World -   

1
An Iraqi policeman stands guard at a check point in Basra, Iraq's second-largest city, 550 kilometres southeast of Baghdad, Iraq, Wednesday, Sept. 1, 2010. (AP Photo/Nabil al-Jurani)

U.S. transitions to final phase of war in Iraq

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News Channel: Prof. Stephen Farnsworth
An expert on U.S. politics at George Mason University says the speech by U.S. President Barack Obama was downbeat, and was mainly a transfer of power to the Iraqis and a hope for the best.
Canada AM: Solon Simmons, George Mason Univ.
A political analyst in Washington says U.S. President Barack Obama was careful to avoid language like 'mission accomplished' and while the speech was received by many with a shrug, it is an important move.
CTV National News: Paul Workman in Washington
U.S. President Barack Obama has pulled the plug on 'Operation Iraqi Freedom', and says America's combat role in the country has come to an end, but Obama warned that while the war is over, the danger still lingers.
CTV News Channel: Patrick Basham, expert
The director of the Democracy Institute says Obama's explanation of why it's time for U.S. troops to leave Iraq will resonate with the American people. He says the move will give him more time to focus on the economy.
CTV News Channel: U.S. President Barack Obama
U.S. President Barack Obama has announced the end of America's combat role in Iraq and has urged Iraq's leaders to move ahead with a government that will be accountable to the Iraqi people.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (14) Facebook   

An Iraqi policeman stands guard at a check point in Basra, Iraq's second-largest city, 550 kilometres southeast of Baghdad, Iraq, Wednesday, Sept. 1, 2010. (AP Photo/Nabil al-Jurani)

Photos

An Iraqi policeman stands guard at a check point in Basra, Iraq's second-largest city, 550 kilometres southeast of Baghdad, Iraq, Wednesday, Sept. 1, 2010. (AP Photo/Nabil al-Jurani)

View Larger Image

Date: Wed. Sep. 1 2010 11:04 AM ET

BAGHDAD — The U.S. on Wednesday moved into the final phase of its military involvement in Iraq, with administration officials saying the war was ending even as the new commander of the remaining 50,000 troops warned of the ongoing threat from "hostile elements."

The transfer of authority came a day after President Barack Obama announced the shift from combat operations to preparing Iraqi forces to assume responsibility for their own security. Obama made clear in Tuesday's speech that this was no victory celebration.

A six-month stalemate over forming a new Iraqi government has raised concerns about the country's stability and questions over whether the leadership can cope with a diminished but still dangerous insurgency.

Newly promoted Army Gen. Lloyd Austin also maintained a sombre tone as he took the reins of the some 50,000 American troops who remain in Iraq, with a deadline for a full withdrawal by the end of next year.

He noted "hostile enemies" continue to threaten Iraq and pledged that "our national commitment to Iraq will not change."

"Although challenges remain, we will face these challenges together," Austin said during the ceremony at the opulent al-Faw palace of ousted dictator Saddam Hussein.

Austin, who most recently served in Iraq as commander of troop operations from 2008-09, replaces Gen. Ray Odierno, who is heading to Virginia to take over the Joint Forces Command after about five years in Iraq.

"This period in Iraq's history will probably be remembered for sacrifice, resilience and change," Odierno said. "However, I remember it as a time in which the Iraqi people stood up against tyranny, terrorism and extremism, and decided to determine their own destiny as a people and as a democratic state."

Vice-President Joe Biden, Defence Secretary Robert Gates, and Joint Chiefs Chairman Adm. Mike Mullen presided over the ceremony, which was held at the main U.S. military headquarters on the southwestern outskirts of Baghdad.

Gates, visiting American troops in the Iraqi city of Ramadi Wednesday, said history will judge whether the fight was worth it for the United States.

"The problem with this war, I think, for many Americans, is that the premise on which we justified going to war turned out not to be valid," he said. "Even if the outcome is a good one from the standpoint of the United States, it'll always be clouded by how it began."

Claiming that Saddam had weapons of mass destruction, then-President George W. Bush ordered the invasion with approval of a Congress still reeling from the 9/11 attacks. Bush's claims were based on faulty intelligence, and the weapons were never found.

Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari said his country is grateful for what the Americans have done, but it is now time for Iraqis to secure their own future.

"We appreciate the sacrifices the U.S. military and the American people made while standing with us in these very, very difficult times," Zebari told The Associated Press in a phone interview. "The war for Iraq's future is ongoing and it should be fought and won by the Iraqi people and their leaders," Zebari said.

Obama acknowledged the ambiguous nature of the war in which American forces quickly ousted Saddam but were never able to fully control the Sunni Muslim insurgency against the Shiite-dominated establishment that even now threatens to re-ignite.

Still, he said the time had come to close this divisive chapter in U.S. history.

"We have met our responsibility," Obama said. "Now it is time to turn the page."

Avoiding any hint of claiming victory in a war he once called a major mistake, the president recognized the sacrifices of America's military. More than 4,400 American troops and an estimated 100,000 Iraqis were killed at a cost of billions of dollars.

Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki, a Shiite, said Tuesday the end of U.S. combat operations was a return to sovereignty for the battered country and he reassured his people that their own security forces could defend them.

Iraqi forces on Wednesday appeared to be on heightened alert, spread out at checkpoints across the city intended to reassure the populace and ward off insurgent attacks.

Just under 50,000 U.S. troops remain in Iraq -- down from a peak of about 170,000 at the height in 2007. Those forces will not be able to go on combat missions unless requested and accompanied by Iraqi forces.

But drawing a line between what is and is not combat may not be easy. All American forces carry weapons and they still come under attack from insurgents near daily. Earlier this month, for example, Sgt. Brandon E. Maggart, 24, of Kirksville, Mo. was killed near the southern city of Basra on Aug. 22 -- a few days after the last combat brigade rolled across the border into Kuwait.

Iraq is also far from the stable democracy once depicted by the Bush administration and hoped for by Obama when he laid out his timeline for withdrawing American troops shortly after he took office in 2009.

Half a year has passed since Iraq's March 7 elections and the country's political leaders have so far failed to form a new government.

While Iraqis are generally happy to see the U.S. military pulling back, they are also apprehensive the withdrawal may be premature as militants hammer local security forces. Iraqis also say they fear their country may still revert to a dictatorship or split along religious and ethnic fault lines.

Comments are now closed for this story

DaveB
said

George in Alberta: The timeline for withdrawal was nogotiated with the Iraqis by Bush, and it was the Bush surge that made it possible. Obama demeans himself by trying to take credit for this.Now you were saying something about less educated people?


GHW
said

The Middle East would be a mess with or without Americas help. After 9-11 America should have just gone after Bin Laden and his close buddies laying waist anything that gets in the way and then promptly left. After all this blood and treasure spent they still have not captured or killed the people responsible for the attack.


Dennis L. Krahn
said

After reading some of the comments here today I am very happy that the people writing vitriolic comments about Americans are not in a position of consequence. It is easy to crticize; however looking back on history our state of affairs would be much different without the US. Certainly one of the privelges that we enjoy because of 'the war-mongering' Americans is freedom of speech. This freeedom is a two-edged sword that cuts equally and allows even knuckle draggers to spew their venom.


baryton
said

Americans will be happy to get out of Iraq, just like they were happy to run away from Vietnam. But not to worry - it will not take them long to find some other place to do the war in !


Doug in Ottawa
said

Shayla Grives in Ottawa makes my blood boil!!Her comment is that all Americans are war criminals?How many are war criminals? 1, 12, 100, all 300,000,000? Just the Democrats? Just the Republicans? How many are you talking about?.A lot of Americans think we are all a bunch of lazy, entitled socialist Liberals? This stereotype also is a bunch of b.s.


George Alberta
said

Good on Obama, Bush would still be there looking for those weapons of mass destruction, Bush was a joke he destroyed the US economy. It really gives a good look at the mentality of the right wing-nit jobs. I remember one of Bushes speeches, he said we can coexist with the fishes. Hey George fishes is not a word but polls tell us less educated people vote for a right wing government.


Brian Fr Langley
said

History will likely see this for what it is, the cut and run of the U.S and the creation of Greater Iran. Add a few nukes? and who knows?


Ian in N.B.
said

Yes Gerry, they will be pleased, the President kept his word, and there is less money being spent in an unwinable conflict.


Not John Smith in Toronto
said

@Gerry: Every democracy on earth has Socialism integrated into it's economic model via public education, police and fire etc. You don't understand what Socialism is.@Paul: be quiet. Couch generals like yourself are cowards with an abundance of hatred in the black hole where your hearts and intellect should be. Iraq is the next Afghanistan and when the relatives of Abu Graib or relatives of 14 year old little girl gang raped, killed by American soldiers blow up buildings in New York, you have only USA/Zionists to blame. Welcome to your legacy.


Shayla Grives in Ottawa
said

America is a nation of war criminals. These liars, thieves and murderers attacked a country that never did one ounce of harm to the US but, Israel and AIPAC the most powerful lobby in Democratic history pounced and took advantage of all the fear mongering after 9/11 and manipulated the US to attack Iraq. (well documented by Harvard scholars in 'The Israeli Lobby')As a result, America is bankrupt, millions of innocent Iraqis are dead, raped and in refugee camps not to mention prisoners in torture camps like Abu Graib. Before America and Israel set their sights on Iraq, that country was thriving and a hub of international commerce,banking, technology, education and natural resource revenue. Now, Iraq is destroyed, America owns the oil and American lawyers installed Sharia Law as the highest law of the land. From order to chaos, true shock and awe. Yeah, the cowboys got rid of the boogie man Saddam who ... ehm ... the Americans installed in the first place. Now Iraq is a breeding ground for religious extremism and when it shows up on their doorstep they'll all whine 'why do they hate us?'. Cue the propagandist & phoney "professor" to tell us how uncivilized 'they' are & how 'enlightened' Israelis are.


JFJ
said

The Iraqis have been given a gift by George Bush and the US. I hope they use it well.


Gerry
said

The socialist in the u.s. will all be happy.


Paul ~ Kitchener
said

THANK GOD at LAST !Now the President neeeds to inforce the Education sloga , "NO ONE LEFT BEHIND" , to the military campaign in Iraq ~ (followed by Afghanistan).Anyone left behind, will be at the mercy of this rable of mixed villans, who will enjoy taking them out, one at a timer of maybe a gang" STAY OUT"Home is where we need to be and stay !!!!!


Old Ted
said

The world knows that if you keep the pressure on, the Americans will eventually get bored with it all and leave. They didn't finish the job in Viet Nam, Laos, and Cambodia before leaving. They just left a mess. They are leaving Iraq in the same way and you know there is going to be a blood bath between the Shiites and Sunnis abetted by al Qaeda and everyone else with an axe to grind. They will be leaving Afghanistan the same way. Not the kind of friends you need.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's World Stories

In this March 12, 2011 photo released by the U.S. Marine Corps, CH-46E Sea Knight helicopters depart from Marine Corps Air Station Futenma in Okinawa on Saturday, March 12, 2011 for Naval Air Facility Atsugi on mainland Japan to provide assistance after an 8.9 magnitude earthquake and a tsunami struck Japan. The helicopters will fly more than 1,700 km over open water with emergency equipment.

U.S. could shift forces from Japan to Guam

More

Anti-Syrian regime protesters hold a demonstration in Idlib, Syria, Monday, Feb. 6, 2012.

Western powers ramp up diplomatic pressure on Syria

More   17 Comments 17    6 Video(s) 6

U.S. President Barack Obama speaks in Falls Church, Va. on Feb. 1, 2012.

Obama orders new U.S. sanctions on Iran

More   5 Comments 5  

Most Talked about Stories

The death penalty will not bring back lost loved ones. The death penalty does not stop, or even reduce violent crime. Bringing it back would simply be a step backwards to satisfy vengeful, immoral, people who think 'eye-for-an-eye' is still a good idea (Oddly often Christians, whose own Jesus Christ denounced the practice). No, the death penalty should not be reinstated. However, if they wanted to increase the maximum sentencing to make those worst people rot in jail longer, I'd have no problem with that. Or reducing the 'comforts' that prisoners enjoy.

Ryan, Guelph

Skurka's Spin: Can the death penalty return to Canada?