Top Stories -   

1
beef Beef

Ethanol rules driving up beef prices, damaging industry

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Why the price of beef is rising
Al Mussell, an agricultural researcher, says the increase in grain costs to feed the animals is partly why the price of beef is rising, and explains how pork might eventually go up in price too.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (14) Facebook   

beef Beef

Photos

beef

View Larger Image

Date: Fri. Feb. 3 2012 10:39 AM ET

Beef and pork prices have risen dramatically in recent years and meat lovers can expect to pay even more for their favourite choice cuts as ethanol policies and rising export demands put pressure on the market.

Over the past 10 years, beef prices have risen by roughly 26 per cent, and pork prices have gone up by 14 per cent, said Al Mussell, a senior research associate at the George Morris Centre in Guelph and president of the Canadian Agricultural Economics Society.

Mussell, who has co-authored a new report on the subject, said a number of factors have contributed to drive up the price.

"There's been a lot of growth in export demand, especially demand in Southeast Asia, general inflation, and one of the things we focused on which has been very important is the increase to grain costs to feed the animals, so that's been a big factor," he told CTV's Canada AM.

The price of animal feed has gone up, he said, largely due to the demand for corn and wheat to make ethanol.

In recent years governments have mandated that gasoline must be blended with a certain percentage of ethanol in order to reduce petroleum consumption and greenhouse gas emissions.

In the U.S., 40 per cent of the nation's corn crop is now being used for ethanol production. In Ontario that number is 30 per cent -- an increase of 10 per cent from a decade ago, Mussell said.

Mussell said the U.S. requires a 10 per cent blend of ethanol in its gasoline, while Canada requires 5 per cent.

The measure has created a drain on the corn and wheat supply in North America, which in turn has driven up feed costs for ranchers.

It's simple supply and demand, Mussell said.

"When we create policy that creates this new demand for corn to make ethanol it increases the price of corn over time. That increases the farmer's cost, they have to cut back on production to meet that, and as a result we get higher meat prices."

In his report, Mussell said government ethanol policies have effectively created an entirely new market for feed grains -- to the detriment of the beef and pork industries.

He estimates the Canadian industry, which employs 100,000 people, is losing roughly $130 million per year as a result of the policies.

"In the U.S. for example, in the mid- to late 2000s, the U.S. government increased the mandated use of ethanol to 10 per cent from 5 per cent," states Mussell's report.

"The near immediate impact was a surge in U.S. grain corn prices from a long-term normal level of $2 to $3 per bushel to between $5 and $7 per bushel from 2007-2011."

Corn also increased in price by roughly $2 per bushel or about 40 per cent, the report said.

"Given that corn is the primary feedstock of the livestock industry, this eventually helped to contribute to soaring meat prices as well as dramatic increases in other foods such as vegetables."

Unless the ethanol content required in gasoline changes in Canada and the U.S., Mussell said meat prices can be expected to continue to rise in the coming years -- particularly if ethanol blending requirements rise to 10 per cent in Canada, as some advocates hope.

Comments are now closed for this story

Rev in VC
said

On the bright side, at least all that corn is being used for ethanol should mean less being used to make corn syrup. Less beef and corn syrup might lead to better lifestyle for americans. That's me being optimistic. Of course, the naysayer in me says that they'll probably switch to more chicken and consume just as much cane sugar instead...


MikeW
said

Good job Dolton, another by product of your useless green energy plan. you just implement your stupid plans without considering the ramifications


Ron
said

This is only part of the story, finally grain farmers are getting close the the real value of the grain they grow. Governments are not having to support the grain growers. As well the value of beef and pork have very little to do with the input costs. The value of the beef and pork to the farmer are set off of traded values that move independently from grain prices. It is easy to blame ethanol but he fact is all it does is eat up the over production in the North American market and support farmers so that the public doesn't need to. We should thankful for the cleaner environment and happier grain farmers


Al
said

By-products of ethanol plants, ie. the dried mash is and can be fed to livestock with varying degrees of protein and moisture content. There was to be an ethanol plant in SW Sask. and a feedlot to accompany it to use the mash. I do not know if it became a reality or not.


Geoff
said

@ Desi Demona. You are absolutely right. We should all stop eating meat and let billions worldwide starve. Also cattle should be able to roam the countryside free. I am sure they would flourish. Furthermore, the fall of the meat industry would ruin the Canadian economy! Brillian idea! Typical hippies! Farmers feed cities!


Get Silly
said

Ethanol combustion in an internal combustion engine yields significantly larger amounts of formaldehyde and acetaldehyde.This leads to a significantly more ground level ozone (pollution that contributes to smog) nearly twice as much as gasoline. Sounds like a great way to kill low lying life forms!


Canadian Immigrant
said

@Jim Cripwell Thank you Jim, for the next decade there could be other discoveries too - but till then we should bear the costs which will go up and up. Mexico's 60 - 70% production of Corn goes to Ethanol conversion and it keeps on increasing - bet you that is going to happen to Canada & US


Steve in Ottawa
said

The Federal Government needs to take appropriate action and stop using "feed / food" crops for making of Ethanol. It has been tried, tested & proven that Hemp & Hemp seed (not marijuana, real Hemp) produces far greater amounts of bio-matter that can be used to manufacturer Ethanol & Bio-diesel. Hemp uses no herbicides, pesticides and is tilless. Used as a rotational crop by farmers, it benefits them by allowing the land to relax from chemicals etc for the growing season and helps to aerate the soils plus. A pinch of research on this will verify everything. Look at the "Canadian Hemp Alliance" for more info including Cdn Gov info on the subject.Farmers should be growing Food for people, Feed for animals not for ethanol or bio-diesel.


George in Calgary
said

Go green and it comes out of your pocket. I thought going green was going to create jobs not temper the job market. Oh and I guess that means that more people will starve in drought areas because more food will be diverted to fuel. Gee I guess the greenies are complexed about this. Fewer jobs and more people starving. Yup lets go green, green, green!


Screw Ball
said

How be we let consummers grow their own corn and brew their own ethanol. They could than add it to their fuel and save the Planet.Yahoo!


Desi Demona
said

The average household can save up to $300 a year by not eating meat at all. Ans the environmental benefits of a reduction in meat consumption on the 'food shortage' are well documented. Look at this as a motivating step towards choosing vegetarianism and saving the planet.


alma
said

oh give me a break. willlthe beef farmers benefit from this. NO only the middle man and retailers


Dixie from Alberta
said

I really have a problem when you have to compete with your gas tank for low cost food.


Jim Cripwell
said

This article assumes that the ethanol will only be made from the sugars and starches of corn; i.e the edible parts. There is a high probability that within the next 10 years, the USA could be producing 16 billion gallons of cellulose ethanol per year; i.e ethanol made from the non-food parts of corn and other farm products. If Iogen gets a chance to build a plant in Canada, we could also contribute to this total.

Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    10 Video(s) 10

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1