Top Stories -   

1
A worker monitors the water in Talmadge Creek in Marshall Township, Mich., near the Kalamazoo River as oil from a ruptured pipeline, owned by Enbridge Inc, is vacuumed out the water Thursday, July 29, 2010. (AP / Paul Sancya) A worker monitors water in Talmadge Creek in Marshall Township, Mich., near the Kalamazoo River as oil from a ruptured pipeline, owned by Enbridge Inc, is attempted to be trapped by booms Thursday, July 29, 2010. (AP / Paul Sancya) This July 28, 2010 photo provided by the State of Michigan shows what Michigan officials say is a sheen of oil on Morrow Lake in Kalamazoo County. (AP / State of Michigan) Raul Vervuzco of Eagle Services uses a suction hose to clean oil from atop the Kalamazoo River in a containment area in Augusta, Mich., Wednesday, July 28, 2010. (AP / The Kalamazoo Gazette, Jonathon Gruenke) A Canada goose covered in oil attempts to fly out of the Kalamazoo River in Marshall, Mich., Tuesday, July 27, 2010. (AP / Kalamazoo Gazette, Jonathon Gruenke) John Corcoran, center, and Cam Meyers, right, watch from the 15 Mile Road bridge as oil flows in the Kalamazoo River Tuesday, July 27, 2010, in Marshall, Mich.(AP Photo/The Kalamazoo Gazette, Jonathon Gruenke) Frank Roberts, left, and Trever Miller, contract workers for Enbridge, Inc., Calgary, Canada, discuss the operation of placing booms across the Kalamazoo River, on Morrow Lake, Kalamazoo, County, Galesburg, Mich., in attempts to contain the growing oil spill, Wednesday, July 28, 2010. (AP / Shawano Cleary) Oil

Regulators warned Enbridge months before spill

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Omar Sachedina in Michigan
Officials have ordered an evacuation in Michigan after several million litres of oil spilled into a waterway. The spill stems from an energy pipeline owned by Canada's Enbridge, which is facing harsh criticism over the clean up.
CTV News Channel: Officials update on the spill
Enbridge continues to monitor air and water sources as more resources are pouring into the area to deal with the spill on the Kalamazoo River in Michigan.
Canada AM: Lauren Krugel, Canadian Press
A correspondent in Calgary shares local reaction to Canadian oil giant Enbridge doubling the manpower and equipment for a cleanup operation after more than three million litres of oil spilled into Michigan's Kalamazoo River.
CTV National News: Janet Dirks reports
Over three million litres of oil is spilling into the Kalamazoo River in Michigan, coating birds and fish in the crude. The pipeline owned by Canada's Enbridge has been leaking since Monday as the oil giant doubles its effort to clean it up.
CTV News Channel: Mary Dettloff, spokesperson
The Michigan Department of Natural Resources' Mary Dettloff says it has been a challenge for Enbridge to get a repair crew to where the leak is because its in a swampy area.
CTV News Channel: Tim Martin, Associated Press
A correspondent with the Associated Press says Enbridge feels very confident that it will be able to stop the flow of oil fairly quickly and has made it a top priority to put more resources out there to deal with the issue.
CTV News Channel: Update by officials on oil spill
Speaking from Battle Creek, Mich., officials discuss a leak from an oil pipeline that has spilled over 3 million litres of oil and say that they are focused on excavating to access the pipe and find the cause of the leak and increasing the number of booms.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (22) Facebook   

A worker monitors the water in Talmadge Creek in Marshall Township, Mich., near the Kalamazoo River as oil from a ruptured pipeline, owned by Enbridge Inc, is vacuumed out the water Thursday, July 29, 2010. (AP / Paul Sancya) A worker monitors water in Talmadge Creek in Marshall Township, Mich., near the Kalamazoo River as oil from a ruptured pipeline, owned by Enbridge Inc, is attempted to be trapped by booms Thursday, July 29, 2010. (AP / Paul Sancya) This July 28, 2010 photo provided by the State of Michigan shows what Michigan officials say is a sheen of oil on Morrow Lake in Kalamazoo County. (AP / State of Michigan) Raul Vervuzco of Eagle Services uses a suction hose to clean oil from atop the Kalamazoo River in a containment area in Augusta, Mich., Wednesday, July 28, 2010. (AP / The Kalamazoo Gazette, Jonathon Gruenke) A Canada goose covered in oil attempts to fly out of the Kalamazoo River in Marshall, Mich., Tuesday, July 27, 2010. (AP / Kalamazoo Gazette, Jonathon Gruenke) John Corcoran, center, and Cam Meyers, right, watch from the 15 Mile Road bridge as oil flows in the Kalamazoo River Tuesday, July 27, 2010, in Marshall, Mich.(AP Photo/The Kalamazoo Gazette, Jonathon Gruenke) Frank Roberts, left, and Trever Miller, contract workers for Enbridge, Inc., Calgary, Canada, discuss the operation of placing booms across the Kalamazoo River, on Morrow Lake, Kalamazoo, County, Galesburg, Mich., in attempts to contain the growing oil spill, Wednesday, July 28, 2010. (AP / Shawano Cleary) Oil

Photos

A worker monitors the water in Talmadge Creek in Marshall Township, Mich., near the Kalamazoo River as oil from a ruptured pipeline, owned by Enbridge Inc, is vacuumed out the water Thursday, July 29, 2010. (AP / Paul Sancya)

View Larger Image

Date: Thu. Jul. 29 2010 8:24 PM ET

U.S. regulators warned a subsidiary of Enbridge in January that it wasn't adequately monitoring the corrosion of a Michigan pipeline that leaked an estimated 3.8 million litres of oil into the Kalamazoo River this week.

The Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration at the U.S. Department of Transportation informed the Canadian company's chairman, Terry Gill, in writing on Jan. 21. It said that Enbridge's monitoring of corrosion in Line 6B was out of line with U.S. regulations.

Months later, the pipeline spilled several million litres of oil into Talmadge Creek, a tributary of the Kalamazoo River.

An Enbridge spokesperson contacted by The Associated Press on Thursday declined to comment on the letter.

It's not the first time the company has caught the attention of a government agency in the United States. Since 2002, Enbridge and its affiliates have been cited 30 times by the Department of Transportation's regulatory branch.

The governor of Michigan has been putting pressure on Enbridge to clean up the oil, which had travelled 55 kilometres downstream by late Wednesday.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has taken control of clean-up efforts. But Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm said the U.S. government needed to provide more help, and called the work undertaken by Enbridge and the EPA "wholly inadequate."

The oil has flowed through a city of 52,000 called Battle Creek, which is located 175 kilometres west of Detroit, and is making its way towards Kalamazoo, the area's largest city.

There were conflicting reports from government officials as to whether the oil had surpassed a dam, which some had hoped could help contain the spill.

If the oil were to reach Lake Michigan, which lies 128 kilometres away, it would represent a "tragedy of historic proportions," Granholm said.

Enbridge president and chief executive Patrick Daniel has said the company is "committing to cleaning up anything and everything" that the oil touches outside of the pipeline.

He has also said the company had made "significant progress" in the race to contain the spill, but stopped short of providing information on how long it will take to clean up the mess.

Enbridge has so far put 300 people to work on the Michigan river, placing nearly 4.3 kilometres of protective booms on the river by the end of Wednesday. It will also dig up its pipe to determine what caused the leak.

The company detected the oil leak in its pipeline on Monday in Michigan's Talmadge Creek.

Before the leak could be repaired, the oil flowed into the Kalamzoo River and Morrow Lake.

With files from The Associated Press and a report from CTV's Janet Dirks

Comments are now closed for this story

mike
said

PAUL west coast i see you live in the green peace world so how do you think we should live , you are polluting right now by useing your computer we will be needing oil for a long time to come and i have not heard one of you smart persons say alta can keep it,s transfer funds we do not need them.


Paul
said

Govenor Granholm flexing some Canadian muscle...you go girl!


ROB VIARS
said

i do think now .....since 3 oil spills and or leaks in a 3 months is no qoincidence...... we need to look outside the box and think maybe sabatoge gd be a thought....


Albertan
said

The Governor of the State has no experience in OIL (working that is) in order to comment on the efforts involved by her own citizens. I commend those that acted FAST and prevented further damage. To all - ANY Spill after the Gulf will be criticized because of what has happened and EVERYONE will be on edge it doesn't happen to them. As for the little boys comment about swimming - you won't be swimming for awhile (2-3 years - safety first). Also, get yourself some good PPE (Personal Protective Equipment to wear around the spill - personnel safety is first and foremost).


Steveo
said

Well then Paul West Coast...maybe you can start by not using your oil powered automobile...


Vince M
said

Paul West Coast: "Enbridge has a poor track record in respect to oil spills." Can you clarify? Are you saying they have a poor track record in spill frequency or in mitigation response? I'm not seeing entries in the ERCB database that they have a "poor" record in either.


Gordo
said

Paul WC, please advise of other Enbridge events that contribute to their "poor track record in respect to oil spills". Having worked in the transmission pipeline industry, specifically pipeline integrity for 17 years, and more than occasionally very near to Enbridge facilities, I can't think of one.


mike
said

the govener is trying to look like she is there runing the show , too SCORE points with the voters if she would just shut up and work with the company instead of pissing off the managment then i bet things would get better fast,work together fix it . THEN point fingers if you must


Michael
said

Aleks--how can a ruptured pipeline be "irresponsible", or evidence of "irresponsibility"? Obviously the onus [sp] is on Enbridge, who has said that anything the oil touches or floats on will be cleaned up; what more do you want? or are you one of those who think the industrialzed world can do without petroleum and its byproducts? I have news for you: the Stone Age wasn't really THAT great. The other point I would like to make, more generally, is that the Governor of Michigan, Canadian-born she may be, might be up for re-election this autumn.


Vince M
said

The governor of Michigan is a Democrat. Of course she will complain. That's what (and is all that) Democrats do. Look at their role model.


Doug # BC
said

When all the dust settles,having two oil spills so close to home will almost certainly become a learning moment.After every air plane crash, a lot of people will find out exactly how and why each of these spills took place,and like one industry reduced crashes by building better air planes,this industry will learn to build better pipe lines.Challenges are there to help us move forward,not to frighten us into running away. Cute post by "Aleks Berland".I do agree that the ONUS is on the companies involved to repair the damage.I don't think anyone is challenging that point of view.Other than the reality that the ONUS is also on people who rely on,and use these products for their own survival.Your space talk is almost as hilarious as your assumption that more than 6 billion people can live on this planet and not leave a foot print,or run into problems.Do you have any idea how much oil and how many products are shipped,piped, hauled and toted around this planet every day with no problem at all? Were it not for container traffic from China, most of us wouldn't have the means to whine,on line,every day. So,here's the thing.We either cut the global population by about 30%,or we rise to the challenge of providing food,clothing,and shelter for even more millions of people.At this point in human history,there is no way we can avoid the spectacle of millions of starving people unless we use fossil fuels.I agree with the people who say we need to do a better job.But it is also true that the damage from these oil spills is still far less than the damage to us would be if oil was suddenly unavailable.Overpopulation and unrealistic expectations are the real problems.


Jim in Ottawa
said

I have complete confidence in the expertise and capabilities of the Enbridge team to contain this accident before anything untoward should happen.


Paul West Coast
said

Enbridge has a poor track record in respect to oil spills. The Federal Government is going to allow them to pipe oil from Alberta to the BC coast to container ships. This is devasting news for the environment both on land and ocean, for all species, including the human animals. We have got to get ourselves off oil; we need a new government who can move us in the direction of a cleaner world.


Peter
said

RE: Aleks,I don't think the other posts are downplaying the oil spill. They are commenting on the Governors comments, which I agree are ridiculous.


Mike of the north
said

OK my American cousins here we go again. Last time I commented it was about the Gulf spill, now another, in one of your rivers. Perhaps we Canadians should be more choosy about who we sell this valuable commodity too. Forget about building pipelines to receive raw crude, we should process it here and ship the finished product to you, it might be safer that way. But then again it's dirty oil, so I guess that wouldn't work!


Aleks Berland
said

I really don't follow the logic of some of these posts minimizing the signifcance of an oil spill by comparing it to the largests in world history. It's fair to say that an oil spill always has some human fault involved in it's occurence, so we are already talking about irresponsibility. Secondly, saying that a place is already polluted is ridiculous and infantile reasoning while asserting that parties acted responsibly. Regardless of the parameters of how, when, where, or to what extent an ecological disaster is wreaking havoc, the owness is ALWAYS on the corporation and responsible governmental parties to act quickly and effectively and even the slightest lag deserves full-blown criticism. Despite NASA's discovery of many new earth-like planets... they are 10s or hundreds of lightyears away...so essentially... this is the only planet we have, and setting precendents on ecological issues at this place in time is the tipping point towards reform or our own extinction let alone the natural world around us.


JB in Northern Ontario
said

This spill was shut off so more oil didn't leak out into the river. That right there is better than the BP spill. It also sounds like it is contained. The spill was contained quickly and effectively.If the Govenor thinks things aren't going good, then she can go out there and help out herself and realize it can't be done at the wave of a hand.


jjaycee
said

The Govenor convieniently does not mention that the Kalamazoo was poluted beyond belief before this happened. The water has been unfit for use for decades. Of course it will have to be left in pristine condition after the cleanup.


Sam C
said

Granholm is grand-standing. She is playing to those who think that an oil spill should be as easy to clean-up as spilt milk. Enbridge's response has been immediate and commendable. -- As an aside, there was an interesting comment in a 1995 edition of the 'Advisor,' a newsletter of the Great Lakes Commission, a Michigan public agency: "Backyard mechanics dump more used oil into Michigan's environment each year than the Exxon Valdez spilled into Alaska's Prince William Sound." Hopefully that is no longer the case.


Pugfire
said

Naturally coming on the heels of the Gulf event, this will be jumped on by all involved with both feet and there will be no lack of criticism regardless of who does what. If they had of had it cleaned up within 24 hours, the governor would complain that nobody consulted her on how to do it. A no win situation. I seriously doubt that anyone is deliberately dragging their heels on this, it's too high profile.


Rose
said

Accidents happen. From what I've seen, Enbridge got to work on the problem right away. Typical American criticism of foreigners. This isn't TV, where solutions come in 50-minute packages.


Raj
said

I have been following this, and I thought they did pretty good.They acted fast, can you imagine if this was the BP spill of the century.This looks like a dirty puddle


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt appears on CTV's Power Play on Monday, May 28, 2012.

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    12 Video(s) 12

Air Canada says it appears an engine part fell from the plane and crashed into the windshield of a car in Mississauga, Ont. on Monday, May 28, 2012.

Air Canada plane makes emergency landing in Toronto

More

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    4 Video(s) 4