News Sections
Floor-crossing MP slammed for 'blatant lack of respect'
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
Selected Comment
This MP should resign her seat and run as Liberal in a bi-election.If an elected MP wants to change political philopshy and parties, they should be required to face the very people who voted them in to office. A bi-election should be required before they can sit as a member of a party whose policies the voters of their riding did not vote for.
Face the Voters
Quebec NDP MP jumps to Liberal caucus
talking about
Floor-crossing MP slammed for 'blatant lack of respect'
CTVNews.ca Staff
Date: Tue. Jan. 10 2012 10:15 PM ET
While the federal Liberals cheer MP Lise St-Denis' decision to trade her NDP membership for a seat in the Grit caucus, New Democrats counter that the move represents a "blatant lack of respect for democracy."
Quebec MP Lise St-Denis made the announcement at a press conference in Ottawa Tuesday.
"I have decided to join the Liberal Party of Canada," St-Denis said, explaining that she came to her decision while observing the Liberal caucus at work in Ottawa over the last few weeks.
"I recognize today not only the collective value of their work, but more so their sense of duty and commitment," she said.
Crossing the floor, she added, does not represent a shift in her politics, but rather "the continuity of my thought process on Canada's future and the place that must be taken in our institutions by Quebecois and francophones all over the country."
St-Denis, who was one of 59 NDP MPs elected in the spring election, won her seat in the Saint-Maurice-Champlain riding with 39 per cent of the vote. The Liberal candidate for the riding once held by former Liberal prime minister Jean Chretien garnered just 12 per cent of the vote.
The one-time supporter of fellow Quebecer Thomas Mulcair's NDP leadership bid said her decision to switch parties "is that of a woman free to express her political opinion."
Her motivation, St-Denis explained, is rooted in a view of Canada's political future she now realizes is shared with the Liberals.
"We live in a time of fundamental transformation, globally and nationally. It is thus crucial that we make choices that will undoubtedly protect who we are and who we want to be."
On hand for the press conference, interim Liberal Leader Bob Rae was quick to welcome the newest member of his federal caucus.
"The rebuilding of the Liberal Party of Canada depends on people like Ms. St-Denis who have the courage of their convictions and who join our fight against a Conservative government rooted in rigid and dangerous ideology," he said in a statement.
The Liberals' Quebec caucus chair was similarly effusive in his statement of "heartfelt welcome."
"I have always admired people who make decisions based on their principles and convictions, and I can assure Lise, on behalf of my colleagues in our Quebec Caucus, that she will have all the support necessary to better serve the constituents of Saint-Maurice-Champlain," Denis Coderre said.
Coming the day before Liberal MPs and Senators are due to gather for their two-day policy strategy session in Ottawa Wednesday, there's little doubt the floor-crossing announcement could boost morale.
Later on Tuesday, Coderre revealed that the road to defection began in earnest several weeks ago, when St-Denis first made contact.
"She's a woman of reflection and she's doing her duty on policy," Coderre told CTV's Power Play, adding that St-Denis has sought pragmatism over dogmatism.
In December, Coderre told St-Denis to think about her decision over the holidays, and to make sure she wanted to go through with it.
Among her gripes with the NDP were policy decisions about the bombing mission in Libya and the federally aided construction of the Champlain bridge in Montreal, Coderre said.
"I think that we have to realize that we have a woman who didn't feel that she was in the right place," Coderre said.
NDP issues byelection challenge
But the NDP made it perfectly clear they were not going to let St-Denis' defection go unchallenged, and New Democrat MP Peter Stoffer said that the voters should have the final say.
"I think it's wrong, if she wants to become a Liberal member she should go back and seek a by-election," he said.
Stoffer added that Parliament will debate a bill next month that would seek to eliminate floor-crossing from the political landscape.
"The seat belongs to the people of the riding," he added.
While pundits have said the defection is a heavy blow to an NDP caucus that has appeared rudderless since the death of former leader Jack Layton last summer, Stouffer is remaining upbeat about his party's future.
He characterized the incident as a "speed bump," and he stressed that his party will remain optimistic and focused on the election of a new leader on March 24.
Earlier, NDP Quebec Caucus Chair Guy Caron was blunt in his party's response.
"Recruiting elected members from other parties is clearly the old way of politics," Caron said, characterizing the recent votes for his party as a signal Canadians "have had enough of cynicism, cronyism, separatism and partisanship.
"Changing political affiliation is a blatant lack of respect for democracy that encourages cynicism toward politicians," he continued, before issuing the Grits a challenge.
"If the Liberals think it's what the voters of the riding want, we challenge them to run Madam St-Denis in a byelection," he said.
St-Denis' defection means the third-party Liberals' seat count bumps up to 35, including 8 from Quebec. The official Opposition NDP is down to 101 seats, while the majority Conservatives are down to 165, after Peter Goldring changed his affiliation to Civil Libertarian. The Bloc's four MPs and the single seat held by Green Party Leader Elizabeth May round out the Commons seat count.
Parliament convenes for its next session on January 30.
User Tools
Related Stories
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
If 5000 jobs can be so vital to the nation's economy, they should get what they ask for in bargaining. Simple.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Prof. Pye Chartt
said
Chad in Victoria
said
mike
said
back and to the left
said
Peter
said
Sudbury Darren
said
Speaks for itself
said
Marie
said
Mark in Newmarket
said
JB in Ontario
said
Alien8
said
yukonjj
said
Will
said
Al
said
peter in mb
said
Truth hurts
said
Louis Mohacsi
said
Laurie
said
Nita
said
hark! a solution
said
spaz
said
Ronnie
said
Joe C, London
said
grumpy ol man
said
Doesn't make much difference though.
Its like New and Improved Laundry Soap...same old crap in a new box!
Doug in Alberta
said
Bournefree
said
Joe C
said
gatvol, Edmonton
said
Charlie
said
Money Talks
said
John from Edmonton
said
David Fraser Nanoose Bay BC
said
Alan
said
Bob
said
OMG
said
Jeff
said
norman bowers
said
Steve in Vancouver
said
Ken Duncan
said
Canadian George
said
john
said
john
said
Phil in London
said
Duane
said
Shane
said
Ian
said
Chris in Toronto
said
peggy
said
Ian
said
Ben
said
ian
said
Just Saying - Ottawa
said
Jay
said
United Parties of CANADA
said
JV
said
Anne
said
dualstrats
said
M.M.B. Ont
said
TheOtherLowellInBC
said
Pat
said
susie-q mtl.
said
GHW
said
Thomas
said
Usqueadmare
said
peter in mb
said
Greg from Victoria
said
Pat
said
Peter
said
Canadian Bob
said
SW Calgary Guy
said
Nick
said
Will
said
Joe Szentirmay
said
Don
said
Jazz
said
edCP
said
Steve in Ottawa
said
Claude
said
Tom
said
Bally
said
Rasclaat
said
Chris in Kingston
said
Wayne
said
Mark - Calgary
said
Jane
said
Jack @ Ottawa
said
James in Calgary
said
Anne
said
John Lethbridge
said
This is Surprising?
said
geebee
said
Brian from calgary
said
Fred
said
Canadian Bob
said
KC-bby
said
bcken
said
Rajjer
said
Prof. Pye Chartt
said
tea D
said
Bob
said
Ross
said
Retired in Burlington
said
Jason Daniel Baker, Toronto
said
Dano
said
Len D
said
Dan
said
Original Canadien
said
allan
said
Kevin
said
Jackie Barrett
said
Just Saying - Ottawa
said
Paul in Ottawa
said
Matt
said
Orange Crush
said
FCS
said
The Dude
said
Chris V
said
Remarkable
said
PBW
said
Devil's Advocate
said
George
said
Patti, Mississauga
said
Sailor
said
T.B in BC
said
Alexandria
said
ben
said
Rick in the Hat
said
Len
said
Allan - Angus, ON
said
B in Ottawa
said
Doug
said
Lorraine
said
What's wrong with you people ? People have the right to change their minds however, this having been said the questions' are: "what does their constituents think of a banner change ? Do they agree ? Do they approve ?
If an elected representative finds that the ideology of the banner he/she ran under doesn't suit them anymore, shouldn't they simply become independant instead until a next election ? etc.etc.
To Ross: pertaining to 'tax increase' by the Conservatives, where did you get this info or is it just something coming out of your head just for fun ?
jrayj
said
MexPat
said
spasticus
said
NALA - Ontario
said
Brenda
said
Bill
said
Parliamentary Democracy
said
mike
said
I would bet most people in her riding voted for her becuase of the party. Now they are stuck with her 5 years, but she is still an individual, who can jump ship.
If we vote person, you can end up with a prime minister who you don't like.
We need political reforms. Want disolussioned voters to get more active, at least chop the executive government functions from the house functions, so there are more checks and balances in the system.
Ron from Georgetown
said
jrayj
said
Jazz
said
Bubba: Call an election
said
John
said
Doug
said
TracyQuébec
said
mike beard
said
MARG MM
said
RZ
said
Tim
said
Eggbert A. Fedora
said
Big A
said
mahanna ali
said
BC Ottawa
said
Paul
said
Ross
said
Robert in Beaconsfield
said
Cambob in Toronto
said
FCS
said
Raymond
said
Jackie Barrett
said
Ian Robertson
said
DS London
said
Randy c
said
Mark, Caledonia
said
Northern Princess
said
Free Willy
said
alfred
said
Jim-Surrey
said
QUINN
said
Stella in Toronto
said
Mark
said
TC
said
James, Ontario
said
Vanc Guy
said
PincoCommi
said
Intelligent Liberal
said
Face the Voters
said
Joe Smith
said
lynnees
said