News Sections
Mulroney says Trudeau to blame for Meech failure
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(67)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Wed. Sep. 5 2007 10:12 PM ET
Former prime minister Brian Mulroney directly and bitterly blames Pierre Trudeau for his greatest political defeat: the failure of the Meech Lake Accord that recognized Quebec as a distinct society.
In a CTV documentary to be broadcast Sunday -- and in his soon-to-be-released memoirs -- Mulroney recounts how Trudeau used a personal vendetta to turn the public against an Accord that was supported almost entirely by the political class.
"(Trudeau) called me a weakling, he called us cowards, he called the premiers snivelers," Mulroney told Lloyd Robertson, CTV's chief news anchor and senior news editor.
"You name it, it was all there, it was a vicious personal attack."
The Meech Lake Accord was a set of failed Constitutional amendments hammered out by Mulroney and the 10 premiers, including Quebec's Robert Bourassa, in 1987. The Accord was designed to persuade Quebec to endorse the Canada Act.
Mulroney had hoped to upstage Trudeau, who had failed to persuade Quebec to sign onto the 1981 Constitution after months of debate with the premiers. And it was clear in the interview that the failure of the Accord still troubles Mulroney deeply after 14 years out of office.
Mulroney accuses Trudeau of being jealous of his success in bringing Quebec onside, which is why he said Trudeau and his political followers torpedoed the Accord. He said this view is even supported by one of Trudeau's inner circle.
"One of his cabinet ministers, Francis Fox, said 'Look, the only reason for this, is that Pierre Trudeau doesn't want Brian Mulroney to succeed where he has failed'," Mulroney said.
The Accord died in June 1990, when Newfoundland and Manitoba failed to approve it. The fiasco of Meech ended up generating a sense of disappointment toward the federal system and led many Quebecers to reconsider separation.
"He had the option of being helpful, or being destructive -- and he chose the destructive course," said Mulroney.
While vigorously defending his achievements, Mulroney also dug into Trudeau's past, including the flamboyant former prime minister's refusal as a young man to fight in the Second World War.
"This is a man who questioned the Allies and when the Jews were being sacrificed and when the great extermination program was on -- he was marching around Outremont here on the other side of the issue," said Mulroney.
"He's entitled to make that kind of decision. But it doesn't qualify him for any position of moral leadership in our society."
Mulroney's comments echoed those by critics who blasted Trudeau for riding around rural Quebec on a motorcycle during World War II while wearing a 19th-century German army helmet.
In the 2006 book "Young Trudeau," the authors pored over the young Trudeau's private papers and revealed that the future federalist once plotted to take Quebec out of Canada and embraced francophone nationalism -- while shrugging off reports of Nazi atrocities as British propaganda.
Authors Max and Monique Nemni say Trudeau's attitudes can be attributed to the influence of his upbringing and the norms and mores of the day. But nevertheless, it shocked many to learn of the ideals and influences embraced by the 1930s and early 1940s-era Trudeau.
The two-hour special, Triumph & Treachery: The Brian Mulroney Story, will make its television premiere Sunday, Sept. 9, 2007 at 7 p.m. (check local listings) on CTV.
User Tools
CTV.ca Column
Lloyd Robertson
CTV's chief news editor and anchor on the story behind his two-hour interview with Brian Mulroney.
Related Websites
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(67)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
The chance of the destruction of our planet is very very small with this collider, but who are these people to decide what risks are acceptable for all of mankind? It puts me at unease and adds to my anxiety. CERN acknowledges that there are miniscule risks -- they admit to it so please spare the convoluted retorts.

Comments are now closed for this story
Rawror
said
F.H. Don
said
Cam S
said
It's tough to be a politician. You can't please everyone all the time - and at least that much is certain.
GP Victoria
said
Has Mulroney ever taken any responsibility for anything? Like almost single-handedly wiping the Progressive Conservative Party out of existence. Mulroney was, and still is, a complete loser...to bitterly attack a deceased Canadian Prime Minister of Trudeau’s stature and importance. Mulroney should look at his long list of mistakes before he opens his mouth again...
Mike M
said
Hated or not; Brian did a lot of good when compared with P.E.T.
Steve Carr
said
Mark D. W.
said
A. Landry
said
Find another excuse, Brian.
Robert
said
Useless PM in his time and he has groomed another one named Harper.
CFL
said
Mark Erwin
said
I wonder if we could persuade Mr. Mulroney to give it one more go??
Thanks Brian, for everything.
jonathan sorenson
said
Introduced GST...politically devastating ... in reality it replaced the Manufacturers Sales Tax which was strangling Canadian industry.
Pushed through NAFTA ... again not easily ... but the best thing that ever happened to Canada.
He was in a hard spot having to clean up the economic mess left by Trudeau and he will always have to deal with people who don't understand good economic policy. But in the end he was one of the most influential PM's ever.
DERON
said
kevin
said
Elinor
said
As PM Mulroney's last loyalty was to Canada as a country. His first, to himself and self aggrandizement, his second to the Americans who he seemed to think could help with latter.
Tamouh
said
... I bet if Mr. Trudeau was alive with us today, he'd have enough clever words to shut Mr. Mulroney out.
Rod A
said
Nuff said.
Gary
said
Bill Williams
said
Cochese - Trudeau Voted Worst Canadian
said
Sara - War Measures Act in Canada
said
Padro Mansbridge
said
Devin Maxwell
said
Michael
said
GB
said
Al
said
Gregory Boudreau
said
I think you can blame the failure of Meech on two people: Elijah Harper, and Clyde Wells, period.
I do agree that Mr.Trudeau made mistakes, but name me one Prime Minister who didn't.
Daniel B.
said
Mike Reeder
said
New Brunswick is also a very distinct society... and looking around at all the people who head out west, it will some day be an extinct one as well.
Tom Oldhorse
said
Paul malouf
said
Allan
said
Susan
said
Marie
said
Cecil
said
André
said
adam saunders
said
Po
said
Jack Dreaddy
said
trubull
said
Steve
said
Norm Shanahan
said
Craig
said
Mike N
said
John Scott
said
Lorne
said
Raymond
said
Dave
said
I guess I just saved forty bucks.
Yes Trudeau helped kill Meech Lake- And how is that a bad thing???
Trudeau may have been a nationalist, spoiled, rich, Mount Royal shit disturber but he regected nationalism when he grew up- especially the kind of nationalism that led to systematic destruction of some 10 million people.
patricia
said
Vince M.
said
This is a hero to some Canadians?
Marc D.
said
Blaise MacLean
said
Russ
said
Nicole
said
Forte
said
Ross Douglas
said
Allen K
said
Martin Warren
said
Michael
said
IAN
said
damien
said
Eric
said
Stephen Hall
said
I really resent the implication that Pierre Trudeau, Elijah Harper and or Clyde Wells scuttled Meech/ Charlottetown Accord. Ordinary Canadians like myself scuttled the deal, remember the vote we had where acceptance of the initiatives didn't even come close?
I like a lot of others took the time to read the documents (put out by the Mulroney Government), listen to the arguments and then make a decision. Bottom line is that Mulroney didn't convince myself and many others that this was good for Canada.
From a personal perspective I found that the accords attempted to unite the country based by giving everybody what they wanted in an effort it to be the one cited by history as having obtained unity. Unity based on division is not unity!
Unfortunately, Mulroney, Chretien and others seem to have been more focused on shaping their legacy than acting in the best interests of Canada. To me this is the ultimate act of arrogance. Your legacy should be decided based how you governed, as opposed to how you govern being structured to create your legacy.
Bottom line Brian is that as per the results of the referendum/plebiscite we had you didn't manage to sell the Canadian people the benefits of the agreements for Canada. To ignore this fact and imply that you were a visionary scuttled by Trudeau has to be the height of arrogance........or perhaps you just consider all the rest of the Canadian population to be lesser beings who cannot make informed decisions!
Tom Hawley
said
Mulroney is only trying to rehash old wounds. Look what Trudeau did to you people in Quebec. He was not involved with politics for close to twenty years because people disliked him. Of course we belive he made errors as we beleive he has done great things. As for the Beaver Magazine naming P.E.T. as worst canadian, where is this magazine published? ...
Charles B
said
He also implies that he has moral authority where Trudeau did not? We should not take any lessons from Mulroney on morality unless we consider criticizing dead people for self serving purposes to be a noble act.
jmp
said
We all know that every gov't points a finger at the previous gov't and every gov't takes credit for things that the previous gov't did.... it's called POLITICS!
Mulroney is a jackass, Trudeau was arrogant big deal... both of them had their time in office and now both are out of office... END OF STORY!!!
So, let Mulroney cry in his soup and let Trudeau rest in peace.... and when it's Mulroney's time to rest in peace I hope we let him do just that.
It's time to turn our energies to what our current gov't is doing to help the planet... NOTHING!!!!!
It's time for all Canadians to step up to bat and start demanding our gov't start seriously doing something NOW... not in 10 years!
Don
said
I'll be watchin' the Mulroney interview just to see him do the "Conservative shuffle" around the facts. Should be good for a few laughs!