Top Stories -   

1
Shawn A-in-chut Atleo, National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, holds a press conference following the Crown First Nations Gathering in Ottawa on Wednesday, Jan. 25, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Shawn Atleo, national chief of the Assembly of First Nations, speaks to CTV's Canada AM on Jan. 25, 2012. Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Shawn Atleo, National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, talk as they take part in the Crown First Nations Gathering in Ottawa on Tuesday, Jan. 24, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick /  THE CANADIAN PRESS) Shawn Atleo, national chief of the Assembly of First Nations, speaks to CTV's Canada AM on Jan. 25, 2012.

Atleo calls on feds to back up promises in next budget

Viewer

CTV News Video

Power Play: Aboriginal summit wraps up
Assembly of First Nations Chief Shawn Atleo discusses the successes and the concerns that came out of the Aboriginal Summit in Ottawa.
Canada AM: Important first step made
Shawn Atleo, national chief of the Assembly of First Nations, says the summit was the first step in renewing the relationship between First Nations and the Crown. He also explains there is a need to return to the original treaty, which treats both sides as full partners

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (45) Facebook   

Shawn A-in-chut Atleo, National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, holds a press conference following the Crown First Nations Gathering in Ottawa on Wednesday, Jan. 25, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Shawn Atleo, national chief of the Assembly of First Nations, speaks to CTV's Canada AM on Jan. 25, 2012. Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Shawn Atleo, National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, talk as they take part in the Crown First Nations Gathering in Ottawa on Tuesday, Jan. 24, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick /  THE CANADIAN PRESS) Shawn Atleo, national chief of the Assembly of First Nations, speaks to CTV's Canada AM on Jan. 25, 2012.

Photos

Shawn A-in-chut Atleo, National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, holds a press conference following the Crown First Nations Gathering in Ottawa on Wednesday, Jan. 25, 2012. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

Date: Wed. Jan. 25 2012 8:14 PM ET

Shawn Atleo, national chief of the Assembly of First Nations, wants to see hard evidence that the federal government is willing to back up its pledge to work with First Nations people to brighten their future.

Speaking Wednesday, one day after First Nations leaders met with Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Gov. Gen. David Johnston, Atleo called on Ottawa to demonstrate its commitment in the next federal budget.

Atleo said areas such as education simply can't wait.

"My view is that we can be both practical in areas like education, build on what we know to be the challenge, get to the work together with the Crown, agree to how we're going to implement those changes and then seek the resources to match the required changes," Atleo told reporters Wednesday.

"Those are natural next steps to be looking for. Our children, as I said yesterday, cannot wait."

First Nations leaders and the Conservative government emerged from the talks with a commitment to renew their relationship by addressing a number of concerns.

The decided to form working groups to look at economic development as well as the financial relationship between Ottawa and native communities.

The two sides also agreed to follow up on an already-launched working group examining education.

Atleo acknowledged there have been years of study groups and tasks forces that have resulted in few changes for First Nations people. But he said the difference this time is that both sides are committed to working together to come up with solutions.

"This is about moving away from government unilaterally deciding what they feel is right for First Nations," he said. "That's not a partnership."

Atleo hailed Tuesday's meeting as a milestone despite key outstanding differences in federal-aboriginal relations -- such as the future of the Indian Act.

"Once again there was an articulation that there's much that's agreed on especially around the fact the Indian Act does not serve us. This was an important first step in renewing the relationship between First Nations and the Crown," Atleo told CTV's Canada AM earlier Wednesday.

While the two sides both agree the Indian Act requires a major overhaul, they sharply disagree on how to go about it.

On Tuesday Atleo said the act is a major obstacle that is hurting First Nations' ability to work with the federal government.

"Built on the disgraceful premise of our inferiority, aimed at assimilation and the destruction of our cultures, it was a complete abrogation of the partnership between respectful nations," Atleo said in his speech.

Just prior to that, Harper made it clear from the outset of his remarks that there were no plans to dismantle the Indian Act, but instead Ottawa intended to update it piece by piece.

While he acknowledged the Indian Act is embedded with "incentives" that have led to "outcomes that we all deplore," he said the solution requires an incremental approach.

"To be sure, our government has no grand scheme to repeal or unilaterally rewrite the Indian Act. After 136 years that treaty has deep roots, blowing up the stump would just leave a big hole," Harper said, suggesting that instead Ottawa would work to modernize outdated portions of the act.

Still, Atleo insisted Wednesday that Harper and Johnston's presence, and the meaningful discussions that took place, represent an important starting point for discussions between the two sides. While Harper was initiailly criticized for his plans to only attend the opening ceremony of the event, he ended up staying for the entire day.

"They were listening directly to First Nations leaders from coast to coast to coast and we were saying clearly we need to return to the original treaty relationship as full partners," Atleo said.

The Indian Act-- defining everything from who has First Nations status, to how reserves should be managed and even the effect of marriage on status -- was last amended in 2000.

Since its passage into law in 1876, the Indian Act has given Ottawa exclusive jurisdiction over "Indians and Lands Reserved for Indians."

One of the most contentious features of the Indian Act is the fact that education, from kindergarten to Grade 12, is administered within First Nations communities under the Indian Act, rather than by the provinces.

"Everyone agrees that doesn't make sense," Atleo said.

"We received commitments to get on to work in areas like education and I hope it will be followed very soon by further commitments as well."

Regardless of the issue, from aboriginal health to infrastructure, economic development or education, Atleo said it's vital that First Nations drive the solutions -- a point he said the federal representatives agreed with.

"What we've been seeking is a Crown partner who is willing to do that work with us, not for us, and not having unilateral decisions made by Ottawa, and that is a significant change in smashing the status quo that we've been looking for."

In a joint statement issued Tuesday, the federal government and the chiefs acknowledged they have had a contentious relationship and mistakes can't be repeated.

"Unfortunately, there have been low points in our relationship. A series of misguided and harmful government policies in our past has shaken First Nations confidence in our relationship," the statement said.

"We cannot undo the mistakes of the past, but we can learn from them and affirm that they will not be repeated."

They agreed to set up task forces and working groups on issues such as economic development, and report back on the progress they've made in one year.

Comments are now closed for this story

Seeking Wolf
said

My friends, I honour nothing. My nation, Canada, has honoured me; I was granted opportunity by my country, acceptance based on who and what I was, what I produced through honest effort, advancement based on merit and a life well spent in service to my nation (CANADA) and my family, community, and friends. I am owed nothing, everything I am and gained I earned through honest effort and honestly owe to the simple fact that my country afforded me the opportunity, begining with my service in the 1st Special Service Force. I do not wish any appointments or honours, there are others who desreve more recognition and can serve better.


Jen
said

They can keep on living of the land. No more Government dishing out billions of dollars for a useless race.


Vanc Guy
said

Watching the meeting of all the Chiefs I was struck by how many look more like Europeans than aboriginals. If their benefits are going to be based on race how will that work if they're in mixed marriages? And this is the problem with any race or 'we were here first' arguments. People need to be equal - period.


Marty in PA
said

Well said Seeking Wolf. If I could vote, I would say you would be the best Natl Chief that the FNs people would benefit from. The pendulum has swung the opposite way in trying to assist the FNs and the tax paying Cdns are just being taken advantage of.


a card
said

education is a problem?? unless i am mistaken educatio till grade 12 is free for anybody & i have read in some of the articles that post secondary education is sponsored for any first nation person that want it. I wish my child could get free secondary education instead of me having to pay for it.


Taxed Enough Already
said

No more money...


lawstick29
said

@hal wood..... Xcuse me but First Nations have can and have done alot for their people!! more then you know! for instance surviving many great battles, starvation, physical,mental and emotional abuse... they have lived of the earth for many decades before european "civilization" was unearthed in2 a calm peaceful loving and respectful society!! Native way of life is survival!! why do you think F.N's PPL are still here?? Can you yourself honestly say that you could or would be able to survive in such conditions as F.N's have for hundreds of years?? and yet in this day and age it is ridiculously harder to survive in the white world due to $ and material wants and needs, but if need be they will and can survive in the "wild" without $ as the F.N'S people have kept their traditions and culture ALIVE!!


Joe M
said

@ others here on Seeking Wolf, my vote is to elect him to the Senate and represent people and society as a whole, another HARPER promise that is non-existent. The purpose of the Senate (which I want to keep) is to put people like Seeking Wolf and also to make sure the laws our parliament are trying to put in place, represent the people of this country, knowing the effect of a new law or change to existing law on the people of this country. If elected to parliament, I will ensure the only reform of the Senate is to ride the patronage posts and replace them with deserving Canadians that represent each portion of society, as best I can. Each view of their life is essential to formulate law, not to vote for any Govt of the day, but to say, this law is discriminatory, try thinking this way and see if you can improve the law. Yes, it takes a few years for some changes, because these are laws we should live by for a generation or two. His and their contribution is what you and I live today, not because SteveO put me here because I helped on his campaign. Yes, it’s been happening for years, now let’s do what was supposed to be the intent of the Senate. .. . .. .


Helene
said

All Mr. Atleo knows is to ask for more money..It is time for the Chiefs to go back to their individual reserves and start get things done on their own and withing their resppective budgets.Fix your own homes, clean up your school buildings, provide a safe and secure environment for your people etc...In short, accept resonsibility like the rest of us Canadians have to.


Steph
said

@ Seeking Wolf, your comment was truly inspirational and honest. free money does not bring any pride, ultimately it brings a slow and inevitable death of the soul. I thank you Sir and will be looking forward to read more of your words of wisdom.


Ottawa Jack
said

Interesting to read that Shawn Atleo wants Ottawa to demonstrate its commitments in the next federal budget. Will Shawn Atleo commit to full disclosure & accountability for all federal funds given native Bands & Councils?? If not, then we are back where we started.


michel~kanata
said

Seeking Wolf - you honour Canada!


Hal Wood
said

Until Natives come up with ideas that they can support themselves and build their own houses, this will never end. Everything I have heard from the Indians is Code for give us more money and less scrutiny. They cannot police themselves or control the greed of their beurocracy. THere is no treaty that says a free house to every Native, this is insane and unaffordable.


Jason
said

First off, I feel that if you do not have proper knowledge of a topic, you should not comment on it on a site such as CTV News. Secondly, when you comment on something, you should be non-bias, which is difficult for me to do but I will try my best. For all intents and purposes, I am a "white boy" That has spent much time in several different areas, each with a diverse culture. I lived over 2 years (2004-2006) on a native reserve as well I visited several other reserves in northern Saskatchewan. Throughout my stay there, I whitnessed many disturbing things that would actually coralate quite closely to many racial steriotypes. They continue living these ways because they can. This was proof the so called "solutions" of the past (mainly giving the reserves money or vehicles etc.) haven't worked, Both the PM and Atleo say it perfect with how things need to change. Things need to be taken one step at a time and education is the key first step. The aboriginal community already has the means to become educated, it is now how to refine that education and promote it to the aboriginal community so that they optimize on that opportunity


Brian Fr Langley
said

I reiterate, aboriginals must be allowed title to their own homes on their own land on their reserves. The right to buy, sell, or inherit. As Canadians we can not fullfill our legal treaty obligations by simply throwing money at the problem. All the Indian Act has done is create a racist, collective dependancy. Title to homes and businesses worked for you. Let it work for our 1st nations.


Mick
said

I do not profess to being an expert on the Indian Act, but I will guess a little as to why the two different points of view of Harper and Atleo. To abolish the Act would mean relinquishing control from the feds to the reserve chief. In some cases this would be justifed (ie. The reserve in the Okanagan run by Chief Louie, or the Blood reserve in Alberta). Prosperous and effective reserves that contribute to Canada. On the other hand you have chiefs like Chief Spence of Attawapiskat. To relinquish control to such a person would only be more damaging. Hence the Act is justified. Therefore, one size does not fit all. I believe Harper and Atleo have agreed to come to the middle of the argument and abolish the Act to deserving reserves, and keep the current Act with revisions for reserves such as Attawapiskat.Someone please tell me if I'm interpreting this wrong. If I'm correct, I believe this is a giant step forward in Crown and FN relations. One day, maybe before I leave this earth, I will see the day that Attawapiskat situations will be only a bad time in history.I believe all Canadians, including aboriginals, want the squaller, corruption, and dependence of First Nations to come to an end. But this does not mean sending more money. Transparency and accountability is key.


Seeking Wolf
said

Thank you for the kind sentiments and support, my friends.


Grim
said

Seeking Wolf - straight shooting, to the point, and speaking the truth. If politicians of all stripes, all levels of government spoke this way and acted this way - we could have real progress in our communities, our provinces, our nation and the world.


George V
said

Harper is not going to try the shot gun approach, changing the whole Indian Act in one swell swoop. No he will try to solve it one problem at a time starting with the most urgent. There are a host of problems, these will take years of negotiating to solve as it took years for them to manifest themselves, Let's not forget the cost, truck loads of money.


Thomas
said

reidjr suggest first you learn what you are talking about, for example, all Canadians are native of Canada, the group we are talking g about, the umbrella term is Aboriginals. Having said that in response to your assertion we have to talk about them, please do but, get rid of the racist assertions and rhetoric, no other group in Canada receives this God awful treatment from the Canadian rednecks like the indigenous ones. Man, a person can just arrived here today from another country and get better treatment and be spoken of better. Wake up, talk about them, ya right... Drop the racist over tones is what I am saying, when it comes to the Aboriginals in Canada and the issues that affect them. Personally, I am sick of it and have lost so much respect for Canada because of it.


Mick
said

Seeking Wolf gets my vote. I said yesterday that it's people like you that should step up and speak out to the native population. I will say it again today... We need people like you to run as chief of a community. Now given the fact that you are atleast 70 years old, I would understand if you wouldn't want to take on such a responsibility at your age. However, surely you raised children with the same values your father raised you with. Maybe they could run as chief. I am sick and tired of witnessing the corruption that exists among some of these chiefs. They intentionally supress their own communities for their own gain, then blame the feds. Chief Spence of Attawapiskat is either too stupid, not qualifed, or just plain old corrupt. Maybe all three. Have you noticed they won't let her speak to the media without her regional chief by her side. They are doing this to line their own pockets. That is their only motivation. These chiefs don't want change.When chiefs like Atleo come in and try to make substantive changes, the corrupt chiefs will vote them out. So the cycle continues.


peter in mb
said

@kinger, if you want to talk about the white mans double speak, how about the Aboriginal double speak. When the settlers came over from Europe and wanted trade to own land, the Aboriginals took the money and trade goods and laughed at them and said “ foolish white man No one can own the land!” And now they are saying that they own the land. This comes of course after100 years of the white man who built roads and citys and every thing else we have today with our hard work. And now the Aboriginal want something back (the land) that by their own words they never owned in the first place. There is also an Aboriginal saying that says “it dose not matter who was here before us, we are here now”. lets face it, There has been lies on both sides.


Earthwatcher
said

Both Atleo and Harper have a point. The Indian Act is out-dated and does not serve both interests as well as it should. Harper's analogy of blowing up the stump is accurate and while Atleo is an elitist himself, he acknowledges that First Nations people have to take more responsibility for their own actions. I think that is double speak for changing how they account for the funding they receive, perhaps make it a far more transparent and accountable procedure. The only ones to lose from that would be the numerous corrupt band chiefs and their pals the council members. Those families outside favor get crap. Take a drive through a reservation sometime. What you see is not always a lack of funding but a poor application of it.


Mark
said

Wonderful. "White men" can be attacked but not others....


Joe M
said

Seeking Wolf, i think i would enjoy meeting you for sure, i am the same, 1 land, 1 peoples. Time to unite this country based on Canadian Values and promote the cultural aspects of diversity. All lands belongs to Canada, my grandmother was an aboriginal and never once lived of the avails of society. She endured the depression, hunted for food like other newfies (yes, dad was one) and we all ate and enjoy our lives. Today, the 1st Nations peoples teach their young to have hatred in their hearts and all that breeds is whining, complaining and please give me the money anyway. I see many young today on reserves killing themselves over trivial issues, that to them are huge. Is there a way of providing a 5 year roadmap of moving those families isolated in areas that cannot be services with local services like in a major town (water, sewer, healthcare, heat, etc). Move the families to cities/towns and provide them work transition assistance for 10 years, some form of compensation to live and become more active in society, then use their villages as the summer cottage. I'm sure this is ideology talking, but i'm sure there's a better way of stopping the hatred they have and hatred it creates in other Canadians. Money is the root of evil the communities experience, but the cost of living there is something else also, no more snowshoeing, its skidoo. . .


reidjr
said

Thomas
If we want to fix this as a country we have to stop this we can't talk about the natives because its racist we have to all be open minded.


Morris Hounsell, Saskatoon
said

We need more people like Seeking Wolf and thousands of other people of native decent who have stepped outside the reserve quagmire. While this takes tremendous personal strength and determination, it is this individual commitment that is required to solve this problem. It should be the role of goverment, businesses and all Canadians to encourage every resident of the reserves to follow Seeking Wolf.


charmaine stick
said

HA!! As usual it all turns to money, money, money, money!! OMG how small minded some people are!!! If and when First Nations people quit "asking for handouts" will be the day when WE get all our land back, take all that abuse and assimilation back!! give us our hunting grounds and old ways of life back!! It is a known fact that the lifestyle we have been shown is only borrowed from another country!! Can you say you actually came from SOMEWHERE?? Where do your roots lie?? I know where i'm from and where my roots are and say what you will!! I ALWAYS HAVE BEEN, ALWAYS WILL BE A PROUD NATIV

Frank
said

I cannot understand why the Gov. General attended this summit , he is nothing more than another unelected patronage position like the Senate that is a total waste of the taxpayers money. The Indian affairs department should be scrapped now, there is literaly close to $15 billion of taxpayers money spent a year on that department without a penny accounted for at the end of each year and thousands of First Nations people living in poverty. I doubt very much that the Chiefs and Band council members want anything to really change about their system other than more money being sunk into their hands to put into their own pockets and hide in U.S. and overseas bank accounts. Nothing will ever change until they realize that their system does not and will never work.


Gorg
said

All I can say is that I think it's great that AFN and the federal government are looking at this to make some type of improvement. It won't be overnight. Leaving this alone will become nothing but a festering sore. The current situation as it is, isn't doing anything. Just one more item; I recall hearing from a lot of years ago, that the reserve system was the worst thing that ever could've been done. I agree!Doing that to humankind of any given background anywhere in this world would produce the same disastrous results.


A Koster
said

Glad Atleo figures he has another 100 or so years to live before this whole issue gets resolved... all in all he and other aboriginals are too trusting of a person that has demonstrated over and over again that he can't be trusted.. personally I'm disappointed that Atleo wasn't more assertive and that the outcome wasn't more decisive going forward... there was no clear progress made where their rightful claim to the land and it's resources were not explained and claimed while in the public domain.. oh well... sigh.. if they aren't ready to fight more assertively for what is theirs then I guess they are not ready yet... they have to do it themselves eh.. good luck FN.


John Lethbridge
said

It was interesting to me to see that Harper and Atleo appear to genuinely be enjoying each other's company during this summit. It's one thing to hear their same old and sometimes even eloquent speeches, it would be another to be a fly on the wall during some of their private conversations. These are two very bright individuals, and I think that this level of comradery at the top will bode well for positive change for natives.


Zzintron
said

Nice try, now we need to get rid of all those anti Harper anything folks that fester on forums like this one!


jim in ontario
said

So basically from what i read, all parties have agreed to keep disagreeing and talking in circles, so nothing was accomplishes other than businesses in Ottawa made a kiling on services provided. Soooooo funny.


kinger
said

what would make anyone think Indians had a choice on the Indian Act, Atleo has learned white mans double speak...


TheOtherLowellInBC
said

I suppose at some point in time, the Indian Act will disappear all together and aboriginal folk will integrate into regular canadian society meaning no special handouts etc. That would require a quantum cultural shift and change in attitudes of canadians. In the long run there probably would be less poverty and more successes in that community.


Seeking Wolf
said

This Canadian of Aboriginal descent says: Repeal the Indian Act outright, Disband INAC, End the reserve system and fully integrate the bands into Canadian society. ONE CANADA, ONE PEOPLE, ONE LAW FOR ALL CANADIANS. That means that the bands will have to get rid of the chiefs and councils, end corruption, and EACH INDIVIDUAL MUST TAKE RESPONSIBILITY for themselves. I Left the res in 1940 to join the army and never went back. My family prospered through hard work- that option is available to anyone with the guts to take it. End this cycle of poverty, corruption and dependance. For everyone else, forget this misplaced plolitically correct racial guilt nonsense. As my late father said in the 1950s, show me a 200 year old indian and then you have a land claim.


Ottawa Jack
said

Congrats to both PM Harper & Atleo for both taking the wise approach to these discussions. Change must be gradual but the AFN must realize that, in order to gain credibility with most Canadians, the issue of Band financial accountability must be addressed. Good luck guys. Let's all hope for the best.


Not Thomas
said

Hi, Thomas, I'm that red neck that's going to ruin your good feelings. If good feelings were worth anything I might not comment, however, good feelings don't pay the bills. Harper doesn't want to blow up the stump because that would leave a big hole in the ground. Well, Stevie, I suggest blowing up the stump of the Indian Act and filling the void with something called personal responsibility. You know, that thing that First Nations are sorely lacking. Personal responsibility to pay taxes and become a contributor to society instead of a burden on society. Get rid of the Indian Act, reserves and the chief system. Time they fended for themselves. We can never expect them to act like anything other than children if we keep handing them everything like small children. Then again, all politicians actually love the Indian Act because it provides them with a political football that's always a hot point issue to campaign on. Sort of like the Firearms Registration Act that Stevie said he would get rid of, yet to date he hasn't really made any moves to scrap. Just another political football to use as a campaign issue. If politicians actually resolved these issues what woud they have left to crow about ?


Just Saying - Ottawa
said

According to a reporter on the local radio station here in Ottawa this a.m. Harper and Atleo have been working together for over a year now on some of the issues. Changes certainly are needed for


Thomas
said

It sounds wise and promising for both sides, I pray that all turns out for the best for both sides. Just hope some redneck doesn't come on here spouting their erronous and racist/bigoted knowing like they do on all Aboriginal news stories and ruin the good feeling from this story.


SVCR
said

When are First Nations going to start contributing to society instead of ripping off Canadian tax payers? It is obvious they can't handle money as they have wasted all the tax dollars they were given and have nothing to show for it! Time for them to be self supporting!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Retrospective
said

I guess First Nations should not have agreed to the Indian Act in the first place, but their ancestors didn't think things through I guess. What I want to know is where to get one of those hats that Atelo was wearing.


Richard
said

The saying " white man speaks with forked tongue" is still very much apparent. Harper couldn't care less about the Native people.


Mr.Obvious
said

If there is one thing I have learned about the people running the world in history, they like to keep making the same mistakes over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over.... Glad to see your an optimist Chief.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Related Websites

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    10 Video(s) 10

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1