World -   

1
Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels speaks during a news conference at the Indiana State Fair in Indianapolis, Sunday, Aug. 14, 2011. (AP / Darron Cummings) Indiana State Police and authorities survey the collapsed rigging and Sugarland stage on the infield at the Indiana State Fair in Indianapolis, Sunday, Aug. 14, 2011. (AP / Darron Cummings) Indiana State Police and authorities survey the collapsed rigging and Sugarland stage on the infield at the Indiana State Fair in Indianapolis, Sunday, Aug. 14, 2011. Five people died in the stage collapse. (AP Photo/Darron Cummings) Indiana State Police and authorities survey the collapsed rigging and Sugarland stage on the infield at the Indiana State Fair in Indianapolis, Sunday, Aug. 14, 2011. (AP / Darron Cummings) Fans waiting to see Sugarland attempt to hold up the stage after high winds blew the stage over at the Indiana State Fair Grandstands in Indianapolis, Saturday, Aug. 13, 2011. (AP / The Indianapolis Star, Matt Kryger) Fans waiting to see Sugarland attempt to hold up the stage after high winds blew the stage over at the Indiana State Fair Grandstands in Indianapolis, Saturday, Aug. 13, 2011. (AP / The Indianapolis Star, Matt Kryger) Family members tend to their injured relatives as Indianapolis Fire Department personnel and paramedics tend to the victims of a stage collapse before a concert at the Indiana State Fair Grandstands in Indianapolis, Saturday, Aug. 13, 2011. (AP / The Indianapolis Star, Matt Kryger) Stage Collapse

Indiana governor calls fair stage collapse a 'fluke'

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Daniele Hamamdjian reports
Five people were killed when a concert stage at the Indiana State Fair collapsed after its rigging was blown down by powerful winds.
CTV News Channel: Myrt Price, WRTV
A reporter with WRTV in Indianapolis describes the sombre mood at the Indiana State Fair following the collapse of the stage at a Sugerland concert.
CTV News Channel: Matt Kryger, photographer
A photographer with Indianapolis Star says it was absolute chaos when the stage collapsed. He also says plenty of people jumped in to help each other.
CTV News Channel: David Lindquist, reviewer
A music reviewer with Indianapolis Star discusses the preceding moments of the stage collapse at the Indiana State Fair. He also says five people have been killed and more than 40 have been transported to the hospital.
CTV National News: Stage collapse in Indiana
A stage at the Indiana State Fair where the country group Sugarland was scheduled to perform is shown collapsing during a storm.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (17) Facebook   

Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels speaks during a news conference at the Indiana State Fair in Indianapolis, Sunday, Aug. 14, 2011. (AP / Darron Cummings) Indiana State Police and authorities survey the collapsed rigging and Sugarland stage on the infield at the Indiana State Fair in Indianapolis, Sunday, Aug. 14, 2011. (AP / Darron Cummings) Indiana State Police and authorities survey the collapsed rigging and Sugarland stage on the infield at the Indiana State Fair in Indianapolis, Sunday, Aug. 14, 2011. Five people died in the stage collapse. (AP Photo/Darron Cummings) Indiana State Police and authorities survey the collapsed rigging and Sugarland stage on the infield at the Indiana State Fair in Indianapolis, Sunday, Aug. 14, 2011. (AP / Darron Cummings) Fans waiting to see Sugarland attempt to hold up the stage after high winds blew the stage over at the Indiana State Fair Grandstands in Indianapolis, Saturday, Aug. 13, 2011. (AP / The Indianapolis Star, Matt Kryger) Fans waiting to see Sugarland attempt to hold up the stage after high winds blew the stage over at the Indiana State Fair Grandstands in Indianapolis, Saturday, Aug. 13, 2011. (AP / The Indianapolis Star, Matt Kryger) Family members tend to their injured relatives as Indianapolis Fire Department personnel and paramedics tend to the victims of a stage collapse before a concert at the Indiana State Fair Grandstands in Indianapolis, Saturday, Aug. 13, 2011. (AP / The Indianapolis Star, Matt Kryger) Stage Collapse

Photos

Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels speaks during a news conference at the Indiana State Fair in Indianapolis, Sunday, Aug. 14, 2011. (AP / Darron Cummings)

View Larger Image

Date: Sun. Aug. 14 2011 7:42 PM ET

Gov. Mitch Daniels called the collapse of the stage at the Indiana State Fair a "fluke" event Sunday, as officials released the identities of the five people killed in the incident.

Daniels choked up during a news conference when he called the deadly collapse an "unthinkable tragedy."

"This is the finest event of its kind in America, this is the finest one we've ever had, and this desperately sad ... fluke event doesn't change that," he said.

Five people killed after strong gusts of wind caused the stage to topple at the Indiana State Fair late Saturday night.

At least 45 other concert-goers were injured when blustery winds caused the fair's stage to collapse, sending lights and other stage equipment tumbling into the audience below.

Songstress Sara Bareilles had just finished performing and the crowd was waiting for country music duo Sugarland to take the stage.

Hundreds of revellers scattered amid the chaos while other bystanders rushed to lift steel scaffolding off the injured while emergency crews set up a triage centre near the stage.

"It was horrible," concert-goer Emily Davis told Indianapolis news station WTHR. "People were running and going crazy."

The Marion County Coroner's office said on Sunday that 23-year-old Alina Bigjohny of Fort Wayne, 29-year-old Christina Santiago of Chicago, and Indianapolis residents Tammy Vandam, 42, and Glenn Goodrich, 49, died in the hours after the collapse.

Fifty-one-year-old Nathan Byrd, of Indianapolis, died in hospital overnight. Byrd is believed to be a spotlight worker who was on the stage when it collapsed.

Witnesses reported seeing several people with head and neck injuries and broken bones. Indiana State Police Sgt. Rich Myers would only offer that the injuries ranged from "slight to very critical."

At least 18 concert-goers were transported to the nearby Wishard Memorial Hospital with non-life threatening injuries, confirmed hospital spokesperson Todd Harper. He said the problems included head injuries, bone fractures and lacerations.

A 7-year-old fair attendee was among those being treated in hospital, said Harper, who didn't provide further detail.

The number of reported injuries might rise in the coming days, said Indiana State Police Sgt. Dave Burstein who explained that many concert-goers may have taken themselves to the hospital.

Cindy Hoye, the fair's executive director, told reporters Sunday that all fair workers are "very much in mourning" on what is a "very sad day at the state fair."

Early warning

A timeline released by Indiana State Police showed fair staff placed calls to the National Weather Service four times between 5:30 p.m. and 8 p.m. local time. Fair officials said Sunday they prepared an evacuation plan and notified concert-goers that they may have to evacuate the fair grounds.

Around 8:30 p.m., state troopers moved toward the grandstand to prepare for a possible evacuation, the timeline showed.

A local radio personality took to the stage moments before it caved in to warn the crowd that severe weather conditions were possible, said Indianapolis Star journalist David Lindquist.

Lindquist, who was sitting in the fifth row at the time of the collapse, said the announcer gave the crowd instructions on what to do if an evacuation was necessary.

"Moments later this gust of wind came and crumpled the rigging," he told CTV News Channel on Sunday.

Lindquist said there was a cement slab that is used as a stage throughout the year, but a large metal framework was added to the stage during the 16-day fair. He said each band that played attached its own speakers and equipment to the framework.

Witnesses reported seeing a dark sky with short blasts of lightning just before the stage's collapse. Despite the evacuation warning, Lindquist said many concertgoers chose to stay put and wait out the weather.

The collapse was particularly treacherous because there was an exclusive pit for special guests sitting next to the stage, said Lindquist.

"There was an actual VIP pit close to the stage," he said. "The tragic thing is, in this instance, it put a higher concentration of people in harm's way."

Witnesses near the pit reported seeing a towering wall of dirt, dust and rain hit the fairgrounds before the collapse.

Concert-goer Jessica Alsman told The Associated Press that the towering, metal stage "kind of wobbled at first" before crumpling into the audience.

Faced with an initial blast of wind, Alsman and her friends grabbed each other and formed a chain. The group of four wasn't expecting what happened next.

"You can't imagine," she said. "We just thought it was going to rain or something."

After the storm

In the wake of the incident, fair officials cancelled all festival activities scheduled for Sunday.

Instead, emergency crews continued to search through the wreckage on the Indiana fairgrounds to ensure there were no other injured concert-goers who wandered off after the collapse.

The fair, which was slated to run through Aug. 21, is expected to resume Monday with a service honouring the victims.

Jennifer Nettles, the lead singer for Sugarland, said that members of the country band were heartbroken for the fans and their families in Indiana.

"We hold those injured in our prayers at this very sad time. There are no words. It is tragic," Nettles said in a statement.

With files from the Associated Press

Comments are now closed for this story

jay
said
0 0

William Stevens
The storm in ottawa was anything but normal the winds were 130k countless trees were blown over in manyc ases were talking about massive trees houses aslo have roofs bown off.


C.R.
said
0 0

There is a lot more to designing a proper temporary stage structure than appears to those not in this industry. It is left to genuine experts, which the guys who erected the one in Indianapolis are. I know this company, they are NOT hacks, they are not a 'budget choice', they are the area experts. OSHA inspections of the debris will show lapses (if any) in design implementation, and barring that, any comments decrying them are IMHO unwarranted and ludicrous.

Every structure design is rated for a specific amount of wind loading (often 60MPH or more). In this instance, wind gusts were clocked at 77mph at a location just preceding the fairgrounds, which is distinctly atypical of this area. The roof panels and side panels are designed to peel loose to lessen the wind load at their extremes. Unfortunately, there is no way to ensure that they actually come clear of the structure as there is no way to predict wind direction. In this instance it appears that this was a factor, leaving a sail attached to one side of the rig. These winds are typical hurricane force/F1 tornado intensity. Common sense dictates people should be taking cover, NOT waiting it out to see a show.

My heart goes out to the victims and their families & friends.


Sam C
said
0 0

I am by no means an expert, but as I look at the pictures I see a giant sail -- a tarp-covered frame, with no way for the wind to escape once it gets in under the tarp. These temporary set-ups need to be designed to allow the wind to pass through without lifting or twisting the supporting structure.


Brent
said
0 0

Unfortunately, all of the fabric that wraps around the back and the two sides act as a sail. Add some wind and you have certain disaster.


Don
said
0 0

Very sad indeed, these temporary stages are not made to withstand high winds and obviously not safe. I have said this before, but I'm sure that these places that have these stages have them every year, so why not build a concrete band shell? Local sponsors and business would love to all get together and have them built in their respective cities.... maybe now this will cross the minds of the organizers......


Trudy
said
0 0

I am saddened that these structures are not capable of withstanding natures forces and the lack of safety and emergency prepardness is lax. I am sure lawsuits are pending in light of this avoidable tragedy.


Irene
said
0 0

This is such a tragic accident.It is such a shame when fingers are pointed when things like this happen.


William Stevens
said
0 0

This is becoming epidemic - there was the Blues Fest stage and I seem to recall another in the US after Blues Fest and before this one. These stages are blowing down in normal summer storms. We are not talking about tornadoes or hurricanes, but just the normal storms that roll through Canada and the US several times each summer. It sounds like typical corporate or government penny-pinching - giving contracts to the lowest bidder no matter how shoddy a job they intend to do. That's why infrastructure is constantly falling apart and that's why people die when stages (or bridges, or buildings) fail.


William Stevens
said
0 0

This is becoming epidemic - there was the Blues Fest stage and I seem to recall another in the US after Blues Fest and before this one. These stages are blowing down in normal summer storms. We are not talking about tornadoes or hurricanes, but just the normal storms that roll through Canada and the US several times each summer. It sounds like typical corporate or government penny-pinching - giving contracts to the lowest bidder no matter how shoddy a job they intend to do. That's why infrastructure is constantly falling apart and that's why people die when stages (or bridges, or buildings) fail.


Laura
said
0 0

I can't imagine the US laughing at anyone's tragedy. We are known for stepping up and helping out no matter where a disaster happens.


esumler
said
0 0

It is a very sad state of affairs, indeed, to think that something like this could still happen, especially when we should have, and could have, known better.

Yet, it just proves once again, that Life is so short, and so precious. Perhaps they are in a much better place, now.


Shannon
said
0 0

I agree that this is a HORRIBLE tragedy, and I also agree that this was 100% preventable..While I do understand the construction of the stage wasn't all that (which it should be in the first place) I personally, would hold the officials in charge of this concert/fair responsible in not CANCELLING the show when clearly they had a chance to. Shouldn't it be enough warning when: 1) they knew bad weather was coming and 2) the stage starts to "wobble??!" my heart and prayers go out to these precious families and friends :(


Ellen Winters
said
0 0

Our prayers for all who were in harm's way last evening.


And the USA was laughing at us?
said
0 0

First and foremost, this is another tradegy that was 100% preventable. Secondly, why was the USA laughing at us when the Bluesfest stage collapsed under 120km per hour winds and now theirs goes down and kills people in 50 mph? Glass house should not throw stones. It is a tragedy yes but it was like so many others 100% preventable. What will it take for people to learn?


Rob
said
0 0

Here we go again , another stage collapse. What are these stages made of if a gust of wind can knock it over. Really, do those responsible not learn anything from other accidents like this. For goodness sake this is a stage , not building a rocket. No doubt its the almighty dollar at play, they'd rather do a cheap job and put people at risk. I shake my head at this foolishness.


Stan Dawson
said
0 0

What an utterly, stupendously, asinine, idiotic, moronic, completely brain breathed structure to have at an outdoor fair in Indiana. This outcome was a foregone conclusion. I hope those responsible are sued out of existence and then put in a 4 by 8 prison cell for a very long time.


Norie
said
0 0

OMG Them poor people, my thoughts and prayers go out to all the families :( so tragic and heart breaking :(


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's World Stories

Former Liberian President Charles Taylor waits for the start of his sentencing judgement in the courtroom of the Special Court for Sierra Leone in Leidschendam, near The Hague, Netherlands, Wednesday May 30, 2012.  (AP / Toussaint Kluiters)

Charles Taylor gets 50 years for 'brutal' crimes

More   5 Comments 5    2 Video(s) 2

This frame grab made from an amateur video provided by Syrian activists on Monday, May 28, 2012, purports to show the massacre in Houla on May 25 that killed more than 100 people, many of them children. (AP / Amateur Video via AP video)

UN observers in Syria discover 13 bound corpses

More

Pakistani doctor Shakil Afridi taken in Pakistani tribal area of Jamrud in Khyber region, July 9, 2010. (AP / Qazi Rauf)

Pakistan doctor guilty of militancy, not CIA links

More