Top Stories -   

1
FILE - In this Sept. 22, 2011 file photo, a man suspected of being a Gadhafi loyalist shows wounds on his feet at a detention facility in Misrata, Libya. Libyan rebels

Canada blasts Libya over torture reports

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Libya accused of torture
Canada's relations with Libya's revolutionary regime has taken a tough turn over charges that prisoners are being systematically tortured. Daniele Hamamdjian reports on Ottawa's demand for answers.
Power Play: International help needed in Libya
Bessma Momani, a professor at University of Waterloo says it takes time for a transitional government to develop and she also discusses how the international community should get involved.
Power Play: Canada blasts Libya over reports
Chris Alexander, the parliamentary secretary of defense says the Canadian government will continue to work with the Libyan people and he also discusses the recent report about torture in Libya.
CTV News Channel: Reports of torture
Mercedes Stephenson discusses how the Foreign Affairs Department delivered a rebuke to Libyan officials after reports of torture and executions of captured loyalists.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (17) Facebook   

FILE - In this Sept. 22, 2011 file photo, a man suspected of being a Gadhafi loyalist shows wounds on his feet at a detention facility in Misrata, Libya. Libyan rebels

Photos

FILE - In this Sept. 22, 2011 file photo, a man suspected of being a Gadhafi loyalist shows wounds on his feet at a detention facility in Misrata, Libya.

View Larger Image

Date: Fri. Jan. 27 2012 6:33 PM ET

Canada delivered a harsh diplomatic rebuke to Libyan officials in both countries Friday after "credible" reports of torture linked to the country's interim government.

The Foreign Affairs Department delivered the demarche, or diplomatic note, after reports of torture and executions of captured loyalists of dead dictator Moammar Gadhafi surfaced.

Two international organizations -- Doctors Without Borders and Amnesty International -- said Thursday detainees have been tortured and killed in recent weeks and months, coupled with widespread abuse of former Gadhafi supporters.

Doctors Without Borders said it's pulling out of the city of Misrata because detainees were only being brought for care so they would be suitable for further interrogation.

Ottawa is "deeply concerned" by the reports and maintains that torture is "totally unacceptable," Parliamentary Secretary of National Defence Chris Alexander told CTV's Power Play.

"We are making our views known through diplomatic channels... but we continue to work with the Libyan people and the legitimate authorities to rebuild the country," he said.

Building a better Libya was the whole point of Canada's involvement in last year's rebellion, he added.

Alexander speculated that the torture, though still unacceptable, could be a case of some Libyans settling old scores with former authorities -- as occurred in the Balkans after its regime change and in Afghanistan after the Taliban.

"A lot of people were abused by the Gadhafi regime," he said. "Some may be having an eye for an eye."

But the country will need further guidance through the choppy, post-revolution waters if it is to form the sort of government and justice system for which the rebels fought, added Dr. Bezma Moe-mani of the Waterloo-based think tank the Centre for International Governance and Innovation.

"I don't think we should write off this new government. We do have to keep in mind that this is a transitional government. There's a lot to be learned and they're learning quite fast," she said.

Baird and Prime Minister Stephen Harper are attending the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland this week.

The United Nations' top human rights official told Libya's transitional government to take control of its prisons and stop atrocities against inmates.

"There's torture, extrajudicial executions, rape of both men and women," Navi Pillay, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, told The Associated Press.

It's believed there are around 8,000 prisoners being held in 60 detention centres in the war-torn country.

Libyan rebels overthrew Gadhafi's brutal dictatorship - that ended with his death in October - with the help of Canadian air power and support from other NATO countries.

Canada has pledged about $20 million to assist the new government, but has said its priority is to get weapons out of the hands of the country's fractured militias, who control many of the prisons.

Comments are now closed for this story

steve
said

We created a monster!


pet_rock_mtl
said

one despot replaced by 100 new ones,no wonder the world is turning into a toilet, i am sure glad i live in a country with real laws and a real government to back it up


Tortured soul
said

Why should we be surprised?People in this region of the world have been killing each other for thousands of years.We kill Julius Caesar,nothing changes,We kill Saddam Husein ,nothing changes,We kill Gaddafi,more of the same.When are we going to learn?If we saved all the money we spent killing we would not have to torture our own seniors by cutting off OAS.


Dave
said

We bombed and killed some of them. If they did that to us I would not be happy if they complained about our policy of allowing admitted war criminals and torturers such as Bush and Cheney into our country. Canadians just hand them over to be tortured , cause were the good guys.


Rev in VC
said

Obviously this is going to take time to fix. All these people know under the old rule is that this kind of torture and behavior is normal, so of course they believe it's normal or generally accepted. It'll take time and education to turn all this around unfortunately.


Joe in Ontario
said

I had a bad feeling about this intervention from the very beginning. I find it very difficult to believe that the intelligence arm of each of these Western countries did not know that this was going to be the result of putting these people in power. There is simply no way that we should have intervened and put the lives of our brave men and women on the line. Let us also not forget the millions of dollars that we have wasted on this intervention. Those are monies that obviously could have been better spent elsewhere. This is truly sad. These Western governments should have known better.


KEVIN
said

There is no right rule of law in these countries and for anyone to expect a kindler gentler regime is just plain naive. Democracy cannot work in a country without a stable judicial system, and while ours is not without corruption, there is law still in place, a police force not subject to a government but to the law, and a political system subject to the people and law - all in place to deal with corruption. These countries have none of this and it takes generations to put this in place. Till then you get what you get.


Mar
said

@Jamie D: Where does it say Canadians are complicit in the torture? That did not appear in the article. Sadly the replacements are rarely better than the dictator disposed of. Its really up to the people of these countries who they pick to lead them, and until there is a major shift in the mentality in these countries, the replacement will rarely be better. Strong leaders who hate the West are generally all that is available, and as one poster said, violence is so common in these countries, without a major shift, that is not going to change overnight. Countries cannot be forced into a democracy or the rights and freedoms we enjoy, it takes decades, if not hundreds of years.


steve
said

since when does our conservative government listen to these two agencies, unless it works for their propaganda war machine. no doubt this is going on and our government is partly to blame.but war loving con supporters will no doubt put their spin on it. spin away guys and gals. ee haw


devils advocate
said

Democratic western governments should be much more careful about who they support as a replacement for whatever foreign despot they are cheering the removal of. It happens repeatedly that the "cure" is not much better that the "disease" when it comes to who is waitng in the wings to take over in a long ravaged third world country. Remember it was the Taliban that helped chase the Soviets out of Afghanistan way back when. Don't be so surprised when yesterday's "freedom fighters" become today's cruel oppressors. Not every "leader in waiting" is a Nelson Mandela style hero and altruist. If recent events are any indication they are far more likely to be just another thug looking to reap the benefits of power than a true statesman looking to free their people.


dano
said

Really, did our government or any other expect anything less. We help them, and they do this. Same will happen in Afghanistan. No shocking news here. Savages, the lot of them


Prophecy Came True
said

Oh big surprise.... Please note sarcasm! Bring Gadhafi is good idea eh? Nottttt...... Libya will be worse off - not better off........... Time will tell... This is just a beginning....


allan
said

I cant believe how naive our leaders are. Do they actually expect that " Arab springs" will actually result in kinder, gentler regimes? Violence is in teir nature.


NS
said

Doctors without borders is a well respected international organization for sure, but "leading and respected international agencies" no longer refers to Amnesty International. They are just to far left leaning in their politics to be taken seriously in recent years. Of course we in North America denounce torture, but for countries that have lived under the rule of dictators have have only known this as regular life, it gets more complicated. I do not think we should be trying to make the world into one big Western democracy. Let them grow into a democracy, but do not force feed it to them.


Jamie D
said

Canadians are complicit in this crap? Wow. We have come a long way baby.


Gerald
said

Nasty


Shane
said

And is anyone surprised by all this?


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Graham James is seen exiting the courthouse in Winnipeg, Wednesday, Feb. 22. 2012.

Graham James apologizes to victims, hockey community

More  3 Video(s) 3

Public Safety Minister Vic Toews (left)and Justice Minister Rob Nicholson take part in a news conference to announce measures protecting children from internet predators, in Ottawa, Tuesday, Feb. 14, 2012. (Fred Chartrand / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Canadians will likely pay for online surveillance bill

More   49 Comments 49    2 Video(s) 2

Remi Ochlik and Marie Colvin

Journalists grieve for slain comrades in Syria

More   20 Comments 20    7 Video(s) 7