News Sections
Chile officials blame T.O. police for soccer brawl
CTV News Video
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(93)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Fri. Jul. 20 2007 11:01 PM ET
An angry post-match confrontation between Chilean soccer players and Toronto police has escalated to become an international incident, with officials in Santiago laying the blame squarely on Canadian authorities.
Chilean President Michelle Bachelet told local reporters she was dismayed with the use of "unjustified aggression" by Toronto police after a bloody brawl following a FIFA U-20 World Cup match late Thursday.
"In our judgment, what happened was particularly serious because the Chilean delegation suffered unjustified aggression," she said.
Her government is lodging a formal complaint with Canadian Foreign Affairs Minister Peter MacKay to demand an explanation for why police used "such unusual methods'' to deal with the situation.
But Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper, who just visited Chile a few days ago, said only that "international soccer matches are hotly contested and often become very emotional."
He added that "There are processes in Canada by which the authorities review these kinds of things and I don't intend to comment any further."
Toronto police say they were responding to aggressive behaviour with necessary force.
At a packed press conference on Friday, Chilean Football Federation President Harold Mayne-Nicholls apologized for the behaviour of the team, but slammed the police response.
"I personally saw that the police of Toronto did not act as our police is used to acting with people that are just playing a football game,'' said Mayne-Nicholls.
"For us, as the chairman of the Football Federation of Chile, we cannot accept those kind of things coming from the police. Our players are 19-year-old, 20-year-old kids. They were playing football and they never deserved the treatment they were receiving.''
Mayne-Nicholls wouldn't say what prompted the fight, only that the players were relaxed in the changing room after the match.
"I'm sure they are completely innocent on this but I want to know exactly what happened,'' he said.
Mayne-Nicholls told reporters that the Federation is waiting for a final report to learn exactly what transpired.
Despite the friction, the president of the Chilean Football Federation assured media the players were prepared for their match against Austria for the third-place spot on Sunday.
The consul general of Chile also weighed in on Friday, saying Toronto police need to do more than just apologize for Thursday night's brawl with members of the Chilean FIFA U-20 soccer team.
Apology not enough
"I don't think a mere apology would be enough, I don't think so," said Ricardo Plaza. "Clearly something much more serious needs to be done. This is a serious problem and it needs a serious solution.
Speaking with CTV News, Plaza said police were rude to him when he showed up at the stadium after learning of the scuffle that took place outside the National Soccer Stadium.
He accused the police of using excessive force with the players, all of whom are under the age of 20. Instead of protecting the players, they attacked them, he said.
"They used extreme, excessive force, not used in appropriate way," he said. "I can't understand how they could react in such a way. It's not understandable and it's unacceptable."
Tensions erupt
Tensions between the two teams competing in the FIFA U-20 World Cup semi-final reached a boiling point after Chile lost to Argentina 3-0.
German referee Wolfgang Stark called 53 fouls -- 30 against Chile. Two of their members were eventually ejected during the game.
During the game, nine yellow cards were issued to the team while two yellow cards were issued to the opposing Argentina team. A yellow card is considered a serious warning -- two of them in a single game and the player is shown a red card, which means ejection.
Emotions were running high among players, angry at what they said were unfair calls by referees.
When the final whistle blew and Chile had been shut out 3-0, the team started to go after the referees, egged on by an angry public audience. However, police ushered the refs away to the tunnels underneath the stands.
Later outside the stadium, an altercation erupted between police and athletes as they headed to their bus.
A reporter with The Canadian Press said he heard people yelling near the Chilean team bus after the game. A scuffle then broke out between four or five people, and quickly escalated.
'A big dogfight'
"Next thing you know, the bus just unloads and there's eight, 10 players come off the bus and there's just fists flying everywhere, between the cops, the security guards, a couple of ladies were involved that were security," said reporter Nathan Denette.
"It looked like a big dogfight. People throwing fists and cops with their billyclubs out and then all of a sudden it got out of control."
A police officer then used a Taser to subdue one of the people in the melee, though it was unclear if he was a player or an official with the Chilean team.
"As soon as that happened, it got even worse," Denette said.
Hundreds of angry and chanting fans were kept at a distance, separated by a fence as FIFA and Canadian officials looked on in shock.
Police soon got a handle on the situation, handcuffing team members, many of them bloodied and screaming, and escorting them back into the dressing room where they remained detained for several hours.
"They hit me with an electrical current and I fainted,'' player Isaias Perralta told Chilean media. "When I regained consciousness, I saw 10 police officers were hitting me and throwing acid in my face.''
All 21 players from the Chilean under-20 soccer team were detained by police.
Eventually, police let them all go without making a single arrest.
"All (Chilean) players have been released from custody of the police to care of the Chilean delegation,'' FIFA spokesman John Schumacher said. "The Chilean players were detained by the police to de-escalate the situation that was taking place in front of the stadium."
"The entire situation is under investigation by FIFA, the LOC (local organizing committee), the police authorities in Toronto as well as the Chilean delegation,'" he continued.
FIFA President Sepp Blatter told reporters at a press conference on Friday that the association had asked the relevant authorities in Toronto to report details of their probe back to his organization.
Police reaction
Toronto Police Chief William Blair released a statement Friday outlining what happened.
"My officers were forced to intervene, initially, to protect the referees. As the teams were leaving the stadium, an argument broke out between a member of the Chilean team and a rival fan," he said. "My officers were forced to intervene, again, to end the dispute. Members of the Chilean team then decided to direct some of their aggressive behaviour towards my officers."
Blair said the officers did what they had to do to control the situation.
"The job of my officers was to respond in a firm, but fair, manner to end that violence. They are trained to do so, and that is what they did," he said.
"We will look, in detail, into what happened last night to see what changes, if any, we need to make to the policing arrangements for Sunday's matches."
There are no plans to investigate the matter further, although police may respond to the allegations levelled against them, said Toronto police spokesman Const. George Schuurman.
"As far as I know, it's a case closed,'' he said.
"It happened last night, people were arrested, they were investigated, they were released, no charges -- and that's the end of it.''
Toronto Mayor David Miller called the incident "regretful" considering the tremendous success of the games so far.
However, he wouldn't comment on the behaviour of the police force.
"Until the police investigation is complete, I can't comment on any action police took," he said.
"I do know the inspector in charge showed tremendous good sense to return all players to the custody of their coach.
'Upset with the ref'
"The players were upset. They're young players,'' Chile coach Jose Sulantay said at a post-match press conference through an interpreter, referring to the melee on the playing field after the final whistle. "The red card affected them."
"The coaching staff tried to calm them down, but they were upset with the ref and the red cards.''
While Sulantay explained away his players' frustration to reporters, the brawl was breaking out outside the stadium.
Chile is expected to play Austria Sunday for a third-place finish before the finals between Argentina and Czech Republic.
Plaza said he hopes the team will recover from Thursday night's incident in time for the game.
"I hope they will recover and will be assisted and will be able to play on Sunday as if nothing happened," he said. "It will be very difficult. They will have the incident in the back of their minds."
The under-20 competition is FIFA's largest tournament after the World Cup. The organization was congratulated for setting record ticket sales for the tournament at BMO Field.
The field is being dubbed the National Soccer Stadium during the tournament because of issues around sponsorship.
User Tools
Related Stories
CTV.ca Special
In Pictures: FIFA Brawl
A rough semi-final between Chile and Argentina deteriorates into a brawl with police.
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(93)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
Two questions:
1) What does Mr Colvin personally have to gain by what he is exposing ?
2) What has the Goverment gain or protect by discrediting Mr Colvin?

Please Add Comments( )
John Scott
0
said
0
Allan Eizinas
0
said
0
George Sanidas
0
said
0
David
0
said
0
Paul
0
said
0
Average number of fouls per game 5.9
Average number of yellow cards per game 2.6
Average number of red cards per game 0.2
...here's a thought, maybe the referee had something to do with it!
Jackie
0
said
0
Etelle B.
0
said
0
Caroline
0
said
0
C.J. Dembski
0
said
0
The ref. was horrid, simply a disgrace to the game. My heart goes out to Chile, and shame on Argentina for diving every two seconds.
Allan
0
said
0
Louis P.
0
said
0
Esther
0
said
0
IAN ORWIN
0
said
0
barry
0
said
0
Jason
0
said
0
Because if you say that, then sure, it was the refs fault. No matter what the refs did, there is ZERO excuse for fans and players to act out in violence. Chile should be banned for their actions. I don't care what team does it, you don't come flying off your bus to start fights no matter what.
Fernando
0
said
0
Lorraine
0
said
0
Fernando V.
0
said
0
Alex Kovalenko
0
said
0
Amanda Farias
0
said
0
Stewie Griffin
0
said
0
Glas
0
said
0
JF Chalmers
0
said
0
Sean
0
said
0
Bad reffing or not, the players' behaviour was completely unacceptable and they should be offering apologies to FIFA, event organizers and the host country, not the other way around.
At the end of the day I hope that soccer takes a firm hold here in Canada, but we can do without the "hooligans" and their type of behavious that have plagued the sport in other parts of the world.
Selassie
0
said
0
Danny Sayers
0
said
0
Jeffrey Alexander
0
said
0
Dean
0
said
0
j. Arnold
0
said
0
Perhaps the Canadian press chould cover this story more indepth, instead of the Harry Potter book. This has become an international incident that will see Canada written off as a host country for future sporting events.
Ryan
0
said
0
Unfortunately, this seems typical to the sport of soccer. Too bad
Ignacio Montero
0
said
0
South America fans are very important for football (you call it soccer). Giving autographs and shake hands after the game before entering the bus is normal, even necessary. On the other hand, police and security has their own agenda, and presumably were too strict and narrow-minded to see this dynamic relationship player-fan (in Canada sorry to say it, you don't know about football and its surrounding culture and codes . Chilean players didn't mean to misrespect the policeman, just to continue in their role of professional players in and outside the field.
Jessica
0
said
0
Nancy Telford
0
said
0
Roberto Iturrieta
0
said
0
Also I like to add that Argentina did not play better than Chile, the score doesn´t show how the match was.
Joel
0
said
0
Geoff Sanders
0
said
0
Sean
0
said
0
fcs
0
said
0
Jeff
0
said
0
Charles Bowman
0
said
0
"Could it be possible that the Chilean players, all under 20, average height 5.5, 165 pounds are dumb enough to confron trained police officers, carrying tasers, clubs, pepper spray and outnumber them by far?"
Pretty clear to me.
Erick Govaz
0
said
0
Robert
0
said
0
Alan Duguid
0
said
0
Ivonne
0
said
0
I believe the police officers used force that was needed to restrain the Chilean team and fans, because of their behaviour was out of control. Police Officers are well trained for this kind of actions and is in their hands to control violence.
I believe the chilean team owns a big apology to the canadian officers that they attacked they were only doing their job and what the FIFA told them to do keep the players moving out.
Eric
0
said
0
ALF
0
said
0
now the this kids follow their behaviour... sad... very sad...
Ruben E. del Castillo
0
said
0
The chilean and argentinian fans were soaking wet sitting all together to enjoy the game. If it was in my power, I would sue the referee personaly to pay back the money the fans paid to watch a game that he simply decided to ruin acting like a narrow-minded dictator.
Rodrigo Bravo
0
said
0
Rob
0
said
0
Michael
0
said
0
Jonathan Fieldhouse
0
said
0
Christian Guzman
0
said
0
At least here in chile, not too many people speaks english, and the people that speaks english, are adult people who have jobs.
I think that soon we will get to know the real story about this awful and embarrassing incident, ¿was the chilean players who started this riot or the cops?, soon we will know.
Richard Gerdingh
0
said
0
Shame on FIFA for providing such an incompetent referee in an international game and on the Argentinian player for a total lack of sportmanship.
Walter E.Eibisberger
0
said
0
Our Police officers did the right thing by keeping the lid on things.
Carl Jones
0
said
0
Chad B.
0
said
0
L. Rutledge
0
said
0
Jennifer
0
said
0
Craig
0
said
0
Trent Paulhus
0
said
0
CJ
0
said
0
The apology should come from the poor sport players and not the police for doing their jobs.
Noogie P.
0
said
0
Connie Ewashko
0
said
0
As for who was responsible for what happened after the game...how about giving us the WHOLE, REAL story!!!???
Our Canadian police have a job to do...but hey they have also been known to misread an incident and overreact!!
The fact that there were no charges put in place makes me wonder what the REAL story is...and I want to hear it!
How can Chile play another fair game on Sunday?
Earl Larocque
0
said
0
Our police responded with appropriate measures.
Is this what Toronto really wants? I think not.
TG from Northern ON
0
said
0
Thomas Leroux
0
said
0
When the police say do something, you do it.
Andrew
0
said
0
Too many hippies in this country.
Janus
0
said
0
Jake
0
said
0
Who cares what Chile thinks, really? Let 'em complain!
Don't turn around and demoralize your own police with endless bureaucratic inquiries.
If this happened in the US or UK, do you think they would jump just because Chile complained? Never.
Alfredo Mella
0
said
0
1) There is a big racism problem in Canada. Toronto Police treated us (Chileans) like animals with no justification at all. All political relationships with Canada should be eliminated, along with any protection to Canadian ambassadors in Santiago.
2) Argentina isn't a team that deserves to win a World Cup, but they do deserve an Oscar for their performance last night.
Alan Todd
0
said
0
If they (including their coach and diplomats) dispute the fairness of the game they can complain through official means.
In acting like dissapointed children the Chilean team disrespect the game, their nation and themselves. Isn't there enough stupid conflict in our world? Can't we enjoy sport in the support of a just and peaceful world. Come on people!
Louise
0
said
0
Troy
0
said
0
The cops were completely justified in using force. Players tried to assault the refs, rival fans and then the cops, and subsequently got their s*** pushed in.
Complete fault on the Chilean team, and their coaching staff and management who couldn't control them. They should be banned from the rest of the tournament.
Al
0
said
0
joey campbell
0
said
0
Rodrigo Tornvall
0
said
0
However it is a shame on Canadian police to react like that on 20 year old kids that were only trying to greet the fans and sign some autographs. While this incident was happening every single journalist from all over the world was kept beyond bars and they were obligated to shut the cameras off. What were they trying to hide with all this? I have seen todays news and the brutality of Canadian police is just evident. Several players had injuries all over their bodies and some of them couldn´t even walk. I have seen that myself and you can look it up on many Chilean newspapers on the web to see how damaged the young players ended up. The Chilean Government made a formal complaint that was forwarded through the chilean ambassador in Toronto to the Canadian government. Even the canadian ambassador in Chile himself apologized for what happened last night. It is very sad for me to see my people and my entire country so devastated after this. I just hope we never see this happening again.
Valerie Ford
0
said
0
Sterling
0
said
0
That said, a nations experienced U20 player ought to know better than to attack a ref. When did that become an acceptable or excusable reaction? Kids know that.
If you'll excuse the metaphor, the chileans are diving on the field, so to speak. Crying about something that shouldn't be cried about.
Take some accountability.
Travis Smith
0
said
0
Bonnita
0
said
0
CTY
0
said
0
Abraham
0
said
0
In the end instead of taking proper precautions the police are involved in the ugly incidents that followed.
This just shows the growing intolerance in our society today.
Cameron
0
said
0
Scott
0
said
0
soccergirl
0
said
0
Again, these hotheads clashed with authorities. Bravo to Toronto Police for not taking any of it.
Kyle Morrison
0
said
0
Now, after reading this, how could anyone claim that the Chilean fans are anything but calm and reasonable?
Corina Contreras
0
said
0
Bruno
0
said
0
CTY
0
said
0
Ivan
0
said
0
Kevin K. Klaus
0
said
0
markus
0
said
0
Lee
0
said
0