Top Stories -   

1
Low-paying jobs in hospitality and restaurant services, wood and miscellaneous manufacturing, and personal care were all on the rise, according to a new report from CIBC World Markets that warns Canada's job market is perhaps the worst it has ever been during non-recession periods.  (AP / Christophe Ena) A new report from CIBC World Markets warns the country's job market is perhaps the worst it has ever been during non-recession periods. Canada economy

Job quality worsened in 2011, CIBC report says

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News Channel: Quality and quantity of work
Merella Fernandez says high paying jobs only rose by .4 per cent, while lower paying jobs were on the rise, and explains job creation for 2012 will be remain 'subdued.'
CTV Toronto: Job fair connects graduates with employers
New graduates, many dressed for success, lined up at Toronto's convention centre, hoping to meet their future employer. Michelle Dube has the story.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (59) Facebook   

Low-paying jobs in hospitality and restaurant services, wood and miscellaneous manufacturing, and personal care were all on the rise, according to a new report from CIBC World Markets that warns Canada's job market is perhaps the worst it has ever been during non-recession periods.  (AP / Christophe Ena) A new report from CIBC World Markets warns the country's job market is perhaps the worst it has ever been during non-recession periods. Canada economy

Photos

Low-paying jobs in hospitality and restaurant services, wood and miscellaneous manufacturing, and personal care were all on the rise, according to a new report from CIBC World Markets that warns Canada's job market is perhaps the worst it has ever been during non-recession periods.  (AP / Christophe Ena)

View Larger Image

Date: Wed. Jan. 25 2012 8:13 PM ET

Both the number and quality of new jobs in Canada is on the decline, according to a new report from CIBC World Markets that warns the country's job market is perhaps the worst it has ever been during non-recession periods.

According to the bank, Canada's employment quality index fell by one per cent over the last year, due to both sluggish job creation late in 2011 and worsening job quality in the national labour market.

Report author Benjamin Tal of CIBC World Markets said among other negative effects, a falling employment quality index puts pressure on Canadians' wallets.

"With both quantity and quality of employment falling in tandem, it is hardly a surprise that real disposable income was unchanged in the first three quarters of 2011 -- the worst showing in fifteen years," Tal wrote.

The bank measures job quality by looking at three factors: the ratio of part-time to full-time jobs, levels of paid employment compared to self-employment and salaries for full-time work.

The report found that despite a swift pace of job creation in the first half of 2011, the creation of new jobs essentially ground to a halt in the last six months of the year.

Statistics Canada data released earlier this month found that although December saw a modest uptick of 17,500 jobs, the last three months of the year saw an overall loss of 55,000 jobs.

Canada's unemployment rate also rose for the third month in a row, to 7.5 per cent, Statistics Canada said.

Overall, though, full-time employment rose by 1.5 per cent in 2011, while part-time employment dropped 0.3 per cent, "a positive factor in terms of overall employment quality," Tal wrote.

However, the number of self-employed Canadians was up by two per cent, double the number of Canadians who found paid employment. A jump in self-employment figures reduces overall employment quality, the report said, because a self-employed worker earns on average between 10 and 15 per cent less than a regular employee.

The number of high-paying full-time positions rose by only 0.4 per cent in 2011, a mere quarter of the rate of low-paying jobs.

Low-paying jobs in hospitality and restaurant services, wood and miscellaneous manufacturing, and personal care were all on the rise. High-paying jobs in public administration, transportation and mining, as well as chemical, computer and electronic, and petroleum and coal manufacturing experienced a net loss last year.

Tal told The Canadian Press the picture is not all bad, given that more than 600,000 jobs have been created since the recession of 2008-09. That's more than were lost during the downturn and a stronger showing than many other countries.

But according to Tal, the outlook for 2012 is less than rosy. Employment quality "will remain subdued," he wrote, largely basing his forecast on two factors. First is the number of construction jobs, which jumped 3.5 per cent in 2011, and will level off when the housing market cools as many economists predict it will in 2012.

"Furthermore, public sector employment is already starting to fall," Tal said, "and the likelihood is that overall employment in that sector will continue to fall in 2012 -- a significant potential negative to overall employment quality."

Comments are now closed for this story

Wage Serf
said

Tory(Reform) Times = hard times.


doug
said

Some of the comments ring with some truth but many perpetuate the myth of "poor me, I am not getting what I deserve. They should provide me with a living wage".

What is a living wage, someone please define it so we can help you?



CloneMe
said

Not only the new jobs have quality problems. Take someone like me who ended up working TWO positions when my workmate retired and the top brass refused to replace her. Now I fear this job will be the death of me.


xcon
said

the work culture preached by conservatives is based on profit only. Workers' rights and well being does not make any sense to their ideology. Vote intelligently and not emotionally next election.


Jethrine.MacKae
said

In the mid 1980's my husband opened his own business because neither of us were able to find employment. He worked 60 hours a week and brought his work and all the headaches home with him and I also pitched in. It was a good income but not if you took into consideration the number of hours we put into it. So, now again, there is not a job to be found in the City of Toronto or GTA so I'm promoting welfare ... ... Dispel the Myth: http://www-work-com.blogspot.com/


Mq
said

I think you should all take the time to read Bruce in Alberta's comment. And think about it, really think about it, because he 100% right. This notion that you are only entitled to a living wage and dignity if you attended post secondary school, or a forum of specialty training is total garbage. So lets just say EVERYONE trains tomorrow to be a doctor, or lawyer or accountant. Who does all the things you like to spend those salaries on? I would suggestion a National one day general strike of ever single business minium wage employee. Every single business would be closed from coast to coast. Maybe then they would see just how many of us there is. Who's gonna fill your tank, was your car, poor your tim's, or deliver your pizza. Or what now we think those that provide the services are less then important to society. The idea of this makes me sick to my stomach. The last boss that said to me, who cares what your think your disposable got a punch in the face. What kind of society are we living in were this sort of common language is acceptable to a member of society. Whether it be a doctor or a garbage collector. Who the hell are corporations to say to the citizenship WE are disposable. It's this sort of management thinking that has placed us in this mess to begin with. I urge you all to boycott major business, then they will know what real profit loss is.


Gregg
said

I'm frankly confused - here are these reports and commenters hoping for better jobs, yet the CTV unofficial polls consistently show about 65% support for the 1% and pay inequality?


jrm
said

Do not despair! With the tax break the Conservative promised to the large corporation, new jobs will be created! Oh yeah!


Steve In manotick
said

I have to ask you all a question. Has your life improved in the 6 years? If not you can thank Stephen Harper for your loss.


James
said

Everyday I go for a walk I see another vacant store, things are getting worse lots of unemployed. The jobs that are available only kids living at home can afford to take them. I have a good job but most of the one out there you'd need 3 just to make ends meet. Tory times are always tough time, lots of unemployed, that's why we always vote the liberals back in.


Beverly
said

Harper & his cronies are in a world all of their own! They preach & announce how well Canada is doing & about the recession; WHATEVER! He could care less what is going on in Ontario; creating jobs, etc. He is so out of touch with reality, it isn't even funny. Harper you need a lesson from Obama, at least Obama cares and is trying to bring business to the different USA states to give people jobs.


Aaron in Toronto
said

Big corporations downsize their workforce and ship out factories to wherever cost them the least. When they make their millions and billions of profit, they keep it to the senior management team. They have no regard to their consumer or how they can continue to consume with low paying jobs. CIBC is one of the worst as they downsize and shift to online banking. They save so much $ but don't lower their interest rate on loans and CC and would not increase saving interest. Pretty soon the so called developed world would turn into 3rd world and have not countries. Only the rich get richer, look at the salary and bonuses their CEO and top management are getting. The Occupy Wall Street movement were right and valid but it was organized poorly. We as regular Joe need to follow what the Polish did back in the early 80's but general strike and send a strong message to the elite that enough is enough.


Joan in Real World
said

Of Course Harper has everything to do with this. --- For example, stepping in in favour of Air Canada and Canada Post during union disputes sends a clear message to corporations that the government will not protect the worker. It emboldens plants to start demanding 50% wage cuts from its employees or face look-out (as we have seen), while their CEOs enjoy huge income increases --- Removing 68,000 public sector jobs is another example. The work need to be done. A lot of these jobs will be contracted out (and simply replaced by lower paid non-protected private sector jobs). ---- Those are the kind of actions that widens the gap between rich and poor, and lower the living standards of the non-whealthy. It is the REFORM agenda. Why people are surprised that this is happening is beyond me.


Bruce from Alberta
said

I just need to comment on the go west and work in the oil feild comments I always read on here.Okay it's true there is jobs, but I like going to a movie, I like ordering a hamburger, I like someone else to change my oil, fix my computer,cut my hair, clean my streets, fix my plumbing etc.If all these people can't live off their earnings then society just is not going to work.These people all need to have a place to stay, the money to raise a family and the ability to retire.Or is having a family and a place to stay a Luxury now?


Frank
said

worse job market in non-recessionary times says the report. Food for thought.


Peter in Kingston
said

we look more and more like Americans... pretty soon we'll have the rich and the poor, and no middle class. No wonder Gingrich was praising Harper last week. He's turning Canada into the State, bit by bit.


testy
said

To make its claim about self-employment, the CIBC has studied the numbers for paid employment vs self-employment. --- Sure, there are a lot of people who make good money being self-employed. But the reality is that "self-employment" is a catch-all category which includes those who try to "create their own job for lack of paid employment". There are more and more of those people around everyday... and more and more of them barely make ends meet through "self-employment" -- To deny that is to deny the reality of the employment situation in Canada. It's right-wing CRAP.


Wayne
said

I wonder how many of those part time jobs were filled by people retiring ffrom full time employment. The new reality is retirement means working less and not stopping work altogether.Fewer people can afford to do that.


Jack in Edmonton
said

This is not any politiacal parties doing. It is the fault of, with a combination of, consumers, manufacturers, corporations and the all might greed.If you want it to get better and not worse here are some ideas I have after paying attention to things over the years. Stop buying junk made in China. Stop refining oil in the US or China and do it here. Stop manufacturing everything in China or Mexico, it's all junk anyways. And the biggest problem that started the whole junk made in China trend, stop shopping at Wal-Mart.These things will never happen though.People love the Wal-Mart cheapness, that has led to stuff having to be manufactured cheaper both in price and quality, hense the crap coming from China. Building refineries in Canada would cost huge money, but would creat jobs an make gas about 3/4, if not 1/2 the cost it is now. Not making things in China would cost more, but again would creat jobs here and the quality would be better. And most of all, making the changes would meen the corporations may not make as many millions of dollars they are now.The consumers have dicided the fate of the Canadian economy, and North America for that matter. You can't blame the government for this.


Joe Average
said

What are you guys talking about? I got two sweet part time jobs to make one paycheque. Wendy's and a call-center. Living the good life!


Invictus
said

What's with all the complaining? The country voted for Harper and his cronies. Canada will now reap it's just rewards. Every time the conservatives are in power, the country's going downhill...remember lyin' Brian?


BA
said

I can't stand the mentality of some of the people commenting on this page. The advice of "if you don't like your job, then go find a new one" is to completely asinine. When there are no decent alternatives to the job you currently have, then how can you make a change? When a particular industry as a whole is plagued by stagnant salaries with excessive workloads, then you're effectively trading one rotten turd for another. It's even harder and riskier to make a change when you have a family to provide for. So many of us are stuck these days, and there is nowhere for us to go. Cost cutting and downsizing has affected all industries, all in the effort to provide overly generous increases to the already exorbitant CEO salary.


Tamara
said

The rich get richer and the poor get poorer. Problem will be who is going pay all the huge taxes? The little working slave (middle class) who work at these crappy jobs low paying jobs also pay the majority of the taxes. So the way I see it crap jobs or low quality jobs equals less people working less taxes paid and more burdens on our social system. Insult to injury when your CEO's get 27% raises, some working class who might be lucky enough to get a meager 2% and the Government continuously mismanages your tax dollars continuously with their irresponsible spending! It just gets more and more difficult to eat and pay your bills. Scary thought when the working class can no longer afford to pay their bills on their meager earnings and the continuously increasing cost of living. I guess when we get to this stage no point in bothering to work cause you can't support yourself anyways.


Jeremy
said

I hear that with the Harper Gov't leadership, McDonalds is on a hiring boom. I wonder what kind of Pension plan they offer. Hey, can't afford the mortgage or food anymore, but at least it is a job. :(


TheOtherLowellInBC
said

I work on contract (self employed) and I was under the impression that contractors make more than full time paid employees for obvious reasons. We do go from contract to contract and we have to take care of our own benefits not to mention pay accountants and lawyers and such to keep our business running. That does not translate into a lower quality of work in fact one could say it produces a higher quality because we have to keep on our toes to keep our competitive edge.


Jim - North Saanich, BC
said

Some of the responses I read here simply do not compute. I have been self-employed for many years and frankly have enjoyed life a great deal more than when I was a wage slave in a major engineering company more than 20 years ago. I do not go from contract to contract so to speak and in fact have never once be on a contract to any level of government so that is not an issue.

At 72, I am still in demand in my field and largely pick and choose the work I wish to do and am very well paid for it. If that is indicative of a deteriorating "quality of employment" and "low job satisfaction", may there be more of it. The world changes rapidly and if individuals have neither the foresight nor the skill set to keep abreast or, better, ahead of those changes then I suppose pouring coffee at Timmy's can be the end result. Given what I believe is still a major global economic recession, Canada has fared a great deal better than almost any other country in the world and if you are in doubt, just look south in to the United States.


Scott in TO
said

But wait, won't this all be corrected with the merger of two of the largest unions? ...NOT.


Brent
said

My situation improved in my workplace: benefits, flexible hours, nice people to work with and for. Great customers, etc. Its a really good situation. Thank the Lord!


Ryan
said

Go west...Jobs in eastern Canada are still being affected by the slow US recovery. Government policy has nothing to do with it.


Doug from BC
said

I think this article and the CIBC report are smoke and mirrors. Most good jobs today come through networking and are not advertised. I am not a CEO, but an ordinary working guy, and my job situation and my take home pay has improved greatly over the last 4 years. Keep it up Mr. Harper.


mimi2005
said

Remember Ontario during the Harris days? Who was finance minister? Now who is the finance minister of Canada? Same guy. Brace yourselves.


Doug
said

If we can forget the politics pushing our comments then we could see the folly of wanting, wanting and wanting more; there is no one willing to pay for all these wants.

Remember if our employers must pay us the amount our 'entitlements' demand someone must pay the employer the inflated cost of our products. The more we cost the more we must pay; where is the logic in that.

Once we decided that only one salary could not buy our dream house and our partners started to contribute the price of housing went up to match??????


The Central Scrutinizer
said

Of course Canada's overall job picture is getting bleaker. Too many corporations are taking advantae of the loophole in our labor laws that permits them to deny benefits to part time employees. Soon, everyone will be a part timer. Unless of course, our government does it's job & introduces new law to stem the tide. Not likely with Harper & his gang of corporate thugs at the helm, however.


whatsup
said

I read (and hear) people complain about their jobs and how they are poorly compensated...but yet I rarely see anyone do something productive about it. If someone doesn't like their job or the job is not fitting their needs, find a new one.


Shane
said

Hey relax folks. This is just to prepare us for jobs in the new jails being built!


Troubadour
said

Remember folks. We saddled ourselves with quite a deficit to give biggggg business the tax cuts needed to give us this nice reduction in job quality. --- Thank God Big Corporations were still able to give their CEOs generous 27% raises. Am I the only one that sess something terribly wrong with this picture?


Steve G
said

Keep cutting those coporate taxes....it has to create jobs eventually!....right?!?!


Lorne-MTL
said

you can add to those the 68,000 public servants the REFORMERS are about to put out of work. There jobs will probably be replaced by lower paid precarious private sector jobs that will further reduce the quality of jobs in Canada./// Right-Wing policies 101 - Corporations get stronger and richer, while the worker loses its security and sees his paycheck reduced.


Joan in Real World
said

What do you expect with a right-wing government in power? This is the direct result of pro-Corporation anti-union , anti-worker policies. --- Notice all the union bashing talk from Harper supporters lately? Notice all the attacks on "public servants" for being "so-called overpaid, pension sucking leechers"? -- That is the attitude that leads to drops in Job quality. And it is the attitude of our current reform government.


eddytoronto
said

Government will likely try to inject more debt and more economic stimulus(bailouts using Tax-payer Money) the system is broken and there is simply not any quick fix that is available that is going to get things back to normal...Well we all need to start becoming a lot less dependent on the system...That means forget about Your Pensions...You should all consider buying Gold and Silver as money and grow your own food and trade that Gold and Silver within our own communities...The entire system is starting to break down it is those who are the least dependent on the system that will have the best chance to prosper during the times ahead...We must cut off Our Criminal Government they will devalue your hard earned money if its in Paper or Electrons....Its over for the Apple and other gadgets people will have to decide food or Apple iPhone...Beware they have 2 sets of Books..


Doug ^^^ BC
said

Why is self employed a negative/ I mean the left wiong whackos hate corporations.They do all they can to tax them out of Canada.If you take away corporations and the self employed,it should surprise no one that the only jobs left are either in public sector unions,who extort their wages from other taxpayers,or pouring coffee at Tim Hortons. You want good jobs? Stop saying "NO" to every industry that wants to grow in Canada.We are already a high cost producer of almost every thing we try to sell.If people want to receive their welfare cheques on time,they had better get behind some kind of economic growth in at least a few industries. Higher costs to industry,when added to the high value of the CAN$ is hardly a positive plan for economic growth.Especially in a world with a very slow global economy. Or,or course,we can always go back to the Chretien Buck.You know the one.It's the one worth 63 cents.But if you think you won't pay for that too,you are seriously dilusional.You do know that a devalued dollar is just another subsidy to industry,I hope.We don't pay for it in taxes,we pay for that in higher prices.But it's just and much a form of "corporate welfare" as lower taxes are. Don't buy into the politics to much.Until the global economy is better,things won;t get a lot better here either.The best we can hope for is to not go to far backwards.Like Greece,for example. Another nanny state.


Steve H
said

Pye these self employed get free money from the government, when it's gone they join the unemployment line. The country is going down hill fast under Harper & his reformers. Can you read the news? Harper is the only dope that should be illegal he's destroying millions of lives.


bcken
said

Tory times are tough times. Unless, of course, your rich or own a corporation, then it's party time all the way to the bank. Four more years of this. Oh well, at least we (BCers) will get rid of the Liberals (read CPC lite) next year.


steve
said

this comes as no surprise as we do not all have access to dirty oil jobs.


LucR Elliot Lake,ON
said

Realistically, in many cases self-employment is a step down from a relatively good paying job. For those of you who are the exception to this, congratulations, but most self-employed individuals are so because of a shortage of good paying jobs or loss of a good job and resort to delivering beer and pizza, shoveling driveways, detailing cars, etc.. for much less than they were earning before.


testy
said

"self-employment" for most means going from contract to contract, with no assurance of renewed work and no unemployment insurance to help you through the rough patches. A percentage only of "self-employed" indivduals make a good living at it... and these are mostly the individuals that "chose" self-employment and are not forced into it becaus of lack of jobs, like is happening here. Self-employed workers have no protection whatsoever, no pension, no access to unemployment insurance.


Ray Fortier Cambell River BC
said

Banks historicly have been guilty of the worst pay schedules for their workers. Even fast food outlets depending on the volumes of business have been known to pay burger flippers $25/hr. When was the last time you heard of a bank clerk making that kind of money. We have been overwhelmed by IPPs, 3P arrangements, and the sell off of Public Corporations that have only reduced government revenues over the long term and increased the service costs to the public. Independant business has created havoc in the day to day lives of Johny Q public as we usually get snagged for subsidizing the costs for everything.


Northern M
said

It should be no surprise to anyone that has been self employed the utter contempt that banks show towards them.


jrayj
said

Wow and this news comes from a Bank that makes hundreds of millions of profit on the backs of the poor, their own employees are lucky if they get over the $14 dollar an hr. bracket.


Bert
said

Well, the 99 % is becoming 99.999 % while the 1% is getting closer to 0.01%. At this rate, Canada's wealth distribution will rival that of US, India and Brazil (in a negative way, of course).Filet menon for the CEOs, cat food for all other !


DL from SW, ON
said

If you know a CIBC employee ask them what they think of their employer. I think you'll find the answer is that CIBC is doing their part towards reducing the quality of a job.


Chris/Manitoba
said

I don't see why becoming self employed is considered a lower class of job , or is it because the "big" corporations loose a bit of control?


Duke
said

Something is wrong here, Harper and his side kick Flapperty are constantly reminding us of the thousands of new jobs created.
Whoops... my mistake, I wrongfully assumed that these were jobs that a person could actually make a living that did not include cat food as part of ones daily diet.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

Hmm. I didn't realize that "turning to self-employment" from "paid employment" contributed to eroding one's country's jobs-quality rating. Gosh; I left a salaried job running a company in the U.S. over a decade ago and started a business in a related field back in Canada. It was a struggle, yet, I gradually became quite successful (a millionaire in my 40's). Historically, this entrepreneurship is precisely what has built the economies of major Western nations. Stupid me, I guess. My apologies to my fellow Canadians, and those individuals and companies I contractually employ and do business with. (This is another one of those negative eye-roll stories. Yeah, we get it; we're still suffering the effects of a severe global economic recession.)


James, Ontario
said

Self employed fits on the negative side of this scale? I find that idea objectionable. Surely any factors that may become a problem under self employment are captured under the other variables. The potential benefits to self-employment are unlimited.


Tim
said

Not if you were making the millions in public and private corporations.


Niagara George
said

Some of us have posted this very thought when supposedly positive job statistics made the news. Let me save you right-wing Cons In Blinders some time and say that the CIBC doesn't know what they are talking about and yesterday, the IMF didn't know what they were saying. Apparently, only those wearing blue glasses have a clear view. Oh, I'm just teasing. I know everyone making minimum wage at Tim Hortons is thrilled beyond belief for the opportunity to serve you coffee. Afterall, that was why they got their degree.


Len
said

Just as many of us knew. Please make sure Flaherty and Harper understand this when they brag about job creation. Good jobs in oil lands but not everyone can go there. Too many jobs are now part time or minimum wage. Wish the corps would not hoard their new-found riches and open up a bit. Keep your business in Canada and use the extremely low corporate taxes to help out the average citizen.


Steve in Manotick
said

Why is it this always happens to Canada when ever there is a Conservative government in control? God help those who are caught in this vortex of fiscal mismanagement no future.. Thanks Steve and Jimbo you really did it to this once fine country.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Graham James is seen exiting the courthouse in Winnipeg, Wednesday, Feb. 22. 2012.

Graham James apologizes to victims, hockey community

More  3 Video(s) 3

Public Safety Minister Vic Toews (left)and Justice Minister Rob Nicholson take part in a news conference to announce measures protecting children from internet predators, in Ottawa, Tuesday, Feb. 14, 2012. (Fred Chartrand / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Canadians will likely pay for online surveillance bill

More   49 Comments 49    2 Video(s) 2

Remi Ochlik and Marie Colvin

Journalists grieve for slain comrades in Syria

More   20 Comments 20    7 Video(s) 7