Top Stories -   

1
Assembly of First Nations Chief Shawn Atleo appears on CTV's Question Period on Sunday, Jan. 22, 2012. Anishinabek Nation Grand Council Chief Patrick Madahbee speaks to CTV Sudbury about the upcoming summit on Saturday, Jan. 21, 2012. Prime Minister Stephen Harper sits down to speak with Assembly of First Nations Chief Shawn Atleo in his office on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Dec. 1, 2011. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Assembly of First Nations Chief Shawn Atleo appears on CTV's Question Period on Sunday, Jan. 22, 2012.

First Nations want full partnership, Atleo says

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Native leaders concerned
Prime Minister Stephen Harper and many of his cabinet ministers will sit down this week with more than 400 native leaders to come up with a plan to improve living conditions of those living in First Nations communities. Roger Smith on the leaders' worries.
CTV News Channel: Native leaders meet with PM
A regional chief in Ontario, Andy Toulouse says because this nation is founded on treaties, Ottawa needs to figure out if they're ready to reaffirm the original relationship that was based on those treaties.
CTV's Question Period: Improving relationship
Assembly of First Nations National Chief Shawn Atleo discusses what the First Nations chiefs are expecting out of the meeting with Harper.
CTV Northern Ontario: Ont. Grand Chief optimistic
First Nations leaders are looking for real change when they meet with Prime Minister Stephen Harper and government officials at a summit Tuesday in Ottawa.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (67) Facebook   

Assembly of First Nations Chief Shawn Atleo appears on CTV's Question Period on Sunday, Jan. 22, 2012. Anishinabek Nation Grand Council Chief Patrick Madahbee speaks to CTV Sudbury about the upcoming summit on Saturday, Jan. 21, 2012. Prime Minister Stephen Harper sits down to speak with Assembly of First Nations Chief Shawn Atleo in his office on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Dec. 1, 2011. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Assembly of First Nations Chief Shawn Atleo appears on CTV's Question Period on Sunday, Jan. 22, 2012.

Photos

Assembly of First Nations Chief Shawn Atleo appears on CTV's Question Period on Sunday, Jan. 22, 2012.

View Larger Image

Date: Sun. Jan. 22 2012 9:16 PM ET

It's time the federal government "smashes the status quo" and allows aboriginals to become full partners in Canada, Assembly of First Nations Chief Shawn Atleo says.

At least that's one of his objectives going into the upcoming First Nations summit in Ottawa on Tuesday.

Speaking on CTV's Question Period Sunday, Atleo said First Nations are looking for real change from the government in terms of education, adherence to treaty rights and economic development.

But more importantly, First Nations need to be cut loose from the "remote control" that Ottawa has used in native affairs in the past so they can become "full partners" in Canada.

"Those are very fundamental, really important pieces that First Nations have been working on for a long time," he said.

While he's not expecting a full-day of budget talks, Atleo wants to see positive movement from Ottawa in these areas.

"You know, we're building on literally decades of work and reams of reports in areas like education," he said, adding the summit will not be a day for starting from scratch.

And, a lot of groundwork is already in place to take these key issues forward, he said.

Atleo said it's also a chance to move past First Nations' mistrust of Ottawa that's built up over years.

"It's an opportunity to be both practical and lay out those specific action areas that require change," Atleo said.

Although Harper won't be there for the entire event, it will be his first time to officially meet with native leaders since taking office in 2006.

That doesn't worry Atleo, who said the prime minister has shown his commitment to the process by having at least one-third of cabinet present at the summit, or the "whole machinery of government."

It's also important that Gov-Gen David Johnston will be present, reaffirming First Nations' relationship with the Crown, he said.

"What's really important in our interactions with this government and my conversations with this prime minister . . . we in fact are not working from scratch," Atleo said, referring to the joint action plan agreed to by Harper and First Nations leaders last year.

One northern Ontario chief attending the summit is optimistic progress will be tangible.

"There's been millions and millions of dollars spent on consulting but now we need to address the real needs in our communities," Anishinabek Nation Grand Council Chief Patrick Madahbee told CTV Sudbury.

The meeting comes at a time when the northern Ontario First Nation of Attawapiskat declared a housing emergency, which highlighted some of the problems faced on native reserves.

The federal government stepped in and appointed a manager to look after the band's finances, a move that angered native leaders across the country.

"There's been nothing but really tragic news in the media about the conditions in the Far North and those conditions exist in a lot of First Nations (overcrowding)," Madahbee said.

"So we have the solutions built into all these reports that have been done and we need some political will to effect some action," he said.

Madahbee would like to see a first ministers' conference held in the next 12 to 18 months.

Harper had earlier downplayed the summit's potential, stressing that the meeting will not be a "big bang" event with grand announcements and big funding boosts.

The prime minister is said to favour an approach that starts with pilot projects and builds on small successes.

With files from CTVNews.ca staff

Follow John Size on Twitter

Comments are now closed for this story

Doug in Alberta
said

@ Carl: I asked my MP the same question, and the answer I got back was basically the Federal Government doesn't have the stomach to even look at it.

@ Seeking Wolf: You have my absolute respect.

Maybe if we all wrote our MP's and asked for a review of the Treaties and the Indian Act, they might be convinced to do so. Mention Seeking Wolfs' story, as an example of what one man can achieve.


Guelph Observer
said

I'm sure most Canadians would like like to have a full partnership with the beloved leader of the Conservative Reform Alliance Party (CRAP). But we haven't gotten it in the past 6 years. So I've lost all hope. I'm sure that when the beloved leader wants the opinion of the First Nations peoples he will give it to them.


Lorne
said

Does this mean they are prepared to work and pay taxes just like the non-aboriginal people.I'm all for equality. This means aborioginals do not want government assistance anymore,will pay for their own housing, medical costs, prescription drugs, etc. It's about time and I agree with the Chief if that is what he wants.If I'm wrong and the Chief still wants all the amenities aboriginal people receive, then all I can say is "stop blowing hot air". Tired of listening to the same rhetoric!!!!!!!!!!


additup
said

i don't understand how people can jump up and down and flail their arms about and claim it is their tax money..try adding up the total in natural resources that are made than total up the budget allocated to aboriginal peoples and you will see it does not even equal .001 Percent.

A Koster
said

"Harper had earlier downplayed the summit's potential, stressing that the meeting will not be a "big bang" event with grand announcements and big funding boosts. The prime minister is said to favour an approach that starts with pilot projects and builds on small successes." .. Which means what exactly?.. that he gets to drag this on for another 100 or so years? I trust that FN will remember their protection of the evironment before their claim for resource royalties on any new projects.. forget the 'beads for Manhatten' mentality even if Harper can't.


mexican gringo
said

Start paying income tax and we'll talk....


Old Ted
said

What the first nations need is Clarence Louie running the show. He has shown, without a doubt, what works.


Truth Speaker - Toronto
said

@Flowerwoman - Have you ever lived on a "rez"? The majority do view these as free handouts. As for your implication of wrong doing, why should I pay for mistakes made by people hundreds of years ago who have no relation to me? Survival is about adaption. WE ALL need to adapt when our situations change. If we don't then our life turns into garbage. Why should 'first nations' be exempt from this reality? I have seen the 'reality' of a reserve first hand. It was insane and the problem is not the white man or a lack of money. The problem was with Chief and Council. When I was there the had lots of problems with the water purification system, it didn't work. The budget had money set aside to replace it but Chief and council took that money and bought new video slot machines instead. Mismanagement, and lack of oversight, is the biggest problem on reserves.


bill
said

Our government (both left and right) love spending tax dollars overseas on wars and aide at the same time they fail to fund and honor commitments to first nations,health care............It is stunning how many support the trillions we have sunk into places like Afghanistan while at the same time bash tax dollars going to our own people.As long as much of the population supports this upside down view of the world nothing will change.Is it any wonder most politicians treat citizens without deep pockets like morons when we act the part.


Rachel French
said

We need real change ....Make a difference today..


Ivan
said

Nothing will change until Aboriginal people take responsibility for their own futures and the Federal government lets them.


SUNNYMIST
said

I was once told that ALL Non Aboriginals in Canada are immigrants expect for the Aboriginals , Aboriginal people are The True Canadians because Canada was always the Aboriginals people First ..! It Great to hear that the aboriginal people are pushing for Answers.If the Conservative Government don't want to listen or change their attitudes towards the aboriginal people then it time that ALL Aboriginals People Stand Up together ,across Canada and Not support the Conservative government in Future Elections ! Nor have any more Aboriginal people to be candidates in the Conservative party ! Good Luck For Positive Changes , I hope the aboriginal people will be heard ...!


MikeInBC
said

Terry from Alberta: Could you please define "full equal partnership"? Does it mean that the First Nations will get all the same benefits that the rest of us get and in return will be responsible for looking after the own houses etc. Does it also mean that the First Nations People will also pay taxes like the rest of us do? Does it also mean that the First Nations will not get billions of dollars like the rest of us don't. Does it also mean that the First Nations will be responsible for their children attending and completing the schooling that is provided for them at no charge (including University)? If it means all of the above I think there should be an equal partnership.


Jonathan from Saskatoon
said

Full partnership means full accountability. Time and again we see that that is something they really don't want. Whether its the mishandling of funds at Sask Indian Gaming Authority (SIGA) (the executive who stole thousands was given a post facto raise to try to cover up the nearly million dollar fraud, and recently elected Vice-Chief to the Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations (FSIN)), the nearly decade long debacle of mis-spending at First Nations University of Canada (FNUC), or the coup at FSIN which ousted the one guy willing to bring accountability to FNUC in order to preserve it. Dutch LeRat, notably, was the executive at the center of the SIGA scandal, and one of the principle players in the FSIN coup. And that's just the last decade or so in Saskatchewan. Let's not forget the Northern Ontario reserve that spent tens of thousands on a brand new Zamboni while families were living in tents waiting for mould remediation as winter approached. The manager sent to start to fix the problem was promptly run off the reserve.Most chiefs strongly oppose the Accountability Act before Parliament, and despite having very negative views of the Indian Act, tend to oppose any proposed changes to it as it is their basis for near dictatorial control over their people on reserve. Dozens of chiefs take home more than the Prime Minister while being responsible for only a few hundred or thousand band members (the Mayor of Saskatoon, by contrast, has a salary of just over $100K for a booming city of about 250,000 residents).

spearitofcanada
said

How can a population of a specific ethnic backgroud, as small 698,025 /- persons, dictate how the rest of Canada should act towards them. I agree with most peoples comments. If they want full partnership than full taxation and the end of hand outs to them. Otherwise we will never have fair terms in dealings.


C - Calgary
said

I am all for a full partnership if the natives stop receiving these payouts and tax free priviledges. Otherwise, they need to sort out their finances (especially the chiefs) and make sure every native recieves the $70,000 the government is giving them. I am so sick of the back and forth of both sides.


Kevin
said

I am in support of the chief's issues. However, I am amazed of a lot of these comments that seems to place native issues in a negative tone. Canada is really First Nations. Native peoples were here first and what we, as all Canadians, built, used, or acquired in whatever way, came from the usage of the land of native peoples and we cannot ignore or forget that. Before Canadians start assuming native peoples are freebies to society, you all should learn the history of our native peoples in Canada and their tragedy caused by the government and the church!


Michel in Ottawa
said

It's time they become part of Canada and pay taxes just like everyone else.What happened to their people happened 400 years ago.. it's time to move on and it's time for us to stop pitying them... they are humans just like us and should be treated just like us... pay taxes and get nothing for it...


Scott ON
said

it's always baffles me how Natives think they have it so tough. Ask yourselves, when most people are invaded and their land inhabited by an opposing force, what happens to the Natives? just my 2 cents. I'm all for them being equal partners, just like the rest of us. That means taking and giving just like us. Nothing more, nothing less


An MBA in Toronto
said

gee, how much revenue (royalties, permit fees, taxes.etc) does the province get from mining and resource extraction on aboriginal territory? lots, you idiots. and non of that goes back to Attawapiskat. non-natives get the kickback from that in the form of good schools and hospitals down south. if timmins got nothing from all the resource development on their lands and it just went to queen's park, they would be pretty upset too. original treaties specified a sharing in the resources, but none of that money funnels back to the community. the treaties promised housing and education in exchange for access to those resources and they aren't holding up to their promises - the schools and homes are the worst! The combined total of all government spending (federal, provincial and municipal) is $24,000 a year for each Torontonian, in Attawapiskat its about $11,355 per capita. Attawapiskat doesn't have access to proper services - the basic requirements to life - shelter, water, education, nutrituous food and an healthy environment. It is very difficult to be a productive member of society when you must think of how your going to survive everyday. you people are so ignorant and so self-focused on your own tax dollar, you forget that your very privilege is reliant on the poverty of lands near where the resources come from.


Roger in Ottawa
said

Canada - all for one and one for all. We are all Canadians. End of Story. This is the 21st century. Time to move on. This First Nation business is hogwash in today's society. We all work together for one Nation. Period.


hollinm
said

What does he really mean when he says he want aboriginals to be full partners in Canada. Does it mean another level of government? Just hand them the money and don't ask questions? Recognize them as their own nation whatever that would mean? They keep using buzz words but they don't take responsibility for their own people. There are so many leaders for aboriginals the government does not know who speaks for all aboriginals. Perhaps instead of worrying about the feds Atleo should get rid of the corrupt leaders and chiefs rampant in most bands.


Terry from Alberta
said

I fully agree with Chief Atleo, that our First Peoples should have complete partnesship with our people of Engish and French heritage. It's way over due! Our Canadian government must stop it's condescending attitues towards our Aboriginal people - for decades treating them with such distain, like they were mindless children... as if they were sub-human. It's no wonder that many Canadians feel they can treat our Native people in the same disrespectful way. It has to stop! The time has come for our First Nations to take their rightful place in Canada, with full equallity, partnership, and governace in our great land.


No Feathers - Ottawa
said

While the Chief was on Question Period he was saying it is a matter of getting the young on board to show how working together will be great for the country. Time for the people of their nation to let people in there to teach what is needed and make something of their lives. The opportunity to work their land and benefit "all" Canadians as well as self worth.


Sober
said

Full partnership, full taxes and full responsibility.


Lev-Tov ZOHAR
said

I was raised to believe that all human beings are absolutely equal. Why are we being racist? Sorting out people, based on colour, is evil. South Africa studied the Canadian Department of Indian Affairs and implemented apartheid. It was evil. Tear up the British treaties, or let England pay. Let the "First Nations" people free. Oh, by the way, I support a one-million dollar settlement for every "First Nation" person who was alive when the British arrived. Everyone else starts fresh, as Canadian.


Gerry
said

I fully support the partnership proposal. Its about time the rest of Canada be granted the freedoms and economic benefits currently enjoyed by the self-styled First Nations. The current system of racism and corruption must end.


Ian, Duncan B.C.
said

I will support a Government of Canada that eliminates the term "First Nations" and dismantles the Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada department. When that happens, all First Nations and Inuits will be equal partners-- Canadians, just like me, you, and that brand new guy who just became a citizen last week.


MAL of TO
said

I believe it is a scientific acceptance that man as we know it, originated in the Middle East/African area then spread out across the world. The people we call natives came across the Bering straight or by other means from this area. So, since I am a third generation Canadian and my boys are fourth generation, why are we LESS Canadian than those who just emigrated here a different way? How many generations until my descendants are 'native'?


Highground
said

First Nations want a full partnership with Canada, then let's dissolve all those agreements, traties, they can start paying taxes, we don't have to pay thier education cost for post secondary etc ... all their travel expenses and they give all claims to ancestral lands. Maybe then we as Canadian Taxpayers can look at that sort of thing, but until then .....


Albertian
said

Living in northern Alberta I have seen the native issues first hand. "Full partnership" aka more money is not the answer. Our political leadership has known this for years. The average Canadian needs to realize that giving more money to the reserves will only continue the cycle of mismanagement, crime and general lower quality of life. Only when voters understand the realities of the situation and support real changes will politicians consider touching the subject. I suggest we start by examining the Osoyoos Indian Bands success story.


Seeking Wolf
said

Let me share my perspective. I am a Canadian who just happens to be of full aboriginal descent. Mr. Atleo, partnership means you have to take responsibility. Partnership does not mean you get to keep any special status or treatment. The bands in this country have NOT demonstrated that responsibility. Renounce status, take responsibility for yourself, including all the responsibilities of citizenship. All Canadians must have the same responsibilities and obligations, with NO special status or privilidges for anyone. ONLY then will you get any kind of "partnership". I left the res in 1940, joined the Army and never went back. Everything I have, and my family has, was earned not given.


R Edwards
said

Reading the article, it appears to me that First Nations have no desire to be equal partners, they want to be senior partners. Equality means that they would get treated the same as me...pay their own way. No, I don't believe they want to be equal.

Linda in Vancouver
said

Becoming "full parteners in Canada" has a nice ring to it.But "FULL" has to mean "FULL'.And that should apply to all Canadians.Not just people from First Nations. If you want to draw money from the public purse, you also need be willing to help put money into the public purse.If you want to be a full partner in Canada,you also have to stop saying "we are not Canadians,we are First Nations people". It seems to me,and as noble as Chief Atleo's statement sounds,he is a long ways from speaking for all First Nations people.Doesn't he have to get a concensus from them,before he can bring anything useful to the table? I doubt all First Nations people will be happy with any one position Chief Atleo takes.Some will.Some will not.It's like the east is different from the west. In that respect,they are exactly the same as every other group in Canada.Individuals with a variety of ambitions,a variety of living standards, and a variety of opinions. In fact,all that many of them have in common,is their opposition to non First Nation communities. Has no one else noticed that,before non First Nations people came along,many of these bands fought with each other? I do respect these people.That's why I refer to them as "First Nations".That's what they like,and I have no problem with that.I just can't get a coherent message from the collective that we refer to as "First Nations". No one is able to speak for all of them,because they are not all the same.


Logic
said

Too bad Clarence Louie, the Osoyoos band in B.C. is not THE Chief. He has made his band the most successful anywhere in North America. He treats his own people the same as others who work for the band's assets: winery, golf course, resort and spa, cement plant and many others. He tell a native prospective worker: do you think I should hire you because you're Native? If so, I won't because that tells me you think you need a break, therefore you're inferior. So pick up your boot straps and I'll hire you on your own merits.Therefore, that band is very successful and the people are very proud and should be.We need many Clarence Louie in this country.


Michael Kannon
said

Northern Affairs has been less that forth coming on Accountability and Transparency on how they conduct business. What do those 5,200 employees do exactly for Canada and First Nations? No one knows or is publishing reports.

Put Minister Duncan side by side with Chief of Attawapiskat, and Duncan is the one hiding numbers and not following his own Departmental Guidelines.


Ken S
said

So repeal the Indian Act, abolish reservations, eliminate all the freebies (education, health care, etc.) and require all aboriginals to pay all taxes on the same basis as the rest of us must.


Dayton
said

Why is it always about "us" and "them"? Can't we agree this is about "OUR" Nation that "WE" can build. Why the segregation? Offer the first nation's the dirt and assets on a per capita and let the chips fall where they may. Enough of this B.S. It's 2012 folks not 1812.


Flowerwoman
said

These are not free handouts! Your living on Native Land, you can't expect it to be free! They gave up their way of life and this is the thanks that they're getting?! Really people? Pretty ungrateful if you ask me!


Deb Ris
said

@Jake - You said Canada was Indian land and if I weren't Indian I should get off of it. WHY? When I listen to what they say their beliefs were in the past, they said Mother Earth couldn't be owned. Therefore when they "sold" the land to the white settlers, they committed fraud. They sold what they didn't own. It is illegal to do that, at least it was the last time I checked. Therefore all treaties should be considered null and void. Time for them to start paying their own way. My forefathers never stole anything from them. And according to the original treaties, they signed away the rights of future generations to lay claim to anything, or make more demands on the rest of the country. History can work both ways!


Shuswap Frasky
said

Enough already. Talk Talk Talk....... Give Give Give. It's about time the Canadian Taxpayer was given full and complete disclosure of the money that is given to each and every band in the country. It is also about time that the bands were required to produce a statement of expenditures to justify their program money from the Federal Government.It's also about time that the natives quit covering up for their greedy band leaders. If you want to live in squaller then that's one thing, but don't blame the Federal Government or the Canadian Taxpayer. Frankly I'm tired of everything in my province of BC been given over to the natives and everything renamed.


Proud Albertan
said

I can already see where this will go. Hey Mr. Harper we should be able to solve all the problems on our lands all we need is a massive boost to our funding! Oh yea and we want less government oversight. WAKE UP PEOPLE! This has to end!! How come we are the ones footing the bills for something that happened nearly 100s of years ago!! Why are we letting ourselves be guilted into paying all this money??


Bob Williams
said

Time for aboriginal nations to unite in a new province that incorporayes all reserves and claimed lands.


Jerryatric
said

Time to cut the strings alright - THE PURSE STRINGS!Successive governments have squandered billions to the chiefs. Nothing gets done. Time to get on their own 2 feet (novel idea) & become REAL partners by contributing instead of draining our economy. It's enough about how they've been unfairly treated 50 years ago & before. Look at the many immigrants who have come here from horrific conditions, struggled & made a success of themselves. Only the native Indians have sat back, collected government largess & always cried for more!!!


Dave in Ottawa
said

Partners are people who bring something to the table. Partners take the same risks and share the same rewards as we do. That's why we have them. What are you bringing? I know what you want, but what you giving in return. Or is this just the same old crow?


Swarley
said

Free handouts for school, cars, houses, food, no taxes and guaranteed government jobs because of your race? Clean up this mess. This country is run on racism. This takes billions out of our economy, and last time I checked our government was spending more on the "natives" than they were on anything else including national defense. Disgusting. How about a free one-way ticket to Quebec, and we just let 'em all go at once? Sound good to anyone else?


Actions speak louder than words
said

He may sound eloquent but actions speak louder than words! There will never be full equality until the double standards are eliminated. (they don't have to pay tax, yet get free health care, they don't have to follow the criminal laws yet normal folk have to) frankly the AFN is starting to sound a lot like a mob family or a group of domestic terrorists! Atleo you need to rein in your rhetoric and start DOING something for a change!


David
said

Lets smash the status quo by cutting all funding and let the first nations support themselves. They may have been here first but lets face it, when push came to shove they lost.


jrayj
said

I have worked for many years counseling on Native reserves, and I have come to the conclusion if we want change for the (RES Natives) then we need to get rid of the grand chiefs and (RES chiefs) and start giving the money the government allows to the people, and not to all the high flying corrupt chiefs that live high on the hog and do nothing for their people. The government is responsible for these people it's time they start showing that responsibility by helping the people, and not the fat cat chiefs out there that do not walk their talk.


Andrew in Vancouver
said

I don't like or agree with the term "first nations". I am not a "second nations" Canadian or a second class citizen and I don't believe for a second that the Aboriginals had the right to claim the entire continent for themselves or that Europeans did something wrong by coming here.


Carl
said

The only way Canada's aboriginal people can have full partnership in Canada is to get rid of the Indian Act, tear up all the treaties, abolish the federal Department of Aboriginal Affairs and start treating aboriginal people like everyone else. Then and only then will be all be true partners on an equal footing.


MAE in Ontario
said

This is just like a kid wanting to be treated like an adult. That kid doesn't get that right until he is earning his own way. If Aboriginals want to be treated equally then they should stop taking handouts from the government. You can't say give me the money and let us decide how to spend it no more than you are willing to do that with an adoklescent child. The aboriginals have to learn that he who holds the purse strings calls the shots


oddmerlin
said

Canada does not belong to the Indians it belongs to Canadians who pay taxes (Jake if you do not like it you get out) I am tired of all the crying you do for the little you contribute to society and Canada. We have way to many indian reserves we must stop the treaty system now close all reserves and let the people into society --they are all here anyways--to much money is spent on reserves they have been given to much money already all it did was make the car industry and tv people rich-- no more free handout --get a job pay taxes like everyone else and quit bitching -- Canada does not owe you anything


edgar nickel
said

I beleive that it's about time the hand outs are stopped period. These people are so used to being given everything for so long that they are incapable of doing anything for themselves.A big percentage of Canadian's are tired of driving through reservations where newer houses sit in ruins because they are to lazy to do any maintenance on them,and newer vehicles sitting in a heap in the yards because they know that "we" will buy them a new one.It's time to put everyone on the same playing field and quit wasting millions of dollars on people that don't respect it anyway.


Linda in Vancouver
said

I may be wrong,but it seems to me that a lot of people talk about First Nations people as if they were a monolithic group. Since they often stand together to support each other, I can understand why. But when the smoke clears,it ;looks to me that they have many differences among them selves,and that not all of them have the same needs.Or even the same ambitions. For example,there are quite a few bands in BC that seem to be doing fairly well.Some are logging their lands.Some are mining.Some others are in the energy industry.And one local band is trying to build a shoppoing mall.They are earning their livings by taking part and working in the national economy. Where this gets tougher,is where there are bands living on "traditional lands" that don't have the resources to sustain anything more than a mere subsistance kind of living. How do we move them forward? They don't want to leave the home of their ancestors,but bringing 21st century education and health care to remote parts of the country is a challenge that could easily take a century.Maybe more. Am I wrong? What am I missing if that is the case.What "they" are asking for,and what Canada has the ability to provide confuses me on a regular basis.The whole process seems to adversarial.


Aleithia
said

I was impressed by the interview. The Grand Chief's eloquence was excellent. I especially liked the idea of a first nations auditor general. So long as that is a serious commitment, not more window-dressing and deception, and AG would go a long way in helping Canadians rally behind 1st Nations people. I look forward to the day of better accountability, and a discipline towards those who have acted fraudulently on behalf of their reserves.


Kelowna_Win
said

The meaning of the treaties and wording have been taking totally out of context! Equality, I hate to be less than equal! A Caucasian Canadian


a guy from alberta
said

i agree with changing the way we treat natives. if a family can immigrate to canada with $50 and the clothes they are wearing and do ok, there is no reason we can't set up all the reservations to be self-sufficient


Bob in Chatham
said

Custer has it right. Why should one group of people be exempt from the taxes that are needed to provide the services that we all expect and use. Can my great great grandchildern look forward to being classified as a " native ". How many generations does it take before we are considered indiginous ? I'm a fourth generation Canadian, is 7 or 8 enough ? Giving handouts to these people will ensure that they never lead productive lives as Canadians.


rmsbl4
said

@ G.A. Custer Are you sure you are not describing Quebec.


gar
said

If they go there with the attitude that the deserve more hand outs from the taxpayers of Canada for something that history left them ,then Harper should tell them to get lost. If their attitude is we are all Canadians of equal rights they may find a great change for their people .such as personal land ownership. they should also be reminded that land Canadians own is subject to expropriation if it is deemed to be the betterment of all.


mike
said

If there are 600 chiefs then what are they being paid for? They certainly are not helping there people as we have seen across Canada with the housing conditions and poor living conditions.It is about time to end these free hand outs and have them join the ranks of all Canadian tax payers.My family have been in Canada since the late 1700 hundreds and they recieved no hand outs like the natives and the immigrants that come here.No more hand outs, start working for a living, you will probably find that hard work will make you appreciate what you have.


Sunnydog
said

The chiefs are ripping off the members of their own communities. They live on salaries in the tens of thousands while their fellow community members live in poverty. What's so difficult to understand about that.


Jake
said

Canada is Indian land. If you ain't Indian get off it.


Slewhigh Yendick
said

These 600 chiefs,, how much are they paid and where does that money come from ??


G.A.Custer (ret'd)
said

Scrap the Indian Act, patriate all indians as Canadian citizens. Stop the treaty system of free handouts and make them pay taxes like everyone else. Enough of this babying them and treating them like children. They will never grow up and be responsible citizens as long as they are being treated like two year olds at Christmas. Two year olds at Christmas don't care if anyone else gets anything at all just as long as they get everything they asked for.


Jake
said

round and round we go......


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    7 Video(s) 7

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1