CTV News | Some Burnaby residents may lose homes to spill

Top Stories -   

Some Burnaby residents may lose homes to spill

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV British Columbia: Reporters cover the dangers
CTV News: Sarah Galashan on the long-term impact
CTV Newsnet: Bill Wareham, David Suzuki Foundation
CTV Newsnet: Margot McMillan, West Coast Environmental Law
CTV Newsnet: St. John Alexander in Burnaby, B.C.
Canada AM: St. John Alexander in Burnaby, B.C.

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(13)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Wed. Jul. 25 2007 10:20 PM ET

Some residents of an oil-splattered Burnaby, B.C. neighbourhood face the loss of their homes after an excavator ruptured a major crude oil pipeline.

Mayor Derek Corrigan said Wednesday if oil from the ruptured pipeline seeped into the siding and foundations of 11 damaged homes in the Vancouver suburb, "those houses may not be salvageable.

"Those were the houses where we urged very strongly for the residents to move out for the night and possibly for longer, while others were allowed to return voluntarily," he said.

About 90 people stayed elsewhere Tuesday night, in part to avoid the intolerable stench of the oil.

Mario and Sabrina Siniscalchi were to move into their brand-new dream home on Wednesday. "As you can see, it's been completely splattered with oil, from the bottom right up to the roof," Mario told CTV British Columbia.

"It's not beautiful now," said Sabrina of the home. "My main concern is the soil and all the effects it might have on my children. I have four boys."

Everything in Sheila MacFayden's front yard was covered with a mist of oil droplets. "It's so sticky. It's all on the bottom of your shoes," she said.

MacFayden wondered if it was safe to let her puppy or kids outside.

"Somebody needs to step up to the plate and take care of the homeowners here," Mario said.

Crews spent the day shoveling and soaking up oil using sand and peatmoss to lift the stain of the black crude. Asphalt on the Barnet Highway is simply being torn up rather than cleaned to remove the tar-like oil.

Kinder Morgan Canada, which owns the pipeline, estimates 234,000 litres of oil (about 1,400 barrels) escaped as the ruptured line spewed for 30 minutes.

New Democrat MP Bill Siksay, who represents Burnaby Douglas riding, said the accident raises questions about how well protected residents who live near industrial infrastructure, such as pipelines, are.

"Burnaby Douglas is criss-crossed by pipelines, so we want to make sure that people are safe where they live,'' he said.

Baird pleased with 'quick' action

Federal Environment Minister John Baird, whose department is responsible for any marine cleanup, surveyed the Burrard Inlet, where some of the oil seeped down to the water, from a patrol boat Wednesday afternoon.

"I'm pleased to see that such action was taken very quickly. The overwhelming majority that made its way into the water was able to be contained," he said.

Oil-containment booms kept the spill from moving further into the heavily-used inlet and several dozen people were working along the shoreline.

The National Energy Board has been appointed as the lead agency in the investigation, and Baird promised the investigation will be free from political interference.

As to who should pick up the clean-up tab, "I can tell you I'm a big believer in 'polluter pays'," he added.

The pipeline carries crude oil from Edmonton to the Burnaby area, where it is stored before being piped onto ocean tankers for distribution.

The city of Burnaby and the pipeline company have been sparring over who's responsible for the accident.

The city's contractor claims the plans they received showing the pipeline's location were flawed. The company insists they gave the right location.

Kinder Morgan's record

"I think that Kinder Morgan has a record that is not enviable," Corrigan said.

In Walnut, Calif., an excavator hit a petroleum pipeline in 2004, causing an explosion that left five people dead. Four companies were fined, Kinder Morgan most heavily.

A report by the Office of the State Fire Marshall blamed Kinder Morgan for not properly marking the pipeline's location.

"Kinder Morgan's record in the U.S. and throughout North America is stellar and better than average," said Ian Anderson, president of Kinder Morgan Canada.

"The investigation at the end of the day will determine cause," he said. "At this point, our focus is not on blame. Our focus is on cleanup, communication with the residents, making it as easy for them to get information as possible."

Kinder Morgan's inspector gave the contractor the pipeline routing information, Anderson said. "The maps were provided. We're doing our due diligence to understand what the cause was."

Cusano Contracting, the company doing the excavating, did not comment Wednesday.

Baird said the NEB will look at how the spill happened and how it could have been prevented. In addition, Environment Canada officials will see if the federal Environment Act was violated, which could result in charges.

With reports from CTV's Sarah Galashan, CTV British Columbia correspondents and files from The Canadian Press 

Please Add Comments( )

Kristine Grantham
said
0 0

Kinder Morgan is a multi-million dollar company. Here's hoping that the people whose homes are destroyed retain high-powered legal counsel and sue them for millions for damages and inconvenience.


J
said
0 0

How is it Kinder Morgan's fault? Their pipeline was marked, the city should pay.


David
said
0 0

A little premature to be pointing fingers with lawsuits. Sounds more like a money grab Kristine. Yes, who ever is responsible will have to cover damages but I have not seen anything deciding this yet.

Besides we all carry insurance to cover these occurances in our society, let them perform their function instead of getting the legal system involved and driving the cost of everything up, including your insurance.


john virginillo
said
0 0

Food for thought

1. Why does it take 30 minutes to shutdown a pipeline. Safety precautions should require a person on site who has direct access via phone to an emergency number which gives him authority to request immediate shutdown of a pipeline should a catastrophe occur.

2. Why are the refineries not required by law to have oil booms on site? It seesm to me this would be 'normal' safety equipment on site to avoid environmental disaster. It is pretty alarming to know we have several refineries on Burrard inlet who could any day have a spill without adequate equipemnt available to avert a disaster.

3. Where is all the contaminated soil, building materials, pavement going? Who is paying for the disposal of this?

It seems to me there really is a double standard as to what the average person in society has to do in terms of building permits, call before you dig, fines for breaking laws etc. and what the corporate community is allowed to get away with.


Tim
said
0 0

Sue to Kinder Morgan? I would disagree with Kristine Grantham. People should sue to whoever did created wrong map for underground (Electricity, Cable, Water, Sewer, Pipeline)


Laurie
said
0 0

1. Sounds like they shut down the pipeline as quickly as they could. Do you know what's involved? I don't. It may not be as straightforward as turning a tap.
2 & 3. Good questions - I'm sure these questions wil be answered.
We don't know there is a double standard. It does take time to assess a situation. You can understand the authorities will need to question and get answers before they themselves decide who, what, where, when and how.


Andrew
said
0 0

It's safe to say that the responsible party will have to pay for the cost of repairs and cleanup. "Kinder Morgan has already said it will pay for the immediate costs of the cleanup" that seems more than expected concidering it was not their fault the pipeline was punctured.


Wendy
said
0 0

It is the City of Burnaby's crew that is responsible for this. It has nothing to do with Kinder Morgan, it is the professional negligence of the contractor. They should start to change their work style. You can tell they don't focus by the way they control the traffic around the work zone. They turned their back to the traffic and chatting in groups. If this culture is not corrected, next time it may be a gas line to Florida being cut through!

Wendy
said
0 0

Kristine, if I live above you in a condo, the water from my bathroom goes thru your ceiling, do you pay for it or I should cover the cost? Please check with a lawyer.


Shane
said
0 0

Wow ! first comment was about suing someone...especially when it was not even Kinder Morgan’s fault. One would think that the city would have to pay for a large amount of damages. I think Kinder Morgan did an excellent job in shutting down the pipe line. If you assume it is like turning a tap then you are wrong. Don’t forget that even when you shut a hose off water still comes out; imagine a hose million times bigger with more pressure.

Edly
said
0 0

Here's the other question - what are they going to do with all the materials used to clean up the oil? Burn it? Burry it? Not as easy as just patching up the ground with some sand.

There are also long-term issues to deal with for both residents and wildlife. They'll essentially have to dig up / remove all oil soaked trees, grass, materials, and soil as if it was contaimated with radiation. As I mentioned earlier, they'll then need to figure out where to put the same.

Francesca Sanna, Regional District Planner
said
0 0

Residents with chronic repiratory illness or their children should be made aware that strong aromatic (oil, petroleum) can trigger or worsened ashtma attack.

I am concerned that the authority judged that it was safe for the residents. Having asthma myself, and having beeen exposed to a small gas leak, the Kelowna police and fire authority judged that even though it was somewhat safe for the other employees, it was certainly not the case for someone with known asthma or other repiratory illness.

Please contact the BC lung association for more information on preventive measures and maybe contact the Health Authority so as to properly inform the residents.

Jon Tooley
said
0 0

One will find out that this was NOT Kinder Morgan's fault as one can be sure that their line was adequately marked and that it had been located on site prior to the excavation work. A Company the size of Kinder Morgan will not take unnecessary chances with a line in such an environmentally sensitive area. We will probably learn soon that the cause was related to how the line was being excavated and whether proper excavation methods were being incorporated at the time and whether a Kinder Morgan representative had been notified to be on site by the construction contractor. Now is a time for cool heads until the facts have all been evaluated and sorted out.

Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

CTV.CA SPECIAL

Wildlife in the Burrard inlet will be affected by the oil spill. (CP PHOTO/ Sam Leung)

The impact

Bill Doskoch on the environmental consequences of the Burnaby, B.C. spill.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz