his leadership skills.

"I think the question that's being asked is: Why or how can Stephane Dion now claim, as he did during the Liberal leadership race, that he would bring Quebec back to the Liberal Party? How has that promise not been fulfilled and how do they keep the Liberal brand from sliding further?" Antonia Maioni, director of the McGill Institute for the Study of Canada told CTV's Canada AM on Tuesday.

She said two key battlegrounds are emerging in Quebec -- one on the island of Montreal, where the Liberals have historically dominated, the other throughout the rest of Quebec, where the Liberals seem to be losing ground among francophone Quebecers while the Tories seem to be gaining traction.

The Conservative victory in Roberval--Lac-Saint-Jean seemed to indicate that Harper's 18-month courtship of the province had paid off.

"I think in the short term, the NDP victory is a very good one for the party. But I think in the long-term, it's the Conservatives who have shown that they are emerging as a federalist alternative in the rest of Quebec that is off the island of Montreal," Maioni said.

One anonymous Liberal MP pointed out to the Canadian Press that the Liberals' current seat count in Quebec -- 12 of 75 -- is the lowest since Confederation.

"There are going to have to be changes in the leader's entourage," said the MP.

The Conservatives now hold 126 seats in Parliament, while the Liberals have 96, the Bloc 49 and the NDP 30.

Three seats are held by Independent MPs and four remain vacant.

Comments are now closed for this story

Jesse
said

Time for Dion to go. Lets give Ignatieff a shot and see if he has any luck articulating an alternate vision of Canada and stopping the Harper juggernaut.


John in London ON
said

I have been waiting 15 years for this.

More Liberal infighting is on the horizon, and its music to my ears.

Conservative majority here we come!


reid
said

What leadership? After years of Mr.Dithers backstabbing his leader,the Liberals picked the worst of a bad bunch to try to regain the keys to the taxpayers vault. Good riddance to all of them. Let's hope Prime Minister Harper has a long and productive career as prime minister.


Dennis LeDrew
said

The Liberals have had the poorest ever showing in Quebec since.....Confederation?!

Ouch. Clearly, the Liberal brand is on a sharp decline.

For someone who was a native Quebecer and was supposed to revive Liberal fortunes in Quebec, Stephane Dion sure has a funny way of showing it.


lenwick
said

Dion is smart but was the wrong man for leader.


Brent - New Brunswick
said

Canada cannot afford another four years of Harper. It is time for Dion to place his country and party first and step aside. He's a good man at the wrong time.


Chris
said

Always was a Liberal however Dion isn't a leader....I like the NDP however wish they were given a chance. Harper is VERY disappointing on his Environment platform. The issue of Global Warming and decreasing Greenhouse gas emissions is important. I wish people would wake up!. The time to act is now...before it's too late. What kind of world are we leaving the future generations?


Stephen in good old Montreal
said

I was so surprised that Dion was elected top leader of the party. This only proves that the Liberal machine is operating without any logic. I think as Pauline Marois is the best thing for English Quebec, Dion is the best thing for a successful Conservative majority. Let's face facts, his English is poor to bad, his demeanour is that of a wet towel and his positions are always controversial, he brings nothing to the table but his incessant whining.


Nick D
said

After years of Liberal corruption, they finally pay the price at the electorate. Hit 'em where it hurts!

Harper-led Conservative Majority on our way!


Steve
said

It's great to watch all of this unfold, as a small-c conservative who endured the taunts of Liberals as we wrestled with our demons in the 1990s. Smug Liberals now are getting their comeuppance!


Scott Buck
said

I hope this is the first step in giving Dion the boot. I was shocked when he was announced leader months ago and knew as long as he was leader the Liberals would gain no ground. Ignatieff would be more of the same. I'm tired of these leaders who think that holding the top seat in the country is about sitting on the fence, keeping things status quo and making as few waves as possible. It's time for something different.
I personally don't see Harper as a Canadian favourite either, nor do I think he's a 'juggernaut' or that Canadians want a Tory majority. However, lacking any other choice Canadians may grant them just that. What happened to leaders with charisma and passion.
Here's to hoping Layton, the only intelligent, passionate one among them, jumps ship and takes the reigns of the Liberal party!


Brian
said

The longer Dion stays the weaker the Liberals become. I don't think this guy could manage himself out of a wet paper bag...much less be Prime Minister.






Donny
said

Hopefully the Liberals will realize that Dion was not the candidate of choice for the general population as per the poll showings before the leadership convention. What matters in an election is the voice of the people and not backroom deals made amongst candidates and delegates.


Janus
said

Excellent news.

Now for a Harper-led majority.


Ryan
said

I wonder how many Liberals are going to cross the floor again. The Liberal ship is sinking and Layton seems to be campaigning for the Leader of the Opposition office.


Bernie
said

Do we really want a Conservative Majority.
Think George Bush!!!
Think how arrogant Steven Harper is now.
Dion unfortunately is the wrong man. Maybe Kennedy.


Don
said

Dion should go but Ignatieff is nothing less then an american in sheep's clothing. I prefer the liberals to the conservatives but for positive change the leader must be chosen carefully. Ignatieff is not the man you need. Kennedy should be seriously considered, maybe Trudeau, the point is you should be looking for younger candidates.



Steven Booth
said

The last time we had a leader with passion, he permanently alienated the West. The only thing keeping Alberta in Confederation is P.M. Harper.

And as far as the man-made Globull Warming hoax is concerned, Canadians are getting wise to this warm mongering. When the biggest polluter in the world - Communist China - is exempt, this proves that this is all about wealth distribution from the West to socialist countries that under perform, led by the Watermelons of the world: Green on the outside but Red on the inside.


DG in Exeter
said

There has never been no better a supporter for the Conservative party - much thanks Dion - appreciate all you do for us :-)


Felix
said

The fact that Mr Dion lost Outremont is absolutely pathetic on his part. look they held the seat since 1935 if I'm correct and now the NDP sneak in and steal the seat.

Earl Robert
said

Stephane Dion is not a leader. Prime Minister Harper is. Canada needs strong leadership and the Conservative party is the answer.




Douglas Speer
said

Stephane Dion is an honest man. He is a man of conscience, intelligence and integrity. He would be an excellent prime minister. However, the Liberals are in a street fight within their own ranks and the other political parties and Mr. Dion does not have the kind of leadership that it takes to lead his party to victory.

Mike
said

Finally the Quebec dog wags its tail instead of the tail wagging the dog... this is good for Quebec and good for Canada.


Tamouh
said

Though I've to agree Mr. Harper had not done much harm to Canada, I still do not trust the man. Hence, I would only want to see another Conservative minority. The Dion's Liberal is definitely no longer an option and now I'm pondering if NDP is the real answer for another minority government.


Den
said

Whilst I am not a fan of the Conservatives or the NDP, I never had much faith that Dion could pull the Liberals out of the fire. I know Ignatieff is not the solution; from a Canadian point of view, he is too Americanized.
Didn't the Liberals think of their constituents when they selected their new leader? Silly me...of course not!
What the Liberals need is NEW blood, not some recycled old stuff.
Justin Trudeau was a good start but he is still less than 1/2 a percent of what's needed. Change the cheese, Liberals!


Jonnay
said

If Dion wants to beat his main opponent on the other side of the house, he has to become as mean as the cowboy on the other side of the house. He's too nice now, holds too much of a smile. That's no way anyone can beat a liar with all his trolls.

As for you pro-Harper-party-majority freaks, I suggest you think twice about the broken promises and increased income taxes.



Neil
said

It's time for the Liberals to realize that the other parties' spin doctors have caught up to the Big Red Machine - the Tories aren't the scary, polarizing party everyone expected when Harper took over, and Layton's NDP isn't the same one-message fringe party it's been for the past 20 years.

The Liberals also need to realize that Canadians aren't necessarily looking for high-brow intellects (Trudeau, Dion), or bumblers who appeal as "men of the people," a la Chretien. Love or hate his policies, Harper is winning people over as leader by employing the right mix of logic, inclusiveness and backbone.


Neil McKenty
said

Stephan Dion has always been underestimated. When Martin dumped him from the cabinet, when no one gave him much chance of winning the leadership. I predict Dion will bounce back - big time.


Michelle
said

Dion is a dedicated politician but he needs to think of his party and step down b/c he
quite obviously has not clicked with the Canadian people.I think Kennedy would have made a much better leader!!
I find Harper and his cronies too pompous for their own good, too much like Bush. Time for another liberal
leader convention!!


Les from Alberta
said

Sept 17 was a great day for Canada. Quebecers and Canadians will never forget the 13 years of lies and theft from the Liberals.


Greg
said

Canadians finally speaking up and voting in a party that gets things done.
How easily we all forget what the Liberals were like in power.
It's all starting to show, Conservatives are the new National party of choice.
How any one can not like or stand the Conservatives is beyond me.... Liberals need to stop thinking they are intitled to running the country, which clearly they are not.
Mr. Harper is a real leader!


Rollie
said

A sad state of affairs! it appears that the current leader and any potential leaders have all left the building. A lot of work to rebuild the party must be done.


Manboy
said

If Dion is as smart as everyone says he is, and if he truly loves the Liberal Party as he says he does, then he has but one thing to do - resign. Being smart he must now know that his leadership is not going to bring votes to the Liberals but will in fact chase voters away from the party. People don't want him as Prime Minister. Canadians demand someone with charisma or presence or some kind of mistique - like it or not. For the sake of the party he must resign.


Michael
said

Harper is in power ONLY because the other parties leaders are weaker than him - not because he is strong. If a good liberal leader would be found , Harper's days will be over.


Mike
said

I am sick of hearing Liberal and NDP supporters complaining about the environment platform of the Conservatives. The Liberals did absolutely nothing for the environment when they were in power expect make promises that were impossible (Kyoto).

The NDP wants us to honor our Kyoto "obligations". That would be irresponsible and illogical. When the biggest polluters are not signed on to Kyoto (United States and China) then why should we cripple our economy when the effect on our pollution would do nothing on the world stage as long as China and US do not change. Think about it people!! It's one thing to support enviromental laws that would help our environment but think about the consequences of Kyoto on our economy and the empty promises of the Liberals.

The Liberals have always had one agenda and that is to get elected or re-elected and they will say what ever they have to to obtain that objective.


Chris in Vancouver
said

Harper delayed parliament from sitting in order to analyze the outcome of the Quebec by-elections and the results of the Ontario provincial election. If Ontario goes conservative, I predict there will be a general election this calendar year. The barometer reads 'change' in Quebec - we'll know how Ontario feels in weeks. The Liberals have no leader - from a strategy perspective, delaying parliament was brilliant.


Ian
said

Harper is a liar and needs to be removed. Just shows that the Quebec people are quick to sell their votes for a bag load of money. We paid big time in the last budget for Harper to buy those votes.


Alan
said

Too many years of Liberal vitriole seems to have confused some Canadians.

Harper, arrogant? No Bernie, that's mistaking leadership for arrogance.

Dion. Now that’s arrogance. Fence sitting, double-talk, whining, spin, and self-serving actions with a smile on his face as he’d hand out dollars to his friends without guilt, shame, or any larger sense of vision. (Remember, Dion was part of that pack and one reason Quebecers will NEVER embrace him.)

Harper? Intelligent. Decisive. Comfortable with other world leaders. Recognizing the significant regional and cultural diversity that contributes to one great nation. This isn’t arrogance; it’s called LEADERSHIP.

It seems we've been without leadership for so long some can't recognize it when they see or hear it.


Rick
said

Wonder what the turnout was? By-elections are usually volatile, and seldom mean much when a general election rolls around.

Liberals DO need to be more effective in countering Harper, and Dion might be too nice for the job.

When Ontario comes into play, Harper will never win a majority. It is an impasse.


Kris
said

I think Dion is a nice man who genuinely loves our country, but I don't think he is a great leader.


Dave W
said

I loved Preston Manning, but he just wasn't PM material....too awkward. Now multiply that awkwardness 10 fold and you get Dion. The man is no way seems to be a PM in waiting.


C.B.
said

When it comes to global warming, Canada could cease to exist - no people, no cars, no greenhouse gases - and it wouldn't make a difference. This is because China, with its ever increasing population, overwhelms any contributions to greenhouse gases that Canada makes with just its yearly increases.

I'm all for a cleaner environment, but the liberals have never done much to clean up Canada. They can't even clean up their own act!

The Greenest PM we've had so far was Mulroney (ask Elizabeth May). Harper isn’t perfect, but at least he isn’t a Liberal.


Ed
said

Finally, in Harper, we've got a leader who happens to be smart enough NOT to insult our US neighbours or look on the public treasury as his private piggy bank.

Forget the pathetic distraction of Dion. Give The Conservatives a majority and watch as we continue to develop as a world-class nation. Be a country builder, not a finger puppet for the party who invented ‘finger-use’ in Canadian politics.

Rest assured, Dion would be poking his finger in the eye of the US just like those who groomed him, regardless of who is the US President.

It’s ironic how the Liberals complain vigorously whenever the United States offers any opinion about Canadian Governments, but seem to feel at liberty to offer a running commentary (usually through through the media) on almost anything the Americans do or say.

Curiously, the Liberals seems to have covertly trained a troupe of Canadians to join the finger-puppet parade. Time to take the act backstage and let the Liberal gang party on their own for a while (in obscurity).



Luc
said

Well, Dion must go.
The English speaking Canadian can't stand a PM that can't speak English correctly... and French speaking Quebecers can't stand a PM that speak like he just came out of PARIS (Paris, FRANCE, not Paris Hilton). Stephen Harper is the perfect example of how the "Chief must come from the Belle Province" rule they used for the last century is just wrong.


Dennis
said

Dion is not the man for the job. Sorry. He just doesn't have ANY appeal. Ignatieff would be better, but not by much.

The Liberals need someone with mucho charisma. Dion and Ignatieff are so forgettable.

They need someone who will appeal to a broader span of Canadians and not from Quebec. A good candidate would Frank McKenna, but I don't blame him for not jumping in. He knew what was in store for the Liberals. If they can get their act together once more, he would give Harper a run for his money.


Katie
said

Mr. Mulcair is a former Liberal Cabinet minister with enormous popularity. Mr. Dion's image was partially created by the Conservative attack ads.
Mr. Dion has not been leader for very long and it takes time to create your own niche in the Canadian psyche.
I don't entirely approve of "leapfrogging" at a leadership convention but since Mr. Dion won the leadership under convention rules, he can't be fully assessed until he takes his party through a general election. On the final ballot, there were only 2 candidates left and Mr. Dion secured a clear win.


Andy Klymax
said

One has to remember the sponsorship scandal when considering the results of these byelections. The scandal murdered the Liberal's in Quebec and it could be sometime before they fully regain their strength in that province. Mr. Dion inherited a mess and is doing his best to revive an ailing party. All in good time...


Brian C
said

A once proud party reduced to ashes. Maybe it's for the best. They had been much too cocky and arrogant for too long. I hope Dion stays around to complete the necessary rebuilding once the rats have all run away.


Leadership not popularity counts:
said

Like it or not Mr. Harper is getting the job done. He has demonstrated he is not just a Conservative leader but a leader for all Canadians and is doing us proud on the international stage as well.

Proud to support the Conservative Prime Minister Mr. Harper.



Bob Smith
said

Looks like transferring billions of dollars from Alberta to Quebec is the key to forming a majority government.


bubba
said

Dion and the liberal party have been imploding since he became the party commandant. Their old school arrogance,misplaced sense of entitlement,lack of morals and deep rooted corruption have no appeal to the ever increasing numbers of free thinking individuals. Thanks to Prime Minister Harper for bringing Canada back into the light.


Jeremiah
said

This is not just the fault of Dion. This is a result of the Liberal party as a whole, not performing well when they were in power and being mediocre as the opposition. Add that to the Conservative's party relatively steady leadership, and you can see why the Liberals just aren't an appealing choice anymore.


Richard Reeves
said

Good to see, now to rid of Dion and bring back Kennedy!! He will be the best PM in a long time!


James, Saskatoon. SK
said

Let's get Ignatieff on the leadership front, he is the only one who knows and best for Librals to bounce back. I can't believe the Reps even picked Dion to be the leader in the first place, he is a good guy but not a leader. Dion step aside and think of the party first before anything else. I don't want anymore of Harper ruling this country, wrong direction as far as I know.


Donna
said

I think that Quebec is finally waking up to who the true leader is in this country. All of the scary predictions about Mr. Harper have not come true. He is proving to be a leader who looks at all the facts before making changes, has finally put our country back into a positive relationship with the US. Our country is strong, we have none of the money problems the US is having and he is not willing to destroy our country for global warming changes when the US & China are doing nothing and they would make all the difference. The western part of Canada has grown very tired in recent years of always having the leaders from Quebec speaking French. Finally Quebec is showing they can no longer be influenced by that fact, good for them. Let's have an election & give Prime Minister Harper a majority government that will work to make our country even stronger. Let's try & put all the years of poor and scandal ridden years of Liberal government behind us and continue to move forward, maybe this time as a united country under Prime Minister Harper.


Chris
said

Congrats to PM Harper on his win. It is time for people to stop comparing him to President Bush as there is no comparison. It is about time we had a Prime Minister stand up for Canada and that is exactly what Harper is doing. As for the Liberals, they are a hurting party with out a strong leader.


Gord Cowan
said

As a westerner I could never never vote Liberal, Liberals don't know we exist and those that do could care less about the west. My hat is off to the great spirit of Quebecers who are going to make those Liberals pay. Maybe the next Liberal leader will actually be able to speak english.


sam
said

I hardly think this by-election reduced the Liberal party "to ashes." People tend to vote regionally in by-elections. Mulcair is an ex-Liberal. Yes, the Liberal party needs to pull itself together, strengthen its message, but national polls aren't showing much change. CPC united three parties, and they still are neck to neck with the Libs, who share the left with others. Harper and his deceits, personal attacks rather than policies, and constant flip-flops directed by polls will be in for a fight next election. He knows this, which is a main reason he "cut and ran" by proroguing parliament.


J.Visser
said

Canadians can be sure that PM Harper is winning the game.


Helen
said

What makes the Liberals think that they have sole ownership over this country???? Hurray for the Conservatives and let it continue. Our Prime Minister Stephen Harper is the politician to make Canada proud again.


Cody
said

Dion has taken responsibility but really what is it he must do? The Liberals had their chance to elect a leader better suited and no Ignatieff is not the man. Kennedy may have had a chance but it would've been hard for him to relate to Quebec. Bob Rae may have been the man to give the Liberals a new image but then how would he fair out in Ontario. When Dion was elected the problem everyone was talking about was how he would relate to English Canada, now the Liberals have a nightmare because it is hard for him now to relate back to Quebec. Someone said maybe Trudeau would be a good leader, let's not let a name deceive us.
The NDP may actually have a chance to become the official opposition but Layton has to play his cards carefully and correctly. Harper is not perfect but he is displaying characteristics of leadership that Canadians wanted and now have. But where do the Liberals go now, if Dion stays and aggonizes through an election it may severly hurt the Liberals for who knows how long. On the other hand if Dion goes the Liberals may have to face an election with an interm leader or an "appointed" leader and this also could spell danger. It could be good days to come for Conservatives.


Sean P. Hogan
said

Time for Dion to take a hike. He hasn't made any inroads in Quebec. If an election is called soon, he surely won't win a majority, as a matter of fact, the Liberals may stay in opposition.


Po
said

Dion will not win a general election, I'm sad to say. The anglophones don't like him because he's very French (huge accent and difficulty expressing himself when speaking English) and the francophones seem to have a problem because he sounds more "French French" than "Quebec French". He is clearly very intelligent and the "bad leader" comments are obviously Conservative-generated propaganda, which most of Canada is just gobbling up.

I think Justin Trudeau would make a good PM, love his openness and social consiousness... unlike Harper who doesn't care about anyone who isn't in a power position or who isn't a Conservative.

Oh, and I won't even go into the environment, Conservatives are in the stoneage when it comes to the environment.

Victor from Vaughan Ontario
said

Big words for little Dion. He is a puppet from the Old Liberal guard and the party should have turned the page with the many new folks they had lining up to take up the torch.

Not even a good number of Liberals like the same old guard anymore.

Anyhow, they are stuck in the old ways of relying on big corporate money to fund elections, and the sooner they start going after the grass roots and small companies again for contributions of $ 1,000 the quicker they will start getting up off the mat.

They look like they are face down right now.

Dale Norman
said

Timing is everything in politics and Mr. Dion was the one chosen to hold the hand grenade this time, much as Ms. Campbell did for the conservatives all those years ago. It's all a perfect set-up for the liberal heir apparent (you know, the baby Trudeau) to make his triumphant journey to the PMs office in the general election of 2013.

Hard to see how a conservative majority can be avoided next time out, my kids soccer bag could get more votes in Western Canada than Mr. Dion. Don't forget where the money is now and which part of the country is growing most quickly. The Quebec vote, while far from insignificant will certainly not be the be all and end all of Canadian politics in a few more years. Thats IF the West hasn't said the hell with it and left.

GW
said

Layton and his commu…I mean socialist party as official opposition? What is the world coming to! It’s strong businesses and banks with a splash of socialism that provides us with the high standard of living we currently. I still don’t understand people who vote for NDP. I probably never will.


Kris Valgardson(Zeke)
said

At the last Liberal leadership convention when Dion was elected leader wasn't it one of his M.P.s that said we just gave Harper a majority. Truer words were never spoken.

Lloyd - Winnipeg
said

Dion deserves to be PM, unfortunealty for him he has advisors that are just as incompetant as those who advised Paul Martin. While Ignatieff may have a stronger team, he won't do any better, the Liberal Party needs youth and charisma; Kennedy is the guy. The Liberals must eliminate the arrogant old boys club who zest for power not for governing and until that happens the party will continue to dissipate regardless of the leader. Infighting for the leadership only demonstrates the lack of leadership....duh.

Sean
said

Way to go Mr. Mulcair! Thanks for bringing the NDP into Quebec and may you and Jack have nothing but greater and greater successes.

In the future! Bring better and fairer government to Canada with our first NDP Government!

Don't let them tell you it can't be done!

Ken M
said

Hardly anyone is giving the NDP the credit they deserve here. The stories all concenrate on Dion losing, not Jack and his gang winning.
The next leader of the opposition will be NDP unless Dion is dumped. I can live with that. A good counterbalance for Harper.


Mickey
said

The Liberals should have picked a more charismatic leader. Stephane Dion is virtually unknown. Ralph, where are you?

Julian in Manitoba
said

Dion will not bring Quebec closer to the Liberal Party, Ignatieff lets see what you can do!

L.Miller
said

Mr. Dion is no leader, he can't reunite his own party. Lots of 'in' house fight still going on. A scramble to save this party, and he, I'm afraid is a lame duck.
Ignatieff will be no better, he hasnt lived in Canada, how is it he has the finger on the pulse of 'this' country. Shaking my head, at least we now have PM that other countries know, and some have come to admire. I lived in the UK and France, and hardly anyone could tell me who Mr. Martin was, or the PM that proceeded him.

Terry Van Oerle
said

I usually pay little attention to the results of byelections as they are a chance for voters to send the government a message without changing the governing party. But these three Quebec elections are significant. Opposition parties are suposed to do well in byelections, but these were disasters for the federal Liberals. Not only did they lose a safe seat, they finished dismally in the others. Under Stephane Dion, this party is in a lot of trouble.

richie
said

If people do not like the will of Europe being imposed on Canada they should perhaps try to have a leader who doesn't still hold French citizenship like Dion.

Ian
said

Stay the course Dion. You haven't hit rock bottom yet. That time will come soon.

Al
said

No conservative majority for Canada; wheather NDP or Liberals, it's their duty to push it all the way to make sure that doesn't happen.

Mr. Dion is a smart and honest person and i envy that, but i don't think he's a strong leader and right now Liberals need a big leader to take back the damage done over the past few years.

So PLEASE, Liberals wake up and step up!

Brenda
said

"Harper, arrogant? No Bernie, that's mistaking leadership for arrogance "

That's dead on! leaders who lead take the bull by the horns and get things done...Harper all the way!

username
said

An excellent night for Progressive (that is we on the looneyleft) voters last night. 2 out of the 3 ridings went to leftist parties. I say that is a good sign.

Jim
said

I think it is better to focus on the positive. It is great to see the BQ declining in Quebec and a growing federalist alternative (the Conservatives and NDP) in the province. This is good for Canada.

Mitch
said

The Liberals have no credibility with federalists after last night and what little credibility they had with nationalists was lost back in 2006. For too many years, the Grits have taken anglo and immigrant voters in Montreal for granted but Montrealers are far from stupid. Mr. Charest's collapse last March showed that without the regions, a Liberal can't carry the province and if the Liberals are unable to win seats outside Montreal, why should anyone INSIDE Montreal vote for them?
The answer to the Liberals' problem is to correct their approach to federalism. They need to move away from the Trudeau method. Ignatieff has that vision. But rural Quebec has always been more conservative than Montreal. Just ask the creditistes!

Ottawa Mike
said

Liberals held themselves out as the conscience of Canada and demonized Conservatives for everything and anything while they were ripping off taxpayors. They polarized Canada and destroyed our healthcare system under Chretien and Martin. PM Harper is working to empower regions, build unity and fix the mess and set out a new vision for Canada as a nation which is socially and fiscally responsible and an example of moderation to the world. He leads by conviction not by the latest "poll de jour" as the Liberals do. Harper is a leader who deserves respect even if he isn't quite perfect.

Jim Pook
said

Stephan Harper's leadership wins the day in Quebec by-elections! It is great to watch the big Liberal machine grind to a halt in Quebec. Perhaps we will soon be rid of all the Liberal corruption in Canada.

It is interesting to note that if you put the three by-election results together, that the Conservatives won the popular vote. What could this mean to future elections in Quebec? Conservative majority? For the sake of Canada, we can only hope.

A Haper/Conservative majority victory is what Canada and Canadians need at this point in history.

Kevin Driver
said

I am so glad the Liberals went down in flames. PM Harper has given us desisive leadership.

Let us look at Stephane Dion in my opinion the man is a total hypacrit. The only decision I ever agreed with Jean Chretien about was Afghanistan, he sent Canadian soldiers into battle in 2002. Dion was in Cabinet and did not jump up in protest. paul Martin sent us back to battle, and Dion was in cabinet and did not jump up in protest.

What he has done is also say his job is to oppose the government, well NO his job is to represent his constituents. I am sure there can be some common ground for the common good. If PM Harper and layton or Duceppe can work for the common good why can't Dion, easy they just want POWER.

Bye the way Mr. Dion it takes more than naming your dog Kyoto to show Leadership.

Curtis
said

I could care less who is steering the Liberal ship. Too many years of sleaze and ripping off Canadian taxpayers has left me with only one choice for our Country's leader and that is Stephen Harper. I may not embrace all the Conservative's policies however Harper is proving to be a decisive and proactive leader. As another writer put it, this isn't arrogance, it's LEADERSHIP. As long as many of the old guard remains part of the Liberal Party, including Dion himself, you couldn't pay me to vote for this aimless bunch of thieves who want to run the Canada based on polls and popularity contests while they line their own pockets with our tax dollars. And by the way, don't feed me Ignatief as an alternative either as I doubt he even knows how to spell "Canada" let alone lead it.

Roger T
said

Personal I don't think whatever Dion does will help the Liberals. I myself am not a fan of him as a leader, I'd much rather vote for Jack Layton or just simply NDP all the way!

John Timmermans
said

If Dion would ever become prime minister I would be leaving this country. I am very proud that we have a man that really knows how to get things done.
He paid a good chunk off the national debt that is one fo his aims.

Jerry
said

I have not been this happy since the early 90's.

A CONSERVATIVE FAN
said

Whoo!! GOOD JOB HARPER!!! THE CONS RULE HERE COMES A MAJORITY GOVERNMENT.

JP
said

IAN, "we"? I thought Quebec was part of Canada the last time I checked. Anyway, this by-election result simply demonstrates that people are fed-up with the status-quo. The problem is that the Conservatives offer very little if not just a change. Politics on this side of the Pond is in serious need of a re-birth!


dvg
said

If Dion is really a leader, he will resign. If the Liberals are really a party for Canada, they will find a leader that Canadians would vote for.

It's too bad that the Liberals haven't figured it out yet, but Canadians have had it with the old boys club.

Steve McIntosh
said

"The NDP wants us to honor our Kyoto "obligations". That would be irresponsible and illogical. When the biggest polluters are not signed on to Kyoto (United States and China) then why should we cripple our economy when the effect on our pollution would do nothing on the world stage as long as China and US do not change."

This is a typically conservative short sighted view. You have to think towards the future, pollution and energy waste is a global problem, the longer you wait to get on the bandwagon the more it will cost you down the road. If we do the regressive, american, conservative thing, we will wait until it's too late and pay WAY too much money tomorrow instead of getting a bargain today.

T. A. Chustas
said

It strikes me as odd that we have two sides of the same poorly minted coin passing as political commentary -- on the obverse it is a disaster for the Liberals and the reverse it is a clear victory for the Conservatives. Hold the hyperbole as we get some perspective: the voter turnout for these byelections was way down from the 2006 general election (Outremount down from 61% to 38%; Roberval down from 62% to 47%; and St. Hyacinthe down from 66% to 42%). I wouldn't put too much stock in interpreting too broadly the results that reflect only a minority or at best a plurality of electors.

James
said

I too have been very sad since the late 1980s.


Wayner In Kitchener
said

Dion is just a scapegoat leader till Justin Trudeau is groomed for the role. The timing is not right for Justin right now. I believe the Liberals pick Dion as their Kim Campbell. Give Justin 4 years in opposition and see his star rise in Parliament. Or perhaps I am giving the Liberals too much credit in the brains department.

Roy Cotton
said

I hope Mr. Dion stays on as party leader, that just makes it easier for Prime Minister Harper.


Ian
said

Lloyd what do you mean that Dion deserves to be PM. And why is that? Because he's a Liberal, I bet you mean. After all, Liberals are the only ones who can do the job, right! Your attitude of entiltlement is wearing thin on Canadians, FINALLY! Mr. Harper deserves an HONEST chance to do some good things for Canada without being criticized at every turn. You Liberals are the ones who are arrogant, not Harper!


Chris
said

I am just wondering if
Dion is the Joe Clark of the Liberal party? Stephane who?


dave
said

Not your fathers Oldsmobile huh?

The liberal party lost it big, oh, about 15 years ago, and recovery is not looking good.

Major changes are needed, but I don't see it coming anytime soon.

Keep the resumes current.

Billy
said

I am just musing about Mr Dion's sentiments to last night's results. Could his sentiments be the following:-

This is not fair! We are entitled to win at least one out of three. The voters should immediately apologize to the Liberal party and to me. They are the cause of our/my demise. (tongue in cheek!).


Matthew Crites
said

It's about time the Liberals get what they deserve, the fine people of this nation are finally sending the message that we will not tolerate liars and theives in government. Go Harper Go!


DAP
said

We have a perfectly good Prime Minister in Mr. Harper. A true leader.
Who really cares what's happening to the Liberal Party, except maybe the old guard and Power Corp. The Liberals need a loooong time out, and if they're smart, begin re-building from ground zero. Perpetuating the same old arrogant, entitled ways will no longer wash with Canadians.
Canadians have had a taste of a government that does what it says it will do, and a Prime Minister that does things to make Canadians proud. And you know what?
Canadians like it.


Ken Mc
said

Prime Minister Harper is a very scary man! If you're a Liberal.


hollinm
said

No matter how party members feel about Dion he is going nowhere before the next general election. It takes a year to put together a convention and pick a new leader. Time which is not available for the party. What you see is what you get.
There is no question Dion is mortally wounded and it will take a significant effort for the leadership rivals to sheath their swords. That won't happen and the media will be subjected to many brown envelopes over the next few months. You see for a leadership review to dump Dion he needs to lose the next general election. Some of the leadership candidates are prepared to let that happen.


Jocko
said

If Dion can't win in Quebec, how on earth is he going to deliver any seats in Alberta, or elsewhere in the country for that matter ?


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz