Top Stories -   

1
Employees walk away from the Mabe plant Thursday, January 26, 2012 in Montreal. The home appliance-maker is slashing 700 jobs in Montreal, blaming the high-flying loonie for its woes. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Chiasson S.C.E.P. union Michel Ouimet said that the unionized workers had already made significant concessions and might have made even more if given the chance. videoplayer image mabe closure

Over 700 to lose jobs at Montreal's Mabe dryer plant

Viewer

CTV News Video

Catherine Sherriffs reports
The rising Canadian dollar and slumping American sales have led a Mabe Canada to lay off 740 workers, Catherine Sherriffs reports.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (31) Facebook   

Employees walk away from the Mabe plant Thursday, January 26, 2012 in Montreal. The home appliance-maker is slashing 700 jobs in Montreal, blaming the high-flying loonie for its woes. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Chiasson S.C.E.P. union Michel Ouimet said that the unionized workers had already made significant concessions and might have made even more if given the chance. videoplayer image mabe closure

Photos

Employees walk away from the Mabe plant Thursday, January 26, 2012 in Montreal. The home appliance-maker is slashing 700 jobs in Montreal, blaming the high-flying loonie for its woes. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Chiasson

View Larger Image

Date: Fri. Jan. 27 2012 2:48 PM ET

MONTREAL — About 740 Montreal jobs will be lost between now and 2014 due to the closure of Mabe Canada's dryer manufacturing plan in the city's East End, it was announced Thursday.

In 2009 the factory had planned to transfer about 30 percent of its production to Mexico, but it never actually did so.

Management issued a press release citing decreased profits due to the high Canadian dollar, as well as the economic slowdown in the United States, where 90 percent of the goods manufactured at the Montreal plant are sold.

According to Mabe, the factory suffered significant losses over the last six years and even if the government had given grants and the unions taken massive wage cuts, it would still not be viable.

Mabe Canada, a branch of the Mexican-based multinational, invested heavily in its factory at the corner of Notre Dame and Dickson since 2006.

Their union rep said that the workers had already given up a lot and might have given up even more.

"Five years ago our members conceded over five years, $25 million in exchange to get job security for five years and a non- closure agreement for the plant. So they did their part and probably would have been ready to do a bit more, I don't know, depending on the negotiations," said Michel Ouimet of the SCEP.

"It would have been their decision in the end but right now the position of the employer it's a done deal it's a final decision no matter what," said Ouimet.

Montreal Mayor Gerald Tremblay's administration issued a press release soon after stating that, "The city and borough made intense efforts over the last few months to try to keep the factory running. We had meetings with Mabe, the Minister of Economic Development, the Minister of Innovation and Exportation and Investment Quebec to study possible interventions."

"It's a sad development for Montreal's economy, particularly in the east. We're not giving up, we'll fight until the end to save these jobs," said Real Menard, the Borough Mayor of Mercier-Hochelaga-Maisonneuve.

Almost half the workers will stay until the plant closes for good in 2014.

Mabe Canada promised to respect its contractual obligations, including pensions.

Production of dryers will be shifted to the United States and Mexico.

Prior to being run by Mabe, the factory at Dickson and Notre Dame had long been used to build appliances under various names, most recently Camco.

City of Montreal Opposition Leader Louise Harel issued a press release describing the closure as a "tragic development." She cited statistics indicating that Montreal had lost 42,000 jobs between May and December in 2011. 

With a file from The Canadian Press

The original version of this story said that Mabe had moved production to Mexico in 2009, but that is not the case.

Comments are now closed for this story

Right Wing
said

Maybe if they would have worked for $4.00 per hour plus NO benefits, but receive one shipping box from the dryers to live in, they still would have a job. Workers in Canada DO NOT RATE A HIGH WAGE. Just us right wingers deserve the money train. Now back to work all you lefties ! !


Montrealer
said

You're also a bunch of hypocrites. How many of you, have Samsung or LG appliances in your home? They aren't cheap and they are made in Korea. From seeing friends with those two brands, I know to stay away.

I actually have a GE dryer made in the Montreal Mabe plant along with every other appliance from GE. They work very well and I haven't had one single problem with them.

Yes, I can agree with you, the workers were probably paid a little to much howevwer I bet most of you don't even have an appliance made in North America or from a North American manufacturer.


Susie-Q Mtl.
said

If this plant is closing then is there any places here that make dryers? I have a washing machine but no dryer. I need one. I am trying to save pennies & nickels. Does this mean all our dryers are now going to be shipped here from the States? Does this mean they will cost more? I for sure don't like this. Unions are necessary cause years ago employers & Govt. treated workers like dirt. Now some unions are out of hand. They need to be reigned in. Never a dull moment here. There is no happy medium here. Problems, problems abound. How do we fix it?


Simon B.
said

Having worked for Camco/Mabe on the assembly line from 2004 to 2007, maybe I can add a certain perspective to some comments...
I've met there every type of worker, from the union protected careless slackers to the most dedicated workers you'll encounter. I've always considered our wages to be absurdly high, as during my first year there I had made more money than my brother did after completing a degree in engineering..
I feel a great deal of sadness for my former co-workers, because most of them never enjoyed the benefits of education and simply enjoyed a life of consumption without realising the frailty of their economic situation.
Personally, I saved up and eventually went back to school, but, hey, that's quite another story...


Vincent
said

I feel a need to comment on some of the more idiotic comments. While I'm not a major fan of unions, I do recognize that they are important. Anthony, you mention China and Mexico. Excellent. Is this what you want Canada to be? You want a society where the workers live in poverty while management lives like kings. It says a lot about the kind of person that you are. Look at the Electromotive workers that are locked out in Ontario. (yes, Ontario for all the Quebec bashers). Caterpillar's profits jumped 58% in the 4th quarter to 1.55 billion. They make over 4 billion a year in profits but they want a 50% pay cut for their employees. Oh, let's not forget that the CEO's pay DOUBLED to over 10 million. Sounds like a dream, eh, Anthony. An economist from Western University's school of business called it "an absolute dangerous precedent" that if successful, would potentially trigger other companies across the country to ask for similar wage reductions" This could happen to anybody, union or not. Nobody making 40 000 is living large, unlike the people who are at the top.


Ron S
said

No matter if the average hourly wages are $17-$22 or $22-$30 per hour. Just add about 25%-35% to whatever the average wage is for Fringe Benefits which probably don't exist in China or India to see the true picture.


Ron S
said

This is all too typical as we are competing in a global economy and China is killing us.

We must also accept much of the blame. We demand our Unions keep our wages high and then take our earnings and purchase products made by non-union labourers in 3rd world countries so that we enjoy the good life. We are quite content to do this and do not complain until it is our well paying job that is being lost.

We need to take steps to ensure that we remain competitive and punish those who manipulate their curriencies by placing import duties on them. If we all play by the same rules; many of the jobs that we are about to lose may be saved.

We need to develope more high tech and automated macufacturing processes. Manufacturers typically do not move highly technical manufacturing jobs and/or jobs that have a low labour content to these low wage countries because they are not actually cost effective in the long run. Saving 90% of one's labour cost on a product with a 5%-10% labour content would typically be outweighed by the transportation costs.


Need a fact checker!
said

I find it odd that the Editors Note states salaries are $17-$22/hour, but cbc.ca reported: "Average hourly salary: $22-$30"


johnp
said

EDITOR'S NOTE: Jean Charest is currently at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland.
I stand corrected,you wouldn't think that useless clown would pass up an opportunity to travel the world at our expense


johnp
said

Anyone hear from Johnny Charest yet? he's probably in Paris enjoying a fine bottle of wine

EDITOR'S NOTE: Jean Charest is currently at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland.


david
said

This is what happens when you have someone making 35$ an hour on an assembly line. Unions are destroying this country, everytime they need to close down a plant, they close the unionized plant,do you blame them? Does it make sense for someone to be making 40$ an hour to work at say... Molson? No kidding its 10$ for a beer at a hockey game.

EDITOR'S NOTE: Average salaries at Mabe and Molson are closer to $17-22/hour.


Kacy
said

The fact that a union was mentioned tells me all I need to know...employees were probably paid more than they should be for the work they do to avoid a battle with the union and eventually when you pay out more than you can afford your gonna start going under its the sad reality these days.


Angloman
said

Not surprised.
It's only been what, 15 years since I started hearing politicos and analysts telling companies to start improving productivity or they would not be able to compete with a rising dollar.

Canada's business class has too many incompetents.


Chris
said

Unfortunately, Mabe made garbage appliances sold under other brands such as GE. I had a GE Range which failed after 2 years, and the sticker in the back said: Manufactured by Mabe Canada. They refused to support their product until I threatened to take them to court. I'm not supprised that they are closing. I won't buy another GE or Mabe made appliance.

LorraineH
said

While a Canadian $ almost at par with US $ may be good for shoppers it doesn't help our Manufacturing Industry. Much of the manufacturing we do or did in Quebec was for US owned companies and with the rising Canadian $ we aren't such a good deal anymore.

With the economy being what it is and growing anger by Americans at their companies for out-sourcing manufacturing, many of these companies are returning to the US.

Many States and the US Federal Government are offering good financial incentives, including tax breaks and hiring incentives, for companies to bring their manufacturing back home.

We will see more and more of this as time goes on. We need to do the same for any Canadian companies that have out-sourced any of their work. Time to bring back "Made in Canada".


Ed
said

@ Anthony, could not have said it better myself. All these comments are perfectly explained in yours, well done!


RCawz
said

Unfortunate, but is anyone surprised by the investment environment in Quebec? Quebec wants it all yet refuses to participate in a team approach to make life better here with narrow minded thinking. The persist in this exclusionary positon while the world around them surges ahead.
All we hear is language of signs of major franchises (major employers)..language of the head coach of the Montreal Canadiens, etc, etc. The world is taking notice people. Investors do not want unstable environments for their investments. Either join the global team (even China promotes English in their early education) and most people in business there are pretty much fluent in English.
The world today is a precarious place, either we join together in Canada (Hello Quebec!)..or we lose major ground to what is happening in the real world. Don,t listen to the politicians, they make sure they are taken care of. Listen to your own sense of reason of what is happening around you. Will you listen to what is happening for your children,s sake?
....Think and decide with your own brains and heart because this will get worse.
China and Southeast Asia is coming..and fast.


Mr John.
said

With what happens here often there are grants given to these firms that do not come to light until after the fact.I was aware it was not new but who says it was not refitted with assistance grants to this company...like I said we all know how a lot works here.
Too bad for all involved but, as you say it is really not a total surprise.
With all this political,language nut cases on a pipe dream war path again,goodness knows how many others will be thinking a way out.
The Utex yesterday, Air Canada last week and now this.They may have been in the works but it really does not help that the old dragon facists are snorting and frothing.......

Anthony Kovic
said

Offer $5 an hour to workers in numerous countries (China, Mexico to name a few) and you get a good hard working dedicated employee. Offer the same $5 a hour to a Canadian and they will spit in your face and report you to the minimum wage commmission for gross exploitation. This is the true force that is driving jobs abroad, far more than politics. Like Harper said in Davos, the prosperity of wealthy countries like ours can not be taken for granted. No one but no one wants to pay inflated prices for products made with overpriced labor, not us and certainly not the foreigners. Today, it is the Chinese who are willing to work hard and save - they have the growth, the cash, the future. We have debt and unrealistic expectations.


frank
said

First Johnson & Johnson, then Shell, Now Mabe. Who next Suncor??I'm losing all my clients in the east end.


Norm_D
said

RedMtl is correct. That building was there even prior to WWII. Originally it was part of the Montreal Locomotive plant which with dieselization was no longer required and the locomotive facilities moved one building north where it still is now. GE started making appliances there more than half a century ago. So if you don't like the news and want to get back at them, don't buy GE appliances.


RedMtl
said

The Mabe plant was originally the GE (GE, Hotpoint, Moffat, McClary, Easy, Beaumark), then the amalgamated Camco, plant. It has been there for decades. Mabe was just the latest name on the outside of a building which has been making appliances at that location for a long, long time.

Mabe is a Mexican firm, which joined with GE in 1986. It has been taking over the market for a long time now, and produces most of the appliances used in North America.

The Quebec Government, if it supplied any money at all, did so a long, long time ago, when the place first opened under one of the original manufacturing names. Drive past it and have a look -- it is one of the older buildings in Montreal.

It is extremely unfortunate for both employees and for business in Canada in general, that it will be closing, but given the parent firm is Mexican to begin with, the relocation of manufacturing seems hardly surprising.


Morgan
said

@ Wayne...You're right..and don't slam the door on your way out...
Hurray for Unions..they did their job again, why blame government or business owners. A person can't afford a business in Quebec any more...


JC
said

If the companies want their labor done in China or Mexico then the Goverment of Quebec or Canada should tax these companies. And the money that they get should go to the people who are trying to start a business here in Canada.


felix
said

textiles, toys, applainces furniture electronics, who is next on the list! I would like to know how are we going to pay for our social programs when we will be out of a job soon



Mr John.
said

How much did the Quebec government grant this company to build this factory on Dickson?


Ross
said

This is another black mark on Harper for doing free trade with Mexico nice going.


Mabe Employee
said

Very sad news. Going to miss everyone there. We had good times while it lasted and not looking forward to the difficult times ahead of trying to find a job that pays remotely close to the salary we were getting. I had a feeling something like this would have happened as soon as we got bought over by mexicans, from day 1 they came in they were cutting jobs meanwhile saying they would never close down!


Wayne
said

Last person to leave Quebec please turn out the lights


Aaron
said

WOW because of our dollar people need to suffer, but they rather pay some guy who will only make what $200 a month talk about cheap labour, people need job in Canada where are they supposed to go if everything is going to China or Mexcio? Bunch of DUMBASS"S


Jean Guy
said

Hola y bienvenidos a Mexico.
hay maybe it is time to whine to gouvernement and go on strike unions.
adios amigo !



Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    10 Video(s) 10

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1