Top Stories -   

1
Deb Freele, 58, of London, Ontario, Canada recovers at West Park Hospital in Cody, Wyo. on Thursday, July 29, 2010. (AP / Cody Enterprise, Scott Salisbury) Deb Freele appears on ABC's Good Morning America, Thursday, July 29, 2010. Government agents help Don Wilhelm pack up his campsite at the Soda Butte Campground Wednesday afternoon July 28, 2010 after they were evacuated following a fatal bear attack in the early morning hours in Cooke City, Mont. At least one bear rampaged through a heavily occupied campground Wednesday near Yellowstone National Park in the middle of the night, killing one person and injuring two others during a terrifying attack that forced people to hide in their cars as an animal tore through tents. (AP / The Daily Chronicle, Nick Wolcott) A FWP employee patrols the area where a man was killed by a bear in the Soda Butte campground early Wednesday, July 28, 2010 in Cooke City, Mont. (AP Photo/Billings Gazette, David Grubbs) Deb Freele

Officials nab grizzly that attacked Ontario woman

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Todd Battis reports
An Ontario woman woke up in her tent with a bear gnawing on her arm. She played dead and survived the savage attack near Yellowstone National Park, but other campers weren't so lucky. The grizzly killed one man and injured another.
CTV News Channel: Jim Pissot, conservationist
According to Jim Pissot of the WildCanada Conservation Alliance, the attack on an Ontario woman by a grizzly bear was an extremely unusual and abnormal attack.
CTV News Channel: Ron Aasheim, spokesperson
A spokesperson for Montana's department of fish, wildlife and parks discusses the recent bear attacks. He says the bear is still alive and tests are being done to determine if it is the same bear that is behind recent deadly attacks.
CTV News Channel: Deb Freele, attacked by bear
Speaking from Wyoming, who survived a grizzly bear attack in Montana says she is 'feeling pretty good considering' and expects to be released from hospital by Sunday.
CTV News Channel: Ont. victim describes attack
Ontario woman Deb Freele describes what she did after she woke up in her tent Wednesday morning and found a bear chewing on her arm.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (48) Facebook   

Deb Freele, 58, of London, Ontario, Canada recovers at West Park Hospital in Cody, Wyo. on Thursday, July 29, 2010. (AP / Cody Enterprise, Scott Salisbury) Deb Freele appears on ABC's Good Morning America, Thursday, July 29, 2010. Government agents help Don Wilhelm pack up his campsite at the Soda Butte Campground Wednesday afternoon July 28, 2010 after they were evacuated following a fatal bear attack in the early morning hours in Cooke City, Mont. At least one bear rampaged through a heavily occupied campground Wednesday near Yellowstone National Park in the middle of the night, killing one person and injuring two others during a terrifying attack that forced people to hide in their cars as an animal tore through tents. (AP / The Daily Chronicle, Nick Wolcott) A FWP employee patrols the area where a man was killed by a bear in the Soda Butte campground early Wednesday, July 28, 2010 in Cooke City, Mont. (AP Photo/Billings Gazette, David Grubbs) Deb Freele

Photos

Deb Freele, 58, of London, Ontario, Canada recovers at West Park Hospital in Cody, Wyo. on Thursday, July 29, 2010. (AP / Cody Enterprise, Scott Salisbury)

View Larger Image

Date: Thu. Jul. 29 2010 9:44 PM ET

On Wednesday morning, Deb Freele woke up suddenly when she felt something enter the tent she was sharing with her husband at a Montana campground.

A grizzly bear was right behind where she lay, and was moments from attacking.

"I opened my eyes, I hadn't moved and then I felt the bear crunch down on my arm," Freele told CTV News Channel during a telephone interview from Cody, Wyoming, on Thursday.

"He was behind me when he was biting me, all I could see was stars…I was pretty well blind with pain."

The attack happened in the early hours of Wednesday morning when Freele and her husband were camping at Montana's Soda Butte campground, near the famed Yellowstone National Park.

Freele was one of three victims who were attacked at the campground in the early hours of the morning.

The same bear killed 48-year-old Kevin Kammer of Grand Rapids, Michigan, and injured another male in separate attacks that wildlife officials said were the worst such incidents in the Yellowstone area in more than 20 years.

When the bear clamped down on Freele's arm, the veteran camper from London, Ont., began to scream at the bear, which kept on chewing.

Her husband slept through both the screaming and the silence that followed.

"The bear was very quiet," Freele said. "Even when he was gnawing on me, he didn't make any noise," she added, referring to the bear.

Freele then made a choice to go silent and play dead.

"I'm going to die if I don't do something differently," she recalled thinking.

Asked about the challenge of remaining silent, Freele said it's "hard to refrain from screaming while he's chewing on you, but you can do it."

On Thursday morning, wildlife officials reported that a female grizzly and two of her cubs had been captured inside Soda Butte.

Fish, Wildlife and Parks Warden Capt. Sam Sheppard said officials are confident they have captured the bear that attacked the Soda Butte campers.

He described the incident as an unusual, predatory attack by a grizzly bear.

"She basically targeted the three people and went after them," Sheppard said. "It wasn't like an archery hunter who gets between a sow and her cubs and she responds to protect them."

Sheppard said the mother will be killed and officials must still determine what will happen to its cubs.

Jim Pissot, with the WildCanada Conservation Alliance, called the episode "an extremely rare, unusual, abnormal attack."

"There are a lot of unanswered questions," he told CTV News Channel. "Most bears, including the bears in Yellowstone, are largely vegetarian and so there's no reason for them to be attracted to people at all.

"This is a female bear with cubs," he added. "But this doesn't explain why the bear apparently aggressively moved into three tents. This is what's very odd about this circumstance."

In a separate interview with ABC's Good Morning America, Freele said she remembered attacks that happened in Yellowstone years ago -- and that playing dead was the recommended course of action.

"It was something that I had remembered reading, to play dead," Freele said from Cody, Wyoming on Thursday morning. "I remembered the attacks in '68 that happened in Yellowstone and that was one of the points, I think."

Don Wilhelm was camping with his family in the campsite next to Freele.

He first heard the scream of another camper, deciding that it could be teenagers, or possibly a domestic dispute.

A few minutes later he heard the nearby screams of Freele.

"First she said, "No!' Then we heard her say, 'It's a bear! I've been attacked by a bear!" said Wilhelm's wife, Paige.

The couple then grabbed their two boys, ran to their SUV and drove around the campground honking and yelling to alert other campers about the bears.

Along the way they met with a truck leaving the campground with a teenage boy whose leg was chewed by the same bear. The youth had punched it in the nose in an attempt to scare it away.

An estimated 600 grizzly bears and hundreds of black bears are believed to reside in the Yellowstone area.

Authorities are unsure what prompted Wednesday's attacks, as all of the victims had stored their food properly while camping.

"They were doing things right," Sheppard said after the attacks were reported. "It was random. I have no idea why this bear picked these three tents out of all the tents there."

The Soda Butte campground has 27 sites in total, spread across 10 acres of land in Gallatin National Forest.

Now recovering from severe lacerations and crushed bones, Freele said she will still go camping in future -- though she admits it will take time to get over the horrifying experience.

With files from The Associated Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Jim in the West
said

I understand and agree with the principle that animals must be destroyed once they have tasted human flesh. As all meat eaters know, all meat has a distinctive taste - chicken notwithstanding. Humans are apparently exceptionally flavourful, and therefore we quickly become the snackfood of choice. It might not have been the bear's fault, but realistically there was no choice but to put it down.


Russ
said

I hope that no-one will take from this story that "playing dead" is always the safe course of action in a grizzly encounter. There is prodigious research (mostly compiled by Prof Herrerro at the U of Calgary) demonstrating that, depending on the nature of the encounter, the best defence is sometimes a good offence (i.e. fighting back). I hike as often as I can in the Alberta and Montana Rockies, and it seems to me that I and others who frequent grizzly habitat have an obligation, not only to ourselves but also to those animals, to make an effort to learn at least the basics about their behaviour, and of course to carry bear spray to avoid maulings (which tend, after all, to end badly for both hiker and bear).


Steve
said

I'm pretty sure the bear will attack a sleeping person anytime but after attacking somone and then they play dead the bear thinks it has made it's kill and nolonger needs to attack.


t-baychris
said

How do we know it was the same bear? Seems to me that people feel justified hunting an animal as revenge without ever truly knowing if they have caught the right one. I have no sympathy for those who wander into an animal's territory and then get attacked. We haven't left them much space yet we continously encroach on that space; if an animal defends their territory and a person is injured or killed, tough luck! Let the animal go and continue being just that.


Kent Parker
said

First of all there's no gaurantee that anything will work for a Grizzly on a rampage. Is it safe to say that when building our homes we insure there are no living things on the property to insure we don't 'damage' any living things home? Really now, camping in the great outdoors is a risk but in no means should be avoided. Over 1 million visitors to yellowstone a year, 5 bear attacks. Do the math people!


Beachtree
said

I am not trying to blame the victim here (glad she is going to be alright)but it begs the question - What would you do if there was a lot of bears in your home? We keep moving closer and closer to wildlife and then are surprised when something tragic like this happens. That bear should not be put down, she was just defending her home.


Jen
said

I would like to respond to some of the commenters on this article. My mom (Deb) is the person being interviewed in this story. She is telling her story because she believes that it may help others survive in the future if one of these extremely rare attacks occurs again. She knew what to do because she had read someone else's account of being attacked by a Grizzly bear. Also, she is stuck in the hospital for a few days so the media know how to find her - unlike the other young man. I also feel that I have to say that bears normally do not behave the way this one did. I love nature and believe that humans have done atrocious things towards animals along the way, but this attack came on silently and unprovoked. It is a sad thing that this will likely end in the death of a bear, but I don't think it would be safe to release that particular bear into the wild after it has behaved this way. My prayers go out to the family of the man who died during this attack. I know the amount of fear and shock I went through just hearing about my mom's attack. I can't begin to fathom the depth of that family's shock and grief.


@Andrea
said

It says it is a grizzly, but I think it sounds more like the behaviour of a predacious black bear. If it were indeed a black bear than she could have also fought it off.


bewildered in ONT
said

For everyone who thinks its okay to run away while a Grizzly eats any human alive , I say shame on you. If that was your Wife/Mother or sister would you not at least try ? Of course you would !!! , When will Humanity finally start acting like Humanity ?


Bewildered in ONT
said

I totally agree with "Intelligent Liberal" Comment "the cowardly neighbor ".The stories focus should have been on the whole of the groups reaction or there lack of.Not just the personnel account of one lady ,whom in the heat of the moment decided to play dead ,rather then fighting back. Statistics have proven that standing your ground and fighting back will greatly increase your odds of survival against a Bear attack .I believe this lady just got lucky. The Young boy whom punched the bear in the nose ,should be commended for his bravery. As far as the Cowardly couple who didn't think of the welfare of their neighbor ,but only their own self preservation. I am sure Karma will balance that out eventually.


Dimaggio
said

Arm for an Arm!! or in this case head for a head. This bear should be put down without question! Our justice system could learn a valuable lesson, from the way we deal with animals in this situation.. People convicted of homicide should face the same penalty as the bear.. Put it down!!!! All of you animal lovers would feel quite different if this happened to someone in your family. get real and end this bears rampage!!


Nanook
said

Good thing for that bear she left Chuck Norris's tent alone! Or there'd be two orphan cubs this morning!Good thing for the bear she didn't bite Paris Hilton's tent either. Heebee jeebies are tough to heal from.


Diane Cole
said

It's disgraceful to think that because a human intruded into the bears natural habitat that it will be killed......the poor wildlife can't win, they stay in the forest they are at risk they come into the city and again they are the ones at fault...when will we learn?


Linda in Vancouver
said

I know that black bears are very good at climbing trees.I've watched them swinging from the very tops of fruit trees as they forage for apples and plums.Grizzly bears,I am not sure, but I think they are less skiiled.You really are foolish to assume you can are safe if all you can do is climb a tree.One problem would be how do you get your butt up the tree without turning your back to run to that tree. People who think we can solve this problem by just not going into "bear country" know nothing of what they speak.Most of the continent is "bear country".Or,at least,once was.Like seals in the Arctic region,there seems to be more bears now than at any time in recent history.Especially black bears.You are never completely safe in any forest area.You can mitigate the risk,but never will you eliminate it.We camped in tents,and even slept under the stars for decades,and never had a problem.Though I will say,I see more bears everywhere in BC now,than we did in the past.Given that,we take a lot more precautions,and rarely sleep under the stars any more.Perhaps I'm more risk averse as I get older and wiser.Or perhaps the bears are moving closer to get that free meal.But avoiding the wilderness all together is not on my agenda either.That is existing,not living. And please.Stop picking on Intelligent Liberal everyday.Those posts are my laugh of the day, and absolute proof that switching from voting Liberal,to voting Conservative,was the right choice for me.Hilarious!! Just by claiming to be an Intelligent Liberal,the poster's sense of self righousness,elitism,and arrogance is fully exposed,for all to see.


Dave S
said

@ Jim in Ottawa
Bears are very pridictable it is humans that are not. If you are willing to go into their habitat and camp then you also take the related risks of getting hurt.
Leave the damn bears alone, release the bear back into its home with the cubs.....As humans we just figure that if any other creature on earth has misdeeds with us we will kill it GO BEARS
Dave from Alberta


Tabucur
said

Play dead with a Griz, and you live. But when it comes to Black Bears, fight for your life. In the past several years, Black Bears have turned predacious on humans, and have been known to kill and eat people.Remember the incident in Algonquin park a few years ago involving a Husband and Wife, who were both killed and half eaten. When a black bear is stocking you as pray they approach calmly and slow, or charge without provocation.


Rick
said

Both Black bears and grizzlies are meat eaters. A grizzly is extremely territorial and will defenend their territory completely, and won't hesitate to shred any opposition. Avoidance is the best defence against them but when an aggresive encounter occurs, becoming extremely passive, going limp or "playing dead" is usually your best option. The grizzly' s nasal cavity is hollow to the brain and does contain a "sweet spot" which is why a punch to the snout will sometimes drive them off. They have also been dropped by incredibly lucky and accurate shots by small calibre rifles. Black bears are very fond of meat and have a large hunting area and are opportunistic while hunting. They will general avoid people so being noisy in the bush is wise to help keep them ate a distance. Should they become starled or smell your food there will be aconfrontation. Do not play dead with a black bear as it will drag you off and eat you later. Fighting them and making as much noise is the best defence in this case.


B. Kelley, Ontario
said

@jack - So you want the bear psychoanalyzed to see if she's criminally responsible or not? When a bear turns predatory toward humans then she will not stop. She can't be rehabilitated and must be killed or she will attack again. Those who say that people should not be in the bear's territory need to rethink their opinion. Just where is it written that people should be banned from any place on the earth? We have more right to be there than the animals do because we collectively own the land. Animals are not human and have no legal or moral rights to anything. It is a human responsibility to look after and preserve their best interests with compassion and care but that does not translate to them having some kind of superior privilege over people. Let's get things in balance here. The term "animal rights" is an oxymoron.


Jeff
said

Poor Intelligent Liberal has never been north of Eglinton and probably thought all along that bears ate honey like Winnie the Pooh.


Mark
said

"Intelligent Liberal" Why is it all about her? A teenaged boy punched the bear in the nose since the bear was chewing his leg. Another man was KILLED by the same bear! Why the story focuses on a person lamely playing dead, and on the cowardly couple who decided the best action to help a neighbour getting beared was to get in their SUV and drive around the campsite.Well smarty pants, perhaps the story is about her is because she was the one that got interviewed? As for the "cowardly couple", what would you have done? Would you have rushed in to save them from the grizzly?? Would you still be an Intelligent Liberal after that or just bear droppings? For an "Intelligent Liberal" you made some mighty unintelligent comments.


Chris
said

Some tipsBears are very territorial (mainly males)! They will kill to protect their turf especially when there is lack of food or a food source close. Each bear covers a large area. Even though you can store your food away from you camp site, dumping cooking or cleaning water next to your site can attract them! As well dirty pots and pans (anything that has food sent). Keep separate clothes to sleep in (non scented) , not the ones you are wearing to cook, eat, fish etc., Store dirty clothes away from your tent. As well do not take fragrant stuff in your tent (perfumes, hair sprays etc.) Put them in your vehicle. Park your vehicle next to your tent if possible as a deterrent as well for an escape route. Take an air horn, flare gun or bear spray. Do not take a Dog! Bears are sometime attracted to dogs barking. Chris


Alexis
said

Why are they going to kill the mother and leave two orphaned cubs? Yes, one of these bears did attack a human, but that human was in THE BEAR'S territory! Why should another animal die for doing what comes naturally?


Peter in MB
said

OMG Intelligent Liberal! I cant believe you have the nerve to Critique and insult someone who was attacked by a bear. How would you like it if someone Critique and insulted you when you got hurt.


Sam C
said

@Bob from NL -- black bears may be the largest on the Rock, but not on the continent. Grizzlies make black bears look like house pets. @JamesT -- no, it makes sense to me. The bear chewing on her arm was just checking her out - if he had wanted to eat her, he would have. She is very lucky.


jac
said

I feel sorry for those that got injured or died from this event. But, we really have to start asking - are we invading the bear's space??? From the news report, it seems as though the bear was some criminal. There were statements like, "we caught the culprit bear", "its going to be put down" Was this bear hungry due to lack of food? If so, why didn't authorities keep tabs of lack of food in the area (eg berries)Was this bear fearless due to people being careless with their garbage? Was this bear squeezed out of its territory due to humans encroaching on its living room (eg building home nearby or the camp site getting to big). Bears don't normally just attack humans. They either have to be prevoked or something abnormal is happening in the surrounding area (most likely human influnced).

B. Kelley, Ontario
said

@intelligent(?) liberal. The couple you criticize for getting in their SUV had good reason to do so. They had children they needed to protect. Would you have suggested they leave them in the tent so they could become dessert? On top of that, you obviously have never encountered a predatory grizzly in attack mode. You don't just walk up to one and say "shoo!". If you don't have a heavy calibre gun then you might as well invite him to dine - on you.


mohammed_luvs_pork
said

"intelligent liberal"....oh my gosh!...Now...that is FUNNY!...lol...lol.."intelligent liberal"...as IF there is such a thing!...lol...


Colleen
said

For the people who are wondering how playing dead is differen't than sleeping read the first paragraphs. It says that she was screaming (so she obviously woke up). She then stopped screaming and played dead.


Jim in Ottawa
said

Bears are very dangerous and unpredictable creatures. I urge everyone to exercise caution when enjoying the great outdoors.


ann
said

I don't understand why everytime a wild animal kills or injures a human that we should kill it. This is a mommy grizzly bear with her cubs and I bet she thought the campers were a threat. Why not clear the region from campers and restrict people from camping in the region ? Animals are always wild and unpredictable....this is the chance we take when we go on their territory. Everytime I hike, I know there is a chance something could happen. If I ever got killed by a bear I definetely wouldn't want that bear killed.



Jon
said

Why kill the mother bear? It was just being a bear. Relocate it to an area not frequented by humans.


Yor from London
said

Black bears are expert climbers. Their ability to do so tens of thousands of years ago in order to escape the bigger bear Arctodus, the short-faced bear. Don't run, don't climb. Make lots of noise, stretch your arms up high in the air, and scare the bear away. When I shot a bear one time, the first thing he did was to try and climb a tree.


Joe
said

Why kill the bear? Is in its habitat & trying to survive. Why do these "people" go to these places if there is such a risk? You come into my home & I will probably do more than bite your arm...

I hope the bear is ok.


Alvin Cees
said

Bears can climb faster than they can run you know. Bears, Beets, Battlestar Galactica.


Anne
said

We're in trouble now.... wild life starting to fight back.ps. Rob... Bob said meat eaters not maneaters.


Doug # BC
said

I have to ask the same question as "James T Murphy" asked.Unless she stopped breathing while she was playing dead,I fail to see a big difference between sleeping and playing dead. Cruious though.I grew up on the north coast of BC,in quite a small town.When we were kids we camped and played in the forests all the time and only rarerly saw a bear.And I don't ever re-call anyone beiong attacked by a bear.In recent years I have been visiting the same place for fishing vactions,and the hills are alive with bears running everywhere.It seems to me that the Black Bear population in that particular area has grown tremendously.

Shaun
said

Rob,He said they were 'bran eaters' not man eaters. Very health conscious bears in N.L.


Intelligent Liberal
said

Why is it all about her? A teenaged boy punched the bear in the nose since the bear was chewing his leg. Another man was KILLED by the same bear! Why the story focuses on a person lamely playing dead, and on the cowardly couple who decided the best action to help a neighbour getting beared was to get in their SUV and drive around the campsite.


Brian
said

Now the bear will probably be hunted down and killed because they say that once an animal (be it a bear, tiger, wild cat etc) kills a human, it wants more.

This poor animal will have its life ended short because humans, the most arrogant species to ever walk this planet, decided it would be fun to sleep in their home. All this bear did was live naturally. If you found someone sleeping in your home, would you not take action? The bear did, and now my moneys on that it'll be killed.

I'm glad that the woman is okay, but in some ways, maybe we need more deaths by bears to finally get it through our thick skulls that sleeping in wild animal sanctuaries isn't the best of ideas.

Live and let be, humans.


Andrea
said

WAs it a black bear or a grizzly bear?


Janice Anderson
said

Two years ago in on the September long weekend we were in Glacier Park. The park is beautiful and the road was thickly treed. We were driving and about to turn a corner on our way out of the park. When we had to stand on our brakes.The road before us was littered with cars all stopped. The people were out of their cars. We found out that they had seen a Grizzly bear and they all wanted to see it . I thought what kind of brain does it take to abondon your car on a used road. The people had been joined by park rangers as they apparently watched the bear come down from the mountain and eventually cross the road and heade into the long grass on the other side of the road. While we were there someone saw a cougar in the long grass by the road. One tourist entered the grass to get a picture of the cougar. I thought this is one of the stupidest things I have seen.I cannot decide which was more dangerouse the animals or those that abandoned their cars possibly causing an accident. The tourist in his Burmuda shorts seemed out of his element all together, especially in his excitement to get a picture of the cougar. Glacier is a beautiful park, but there are signs for beware of the animals everywhere. We stayed at Cody and it was a really nice and friendly town. We are planing to go back this fall.This bear inccident seemed unprovoked. I wonder if the Rangers that were therewere protecting the animals from the people.


Rob
said

Bob from NLHow mamy people have been eaten by bears in NL to justify your remark " Black bears in NL are maneaters"


Wayne C
said

Why don't people STAY out of the wildlife sanctuaries. There are plenty of safer places where they do not run the risk of disturbing the wildlife in THEIR home. We get pissed when they come to the city and we get pissed when they are aggressive in their home turf....which way do we want it? Leave them alone.


Andy
said

I was taught, depending on the size of the bear to stand on my toes, increase my height and width and the not to look directly at the bear, as he/she wouldn't challenge me then. I guess when you're on the ground different story? Glad to hear she and the young boy are okay.


Bob from NL
said

I'm very relieved that this woman lived to tell her tale. You wouldn't want to try that with the black bears in NL - they're meat eaters and the largest on the continent.

w.e. coyote
said

why have so many bears? Yellowstone is a WILD ANIMAL NATIONAL PARK.... why so many bears lol.


James T Murphy
said

She was sleeping and the bear was chewing on her. So for defense she decided to play dead. Isn't sleeping like playing dead? The bear attacks when she is sleeping and retreats when she plays dead. Am I the only one that thinks this doesn't sound right?


Terry from Pickering
said

A strong willed person like herself just saved her own life playing dead, it was a chance she had to take or she would have been for sure killed and why have so many bears, people take so much chance to camp in a well populated area of bears, everyone camping got to keep there eyes open or sleep with one eye open.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

RCMP looking for Sawyer Clarke Robison, 27, considered a person of interest in shootings of two of RCMP members.

Person of interest sought in Alberta RCMP shooting

More  3 Video(s) 3

Let's Talk, Bell Let's Talk

LIVE Chat: #LetsTalk Mental Health

More

David Armando Blancas-Hernandez, 45, is seen in this undated image. Blancas-Hernandez was killed in the fatal collision. (Handout)

Driver in fatal crash did not hold proper licence: OPP

More   43 Comments 43    8 Video(s) 8