Top Stories -   

1
In this photo taken Nov. 29, 2011, a poster on a fridge inside a grocery shop in Oslo, Norway reads: Shoppers are bringing home much more than they bargain for when they come home from the grocery store.

Butter shortage in Canada? Fat chance, dairy farmers say

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News Channel: Butter shortage in Norway
Reg Noble of Ryerson University discusses the factors contributing to Norway's butter shortage, including an ailing dairy industry and high demand for butter during the holiday season.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (13) Facebook   

In this photo taken Nov. 29, 2011, a poster on a fridge inside a grocery shop in Oslo, Norway reads: Shoppers are bringing home much more than they bargain for when they come home from the grocery store.

Photos

In this photo taken Nov. 29, 2011, a poster on a fridge inside a grocery shop in Oslo, Norway reads:

View Larger Image

Date: Sat. Dec. 17 2011 12:32 PM ET

Keep calm and spread on.

That's the message the Canadian Dairy Commission has for the nation's butter enthusiasts as Norway copes with a serious shortage of the golden spread.

"It would be extremely surprising to see a butter shortage in Canada," says CDC spokesperson Chantal Paul.

Proverbial alarm bells rang over the security of butter stocks last week when Norway made headlines for depleting its stockpiles just before Christmas.

As a result, the Scandinavian country has seen its butter prices soar. The steep costs reportedly tempted a not-so-slick-handed smuggler to try entering the country with bricks of black-market butter.

Back in Canada, Paul says dairy aficionados need not fret about the nation's butter supply. She says the country's reserves are safe thanks to a lot of vigilance and a little bit of math.

"What we look at is how much butter fat Canada is going to need in the next 12 months," she explains.

Using a little something called a "disappearance calculation," Paul says the CDC is able to anticipate demand and issue a quota for butter production.

Government numbers indicate Canada produced more than 80 million kilograms of butter last year; a figure that Paul says is carefully conceived and includes a contingency plan.

"We always have a buffer with the butter stocks," she says. "If we underestimated demand and didn't produce enough milk then we'll put the stocks back on the market."

There is a certain amount of butter Canada has to buy due to World Trade Organization regulations, but otherwise Paul says the country doesn't need to import the slick stuff.

Hypothetically, she says that would only happen in the event of a Great Canadian Butter Shortage – something Paul says she's yet to see in her nine-year career with the CDC.

Dairy insiders have been quick to blame Norway's buttery crisis on a number of factors including a wet summer that hindered milk production and the growing popularity of a low-carb, high-fat fad diet.

Dieters and unseasonable weather conditions aren't exclusive to Nordic nations, so what is it that makes Paul so confident in Canada's butter supply?

Her answer lies in Canada's size, not its stockpiles.

Geographically, Paul points out that Canada is larger than Norway, which allows the country to spread out production and have one area compensate for another if need be.

"It's very unlikely that you're going to have bad weather from sea to sea in one particular year," she says. "So that kind of spreads the risk a little bit and reduces it."

However, food insecurity expert Reg Noble is less confident about Canada's ability consistently stock shelves with butter – let alone any product -- year after year.

He points out that the global food distribution system runs on a "just-in-time" basis, meaning that a small hiccup on the manufacturing or transportation end could trigger a sudden shortage.

"If there's a disruption in production at the other end of the food chain or if there's anything in between…then we would have a serious problem," he told CTV News Channel last Wednesday.

Statistics suggest Canadian butter production has been relatively predictable. Whether it's salted or calorie reduced, Paul says demand tends to peak around Christmas baking season and dip in the spring.

Production did drop more than 8,100 metric tons between 2005 and 2006, a decline that Paul says might have happened because of a persistent heat wave in Ontario and Quebec around that time. Cows, as it turns out, don't take too kindly to hot and humid situations.

Bill Mitchell, a spokesperson for Dairy Farmers of Ontario, says it's natural for Canadian butter stocks to fluctuate a bit.

Overall, he says it's unlikely that Canadians will find themselves at a loss for the fatty milk byproduct. But as butter prices soar in Norwegian grocery stores and peddlers flood into online marketplaces, Mitchell hasn't ruled out any unforeseen circumstances.

"The demand is very predictable, the supply is very predictable," he says. "Having said that, nobody can ever say anything's impossible."

Comments are now closed for this story

Barry O'Regan
said
0 0

Butter, an untapped Canadian resource! We need to sell,sell, sell to Norway fast before other countries get onboard! Canada could be the Dubai of Butter!


Rob in the north
said
0 0

The price of milk might be going up but don't blame the farmers.These people pay outrages prices for there quotos that the reugular person on the street knows nothing about.Nice tax grab for the marketing board and government.Hard work and little thanks for the hours and money they put into this products.Look at the break down on milk prices and you will see from start to finish a bag of milk the government keeps adding there taxes (hidden or not)... everything has added the increase.


Christina
said
0 0

No matter. I will still go to Plattsburgh to buy cheap milk, butter, cream cheese, eggs and dairy products. You can get a gallon of milk for under $2 and a brick of cream cheese for $1.29. Thank you dairy board for fleecing Canadian consumers!


noodle
said
0 0

Maybe our government should look at abolishing this monopoly and let free market run its course. If its good for the Wheat Board...........


Remarkable
said
0 0

From my understanding, if Canada wants to become more involved in the globalization with new trading partners, the governments of this country will have to get rid of all these different agricultural boards such as the milk marketing board. Out west they got rid of the wheat board and I fear this is only the beginning. If the marketing boards are done away with, all your dairy products will stay the same if not will increase more.


MikeInBC
said
0 0

Our minister of agriculture recently said that the price of milk in Canada was pretty much the same as it was in the US... $4.00 he said. Last year when we were in Arizona a jug of milk was $2.55. We checked with some friends this year and it was on sale in Yuma for $1.59. Here on Vancouver Island we pay over $5.00. Hooray for Dairy Boards (and our Agriculture Minister).


Sam C
said
0 0

Not sure that Norway even has its own dairy industry. Much of their food is imported from the rest of Europe, and the price is (to us, at least) shockingly high. It's a completely different situation to anything we could be facing.


One Canadian
said
0 0

It seems that the World trade Organization is looking to punish the poor even more. how much more are we going to put up with the world deciding what Canadians should pay. Enough, is enough, how is it that we don`t follow the world on climate change, but when it comes to the resources we produce here in Canada, they charges us through the nose... Welcome to the New World Order !!!


Jim Clancy
said
0 0

Thanks to our milk marketing boards, Canada has an excellent system. Maybe if we start shipping our extra butter to Norway, we'd could all make a few extra bucks. LOL


ontario dairy farmer
said
0 0

But thanks to those marketing boards you don't have to subsidize farmers. Americans may not have marketing boards but they receive very generous subsidies which we do not. Marketing Board or no the price of milk, eggs etc will not drop--it isn't the farmer who is getting rich we are just trying to make a living.


But of Course
said
0 0

Thanks to the marketing board, butter is 2 to 3 times higher then across the border in USA, same with milk, cheese, eggs... etc


Ivan
said
0 0

As a friend said: 'Butter isn't a food, it's a lubricant'


vince in kingston
said
0 0

Here we go...... nice job, now it will be an excuse to jack the price of butter here ...... next week butter will be $7 a pound...... keep up the fear mongering...... remember what they said about gas!!!


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    7 Video(s) 7

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1