CTV News | Canadians deported from China get heroes' welcome

Top Stories -   

Canadians deported from China get heroes' welcome

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV British Columbia: Mike Killeen on the reunions
Canada AM: TC Tethong, Canadian protester's father
CTV British Columbia: Dave Lefebvre with the families
CTV British Columbia: Mike Killeen on Olympic politics

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(24)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Thu. Aug. 9 2007 9:36 PM ET

Two Canadians who were detained by Chinese authorities for protesting China's rule over Tibet say Chinese police intimidated and denied them the right to speak to Canadian embassy officials.

Sam Price and Melanie Raoul -- members of Students for a Free Tibet -- arrived in Vancouver on Thursday and were met by family and members of the Tibetan-Canadian community, who cheered and greeted the pair with songs.

In Toronto, a similar welcome awaited Students for a Free Tibet executive director Lhadon Tethong.

Price and Raoul were held by Chinese authorities after scaling the Great Wall of China and unfurling a banner demanding Tibet's independence.

Raoul said she had no regrets and would do something similar again. But Price said this was the second time he had been detained in China for protesting against the country's rule over Tibet, and he won't be going back again.

Price unfurled a flag of Tibet when he arrived at Vancouver International Airport hours after Raoul.

Supporters from the Tibetan community held a banner reading ''One World, One Dream, Free Tibet'' -- the same slogan painted on the banner Raoul, Price and four others had draped over the Great Wall on Tuesday. The official slogan for the games is "One World, One Dream."

Raoul hugged Price, handing him flowers and wrapping a Tibetan ceremonial scarf around his neck. She said earlier that she and her fellow protesters were split up for 36 hours while they were interrogated by Chinese authorities.

"We were detained, we were interrogated and we were subjected to psychological deception," said Price. "They told us we had no right to speak to our embassy.''

But not everyone at the airport gave the protesters a hero's welcome. Upon seeing Raoul, a man yelled: "You got your 20 seconds of glory now? Boo!" When confronted by Raoul's father, Yvon, the man continued: "You're mingling in China's affairs in Tibet. We got separatism about to happen here in Canada, with Quebec."

"They should be protesting in ----ing Canada," the man, who declined to give his name, told CTV British Columbia. "I've lived in China, it's my second country. I'm ashamed of these guys. . . . You don't have to go overseas and start protesting."

But Raoul maintained it's necessary to break laws sometimes to bring attention to "bigger laws that are being broken."

"And what's happening in Tibet with human rights abuses there, is the most atrocious law you can break," she told CTV.

Their ordeal

Raoul said she slept for only 15 minutes at a time and was worried about what would happen, but that her non-violent action has resulted in changes all over the world, including India and the United States.

She said she and her colleagues were repeatedly told they would spend a long time in China, where they would be punished and not allowed to speak to Canadian embassy officials.

She said Chinese authorities demanded they sign a document with a big red stamp on it. But because the document was all in Chinese, the protesters declined.

They were then told they would be deported and within hours, they were on a plane to Hong Kong.

Lhadon greeted in Toronto

In Toronto, nearly a dozen Tibetan Canadians cheered as Tethong was reunited with her father and brother.

Lhadon, a Victoria, B.C. resident and the executive director of the group, was taken into custody on Wednesday. She had been blogging and posting videos of their demonstration.

She had been in Beijing for the past week, attempting to bring attention to what the group says are China's broken promises to improve human rights leading up to the Games.

Tethong said she drew strength from the plight of Chinese and Tibetan citizens during her detention.

"Whenever I felt afraid or nervous or threatened, I thought about what I was doing compared to what Tibetan and Chinese dissidents are trying to do with no protection," she said, adding: "At least I have a Canadian passport."

Tethong said the protesters exposed the "insecurity" of the Chinese government through the use of modern technology such as laptops and video cameras.

"I think that in itself, that they were so scared of us unarmed protesters, shows their weakness and their insecurity."

Her father, T.C. Tethong, said earlier that he was concerned for the safety of his daughter because of their family's Tibetan name.

"A Tibetan name really triggers a lot of difficulties for Chinese authorities, and she did mention that they did allude to that when they were questioning her," he said.

Being a Canadian citizen helped Lhadon's cause, her father said.

Tethong worked with the Dalai Lama for 15 years and has been active in the Free Tibet movement.

When asked if Canada should boycott the 2008 Olympic Games in Beijing, he said a part of him would like to see that.

"But then on the other hand ... the Chinese people I think really are not the real cause of this problem -- it's the government, it's the system."

Tethong said the International Olympic Committee awarded the games to China thinking it would improve the human rights conditions, but he says the situation has worsened.

"There are more violations of the rights of the Chinese right in Beijing -- their houses being demolished and journalists being barred from reporting all this," he said.

"In Tibet it's far worse because Tibet, being under China, especially the minority group, there are special restrictions which many journalists and reporters don't see."

With reports from The Canadian Press and CTV British Columbia

Please Add Comments( )

Charlie
said
0 0

"Protest. The Movie" coming to theatres near you. Order of Canada for all involved can be expected as our media turns these professional protesters into our newest heroes.


Kathleen
said
0 0

I must say that I am very curious about how foreigners look at China cause I am a Chinese. Having no intention to offend you, I just want to let you know that it really takes time to know about China of today and of the past. You might change your mind, have a better understanding of the situation there and will probably love it then.


Phil
said
0 0

According to this story, Beijing citizens' houses are being demolished to make room for the 2008 Olympics. However, the fact is, citizens are being asked by the government to relocate and in return, are given compensations. As a Canadian, I expect CTV news to report the full story and not have any biases.


Escroft
said
0 0

Human rights or not, person can't just waltz into another country and begin demanding them to do things. No stranger has right to walk into another man's home and starts telling him what to do. At least that's my perspective of things. Sure, China has problems, and there is no such thing as a Perfect World, but do keep in mind that unlike Canada or the United States, which governs 30,000,000 and 270,000,000 people, China has 1,600,000,000 people. Think of Canada multiplied by 53, and the United States by 6 times. That's a lot of people to look after. And China is not a full Democratic Country, like ours is, so there is no MIDDLE GROUND. I don't agree with what China is doing to their people, but I also don't agree with people from other countries who don't know the FULL STORY (from BOTH sides) walking into the country and start demanding. I think that's a little out of line. That's my two cents.


Mike Sevenoak
said
0 0

They were very lucky to be protected by the Chinese police immediately after the incident and they were not in the hands of Chinese young students. If you read the web blogs on Chinese websites and you can feel the anger among ordinary Chinese towards them. Many Chinese students even threatened to beat them up without notifying Chinese police if they saw them on the scene because they thought Chinese police were too lenient in this case.


Susan
said
0 0

Houses demolished are reasonably replaced by new, better ones. To be exact, just a relocation based on discussions and negotiations, mutually agreed except some residents who wants extremely more than should. In fact, most people are hoping and waiting for this kind of relocation so that they may have upgraded houses to live.


Yellow Skin
said
0 0

Please advice Canadians do not intervene Chinese politics. What would it be if Chinese support Quebec to be independent? We should respect each other’s country. I am 100% pure Chinese by the way.



Frances
said
0 0

"In Tibet it's far worse because Tibet, being under China, especially the minority group, there are special restrictions which many journalists and reporters don't see." All I know is the minority groups, not just the Tibetans, in China enjoy far more privileges than the Han Chinese. They have better access to universities and they can have more than one child.


Freedomfortibet
said
0 0

Kathleen,

Great that you care about China's image.

I hope you will educate yourself about Tibet and push your Chinese government to change their misguided policies in Tibet.

BTW: I spent my whole life to know about China's policies and conduct in Tibet, what about you?

Best wishes,

A tibetan friend


Tenzin
said
0 0

Hey Kathleen, For your information I would love to see you wearing a T-shirt in Beijing with Dalai Lama written on it and then you will know what really is the situation in China.


Visanza
said
0 0

With all due respect. Relocation with compensation is different from relocation with no choice. What choice do they have? Can they really say no?


Stephan P.
said
0 0

These individuals should be honoured and given recognition as champions of the human rights movement. They put themselves in harm's way in order to attempt to get their message out there. Sadly, I haven't seen mass reporting on it by anyone except Canadian news agencies... It's pathetic when you have to carry a gun in order to be acknowledged as making a difference as far as human rights are concerned.


SM
said
0 0

How well would Canadians receive a group of Chinese students going to midtown of Calgary to protest on behalf of Quebec independence and whip up a huge fluer de Lis? (I would frankly fear for my safety). Or over the complete wipe-out of the native tribe called Ottawa? Or the slurring and booing of native hockey players in a white stadium?


Mark
said
0 0

Don't condemn the Chinese government for taking the Canadian into custody. Think what happen if a Canadian protesting in front of White House over the Guantanamo Bay facilities, would the CIA do the same thing? How about the Arar case, an innocent Canadian was sent to Syria to be tortured.

When you either voice your own opinion or hear others, remind yourself not to take a bias view point or have double standard.

People taken these actions did calculate the risk involved. I would neither call them foolish nor heroic. They do that for a cause. Whether it is right or wrong up to each individual to verify.


Jeff
said
0 0

Every country has its laws and regulations. As most of the Canadians are lawful citizens, I believe we should behave the same when we are in another country. The type of protest Tethong, Price and Raoul did was not legal and extremely disrespectful in China, their custody was an obvious result for their actions. Imagine if there was a group of Chinese protesters went up to CN tower and put a banner that read “Free Quebec”, “Free B.C.” or “Free Saskatchewan”, how would we feel? And would our police just let them do that without giving any types of actions?
Also, how come our media are implicitly broadcasting these people as heroes, when they are really trying to reach their goal in an unlawful way?




Sa
said
0 0

As much as I feel for the people of Tibet, I can't help but wonder.. where are the protests for every other nation that has been annexed in the past?

Including right here in our own backyard?

l.z
said
0 0

Has anyone heard any quality reporting by the media on "Students for a Free Tibet", and those who put on the stunt? Has anyone from the media taken their journalist responsibility duly enough to look at the issue from perspectives of others that may have been affected?

For anyone who has ever paid enough attention to the history of China, the half-truth or pick-and-chose reporting by the mass media is just sadly everywhere.



S
said
0 0

Phil, I too have heard that citizens were given compensation to relocate. However, I also seen journalism reports that some people did not want to move and were being intimidated into it. One thing I would like to know is if the compensation was fair, and what was being done to preseve the historical nature of those neighbourhoods.


simmon
said
0 0

Nobody has the right to say anything about human right issue if they have never lived in China in the past 3 decades. I was born in China and grew up there, and have been living in Canada for the past 17 years. If those protesters had done the same silly thing in 70s or 80s even 90s in China, they would have ended up in jail for sure. Who said that China's human right was not improving. Those guys got out of China free, itself says China is on its right path, human rights are improving there. Please give China more time.


Allan
said
0 0

Leave it to the media to glorify a few idiots looking for their 15 minutes of fame.



Ted Hewlett
said
0 0

The matter of Tibet is only the tip of the iceberg as far as Chinese violation of justice and human rights are concerned. There is the matter of the mistreatment of Falun Gong adherents, and (seldom mentioned by the mainstream press) the mistreatment of Christians in China.
If a country classified as "right-wing" was to have the human rights record of Communist China there would a much louder outcry.


john
said
0 0

Having been to China 14 times since 1983, I can say that there have been a lot of positive changes for the Chinese people as a whole. You cannot expect Western style standards and freedoms that we enjoy here in Canada to be implemented overnight. Things will change but in Chinese time. The Chinese were an advanced civilization 2000 years before the Golden Age of Greece.


Gord
said
0 0

They're lucky they just got deported. You don't go to a foreign country (and a communist one to boot) for the soul purpose of being a s**t disturber.
If we want foreigners to obey our laws when they visit our country we should give other countries the same consideration - even if we disagree with some of their policies.


Peter
said
0 0

US Eminent Domain also does the same thing. Nothing new. Both in the US and in PRC are getting paid. In PRC, they also get free relocation to newly build apartment buildings.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz