Top Stories -   

1
Mohammad Shafia, centre, Tooba Yahya, right, and Hamed Shafia, left, arrive at the Frontenac County courthouse in Kingston, Ont., Sunday, Jan. 29, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Amin Muhammad, a psychiatry professor at Memorial University, speaks with CTV News Channel from St. John's on Sunday, Jan. 29, 2012. Amin Muhammad, a psychiatry professor at Memorial University, speaks with CTV News Channel from St. John's on Sunday, Jan. 29, 2012.

Perpetrators perceive honour 'in a faulty way'

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Man, wife and son learn fate
A jury in Kingston, Ont. reached its verdict Sunday: three members of the Shafia family were found guilty of first degree murder. Genevieve Beauchemin reports on the emotionally charged verdict.
CTV National News: Archaic notion of 'honour'
The Shafia murder case was not the first in which some notion of family honour was invoked. But as Omar Sachedina reports, honour killings are no more supported by religious teachings than they are by the law.
CTV News Extended: Lawyers react to the verdict
The Crown attorneys in the Shafia trial make a statement to the media following the guilty verdict at a Kingston, Ont. courthouse.
CTV Montreal: Muslim community reacts to verdict
Members of the Muslim community and neighbours in St. Leonard expressed relief and anger after the verdict in the Shafia trial came down. Camille Ross reports.
CTV Montreal: Newsmaker: Lawyer Marie-Helene Giroux on the guilty verdict
Defence lawyer Marie-Helene Giroux speaks with Tarah Schwartz about the significance of the guilty verdict and how quickly it came down.
CTV Toronto: Three guilty in Shafia killing
After just 15 hours, jurors found a Montreal couple and their son guilty Sunday of murdering four female relatives. CTV's Scott Lightfoot reports.
CTV News Channel: How did jury decide?
Leo Adler, a criminal defense lawyer and Steven Skurka, CTV's legal analyst discuss the possible future of the Shafias, and how the jury might have come up with its decision.
CTV News Channel: Evidence was overwhelming
Criminal Lawyer Jonathan Rosenthal says the guilty verdict wasn't all that surprising, given the overwhelmingly compelling case that was made against the Shafia family.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (13) Facebook   

Mohammad Shafia, centre, Tooba Yahya, right, and Hamed Shafia, left, arrive at the Frontenac County courthouse in Kingston, Ont., Sunday, Jan. 29, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Amin Muhammad, a psychiatry professor at Memorial University, speaks with CTV News Channel from St. John's on Sunday, Jan. 29, 2012. Amin Muhammad, a psychiatry professor at Memorial University, speaks with CTV News Channel from St. John's on Sunday, Jan. 29, 2012.

Photos

Mohammad Shafia, centre, Tooba Yahya, right, and Hamed Shafia, left, arrive at the Frontenac County courthouse in Kingston, Ont., Sunday, Jan. 29, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

More on this topic

Date: Sun. Jan. 29 2012 10:06 PM ET

Perpetrators of honour killings do so under the mistaken belief that their actions will restore respect for their family in their community, says a Canadian expert on the phenomenon.

On Sunday, Mohammad Shafia, 58, his wife Tooba Yahya, 42, and their son Hamed, 21, were each found guilty on Sunday of four counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of the Shafias' three daughters and the older man's first wife.

The Crown had argued the deaths were honour killings, an attempt to restore the family's dignity in the wake of the girls' rebellious behaviour. The family denied these claims, but Justice Robert Maranger called the killings an "honourless crime" when addressing them after the verdict was handed down, saying the victims were killed because they "offended your completely twisted concept of honour…that has absolutely no place in any civilized society."

Amin Muhammad, a professor of psychiatry at Memorial University in St. John's, Nfld. and an expert on honour killings, said such a crime is usually committed when a female establishes a relationship with a man outside of her family.

Muhammad told CTV News Channel on Sunday that the Shafia case, in which the Crown alleged that the father was angry that the girls had boyfriends and rebelled against some family rules, fits the bill for such a crime.

"Eliminating the victim, they feel that this is the right way to restore the honour," Muhammad said after the verdicts were handed down. "But as you can understand there are some psychological dimensions also to this aspect, that these people who would commit this crime understand this particular honour in a faulty way, would have some psychological disturbance in their own personality and in their life."

According to Muhammad, those who commit honour killings "believe that the people in their community, in their tribe or in their country of origin will hold them in high respect."

Sisters Zainab, 19, Sahar, 17, and Geeti, 13, along with Shafia's other wife Rona Amir Mohammad, 52, were found dead in one of the family cars at the bottom of a Kingston canal in June 2009.

The family said the women had gone out for a joyride and become lost, falling into the canal by accident. The Crown contended that the Shafias killed the women and staged the scene to look like an accident.

Muhammad said that while the family patriarch would have been the driving force behind the killings, his wife's involvement comes as no surprise.

"I'm not surprised because in many such cases accomplices are women: mother, a grandmother, sister, and among the male members, it could be a brother, son, father, uncle or any other relative," he said. "But women are also co-perpetrators under such situations."

Kingston Imam Sikander Hashmi said Islamic teaching doesn't condone honour killings.

"(It's) certainly unacceptable under Canadian law and I think it's inhumane," he told CTV News.

According to Muhammad, honour killings are "globally prevalent," with about 5,000 women killed each year. In Canada, about a dozen cases have so far fit the bill for an honour killing, and he said more can be expected amid heightened awareness of such crimes.

Other high-profile cases include the murder of 16-year-old Aqsa Parvez, who was strangled to death at her family's Mississauga, Ont. home in 2007. Her father and older brother pleaded guilty to second-degree murder. The teenager had run afoul of her father's strict rules by refusing to wear the hijab and running away from home.

However, the Shafia verdict sends a message that honour killings will not be tolerated in this country, Muhammad said.

"Those people who are even thinking about it or are even having those thoughts in their mind should be warned now by this verdict that Canada is not going to accept this particular term and cannot allow first-degree or heinous crimes under this particular term," he said. "And I think this is a lesson to be learned for those people who come here with this mindset."

Farzana Hassan, past president of the Muslim Canadian Congress, echoed Muhammad.

"Immigrant communities need to shed those attitudes when they come to Canada or else go back," she told CTV News.

With a report from CTV's Omar Sachedina

Comments are now closed for this story

Nadine
said

The face of evil, the spawn of satan. A lifetime behind bars isn't enough, and must be twice as long for a mother who should have protected her children and a brother who should shielded his sisters.

hugh
said

The worst part of this verdict is that we will be paying for them to have a place to live and sleep and be entertained for the next 25 years. For this type of crime( along with pedophiles, serial rapists, etc ) bring back the death penalty.Save the taxpayer a whole lot of money


J in the Stitt
said

I don't necessarily agree with the professor's comment about what the verdict means for anyone harboring any notion of "honour killing" to think twice about it. The act, with intent, to cause loss of life to someone else will always be considered murder/manslaughter in our country, our law and our society, regardless of the reason. To even imply that someone's perceived notions of honour overrule the laws of our land is twisted in itself and I would imagine it would be a large part of anyone seeking citizenship here. At the same time though this verdict implies two possible effects. The first effect is that for anyone sharing the same twisted notions of honour, the Shafia family may become a symbol akin to a martyr. The second effect, from an objective standpoint, is that the verdict reinforces the precedent of the first degree murder to manslaughter charge regardless of any truly honourable reason. Any future trials with facts similar to previous jurisprudence including, for example, Sue Rodriguez or Robert Latimer have a greater chance of having that same result simply because any notion of honour, no matter how twisted or socially accepted, is not above the law.


dwayne in da peg
said

@BG IN BC. Our laws are based on being a human, not a christian theology. If that was so, then abortion would be outlawed. I am not a religious person by nature. That being said, religion is an accepted aspect of our society but have you ever heard of a extremist athiest? People who don't believe in a god tend not to go out an kill thoes who don't share our beliefs. More killing has been done in the name of god than for greed by a long shot. Get rid of all religion in the world and guaranteed there could be world peace.


georgie
said

Was the youngest daughter not 13 years old? What could she have possibly have done to dishonour the family?? Why was she killed?


Frank Buchan
said

It shows something that the idea of honour can be twisted so far as to even appear in the same sentence as the word killing.


John L
said

It's not over yet, I think they get an automatic appeal, if not they have money to pay for one, and will demand it.


serving soldier
said

I spent a little over two years in Afghanistan fight against what Shafia believes in. Tha fact that he did this crime in the country that fought so hard to stop this insanity from happening in his own country is a slap in the face. We should send him and the other two back home to serve their term in Afghan prison.


BG in BC
said

@Dwan in da peg: You're mistaken my friend, taking religion out will not would only make the occourance of this sort of event even worse & other cirmes too. Western law is based on Christianity not "if it feels good, do it" which is what our laws in the west would be based if not for Christianity. The issue is man kind's weakneses & lack of moral grounding. It is man kind's tendancy to be evil & imoral. This will always be with us as we are now.


Reece
said

I had friends who lost her daughter in a car accident - funny, I dont recall her being callled a whore, or wishing Satan to defecate on her grave. I suppose these days only honourable men wish that upon their babies. Please allow me to say this....I am satisfied that you people will spend 25 years in prison. Your life is over. After I post this, I am going to book a vacation online for a trip to Cancun where I will enjoy a cold beer on a hot beach with seafood. It is something you will never do in this life time.

theOtherLowellinBC
said

honour killings seem to me to be from the caveman era. Killing one's own family member to gain respect from the community is atrocious to say the least.


Dwayne in da peg
said

@ W.R. Don't bring god into the equation, just as many christians have commited crime in the name of their god as muslims. Its all a distortion of what ever religious book they follow. Get rid of religion and all these crimes go away


W.R.Wodlinger
said

What could be more dishonourable than killing your own family?One of the Ten Commandments is "Thou shall not kill."It is not for us to judge, but God's.But at least justice has been done. These wretched people will be locked away for the next 25 years.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Graham James is seen exiting the courthouse in Winnipeg, Wednesday, Feb. 22. 2012.

Graham James apologizes to victims, hockey community

More  3 Video(s) 3

Public Safety Minister Vic Toews (left)and Justice Minister Rob Nicholson take part in a news conference to announce measures protecting children from internet predators, in Ottawa, Tuesday, Feb. 14, 2012. (Fred Chartrand / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Canadians will likely pay for online surveillance bill

More   49 Comments 49    2 Video(s) 2

Remi Ochlik and Marie Colvin

Journalists grieve for slain comrades in Syria

More   20 Comments 20    7 Video(s) 7