Top Stories -   

1

For 1st time, family doctors more likely to be women

flu, cough, sick, cold, flu season medical contest
flu, cough, sick, cold, flu season

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (12) Facebook   

Date: Saturday Feb. 18, 2012 9:25 PM ET

When Dr. Anne Doig studied medicine in Saskatchewan 35 years ago, only about a third of her classmates were women.

Now, family doctors like her outnumber their male colleagues for the first time in Canada.

For Doig and those who've been tracking the white coat gender balance, the new data from the Canadian Medical Association show a clear trend that's set to continue.

As of January, there were 239 more women than men certified to practice family medicine -- a telling shift, although female doctors are still woefully underrepresented in many other specialties.

The number of female physicians and medical students has been steadily rising over the years. First-year medical school classes across Canada have been registering more women than men since 1997.

Even though 64 per cent of all active Canadian doctors are male, the fact that women now make up more than half of the largest medical specialty in Canada -- family practice -- is significant, the CMA says.

"We are witnessing a demographic transformation of what used to be a very male-dominated profession," CMA President John Haggie said in a recent article posted on the association's website. "A decade ago men outnumbered women in every specialty."

Now, seeing female physicians in various roles is "a fact of life" that reflects general societal trends, said Doig, who runs a practice and teaches medicine in Saskatoon.

Surgical specialties like neurosurgery, urology and orthopedics are still male domains, but women are making strides elsewhere.

They now account for nearly half of all Canadian obstetricians and gynecologists and outnumber men in geriatric medicine and pediatrics.

What's more, the CMA projects women will account for more than 45 per cent of Canadian doctors by 2025.

"It's certainly a positive...and it's been happening for years," Doig said in a phone interview with CTVNews.ca.

This growing cohort is also younger: more than two thirds of family doctors under age 35 are female.

Female physicians are also taking on more leadership roles in their communities, as well as on provincial and national levels. In August, Yellowknife emergency room doctor Anna Reid will become the third female president of the CMA since 2005. In the first 137 years of the organization's existence, only three other women held that role.

"It's an amazing feat," said Dr. Unjali Malhotra, a Vancouver family physician who specializes in women's health.

"There are a lot of women who want women (to treat them) and this really helps us with community care outreach," Malhotra told CTVNews.ca.

As a member of the Federation of Medical Women in Canada, Malhotra said the shift "creates a lot positive role models" for rookie doctors and girls considering a career in medicine.

"It's great to have that sisterhood for support," she said.

But changing demographics don't necessarily transform a patient's experience at the doctor's office, Doig said.

"I don't believe that the quality of being an excellent physician is tied to one gender or the other," she said. "There is a stereotype out there that a female doctor will spend more time with you, or be more compassionate. That's not true."

Malhotra agreed that there are a lot of "overgeneralizations" about a woman's bedside manner. Still, if a patient feels more comfortable with a female doctor, that could make a world of difference, she said.

In Doig's view, the biggest barriers to career advancements are now individual, not gender-based.

"And that's a good thing," she said.

Comments are now closed for this story

WSV
said
0 0

Factually, the reason there are more females in Family Medicine is because as a specialization, FM is the shortest duration in comparison to all of the other specialties. For a woman wanting to have a family, she cannot biologically afford to be spending upwards of 10 years in a residency program unable to settle down or have children until she is approaching 40 years old. By then, her biological clock will have run out. Men remain fertile until well into their seventies and beyond, making the time commitment to specialize in more complex fields like cardiothoracic and orthopedic surgery less burdensome.


EJ
said
0 0

I have had male doctors all my life. I'm in my mid 40's and I now find I now prefer a female doctor. My current one, a male, delivered my last 2 kids, and has been my family doctor for over 18 years. Not a thing wrong with him, excellent doctor. But I feel only a female doctor would really, truly understand my issues at this time in my life... well, because they are women too. So I think its great, personally that is. :)


Brian in BC
said
0 0

C'mon all you tough guys... when you were a kid and got an "owie" who did you run to, your Mom or your Dad? Why should that change now? I have two Doctors who are both women and are both excellent doctors. I have had male doctors in the past and I think that 'maternal instinct' gives women doctors an 'almost unfair' advantage. All throughout history men have gone out and killed supper or each other and the women stayed at the cave and cared for the family. That is the way we are programed, and that is what makes women good doctors.


pwonder
said
0 0

This seems to more and more common in all the health care professions. It would seem that men have less interest in a career in health care


gabby
said
0 0

It's unbelievable the comments I'm reading on here. We should be proud as Canadians that our medical system is growing to be more equitable. It's not as if med schools are holding men back in any way; they're just noticing a gender shift. The article says "Surgical specialties like neurosurgery, urology and orthopedics are still male domains, but women are making strides elsewhere. They now account for nearly half of all Canadian obstetricians and gynecologists and outnumber men in geriatric medicine and pediatrics."Clearly some specialties are still dominated by males, so this nonsense about "feminization" of Canada is unwarranted. Why all the threatening feelings about women being in a position of power? If you really wanted to, you could apply for med school, no one is stopping you... What it comes down to is intelligence and hard work. Regardless of whether your doctor is a man or a woman, you should hope to God they've studied hard and are good at what they do. Keep your gender-biased opinions of it.


Jaid in Toronto
said
0 0

As long as women don't tell men they should be doing the work like women do, this shouldn't matter one bit.


Iam
said
0 0

Out with the bad, in with the good. (thumbs up)


Yort
said
0 0

In truth, we are failing the male gender. Allowing them and enabling them to fill their free time with Video games, Porn, and other mindless media activities. If you think I am being cynical-wake up!


Prairie Boy
said
0 0

The feminization of Canada continues...


Ukie
said
0 0

Time for males to demand equal rights with their female counterparts now that the pendulum has swung the other way. Oh wait a minute, that wouldn't be fair, would it?


PTOL
said
0 0

Men are increasingly becoming irrelevant in our society. Go into any goverment office and you will see a 10 - 1 woman to man ratio. If you are a caucasian male in Canada you are a minority and are always put at the back of the line when it comes to opportunity. Special interests are taking over and it's scary. The 'Jezebel' mentality is starting to take effect and we will not enjoy the fruits - take my word for it. More and more women will be having children out of wedlock (to a man that is) and our future generations will suffer for it.


dan
said
0 0

Why are people so happy about this why does it matter. Now men are under-represented in family medicine. Should we be trying to get more men into family medicine now??, Whoever wants to become a doctor it shouldnt matter. Women outnumber men in many workplaces including mine. I am a medic in the mlitary. howevver nobody seems to care about the under representation of men.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt appears on CTV's Power Play on Monday, May 28, 2012.

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    12 Video(s) 12

Air Canada says it appears an engine part fell from the plane and crashed into the windshield of a car in Mississauga, Ont. on Monday, May 28, 2012.

Air Canada plane makes emergency landing in Toronto

More

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    4 Video(s) 4