CTV News | Mattel recalls 18.2 million Chinese-made toys

Top Stories -   

Mattel recalls 18.2 million Chinese-made toys

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Scott Laurie reports on the tainted toys
CTV Newsnet: Bryan Stockton, VP of International Mattel Inc.
CTV Newsnet: Beijing Bureau Chief Steve Chao
CTV Newsnet: Nancy Nord, acting chair, U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission
Canada AM: Leigh Poirier, Toy Testing Council
Canada AM: Bob Whitelaw, public policy consultant

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(43)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Tue. Aug. 14 2007 11:31 PM ET

Mattel Inc. has announced further recalls affecting millions more Chinese-made toys due to lead paint and the presence of small, powerful magnets that could be ingested by children.

In total, about 18.2 million toys are affected worldwide -- with more than 900,000 of them in Canada, and about 9.5 million in the U.S.

U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission acting chair Nancy Nord listed the recalled products during a news conference on Tuesday in Washington.

The following toys are affected:

  • Play sets with small magnets, including Polly Pocket dolls, Batman Magna, Doggie Daycare and Shonen Jump's OnePiece Triple Slash Zolo Roronoa actions figures. Approximately 890,000 of those are in Canada;
  • 436,000 Pixar Sarge die-cast toy cars made in China. Of those, 32,800 were reportedly sold in Canada between May and August;
  • 683,000 Barbie and Tanner play sets (There is no indication they were sold in Canada).

A full list of product numbers can be found on the Mattel website here.

Health Canada is monitoring the recall but has not received any reports of associated injury or illness.

Nord stressed no injuries have been reported, and the recall is intentionally broad in order to minimize the risk of any injuries occurring. However, she said the magnets and lead paint both present health risks for children.

"This agency has been warning about the dangers of small magnets for more than a year," she said during a news conference Tuesday.

There have been reports of the magnets falling off of the toys. Since Mattel recalled Polly Pocket play sets on Nov. 11 of last year, three children suffered intestinal perforations and required surgery after swallowing more than one magnet.

"If more than one magnet is swallowed they can attract inside the body, causing intestinal perforations, infections and blockages," Nord said on Tuesday.

"With respect to the lead issue, more than 250,000 Sarge die-cast toys are being recalled because the surface paint contains lead."

The toy is a promotional product from the Pixar movie "Cars" and looks like a small military jeep.

According to Health Canada, children who ingest lead can suffer from adverse health effects, including headaches, vomiting, irritability, weakness, weight loss, a poor attention span and slowed speech.

Lead paint has been banned in the U.S. since 1978.

Mattel has stopped selling the affected products and instructed that the toys be pulled from shelves. The company has also made a production change to address the problem, and is replacing the recalled products, Nord said.

Mattel said the Chinese painting subcontractor violated Mattel's standards and used paint from a non-authorized third-party supplier.

In response, Mattel is implementing what they call a "three-point check system,'' which involves testing every batch of paint at every vendor, ramping up unscheduled inspections and testing every production run of finished toys.

Toys made in China comprise about 70 to 80 per cent of toys sold in the world.

Earlier recall

The new recall comes less than two weeks after Mattel recalled about 1 million Chinese-made toys in Canada and the U.S. because of high lead content in paint.

On August 1, Mattel's Fisher-Price division recalled toys featuring characters such as Dora the Explorer, Big Bird and Elmo.

Days after the Fisher-Price recall, Chinese officials temporarily banned the toys' manufacturer, Lee Der Industrial Co., from exporting products. A media report Monday said Lee Der co-owner, Cheung Shu-hung, committed suicide at a warehouse over the weekend.

Health and safety standards in the country have come under scrutiny recently as the one-year countdown to the 2008 Olympics begins.

Tainted toothpaste, pet food, seafood exports and bad tires have all been taken off the shelves in recent months.

Mattel chairman and chief executive officer Robert Eckert apologized for the recent issues.

"Mattel has rigorous procedures, and we will continue to be vigilant and unforgiving in enforcing quality and safety," Eckert said in a statement.

"We don't want to have recalls, but we don't hesitate to take quick and effective action to correct issues as soon as we've identified them to ensure the safety of our products and the safety of children."

Gov't concerned: Harper

During an Ottawa news conference about his cabinet shuffle, Prime Minister Stephen Harper was asked about the toy recall and whether it was time for a "buy Canadian" policy.

"We always have to be careful in terms of anything like a 'buy Canadian' policy with respects to our international obligations, and there are restrictions in that regard," He said.

"With respects to the growing concerns with the quality of imported products from some parts of the world ... I can tell you the government is concerned about this. We are examining this carefully," he said.

Harper noted that this is a big issue in other countries, most notably the United States.

The issue will be raised during the upcoming NAFTA summit in Montebello, Que. next week, he said.

Please Add Comments( )

Vanessa C
said
0 0

I think it is now time to STOP importing from China, period. How many problems with products from there now? It is obvious they have no controls, and only care for one thing - our dollars.


Scott Lundy
said
0 0

Why didn't the company's quality assurance team catch these serious problems earlier? Where were U.S. and Canadian (CSA) consumer safety officials? It is troubling to think that our enthusiasm for free markets, driven by our desire for ever-lower consumer prices, has led (or should I say "lead") to this!


Lynda
said
0 0

I agree with Vanessa. Realizing the complexity of the trade market, the government needs to get tough. Think about it, toys, tires, pet food, toothpaste, chili, chocolate bars, etc. Is there a conspiracy here? China needs a wake up call from us. When BSE hit, other countries slammed the borders shut to our canadian beef. For our own protection, imports from China must stop until they clean up their act. We will survive.


Island girl
said
0 0

It seems rather suspicious that suddenly we're having all these dangerous things originating in China. I believe we've been encountering them for years, but the Americans notice their own economy slipping and the Chinese economy booming and choose now to blow the whistle to protect their own manufacturing interests. I'm not condoning the Chinese business practices, but I feel there is more to the story.


MagnuS
said
0 0

Not only would we survive without China imports, our own Canadian-based businesses would thrive once more and help out our own economy....sure we pay more but get higher quality items that won't kill you!


Jason S.
said
0 0

Stopping all imports from China would be irrational, when the BSE crisis started Canadian farmers were hit hard, and as we have learned, BSE isn't a country wide problem, just a select few were found. Canadian companies need to step up and screen products coming from other countries better, like Scott Lundy said, consumer safety officials need to check these toys better.


Roger T
said
0 0

It really doesn't matter where it comes from defects are defects. You can't just blame and point fingers at the Chinese since Mattle should have implemented their own safety checks on the production line. ALL major companies will avoid at any cost if it's not detected during the production stage. If it's anyone to blame, go after the companies that didn't provide safety checks.


Monty
said
0 0

I think the conspiracy could go either way, if anything the media has jumped onto these opportunities way too fast and have not reported all facts. Lead is definitely bad, but the amounts reported would likely not cause any harm simply due to the nature of how health standards are regulated with a safety factor. The recall for lead was definitely smart for protecting consumers, but come'on, magnets don't just show up in toys unless it was designed to be manufactured, so we can't just blame China for all our problems here. Keep in mind, lead paint was used in the US in the past, for its reddish colouring, and is still used in some industries across America....

CarolynP
said
0 0

Mattel should actually be applauded as this was a voluntary recall on their part and they made the responsible decision to notify the public about this "potential" issue. More companies need to step up and challenge their suppliers to ensure that we are providing safe products for our children.


Rose
said
0 0

First and foremost this is not a new thing. Coming from the Philippines we have encountered fake products coming in from China all the time. The recent one was the fake luncheon meat that consist of Cat and rat meat instead of pork. I think it's about time that veryone should buy due to quality not because it's cheap. Cheap means cheap labour, shody practices and fake materials. I stopped going to Dollar stores because 95% of the products they sell are made in China.


NT
said
0 0

Let's face it, the government won't stop trade with China. There are too many interests involved.
It is up to us, consumers, to protect ourselves and be vigilant when it comes to buying things. I am not sure many people will resist the cheaply priced gadgets or clothes at Walmart, Zellers or even the Dollar Store. Even clothes from China are soaked in pesticides and chemicals banned in other countries.
By the way, those cuddly, stuffed toys from China that we buy for our kids could very well be made with cat or dog fur.


Shayne
said
0 0

I would like to know what will happen to all these toys. I would not be too surprised to hear that they end up in a developing country somewhere that doesn't have the same standards and Fisher Price still profits. There was an article written not too long ago that tracked some fish that was originally denied entry to Canada back a second time...try try again. I don't think we have enough staff to track every container that enters this country at our current level of imports.


Gregg Kiley
said
0 0

This issue has nothing to-do with economies. It is a question about OUR heath and safety, and the health and safety of OUR children. Leave the conspiracy theories to who killed JFK and focus on the issues at hand. SAFETY of our children. It is sickening to see the lack or regard towards the safety of our children and our safety standards.


Marcus
said
0 0

What ever happened to the good old days when we, Canadians, proudly made our own things???


Patrick
said
0 0

Seeing that our government nor the corporations that do business in Canada have the courage to stand up to China, I think it's time for us, the consumer, to stop buying anything made in China. I look at it as protecting the lives of those we love. Let's buy local. I think a few extra dollars more for anything is better than worrying over whether this product will harm us.


Dan
said
0 0

I agree with Island girl
I think we have been dealing with poor quality and Sub standards for years. I remember about 3 or 4 years ago we were at a fast food restaurant and my childs meal came with a toy "from China" it was a package of foam bathtub cutout pieces.
What got my attention was the awfull chemical smell that came off these pieces. It smelt like moth balls but 3 times stronger. It gave me an instant headache, I gave the toys back to the restaurant and told the manager that no child should get these toys because they were so bad. So lead in paint doesn't surprise me.


tawny tracy
said
0 0

Really, get some quality control, or stop importing stuff from them! All things major in our lives are getting tampered with.

david
said
0 0

Blame the Chinese if you want but every company has Quality Control that approves the production before an item is mass produced. Time to ask Mattel a few hard questions as well.


RB320
said
0 0

Island Girl is exactly right. The U.S. Government and corporations have known about these problems for years. However, the Chinese now own 1.3 TRILLION Dollars of U.S. debt and are now threatening to sink the dollar. This is much bigger than lead paint. We are headed for very stormy seas in the near future.


Anne
said
0 0

Unfortunately business in China is less than ethical. Typically, the end justifies the means. So we discover that cheap labour comes with a cost, one that may affect our children; a cost that should be totally unacceptable to us in North America.


Joe Green
said
0 0

As a consumer, I would prefer to pay more to know that toys for kids are made in either Canada or the US and know it is done right and safe.

I agree that we should, for our own security, safty and economic viability start limiting what we import from China. It is obvious they have no safty standards. I wish someone would create a NAFTA store. All things sold are exclusively made in either Canada, the US or Mexico, so then we would have an option as consumers to shop at a store we know does not import from China and would bolster the North American economy.



K Zizek
said
0 0

When are we going to stop the production of toys or all consumer goods by China? How much longer are we going to allow China to poison us? Should we not be more concerned about the poisoning of our children? I say boycot all goods manufactured overseas. Let's get back to MADE IN CANADA!!!!!


David Storms
said
0 0

We have question accountability. Who's accountable? Originally, it was the guy who ordered the lead paint & he is dead. He hanged him self in his own facility. Who is accountable now? Mattel!!! They are now at the root. They did not perform the proper audits in order to be compliant with CSA and U.S standards and are now going to eat the cost of all this. Sure, the actual crime was committed overseas, but it was overlooked here in North America, by us. Our own neglect lead to us complaining about the quality of product appearing on our shelves. For the 2.8 billion units of goods manufactured and exported daily from China, this is merely a drop in the bucket. China will always remain the manufacturing giant. It can't be stopped.


L Bennett
said
0 0

While on some level I agree with almost everything said here, I work in transport at a loading dock. The overwhelming majority of freight I handle on any given shift is from South East Asia and the majority of that is from China. If we were to stop all trade with China we would see an almost immediate end to affordable goods. Save for a few things. Take this into consideration, if lead and other toxins are being found in all these toys, foods, soaps and toothpaste, and so on and so on, then what kind of environmental nightmare are we supporting by trading with this country. Besides, the items we're talking about that we have made cheaply in Asia and shipped here travel on container ships, those ships are HUGE and they run on Bunker C, not fresh air and good vibrations. Everyone of these cheap items are shipped halfway around the world and at what environmental cost?
And while we blame a guy in a board room on Bay Street or Wall Street, the reality is they aren't the ones poisoning these products. It's a Chinese factory supervisor or worker or factory manager who bears the blame. But we can't do a thing, because that person will never stand trial in a US or Canadian court.
Ultimately we can't stop trading with China, at least not on any official level. But we can buy local whenever possible. We can boycott Chinese goods at a grassroots level, if it says Made in China, Product of China or Country of Origin: China. Don't buy it. It's already burned who knows how much oil to get here, is probably the product of child labour, and who makes money from it, a few Chinese business people and an old rich white guy. Buy Canadian or American and give someone a job, save some oil, and don't poison your family.


John Mrnik
said
0 0

Everything I have purchased in the last couple of years is made in China...Clothes, shoes, gloves,etc. Is it safe???? How would I know...


Chris
said
0 0

I like how everyone instantly thinks that products from China come from child labour or some sweat shop. How many of you have toured around Chinese factories personally? I toured around Chinese factories all year last year to do a report/study for businesses here in Canada. From my findings, there are a few factories that definitely need to improve on facilities and working conditions. HOWEVER, the majority of factories I visited (unscheduled visits by the way) are up to our standards and in some cases, in much better condition than some of our manufacturing facilities here in Canada. People say cheap labour...well, in China, the average worker can live comfortably on $1.00USD per hour and even send half of that home to their families in rural China. Workers there do not own 2 or 3 cars like we do, they don't have a 2 storey home way out in the suburbs, they don't consume the amount of goods that we consume here in North America. Furthermore, ALL the factories pay for housing and food to their workers...when was the last time workers in Canada got housing and food paid for?

Please don't get me wrong, I definitely think there are a few bad apples in China and that they are ruining it for the entire country - same in Canada, a few bad apples that seem to ruin the image of our country. China has made tremendous progress - it took us more than 100 years to become a developed country...China is doing it in a matter of 50 years. China is also doing a lot more to improve environmental conditions than we are. Did you know the Chinese government has already completed all the architectural and planning work needed to build 9 eco cities? In Canada we are still trying to establish committees to look at our environmental conditions. In China, they have gone beyond the talk and are actually doing the necessary work to improve their image and environmental standards.

I encourage everyone to visit China personally and then make your judgments - they definitely have much more to improve on, and are looking for our help and guidance on many fronts. In terms of the lead in the paint, as most people have said in the comments, Mattel should have QC people to check everything before it goes out. Mattel's QC people should have detected the lead and should have stopped the shipment before it left China. At least they are recalling the goods and not keeping them in the hands of children.


Joyce Conley
said
0 0

Just seems we do not have control of the Chinese working habits and safety standards, so we need to have stricter controls here with Chinese exports.
We also need to have the corporations who import these to have stricter controls.
First and foremost it is the Chinese Government which has to adhere to international standards and if not, we should ban these imports for the safety of our own citizens.



LR
said
0 0

First Thomas the Train, then Dora and Sesame Street, and now Sarge from the Cars Movie....what toys do I have to take away from my kids next? I don't think it's an issue of where the toys are made, but an issue of safety, quality control, and continuous evaluation of the toys BEFORE they hit the store shelves. Lets get these companies making sure the toys are safe before they are in our stores and homes rather than waiting for these huge recalls after the fact.


SK
said
0 0

I wish the problem was as simple as not importing from China. Unfortunatly, it is us, the consumer, who drives the economic need for Chinese imports. If consumers didn't demand "Always low prices" and "rollbacks" we might be better equipped to combat these issues. Also, it is important to note that while in a perfect world we may be able to manufacture in Canada where do you think the raw materials for these products would come from?


Gis Bun
said
0 0

Canadian corporations are also at fault here for not doing some type of testing of any imported product - not just Chinese.

Canadians are just looking for the cheapest product even though not only are some products harmful but what kind of salary of the workers in those foreign countries are getting?

It's been reported that companies in China get their raw materials from all over. so they have a hard time figuring out where a bad batch came from.


Robin Fidler
said
0 0

I think it's time the Canadian Government stops importing from China we as Canadians have had enough of the dangerous recalls. What's it gone to take some one dying before our government does something or is it going to be more cover-ups.


Bruce M
said
0 0

In this day and age, the use of lead based paints for any product, let alone children's toys that will be surely sucked on, cannot be construed as careless or negligent, but rather as a deliberate decision to save money.

As the recent father of a 1+ year old, I can confirm that it is almost impossible to buy children's toys that are not made in China.

We now have everything from peanuts, gluten, MSG, etc. noted on the side of products, not to mention "caution, coffee may be hot", so I guess we need to now take the ridiculous action of adding a note to products - "this children's toy is free from Lead, PCB's, and other harmful chemicals that can harm your child."

This has to be deliberate, not careless.


Patric Payette
said
0 0

Looks good on Mattel!!! This is a prime example of getting what you paid for. Keep sending our jobs to China for junk product.


David Broughall
said
0 0

Why does everyone continue to insist on calling companies like Mattel a "manufacturer". They are a brand. The don't manufacure anything. They farm out the making of their products to third parties in the third world and a fraction of the labour costs in North America. None of those savings are passed on to the consumer. It's pure profit for the company.

As for the multiple recalls of defective and poisonous products, it's just like the fines for environmental polluters: it's the cost of doing business.


Deron
said
0 0

This is getting scary. Literally one half of everything manufactured on this planet is now produced in a country with virtually no control over hazardous materials being placed into products. Just don't blame the Chinese. Our western corporations want maximum profit, and we ourselves want cheap products. All of us are just paying the price of our own greed, is all.


Caper Girl
said
0 0

I agree with a lot of the things said here, but mostly I agree that it is the health and safety of our children that is and SHOULD be of top concern. We sit and worry how it would change the economy if we were to stop importing from China but something tells me it wouldn’t be such a bit issue if we were sat in a hospital room with a our kid. I think they (matel or whoever for that matter) need to take better responsibility and have better quality control.

That said? If and when they DO find products that have been skimped on to save money or whatever the reason at the price of OUR children? It should be a given that we NEVER purchase from that company again, whether it be China or anywhere else. You cant punish all for the carelessness of some but you CAN see to it that those responsible for such neglect and disregard for the well being of others are stopped from EVER doing it again.

Small price to pay for our children and loved ones I think.



Sylvia P.
said
0 0

I'm sorry but I refuse to buy products from China and haven't for a long time. This is a country with no regard for human life (theirs or ours) and is only concerned with profit.

I personally know of a company who outsourced production of their Christmas products to China and found that the prototype the Chinese showed them complied with all the safety standards. However, when time came to mass produce the product, lead was found in all of it because it was cheaper and hence they made more money. The lead was discovered when the company did its own safety check and promtly shut down production. They lost a lot of money in the process.

Ever try to buy a can of sliced mushrooms from no frills? Every name brand and no name brand is made in China. I wonder what else is floating in the water used to package the mushrooms. No thank you!!




Vanessa M
said
0 0

Who is to blame!!?? How can you even ask that question? Corporate greed in North America and lack of business ethics in China!! Why are we waiting for the manufacturers to recall something? We should be looking for faulty products and launching class action lawsuits that will make these companies look closer at what they are putting on our shelves.

We don't depend on cheap Chinese products. There are plenty of other countries that can produce at competitive cost and won't poison our children and our pets!



norman
said
0 0

You have to remember that everything that is bought in China is bought to the buying company's spec's. These multinational co's want to buy where ever they can get the cheapest price so they can give us the best price and still realize good margins of profit. it is up to the co's in question to ensure quality control on the products that they are ordering is up to there spec's. Chinese are only manufacturers and ultimately the onus falls on the buyer(company) to ensure that the product meets their spec's and is safe to distribute to their customers. Blame the company that orders these goods, not the producer who is under contract to produce.


Rev. Stanley T. Broadus Sr.
said
0 0

I'm concerned not just because of the toys coming china. But how much has this % of led in them ?. Do we need to get rid of everything made by China in toys?.


CCLF
said
0 0

China and Mattel aside, ask yourself....."Why do I feel the constant need to buy buy buy, shop shop shop.......??? excessive consumerism - Millenium Glutony!
In the end??? ask yourself, do i really NEED what i purchase? In the end??? Is the one who hands out the dollar, the guilty one.


concerned parent
said
0 0

The question that I have is how do we know if the smaller companies that bring in goods from China are checking for potentially dangerous toys/goods as well. What about the dollar stores where virtually everything is made in China. Who do they have checking their products?
I agree with Lynda, imports from China need to be stopped. Support Canada and Canadian products


DMcLean
said
0 0

I don't agree with importing these hazardous toys for our children from a country that has no standards. However, people still light up around their children when at home and in their cars. And don't forget we burn coal for power here in Nova Scotia. Should we clean up those toxins as well.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

Related Websites

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz