1
W5 investigates: Why some Canadian doctors are misdiagnosing a crippling disease caused by a shape-shifting superbug -- until it's too late. David Leggett used to be a healthy, active, family man and high school principal, but after getting lyme disease in July 2004, his health began to decline. Lyme is an emerging tick-borne disease -- caused by the bacterium, Borrelia burgdorferi. In Canada, infected ticks are found in parts of southern Ontario, the southeastern corner of Manitoba, areas along the south shore of Nova Scotia and in BC. The disease can be characterized by a special rash at an early stage. If untreated, in the later stages, the disease can involve major organ systems such as musculoskeletal, nervous, and cardiovascular systems. A female deer tick seen under a University of Rhode Island microscope in the entomoloy lab in South Kingstown, R.I. on March 18, 2002 (THE CANADIAN PRESS, AP - Victoria Arocho, File) The red zones mark the spread of the I. scapularis tick in Canada as of 2000. Note: B.C. is not included in this map, and in subsequent maps, as that province is affected by the species I. pacificus. Source: Public Health Agency of Canada. Temperature is said to be a critical factor in limiting the spread of the I. scapularis in Canada. And climate change is expected to drive the spread northward. This map shows a projection for the spread of I. scapularis in 2050, as effected by climate warming. This map shows a projection for the spread of I. scapularis in 2080, as effected by climate warming. The reported annual incidence of I. pacificus spread, which is endemic in B.C., does not appear to be affected by temperature. This map of B.C. shows the geographic distribution of the Ixodes pacificus (I. pacificus) tick in the province as of 2004. The spread appears to encompass the most heavily populated regions of the province, and appears to be endemic to B.C. Over 20,000 new cases of lyme-borne disease have been reported since 2002 in the U.S. every year. In 2002, 12,054 cases were reported among the 50.5 million inhabitants of those states that have endemic I. scapularis tick populations and have borders with eastern and central Canada (i.e. Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, upstate New York, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin and Minnesota)

Why are crippling Lyme disease cases being misdiagnosed?

Viewer

CTV News Video

W5: Out of the Wild, part one
An illness like Lyme disease, that can be caught in the outdoors, should be a priority for Canadian doctors to diagnose. Instead, the tiny microbe is often missed and patients' complaints often dismissed.
W5: Out of the Wild, part two
Critics and Lyme disease sufferers say their illness isn't taken seriously enough and the 'ignorance' and 'arrogance' of Canadian health agencies has driven them to desperation.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | Print Facebook   

W5 investigates: Why some Canadian doctors are misdiagnosing a crippling disease caused by a shape-shifting superbug -- until it's too late. David Leggett used to be a healthy, active, family man and high school principal, but after getting lyme disease in July 2004, his health began to decline. Lyme is an emerging tick-borne disease -- caused by the bacterium, Borrelia burgdorferi. In Canada, infected ticks are found in parts of southern Ontario, the southeastern corner of Manitoba, areas along the south shore of Nova Scotia and in BC. The disease can be characterized by a special rash at an early stage. If untreated, in the later stages, the disease can involve major organ systems such as musculoskeletal, nervous, and cardiovascular systems. A female deer tick seen under a University of Rhode Island microscope in the entomoloy lab in South Kingstown, R.I. on March 18, 2002 (THE CANADIAN PRESS, AP - Victoria Arocho, File) The red zones mark the spread of the I. scapularis tick in Canada as of 2000. Note: B.C. is not included in this map, and in subsequent maps, as that province is affected by the species I. pacificus. Source: Public Health Agency of Canada. Temperature is said to be a critical factor in limiting the spread of the I. scapularis in Canada. And climate change is expected to drive the spread northward. This map shows a projection for the spread of I. scapularis in 2050, as effected by climate warming. This map shows a projection for the spread of I. scapularis in 2080, as effected by climate warming. The reported annual incidence of I. pacificus spread, which is endemic in B.C., does not appear to be affected by temperature. This map of B.C. shows the geographic distribution of the Ixodes pacificus (I. pacificus) tick in the province as of 2004. The spread appears to encompass the most heavily populated regions of the province, and appears to be endemic to B.C. Over 20,000 new cases of lyme-borne disease have been reported since 2002 in the U.S. every year. In 2002, 12,054 cases were reported among the 50.5 million inhabitants of those states that have endemic I. scapularis tick populations and have borders with eastern and central Canada (i.e. Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, upstate New York, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin and Minnesota)

Photos

W5 investigates: Why some Canadian doctors are misdiagnosing a crippling disease caused by a shape-shifting superbug -- until it's too late.

View Larger Image

Date: Sat. Nov. 14 2009 6:56 PM ET

David Leggett used to love the outdoors. He was a healthy, active, family man who enjoyed camping trips with his wife and two daughters. His job as a high school principal came with a long summer vacation -- the perfect time to enjoy Canada's vast stretches of wilderness.

That all changed in July 2004, after camping in a provincial park near Sudbury, Ont. "We were out hiking and then one day I couldn't hike anymore and my knee ballooned up. I felt really, really strange. I had no energy," Leggett recalled.

By October, Leggett was too ill to work. After doing some research on his own he suspected he might have Lyme disease -- but his doctors told him that was impossible because it was too rare in Ontario and it didn't exist where he had been camping. They were wrong.

These days Leggett spends his time lying in bed, unable to get up to eat or even bathe himself. Most of his Canadian doctors continue to insist he is not suffering from Lyme disease, even though a blood test from an American lab came back positive for Lyme.

The chameleon disease

Lyme disease is often called "the great imitator" because it presents like a variety of different diseases or neurological disorders. As a result, Lyme patients are commonly misdiagnosed with a number of other conditions, everything from multiple sclerosis and Parkinson's disease to autism and even schizophrenia.

Lyme disease is the most common tick-borne disease in the Northern Hemisphere. It's transmitted to humans by the bite of a tick infected with the bacterium Borrelia burgdorferi.

Early symptoms may include fever, headache, fatigue, muscle and joint pains as well as a characteristic 'bulls eye' rash. Generally, if the illness is treated early the infection and its symptoms can be eliminated by antibiotics. If left untreated, however, the bacteria can move through the bloodstream and more serious symptoms can develop, which can be disabling and increasingly difficult to treat.

Professor George Chaconas a University of Calgary researcher, has spent the last 10 years studying the Borrelia burgdorferi bacteria that causes Lyme disease. According to Chaconas, it's the bacteria's ability to change the proteins on its coat that makes it so elusive to the immune system.

"The organism is like a strange visitor from another planet," Chaconas told W5. "It's in a perpetual masquerade party and each time you start recognizing it, it puts on a new disguise and escapes your immune system," he said.

This may be one of the reasons why Canadian doctors often misdiagnose the disease, or simply don't test for it.

Medical ignorance

Jim Wilson, who founded the Canadian Lyme Disease Foundation after contracting the disease himself, insists Canadian doctors need to do a better job educating themselves. "The enemy here is ignorance, it's arrogance and it's the lack of impetus of our present system to get off its heiny and go do the research that we need to do," said Wilson.

He maintains that the medical establishment's ignorance about Lyme disease is forcing many Canadians to seek expensive treatment outside the country. "We know families in just about every province now who've lost their homes trying to get treatment," said Wilson.

In 2007, only 109 patients were officially diagnosed with Lyme disease in Canada. During that same year, there were nearly 13,000 confirmed Lyme cases in the American states bordering Canada.

"Ticks don't carry passports. They don't stop at the border, so to think that we don't have Lyme disease in Canada, I think is not realistic," Chaconas said.

Ontario has the highest number of reported cases in the country, with 411 documented cases since 2000, when the province first started tracking them.

In an interview with W5, Dr. David Williams, Associate Chief Medical Officer of Health for Ontario, acknowledges that his fellow physicians have been slow to realize that Lyme is a serious problem.

"Some were saying a few years back it doesn't exist in Canada, it's a Northeast State thing. Now we said it is in Ontario. We've been pushing our Canadian partners saying this is something in Canada we have to be aware of," said Williams.

For David Leggett, any greater awareness of the danger of Lyme disease comes too late. His disease has progressed so far, he worries it may no longer be curable. "I do want to get well. Do I think I'm going to get there? I don't know. To be honest, it doesn't appear that way," he said.

Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's W5 Stories

When it comes to shopping for a second-hand vehicle most buyers are wary of smooth-talking used salespeople who may try to sell you a lemon.

W5: Buyer beware of used car deals

More  2 Video(s) 2