CTV News | Canada votes against UN aboriginal declaration

Canada -   

Canada votes against UN aboriginal declaration

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: John McNee, Canadian ambassador
CTV Newsnet: Chuck Strahl, Indian Affairs minister

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(23)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Thu. Sep. 13 2007 6:40 PM ET

Canada voted Thursday with three other countries against a United Nations declaration on aboriginal rights -- sparking an angry reaction from native leaders, human rights groups and opposition parties.

The non-binding declaration passed 143-4 in Thursday's vote in the UN's General Assembly. Australia, New Zealand and the United States also voted against the declaration, with 11 countries abstaining.

Critics blasted the govenrment of trying to sweep aside an important show of support for aboriginals that took 20 years of negotiations among UN countries.

But in the lead-up, Canada's ambassador to the United Nations strongly defended the decision to vote against the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

John McNee told the UN that Canada has "significant concerns with respect to the wording of the current text" of the declaration.

He said Canada was specifically concerned about a number of issues relating to provisions on lands, territories and resources.

"It's with disappointment that we find ourselves having to vote against the adoption of this declaration as drafted,'' McNee said.

Earlier Monday, Indian Affairs Minister Chuck Strahl also defended Canada's decision.

"The declaration is worded in such a way that it is inconsistent with the Canadian Constitution, the Charter, several acts of Parliament and existing treaties," he told CTV Newsnet on Thursday.

The federal government is focused on other things, like ensuring First Nations are covered by the Canadian Human Rights Act and matrimonial property rights for native women, he said.

"We're moving ahead with tangible things that will benefit First Nations here in Canada," said Strahl. "Unfortunately, that declaration is inconsistent with the Canadian reality."

Specifics

Strahl noted that among many problems with the document, are sections that say laws that affect aboriginals should only be passed with the prior consent of First Nations.

"We'd have to consult with 650 First Nations to do that. I mean, it's simply not doable," he said.

Another section of the UN declaration states aboriginals "have the right to maintain and strengthen their distinct political, legal, economic, social and cultural institutions."

Strahl said that section is also unworkable.

"Some people ... say that means we can have our own legislatures, our own council in our own language," he said. "But no one's quite sure, and that's the trouble with language like that."

The previous Liberal government supported the declaration, but Strahl noted the Liberals and NDP oppose having First Nations covered by the human rights act.

Opposition attacks

The opposition parties condemned the government's move, saying the UN declaration is not binding on any country, and is more of a symbolic commitment to aboriginal rights.

"It's an aspirational document ... it wouldn't contravene laws that are in place," NDP Indian affairs critic Jean Crowder told CP from Nanaimo, B.C.

"I think (Canada's vote) is a very cowardly and, I would say, un-Canadian approach to human rights."

Liberal leader Stephane Dion said by opposing the UN declaration, the Conservative government has signalled to Aboriginal Canadians that their rights aren't worth defending.

"The government has also dramatically weakened the leadership role Canada has long enjoyed in the global human rights movement," Dion said in a statement.

In June, Amnesty International Canada accused the Tories of working to obstruct the declaration.

UN officials say the declaration -- which has been discussed for more than two decades -- doesn't create any new rights.

"The declaration emphasizes the rights of indigenous peoples to maintain and strengthen their own institutions, cultures and traditions and to pursue their development in keeping with their own needs and aspirations," said a Sept. 6 news release.

"The text prohibits discrimination against indigenous peoples and promotes their full and effective participation in all matters that concern them, as well as their right to remain distinct and to pursue their own visions of economic and social development."

Canada's Assembly of First Nations, which represents treaty Indians, has called for the passage of the declaration.

"It's really about setting standards and holding governments to their obligations to ensure the human rights of all people -- including Indigenous peoples -- are respected," National Chief Phil Fontaine said in an Aug. 6 news release.

"This declaration is overwhelmingly supported by many countries because it recognizes the rights of indigenous peoples around the globe. These basic human rights include land, language and self government."

With files from The Canadian Press

Please Add Comments( )

allan
said
0 0

In the first place we should not sign something that has been amended without our witnessing the amendments.
Secondly, I don't believe that any people, anywhere should have special status--I thought we are all from the same planet?


damien
said
0 0

I see, natives want to be able to maintain their customs and traditions. Or do they? I think they want the best of both worlds. They want to live their traditional lives, but want to incorporate modern conveniences.

Buddy K.
said
0 0

These declarations by the UN aren't legally binding anyway. You will find governments claim and point to them being so when it works in their favor, but in reality they are not. It is embarrassing when lobby groups expose this flaw of government.


Barb
said
0 0

I know I will take a lot of flack for what Iam going to say, but I am going to say it anyway. How come the natives think they have anymore rights then any of us they didn't have any deeds on the land they claim was theirs. They were settled on a piece of land same as our ancestors so please tell me why they should have more rights then us?

Roger T
said
0 0

There should not be a vote on this, the Natives have ALL the rights over us all. They OWN this land which was stolen from them and forced into lands that are not livable conditions.

Our Gov't needs to reconize this and give back what was forced upon them - giving up thier rights for the sake of Canada!

The Natives DO NOT need to ask for permissions or granting from our Gov't as this is their land.


Albert Derocher
said
0 0

I believe that the human rights are God given and that this declaration will make the Canadian government be held responsible for their policies regarding Aboriginal Canadians. I am Native and I don't want the best of both worlds I want the best for my children and their children. We have been colonized, land expropriated and stripped of our culture in many cases. These are few of the basic human rights that the Natives of this land have endured for three centuries. To any Canadian today I ask you: Should Aboriginals be allowed to maintain their culture, traditions and way of life? A way of life that so easily defines the Canadian experience for so many people all across this planet.


Big Bear
said
0 0

What happened to all people on this planet being equal? I guess some people are more equal than others.


DWRVB
said
0 0

Let's make them equal that is what the UN wants and what the First Nations want. I also agree that they should get equal rights. But equality means to pay land tax, sales tax, as well as no other special treatment that a non native would not get.


Ken
said
0 0

I am disgusted by some of the comments on this site. I am not a first nations person, but at least I can understand why something like this declaration would be important to these groups. It's not like it's taking away anything from anyone. Many indigenous people have been systematically put down in mainstream society. They have lost their culture and their sense of belonging.

Mike
said
0 0

People have to understand that this declaration is for worldwide. Indians may have rights in Canada but not in other country. Think about it.


CK
said
0 0

Whether it be through our Constitution, The Charter of Rights or a UN Declaration none of us should be able to acquire rights or privledges that everyone does not have. Above all else we are Canadians first. We would be a much richer country, not only financially but morally and culturally if everyone was on an equal footing. Applaud our sameness and although we have many differences don't make them more important than the fact that we are all Canadians and should enjoy the same rights as each other.


Christian C.
said
0 0

What some Canadians don’t seem to realise is that the First Nations were much better of before white man came. Discrimination and suppression are still going on these days and the little CANDIES we are giving them does not even come close to compensate for what we did and doing to them. For those that think that the First Nations have every thing; go live in one of those reserves for a year. Only after will your word have meaning.


dave
said
0 0

It's interesting that people are still so ignorant and blind to social issues here in Canada. First of all, Indians come from India, I'm pretty sure of that. Second of all, the UN is making these Declarations in order to dismantle "Apartheid" laws and structures i.e the "Indian Act" and the Reservations system. The declaration is being made so that First Nations people are able to move out of the margins....I'd like to see "white people" grow up in third world conditions and then say they are treated equal in our wonderful Canadian society.


Julie
said
0 0

Barb - you are right you are going to get flack. The issue is not that both were on the land at the same time, the issue is that they were here before the settlers arrived. They had no deeds because they did not have a European system - nor should they have. The issue is the obtaining of land legally (a system we invented by the way) and it was the settlers that didn't follow the rules to obtain the legal rites to the land. Therefore we still don't have it.


Fraz
said
0 0

For those who screem loudly that the Native peoples already have equal rights, why is it that they experience dicrimination every day? How would like it if you were excluded because of who you are?


Greg Horn
said
0 0

The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples does not give Native people more rights than anyone else. In fact, this document is for Indigenous people all over the world and recognizes that these people, like all others have rights on their own land and territory. It also guarantees that as Indigenous People our right to our own languages, customs and culture. For Canada to vote against a human rights document gives a black eye to your country's reputation. Canada has now lost the moral high ground in relation to human rights. Canada can no longer tell other countries what they are doing is wrong with regards to human rights, since it has refused to adopt this human rights document. Indigenous people want what all other people have, and that is the rights to live their lives the way they see fit, without having to worry about assimilation, genocide and ethnocide....


Francis S
said
0 0

Of course Canada will vote against this, what do they care of Native people!. It's funny not even the world attention could stop Canada from doing what they have been doing for the last four hundred years, way to go Canadian Gov't, keep telling yourself you did nothing wrong, and will do nothing to fix it, whatever helps you sleep at night.


Judi Phillips
said
0 0

There is so much ignorance in this country when it comes to First Nations People. Why is the argument always about taxes...I am from the Saddle Lake First Nation, I work as a television journalist and I pay taxes just like everyone else. Take a deep hard look at what we get. Segregation and a third world quality of life at best. Take a trip to a reserve and get back to me on how "privileged" we are.


chk
said
0 0

I'm pleased that the current gov't chose NOT to support the UN declaration. I the Canadian gov't continues to lean to towards equal right for all and not just one group. It should be the Canadian people making descions for Canadian people, not some UN committee that's never visited our country let alone a First Nations community they claim to represent.


Colin Chau
said
0 0

The UN's almost interventionary role in foreign domestic affairs surely may benefit some indigenous peoples of certain countries, but may completely undermind the bbureaucratic and diplomatic efforts that countries like Canada has taken into working towards equity in indigenous and non-indigenous relations.

Our history is woven by these efforts and its these efforts that make our country distinct, and it's our efforts that in the end could prove to exemplify such diplomatic enterprises other countries may pursue when it comes to their relationship with their indigenous peoples.

This UN declaration is both arbitrary as much as it is ignorant of the unique situation that Canada has been dealing with. Thank god this declaration is non-binding.


Russ
said
0 0

I believe since the aboriginal people were the "original" people of this land that the government should sign the UN document and quit trying to suppress the aboriginal rights of the "First" Canadians. I believe they native population has the rights to be established in these documents


Amanda
said
0 0

Our government has once again embarrased us. I am truly amazed at how some of you have "evolved" since our ancestors came here and stole, burned, beat, raped, and murdered these people and to complain about the fact that they don't pay taxes is appalling. These people deserve this charter and so much more. SHAME SHAME SHAME on you.


Karin
said
0 0

"They were settled on a piece of land same as our ancestors, so please tell me why they should have more rights than us." I am assuming, you did not take history just as you are assuming my ancestors settled on a piece of land? We did not settle on a piece of land, my ancestors were here long before your ancestors came along. Also, we do not want more rights, we want rights, period.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz