Top Stories -   

1
New Democratic Party Nycole Turmel stands during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, Dec. 1, 2011. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS) A man walks down the street in Attawapiskat, Ont., Tuesday Nov. 29, 2011. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Minister of Aboriginal Affairs John Duncan stands during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, Dec. 1, 2011. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Attawapiskat, northern Ontario community, Attawapiskat map, Google Red Cross, worker, Attawapiskat, crisis Red Cross, worker, Attawapiskat, crisis Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan appears on Canada AM from CTV studios in Ottawa, Thursday, Dec. 1, 2011. Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan appears on Canada AM from CTV studios in Ottawa, Thursday, Dec. 1, 2011.

NDP accuses Ottawa of 'punishing' Attawapiskat

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Attawapiskat crisis escalates
New details emerge about how money is managed on the Attawapiskat reserve. Daniele Hamamdjian reports.
Power Play: How to solve the Attawapiskat crisis
Conservative MP Greg Rickford and NDP MP Charlie Angus discuss the best way to resolve the crisis in Attawapiskat, as well as the political consequences in aiding the community.
Question period: Turmel slams Tories
NDP interim leader Nycole Turmel says the people of Attawapiskat need running water; instead, the government is sending auditors. Prime Minister Stephen Harper says the government is acting immediately to the community's needs.
Question period: Bennett and Duncan debate
Liberal MP Carolyn Bennett says Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan doesn't know what he's talking about, and asks when the prime minister will stop blaming others for the Canadian tragedy.
CTV News Channel: Calls for more gov't action
Carolyn Bennett, Liberal critic for aboriginal affairs, explains the situation in Attawapiskat is a perfect example of what is not working for Canada's aboriginals.
Canada AM: John Duncan on Attawapiskat
The Aboriginal affairs minister says quite a bit has been done recently to get the people of Attawapiskat in warm, safe houses. He also explains how he will not travel to the reserve, as he is confident in his officials' briefs.
Canada AM: Where has the money gone?
Alan Pope, author of Report on the Kashechewan First Nation and its People, says the government probe into the $90 million is a good move, as people need to be assured how their tax dollars are spent. He also discusses the dire housing crisis in Attawapiskat.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (179) Facebook   

New Democratic Party Nycole Turmel stands during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, Dec. 1, 2011. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS) A man walks down the street in Attawapiskat, Ont., Tuesday Nov. 29, 2011. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Minister of Aboriginal Affairs John Duncan stands during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, Dec. 1, 2011. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Attawapiskat, northern Ontario community, Attawapiskat map, Google Red Cross, worker, Attawapiskat, crisis Red Cross, worker, Attawapiskat, crisis Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan appears on Canada AM from CTV studios in Ottawa, Thursday, Dec. 1, 2011. Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan appears on Canada AM from CTV studios in Ottawa, Thursday, Dec. 1, 2011.

Photos

New Democratic Party Nycole Turmel stands during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, Dec. 1, 2011. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

Date: Thu. Dec. 1 2011 11:08 PM ET

Prime Minister Stephen Harper says the remote community of Attawapiskat requires financial oversight along with emergency shelter, but Opposition MPs continued Thursday to accuse the government of mishandling the ongoing crisis.

With winter approaching and a number of families living in uninsulated shacks, tents or in mold-infested homes, the northern Ontario aboriginal community near James Bay recently declared a state of emergency.

But during a second day of intense questioning in Parliament Thursday, NDP MPs hammered the government for hiring a third-party financial auditor to track the $90 million Ottawa has spent in Attawapiskat since 2006.

"Does the prime minister realize that with this third-party management, the message he is sending is that if you need help, shut your mouth or you will be punished. That's his answer," said Nycole Turmel, the NDP's interim leader.

"It's interesting to see that the prime minster realizes that there are needs there, but he thinks there are accounting needs, instead of the human tragedy that we are seeing there."

Responding, Harper said that the government is working with the community to provide relief, but he stressed that better management of resources is also a key issue.

"It is obvious there continue to be needs. The government is working to fulfill those needs. But the needs are two-fold: there is a need, obviously, for more services and infrastructure. There is also clearly a need for better management," said Harper.

The issue became the focus of a meeting Thursday between Harper and Shawn Atleo, grand chief of the Assembly of First Nations. Atleo said the crisis should be used as a starting point for new relations between aboriginals and the federal Crown, with a summit between the two groups scheduled for January 24 in Ottawa.

CTV's Daniele Hamamdijian has reported that along with squalor and poverty, the Attawapiskat community recently purchased a new Zamboni for cleaning hockey ice. Hamamdijian also reported some questionable travel expenses amassed by the community's leadership.

She also reported that the reserve's co-manager, who is supposed to monitor how government funds are spent, is the common-law partner of the chief.

The Attawapiskat band council declared a state of emergency one month ago, prompting media headlines, political reaction and a visit from the Red Cross, which is delivering sleeping bags and food to the community.

Though Harper has repeatedly said the federal government has spent $90 million in Attawapiskat since 2006, critics say the government simply hasn't done enough.

In fact, Turmel said that the government's annual investment in the community is about half of the average spent on each person in the rest of Canada. Quoting the government's own numbers, Turmel said that the average per-person investment across Canada is about $19,000.

"How is that possible -- why are you blaming the community?" asked Turmel.

Earlier in the day, Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan said the government's decision to appoint a third-party manager came because "there are a lot of things that don't add up," such as missing reports and money earmarked for housing.

"There are reports outstanding, we understand there are housing moneys that are unspent, there are a lot of things that don't add up and that show we need to have a departmental official in place, a departmental representative in place," Duncan said.

However, the NDP MP from the area said that Duncan's response is unbecoming of his position as the government's point-man on the aboriginal issue. NDP MP Charlie Angus also took issue with the fact that Duncan has yet to travel to the community and witness the squalid conditions first-hand.

Angus went on to ask: "Does (Duncan) have a plan, or is this a desire to punish an impoverished little community for making him look bad?"

Both Turmel and Angus have gone to the community recently, while Duncan has left it up to his staff to report back to Ottawa.

"If he was a leader, he would be there," said Angus.

Long-term plan needed

Turmel said earlier on Wednesday that the community needs more money as a short-term solution to the housing crisis as winter arrives, but also said a long-term plan is needed.

Duncan said that's the goal, with immediate housing solutions being provided for those in the most desperate circumstances, and steps underway to create a long-term plan.

Alan Pope, a Timmins-based former provincial MPP and lawyer who wrote a report for the federal government on the troubled community of Kashechewan in 2006, and is familiar with Attawapiskat, said the issues are not new.

"For all the political declarations by band councils and the clerical histrionics by the local member and political maneuvering in Ottawa, this issue is not one of a sudden emergency, it's a longstanding urgent problem," Pope said.

He added that in 2006 the department of Indian and Northern Affairs Canada told him there was no housing policy in place for First Nations communities -- and that doesn't appear to have changed.

Comments are now closed for this story

Rob in the north
said

You have to remember this didn't all happen over night and it is not just one government that should be blamed for these living conditions.


Lincoln, BC
said

In my socials class today we did played with numbers each person gets about 5500 dollars, but then they need to pay for tons of things that 5500 dollars just doesn't cover. here in BC the provincial gov't gives 8000 dollars to school districts for one person. Kind of sad really the way the Conservatives are doing this. I can happily say I can vote next election and I'l be voting for the opposition


Too Sad
said

Band leaders and all levels of government have been pointing the finger of blame back and forth for well in excess of 100 years now which clearly isn’t solving the appropriate use of funds problem. The pictures show a Cadillac Escalade and the vast majority of residents with Satellite TV computer with internet. This reserve of 1400 residents also boasts a hospital/heath centre easily as large as that of the one in my small town that services approximately 50,000 residents. The band leader has scathingly criticized the sleeping bags flown in by the Red Cross without suggesting just what it is then the resident’s need that would be helpful to their plight.


anji
said

Al, you say relocate the community so they have somewhere to have a "chance"? This community worked well for hundreds of years, until people began to influence them and make them sign treaties... which made them wards of the crown. Fortunately, First Nations have a sacred connection with the lands they are from. A First Nation from the East Coast, won't feel at home on the West Coast. I don't even feel comfortable enough 200kms away from my home community. We're attached to our lands spiritually. I hope that more Canadians learn about us, before judging us. The ignorance I see in these stories, is astounding!And, by the way... I am non-status, pay all taxes and have paid every single dollar of my $70 000 in student loans.


Alien8
said

To the poster who said now is not the time to be doing an audit, I see no reason why the goverment cannot simultaneously provide emergency relief and perform a financial audit at the same time. This would take place by two different branches of government, both who should be engaged immediately for obvious reasons.


J.C.
said

I don't see how according to N. Turmel that the PM is punishing that community. They just want to know where the money went and what it was used for just as many taxpayers want to know. The Chief of the band may very well need this kind of help just as many businesses do. In the meantime, other help is needed for the short term such as emergency shelter, water, and waste disposal to keep infections and disease down. Since this has been going on for such a long time, I would say that all in parliament are guilty of not paying close enough attention. To lay the blame one one party over another is ridiculous. Fighting in parliament will not help resolve anything. Parliament needs to work together and do some brainstorming and some ideas put forward to remedy the situation once and for all.


Bill in Calgary
said

Apartheid ended in South Africa years ago, and it's time it ended here. Keeping aboriginal people segregated in remote gulags under force of arms is reprehensible. These people should be unshackled, and set free to enjoy the bounty of their labor, just as other free citizens of this great country are. Tear down the fences and guard towers. Remove the armed guards, and set them free!


Mark J.
said

Another reason why the NDP will never get my vote. They have an incredibly immature way of looking at this problem.


charlie
said

Only in the loopy minds of the NDP can an audit to determine what happened to 90 million taxpayer dollars, as it apparently all went down the rabbit hole never to be seen again, be considered "punishment". This is how the NDP stands up for the average Canadian taxpayer and seeks value for the tax dollars spent? Would it also be punishment if this was a defence contractor involved who was being asked to account, rather than a First Nations group? The Government is taking appropriate action to see to the critical needs of the residents, aside from the inquiry into the elusive funds. If this is how the NDP thinks, they need not advance any other reason as to why they will never be the governing party. Punishment to ask recipients where all that taxpayer money went, and to ask them to account for how it was used? Punishment? The mind boggles.


Elder
said

Does this mean then that Harper will conduct a forensic audit of INAC to see how much of that money regional INAC bureaucrats hijacked? You remember INAC, that bloated, top heavy, self congratulatory fatheads and apples??


Lorna
said

The Chief of Assmbly for 1st nations is demanding more money to solve this problem. My question for him and the NDP leader is what has happen to all the money the government has already handed over to this band. Just maybe some very hard questions should be asked to the band cheif why with all the money this band has recieved they still have people living in tents. I do not know, with the population of this band and the fact that since 2006 they have received almost 90 million $ I would have thought every family there could have a new house with lots of money left over for other things.


reidjr
said

Emily N
The point people are trying to make is this money should be going right to the people $90 million is alot and for what ever reason its not getting to the people.


Jack in Edmonton
said

WOW, now the NDP say Ottwa is punishing the reserve. Really? Giving them $90 million and free houses and free medical and dental and everything else is punishment. This reserve, and all others, made the bed they are sleeping in. Ottawa gave them money to manage and help their people, they didn't and now there is no trace as to where the money went. Turmel, you and the NDP are punishing Canada just by opening your mouth. There is a small comparison between the natives and Quebec. Always have their hand out for money from the government because they are their own nation and it is never enough. As soon as they are told no, or anybody says anything about it both the Naives and Quebec calls them racist because they don't want to give any more of their tax money to a lost cause.


Vancouver Maria
said

The NDP have lost any regard l had for them. To turn this into a political football is beyond disgusting.


James
said

@Jen: You're aware that Native Americans have similar creation myths that say this land belongs to them? But I'm sure your magical sky wizard trumps theirs for some reason...


Rez lady
said

First of all, The chief and council did not use money from the Education fund to buy that zambonie, they paid that zambonie using the money from nightly bingos...get the facts straight ctv news! and second of all, the money (90 million) was not given to them all at once, stretch that money out in 6 years..the money is all tracked now and I know this cause they did a live broadcast showing the people where the money went and how it clearly shows just how underfunded they still are. so just keep your eye on the news.


Dan from Northern Ont
said

I also think it's shameful that the NDP is using the reserve's plights to grandstand. There's a fine line between constructive criticism and pounding your chest.


IslandGuy
said

Where has the "due diligence" and financial oversight been all this time? And, doesn't this beg the question: "where else is this going on?"


Too Funny
said

Nycole Turmel and her provincial PQ cronies have their own skeletons in the closet regarding aboriginal affairs. Any who, she might want to give The Indian Act a thorough reading after which she might have a clue about the legal obligations of the federal government vis a vis the precise matters of which she is speaking.


peter in mb
said

@ Mishibinijim… the Native are not honouring their side of the treaties either. Written In the treaties is When off reservation lands the Natives agreed to not molest the white settlers in any way. ie, not break our laws. Then they complain that over 80 % of people in jails are Native and cry racism. One cannot just blame it all on the Government. The Native have treaty obligations to the Government as well.


Terry
said

Why is it that I had to go to school, serve my country (in Afghanistan twice) work for my house, car, pay for my kids education, pay high taxes and I keep having to stomach this crap! Cut them off, get a job or go where the jobs are and pay your way! This cant last, take a look across the pond in Europe and the Middle East. Cut the apron strings!! Now!!


Don Soucy Bowser
said

Hey y'all who think the natives should stop whining and asking for redress. After all it all happened too many years ago.

So where do you stand on Israel and the Palestinians? Shouldn't they just be told to shutup and like what they have been given?
Are you all making those sentiments known too? Are you?

Well?

sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander.



Matt from London
said

There is a time and a place for auditing, in the middle of a disaster is not one of them. Help the people there, then do your audits to see where the money went and what went wrong. Lives are at risk, a sense of urgency is needed.


Debbie
said

Obviously the first nation people are unable to manage the money themselves. Either educate them and demand reports of how the money is spent or hire a third-party to do it for them. If they behave like children then treat them like children and don't throw treaty rights in our face. If you can't behave responsibly then you forfeit the rights. Reservations should be abolished anyways and they need to be forced to integrate with the rest of Canadians. Exactly what culture are they "preserving" by living on a flood plain with their hands out constantly demanding more and more.


Jen
said

Land was never promised to the Indians. The Bible says it was given to the Isrialites. What are we throwing our money away for. Let the NDP support them.


Emily N
said

All I hear is I'm a tax payer, I work hard, where is my money going???I'm Native I pay taxes, I work hard, & I don't care where my money is going. Everyone is influenced by the gov't. They control us so shut up already. The money they take from u is gone so stop whining.


Don Soucy Bowser
said

It is clear a 3rd party manager must be appointed and immediately.

The government of Canada and the dept. of Indian and Northern Affiars must be placed under 3rd party management NOW.

The United Nations must be brought in to find out why and how this portfolio msiamangement has resulted in this atrocity.

Only when they are forced into opening the government books and accounting will Canadaians really know who is responsible. This government is the most opaque of any I have ever seen in my 64 years.
I have been pushed to say it this way.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RxzBorBUawk


Al
said

Isn't the first question "why is this community where it is physically?" There is no future for these people there. The biggest crime is paying big money to keep them there where their children have very limited opportunites. Please don't give me that stuff about wanting to live in a traditioanl way! It would be a mistake to fix this communities amenities; spend money to relocate them to somewhere they can have a chance!


Helene
said

Stop irresponsible and non-constructive grand-standing trying to score political points on the back of the needy and poorest people in Canada.What a SHAME....


back to nature?
said

when will First Nations who are living in uninsulated shacks, freezing, and starving because they have to pay $30 for a frozen pizza, get off their butts, build a teepee or wigwam, light a fire, make a beaver jacket, eat a moose and live as they were intended!!


Janessa
said

An expensive Zamboni to remove ice and squalor for homes? Kinda shows where the priorities are. Gov't throwing in more money will not fix a broken way of life and it just doesn't pertain to northern first nation people. We also have young Cdn couples driving new SUV's then going to the food bank for groceries. I think it is called materialism versus the common sense of essential living needs.


It's time
said

It's time that all First Nations Chiefs & Councils show some leadership and 'open the books' to shoq exactky how their millions of dollars of public money is being spent. Until such an 'opening', there willalways be suspicions of misue of public funds. The Liberal & NDP solution of throwing endless unaccountable dollars at the problem is not an answer. Their solurion only makes it easier to misuse public funds. Come on people, accountability is nothing to hide from, unless of course you are guilty


Hope Full
said

We can see that many people who see anyone who is not aboriginal must be white and they call white people racist. What about us black, or yellow or any other color?Some of the treaties are available on the web and it may not be what some aboriginal will want to read. After saying this alll people of Canada must find ways to live together. What is not working on these reserves will not get any better from people who have an attitude that others are less than them. That goes for all colors and every area of Canada. We have all been damaged by people in leadership in the past. I am not going to allow your racism to skew my hope for an answer to all who suffer under poverty in the urban and rural parts of Canada. The NDP has made their point now they are simply bringing division among the people of Canada and what should we expect when their leader was associated with a seperatist movement.


Supercuts
said

Is it a rule that you have to have the worst haircut possible to be an NDP MP ? I mean look at that picture. The only thing being punished is my eyes.


White Guy
said

The Attawapiskat do have audited books,by a chartered accountants com.....and they are on line for all to see......get the facts for yourself and stop believing Harper's smoke screen of crap


worked for several years on a reserve
said

As a former contracter who worked with First Nations, I say we let them sort out their own problems.Aside from building homes for them just to tear down and use for firewood, they screwed us bigtime.My company went out of business because a First Nations Reserve refused to pay for a school we built. The Feds paid their share, but the Reserve didn't. After court costs and years of battling to recoup our losses, nothing. We were out a couple million, and for a mid-sized contractor, we couldn't recover.....set them free to sink or swim.


FCS
said

I wish the government would punish me by giving me 90 million dollars. Enough of the grandstanding already Trumel, I'm actually starting to miss Jack layton.


Les
said

Fact is millions of dollars are being utterly wasted every year by band chiefs and elders on gambling, travel, lavish living etc, while their people suffer. I have personally witnessed this repeatedly. There needs to be accountability.


Mike
said

This is fascinating stuff. The Harper crowd wants financial accountability from these poor people. These are the same guys that inherited a surplus and turned it into the largest deficit in the history of our country. They wouldn't know accountability if it jumped up and bit them in the rear end.


Cal in Ottawa
said

It is reasonable for the Canadian taxpayers to have an accounting of where our tax dollars are going. The PM said 90 million over 5-6 years, so I want to know how it was spent. I also want to know how much band council members are being paid. I bet there are members of various bands who would like to know as well.But there is something else that bothers me. The whole idea of a reserve is somewhat counterintuitve; and then to not be able to own anything is something that belongs in a communist country. Heck even Cuba has now recognised that people need to own their homes! If you don't own it, where is the incentive to look after ti?Now if folks want to live on reserves and be looked after, fine; but don't complain about there not being any economic opportunity if you choose to live in the middle of no where. The choice seems to be live a traditional lifestyle and accept the limitations that entails, or choose to live a different lifestyle.


sheila
said

Only the NDP continues to believe throwing money with no strings will make this better. This band has recieved 17 million dollars in the last year and appears to have done nothing with it. YES, oversight is definately required. More importantly these remote bands should be moved much closer to the heart of the country. The entire reservations system has been a failed social experiment.


James
said

@Chrisbecause this issue is about NATIVE people. people who have more right to this land than anyone of european decent; they've bled more for it by far! learn some history before speaking out about the basis of a particular society's existence on a land that belonged to them to begin with. don't get me wrong, corruption and misuse of public finance is unacceptable regardless where it's originating, but so are ignorant racial slurs!! this is a democracy, we're suppose to be beyond this foolishness - if you can't control yourself then move to the middle east and exercise your hate there. keep in mind folks, you wouldn't be here to make the ax dollars that you feel are wasted on these people if in the early settlement days their civilization was as equally advanced as the europeans when they manipulated, cheated, oppressed, and overpowered an otherwise completely harmless and oblivious people for the sake of their land/resources and essentially forced them to live in seclusion from the newly founded society unless they conformed to 'christian standards', or were of benefit in some way. regardless who you are, your citizenship does not override theirs - no matter how hard you think you work, and how much you think you contribute. get a clue, and be thankful these people unwillingly sacrificed a potential future long ago so that their oppressors' descendents can enjoy the gluttonous lives they have now. so what, a few in this minority drive a nicer car than you - i think that's the least we can do. get over it and be glad that's the worst of it. besides, far more of your 'tax dollars' are being wasted appeasing a much more damaging corruption that ironically the majority of you have no trouble openly supporting.


Carol
said

This is not new --- we continue as a country to support with money and the corruption is deplorable. If the rest of us Canadians are 5 and 6th generation work for what we have and are subject to inspection when we build a home etc.. Why are we treating these Canadians different. the Whole institution of Indian Affairs and treaties need to removed and these people allowed to own their own property and pay taxes like all the rest. In the present state we are creating this mess and wasting our taxes.


reidjr
said

cathy
I find it amazing people are willing to blame harper and company more then any one all partys are to blame this has been going on for years.


reidjr
said

Dave
Someone who is born in canada is not called a immergrant.


Lane
said

The only solution to such problems is to abolish reserves, stop recognizing band councils as anything more than municipal governments, and start treating aboriginals like all other Canadians.


Jones Gomez
said

What is the Native Council of Chiefs referenced in previous comments? Is this a new political party? Perhaps the Caucasian Conservative Party could order that Minister Duncan stop leading from the rear and actually visit Attawapiskat. A balanced and fair report would serve as a honest reference point for informed discussion in Canada, but that would be far less interesting in the current Harperization of Canada and its media.


M.M.B. Ont
said

I believe it is a disgrace for Turmel and even Bob Rae to be yelling and pointing the finger at the Conservative gov't over this issue. Over 90 million dollars of our taxpayers monies has been given to these peoples and yet they want more and their living conditions have not improved. What did the Liberals do for these people when they were in power?? You got it.. NOTHING. This is a situation that has not developed overnight and while efforts have been made by this gov't to help these people, they have obviously wasted the monies and are not accountable. I have heard of stories in the past where the gov't provided brand new snowmobiles to groups of Aboriginals who sped off with them and left them when the machines ran out of gas. What a waste ! I support a third party to oversee the financial situation and make sure the monies are used where are to be to provide the necessities for families .


Scott ON
said

@shaun.....what all those who complain about how rough the natives have it and how poorly they were treated fail to realize is that in every other society, when a people invade another, the inhabitants are usually either enslaved or eradicated. Think about that next time you do the woe is me routine


geebee
said

Well...intriguing how an individual who was once a Minister of Indian Affairs, who later became P.M. padded his legacy by counting golf balls and in reality did very little to be endeared by indigenous peoples.


Why?
said

DWIGHT DUNCAN - "We have gone out of our way to try and get the appropriate infrastructure in many of these communities and it never seems to be quite enough, but we're going to keep doing what we're doing,"Keep doing what you're doing? Why would it work if it didn't before? Stop pouring money into these problems and fix them. Maybe teach these people how to live for themselves. There's a start!


dougmcd
said

The government may have allocated / spent the money but with NO or little accountability, the funds never reach the people most deserving.

A solution to making sure the money for housing goes to the right project, why not

1. Have basic house plans drawn up with list of materials. Suggest using university students in architecture to do this = get credits etc for the course . This would cost basically " 0 "

2. Source / tender the materials needed per house x number of homes possible from the budgeted funds.
REMOVE ALL THE TAXES FROM THE MATERIALS SINCE IT IS GOVERNMENT MONEY - ONLY GOING BACK TO THE GOVERNEMENT + these people have suffered enough ..

This would help provide more materials for homes for people in need !

Once you remove all the taxes + greedy profit taking > be amazed at what can be accomplished.

3. These people need work + a sense to feel good about accomplishing something.

Could also help teach them new skills > building homes for themselves and other members of their community.

To qualify for the program, hire local people supervised by experienced trades person(s) to assist , direct and guide them at building homes. The supervisors would also inpsect = make sure the homes are built to the plans and building code.

Hire someone like " Holmes " to get the idea going.

Habitat for Humanity > great program has a similar program - re sweat equity. Ask - solicit advice from them

GIVING THEM MONEY FOR HOMES IS NOT WORKING !!! MONEY IS GOING WHO KNOWS WHERE

AT LEAST THIS WAY MAKES SURE THE MONEY IS ALLOCATED + SPENT ON MATERIALS TO BUILD HOMES AND NOT WASTED ..








HOOLIGAN
said

"90 million" in 6 years in a village and they have nothing????With that they should all be living in state of the art housing! I live in a small community of about 4,000----could you get the government to send 90 million our way for housing , etc. What a rip-off!


Northern Princess
said

My father always said, 'its not how much you make, its what you do with it'. The First Nations get a lot of funds from the Federal Government (us by our taxes). Where's the accountability? Where are these funds going and being used for if not for what those funds were intended? When I see reservations with pre-fab homes (and not long after, cabinet doors are hanging on one hinge), nice trucks or cars in the driveway, ski-doos, and 4-wheelers, and then I see this article, I have to wonder, what is going on there. Yep, something doesn't add up, that's for sure.


Just Don't Get It
said

Where exactly is their more going? Surely there is some? How can there always be Land Issues, treaty problems, Racism Problems, Money Problems, Substance abuse Problems. What the heck, it must be going somewhere. I don't think that the average taxpayer gets anywhere near the breaks that these guys get! Somebody sort it out, and maintain it, once for all.


Mishibinijima
said

Why can't the minister of Northern Affairs review, study and published native treaties written in Canada, use these treaties as guide lines promised to all First Nations.But all were not honored from DAY ONE, our were not honored from 1836 - 1960 , What is the Canadain government so affraid to review these documents in lue of white settlements across Canada. Native honored theirs but the government, ( NO )


Bruce Ross
said

It is a pathetic display of a lack of leadership for the Government's Minister not to have his feet on the ground in this situation. The 'leaders' and his contacts clearly have done a disservice, not only to the First Nations people here, but to Canadians who have entrusted the Government with making things whole and right, and using our tax dollars to do it... shame on the Minister.


Rick W in BC
said

I do not understand why the National Council of Chiefs are not doing anything to fix this. All they are doing is telling us they need more money. If pumping millions into this has not solved it yet spending billions more won't work. To the National Council of Chiefs, quit being part of the problem and start being part of the solution. It is within your power to fix this by ending the corruption and kickbacks and do what is right for the Aboriginal people who you are suppost to represent. We should not have to put your house in order but if you can't or won't the Government will and you will have no say in it. So quit complaining from your warm comfortable homes and start helping your people.


Pinochio
said

You know there are construction/ renovation contractors like myself that could really help out these people and right now I mean but the governmnet prefers to just throw the money at the band leaders and expect them to figure it out on their own. Heck I don't have any work myself and would love an opportunity to help these people out. It would take very little and only a few days to build and insulate several homes and make them liveable for now and in the summer go back and make it permanent including running water for a pittance of what the government is handing out to these chiefs who seem to be lining their pockets.


tyron Smithfalls
said

Poor ole Natives they have had millions thrown at them and they want more and everytime Ottawa wants to due an audit to find out where the millions went they turn around and tell the government ohhh that was the old band council these people would make great used car salesman


rjc
said

Why are we as taxpayers responsible for building houses for natives on reserves? Was it negotiated in a treaty or something? I don't expect Ottawa to build a house for me off reserve, so why are they expected to build them for natives on reserves. I'm just asking....


anna
said

No kidding: 'things don't add up." And no, it isn't racist to expect accountability for the miliions and millions that has been given to First nations communities. It is less than credible for natives to say that they have a right to self-govenance. Not with my taxpayers money, thank you. Nor will Red Cross be receiving any donations to me, again, in addition to our taxpayers dollars.


shawbrooke
said

No more policies, they've failed. There needs to be transparency and accountability, which means audited books and tied money. I say give each native adult a certain amount of money and let the Band collect taxes.Kudos to the Conservatives for taking action and avoiding emotional outbursts. When is the NDP getting a new leader?


jim
said

Transportation costs are outrages when you ship to Attawapiskat. Does the government realize how much a small box cost to ship on the airplanes.


Steve in Vancouver
said

The NDP and the Liberals should both be held in contempt of parliament for their grandstanding on the backs of these poor people. It is disgusting how they have made a political football out of their poverty. The irony of the situation is that the NDP 's Charlie Angus represents these poverty stricken people in parliament. Why had he not left his posh office in parliament to travel his riding and ensure his constituents have proper living conditions. The hypocrisy is unbelievable.


reidjr
said

MIke
If the money was getting to the people i would support sending more but the thing is where is the money going.


Frustrated
said

and they do that dependent on nepotisim and personalities.The likes of Charlie Angus and others desplay the most blatant racisim . That the Government should consider Natives as nothing more than children where its the function of others to provide all means of support.This NDP attitude is demeaning to all FN persons


member of Stephens new Att. tribe
said

resurfacer (zamboni) for the RL sports plex, funding for the purchase did not come from the education fund but from hard work fund raising from bingo's that are held almost everynight, reporters sould really look into where they are getting their info like they are suppose too, investigate before they make Attawapiskat look like fools. plz repost


beep 011
said

remember peeps our home and native land !!!!!!!


Rat-RippeR
said

For $90,000,000.00 - I would have started a small factory and gave them jobs while at the same time building a few hundred small homes with running water and septic systems . Handing out millions of dollars that goes unaccounted for is ridiculous . Who up there knows how to effectively use 90 Million Dollars ?


JM
said

Do I understand that this is about 90 homes? Is this like the neighbours on the other side of the tracks and why have these neighbours not recieved the same about of monies as the others of the community?


cathy
said

I am outraged and embarassed by the why our goverment is more apt to point blame again to pass governing parties instead of acting and finding help for people of Canada. The minister of indian affairs should resgin his poition as he has no idea what is happening in his own department.


wk
said

Agree with action being taken by the Gov't. The Gov't is supplying emergency assistance to Attawapiskat. An audit is necessary in order to find out where the money designated to improve aboringinal living conditions went and why it wasn't used for the purpose it was designated. Charlie Angus, NDP, was elected to this riding in 2004 and in Nov 2011 he raises his concerns. Where was Charlie Angus between 2004-2011?


Greg Y
said

I think the NDP and Libs have this all wrong. The problems with the Indians is not that they are stupid, hopeless, lazy people who's only hope is more massive handouts from the taxpayer. The problem is the "social justice" setup that past Liberal govts have thrown massive amounts of money into and made these once proud people totally dependent. That is what needs to be fixed. The NDP and Libs now want us taxpayers to build these Indians all new houses and say that will solve the problem. I say it won't because the systems won't be changed. ___ Tell you what - If the NDP and Lib MP's really belive their own words let's challenge them to first each give their own personal houses to one of these families for a year and then see how it looks a year from now.


MIKE FROM RED NECK ALTA
said

STOP POINTING AT THE FEDS. lets put the blame where you cowards are afraid too say. 90 million dollars missing no sign of any work being done. these are not children time too grow up


Angered economist
said

Warning! I think maybe we should look into the financial backgrounds of each and every first nations adminstration. It seems to be a trend that we just throw money away without accountability. If it was someone spending my money foolishly i'd be pretty upset. Oh wait...it is tax payers money. In Attawapiskat the goverment forwarded 92 million. If you divide that by the population, it yields approxamitely $53'000 per person TAX FREE. That amount of money is more than the average median income per family in the country. These natives are receiving far more money than most people earn annually. It's undespicable. How can the government let something like this go, especially during this fragile economy. It's bad enough we give the first nations money.


Miriam G.
said

Having spent two years in Saskatchewan renovating apartment blocks for First Nations people I have seen how little they value material things. The money spent in this community could have built new homes for every family and yet the situation could be much the same as it is today. If they don't pay taxes why is the government responsible to take care of them? It is high time Ottawa started overseeing where the money is being spent and making the band leaders accountable.


Jack in Edmonton
said

"We have gone out of our way to try and get the appropriate infrastructure in many of these communities and it never seems to be quite enough, but we're going to keep doing what we're doing," Duncan said.To far out of the way, and it is way to much. Don't keep doing what you're doing. It is not working.That's like me using credit cards to pay for everything, even though I can't afford it. The going on and saying, I make payments but it never seems to be quite enough, but I'm going to keep doing what I'm doing.We can not afford to keep giving these people money. They are a credit card that has a balance that goes up and up and up but never gets paid because they always want more money. The bad thing is they know they will get it, or they call every body a racist and they own it to them.


A Koster
said

Duncan says that he knew nothing about the situation and blames the ndp mp Angus for not bringing it up with him before.. easy to check at parl.gc.ca and putting attawapiskat in the search box .. without looking through all the results, I found this issue brought up by Angus at least as far as March 2009...


Kevin
said

In a recent news video on this situation I saw a Cadillac Escalade parked outfront of one of these homes. Seriously- how long do we write cheques for these situations and then turn a blind eye when the money is being totally abused? The gravy-train needs to run out at some point, time to be accountable.


Bonnie
said

Right on Mom. Get the help to these people ASAPThe Aboriginal people are now dependant on the government because they don't own the land anymore and aren't free to live the way they used to WHEN THEY LIVED HERE BEFORE WE DID.They bargained in good faith that the treaties they signed would be honoured but we all know when you depend on government to take care of you, you will be sadly mistaken.And now that their land has been STOLEN from them, it is up to us, the people, to see they are taken care of.


jmc
said

90 million!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!That would build lots of sidewalks and gazebos!


Craig from NS
said

To this day I cannot understand how they (native band leadership) can asked to be self governed, when a lot of them are putting the screws to their own people. Clean up the corruption and then talk about self government. Then again, the governing parties for a lot of municipalities provinces, territories and federally have been putting the screws to everyone for a long time as well. I guess I can appreciate some of the frustration band members have with their leaders.


George
said

Make them accountable retroactively.This has been going on for years.This sector of the population is running these funds down the drain faster than they get it.Sure, it's a hot potato for the government but one good way to gain respect from canadians if dealt with logically.


Dave Wasy
said

I hope the "Harper Goverment" is going to spend same amount of time and effort into auditting Tony Clements $50 million give away in his riding. There was just as little done for accounting and transparency. I forgot, Cons do not have to play by the same rules as everyone else.


Dave in Edm
said

Bob, the First Nations people will be responsible for themself when we get off their land... You forget, you are an immigrant on their land...


Cheryl
said

I am so tired of hearing about the poor Natives!! The land has been paid for over and over again by our Government.I have Native blood in me ;but I am too proud to accept hand-outs!! It is not just the Natives that are getting hand-outs from our Government;it is also immigrants. I am a multi-generation Canadian and i have had to work hard all my life to make a living and I think it is "high time" that everyone does! We are seeing too many people living on the street that our government doesn't help! Some of them just need a hand up! It is so sad! Our Government is so confused as to what is right and what is wrong!!we can write all the letters we want to write and it will never change.Quit looking for hand outs!!!


Grant
said

Check out what the Chief drives. Dollars to donuts it's probably a Mercedes. Point is when money is thrown at these people it never makes it through to those who really need it. I bet this audit will all sorts of appalling misappropriation of funds. Watch.


Edmonton Cree
said

@Chris, get your facts straight as a first nations, with a treaty card, i pay taxes, i dont get any free handouts from my rez, except $5 per year, of treaty money,which i dont collect cause it costs more in gas to drive to my rez to collect! I pay into benefits because nothing, including my asthma inhaler, is covered by INAC, you seem to think we get pay outs and everything is free, but i have worked just as hard as you to get to where im at, the difference is you had healthy water to drink, we didnt, you had a decent house,we had shacks...i could go on but think you get my point. You wanna know where all the money is going, straight to the bureaucracy of INAC!


eagle 42
said

The life expectancy of a first nations house is I believe about 7 years and then they get a new one. When I build a house I expect to hand it down to the next generation in my family or sell it in 10 years with a big profit. Something doesn't make sense here!!!


Mom in Ontario
said

Look at the books later, help the people that need it now


Paul R
said

Do not let the six digit salaried chiefs administrate money!! There is blatant corruption on reserves and the government does nothing because of fears of stirring the pot with aboriginal nations. The reality is that most aboriginals would support corruption investigations directed at their leadership. Bring in the RCMP !!!


bob
said

when do you hold the first nations responsible for themselves.I believe handouts or financial support does not enable independence. It seems the more finacial support the government gives the more first nations rely on it. The best answer i believe would be disband reserves and in-corparate first nations into our communities and contribute to the communities


Fay Manitoba
said

All politicians need to work together to help the people on reservations. In some cases the chiefs take the money and live in major cities, not with their people. For the sake of all natives we need to shine a bright light on chiefs that rob their people.


william-ontario
said

duncan needs to get his butt out there and find out where these millions are. it's his responsibility to check this out, not rely on one of his minions. this is millions in taxpayers money we're talking about here. do your job, NOW


melavell
said

RE Mohawk warrior brave --you must be a chief or you would not be saying that-- yes preserve your job the gravy train has left the station --hey why does Canadians not get to vote on this issue bet it would be 99% for the white man --stop giving money to indian bands let there be a better salution for this bad situation


SVCR
said

It is time the First Nations start looking after themselves instead of expecting the government to hold their hand all the time with OUR tax dollars.They probably drank all the monies they were given!!!


Nellie
said

John Baird for Aboriginal Affairs Minister! We someone who can talk and take action -- even if he screams half the time!


Chris
said

I had an ancestor that wasn't treated fairly in 1603...can I have 90 Million dollars. It doesn't sound right for me to demand that. why is it right for first nations people to demand that.


dave
said

It does not surprise me at all. These reserves are just a big money pitt for taxpayers hard earned money. They dump billions and maybe billions of dollars into approving things and no one is held accountable for proper spending of the money. Another area is the terrirtory of Nunavut. I have lived there and seen millions of dollars wasted with no improvements No one is held accountable to ensure the money is wisely spent for the purposes it was intended. It seems politicians claim their business background and fiscal responsibility when they want your vote to be elected but lose all those qualities when dealing with public money. Then we pay people huge money to audit the people we trusted in the beginning. Taxpayers and public are the victims.


Jim Lad
said

Have any of the neighbouring reserve bands offered to lift one finger to help these people?Or are they too worried about their own ledgers?


B.J.
said

To Ms Bennet, what did the Liberals do for the aboriginlas while in power, nothing. This is an issue that has been going on for a long time, and there is no acciountability at all. Money thrown out the window. Aboriginals complain about having no money, yet they all seem to be able to smoke regardless of the cheap cigs. The liberals can squawk all they want, they did nothing thats why they are at the bottom.


Devil's Advocate
said

I am pleased that this has been made to light! This is a VERY SERIOUS issue in the west, especially in Manitoba. This province really lacks the necessary accountability measures in regards to how the money is spent in it's native communities. I am no expert in this matter, but I have a number of native friends I have hung around with for the last few years, and I feel from the stories I hear that many of these communities are in the same or worse situation. I cannot say for sure if wind is being blown up my rear or not, but I feel the federal government needs to do an emergency audit Canada-wide. This looks like a systemic failure so broad it is too early to consider a solution, or even stoop to the blame game. We all love that part, don't we... I cant wait! (sarcasm)


Wendy
said

You all can talk the talk for those who don't live on a reservation. You don't know until you experience it. You should all count your blessing who live in rural areas. I live in a REMOTE community. The cost of living is high!!! Did you know that we pay over 8 dollars for a carton of orange juice!? The cheapest loaf of bread is over $3.00. Produce partially spoils when being shipped to the coastal communities. If we wanted to renovate our homes, our closest building supplier would be in Moosonee, and we'd have to haul via Winter Ice Road or Barge (cheapest way). Our way of life is way different then compared to people that live in Timmins and south from there! During the Spring to Fall, our means of travel is by Air because there is no highway access, and travelling to our closest City (Timmins) is expensive!


Bonnie
said

I think we are paying Mr. Duncan too much money. What a stupid statement out of his mouthin the house of Commons yesterday.90 million dollars is a lot of money but I would guess we have given Kardazi that and more.And it likely cost that much to ship all those construction trailers up north.The way the Harper government blows through our money is a joke. Our finance minister learns a new buz word every day. He is so clueless. A lawyer who couldn't make it chasing ambulances.So make him our finance minister.


KC BC
said

I would agree with most comments here that the current path is not sustainable. This is a classic " tragedy of the commons"; no stake in the game, then draw from the seemingly never ending pile. There needs to be a truly national debate on the issue of first nation poverty and use of taxation to fund needs on the reserves. The throw money to unaccountable leaders is not working. The Canadian tax payer cannot continue paying for the present system. I recall some discussions from a few years back that New Zealand had similar issues with their native population and they had worked out a better way to handle this decades old problem there. For now, the government is probably doing the right things. In the longer term however, big changes need to take place.


Mike
said

The naties have been living on these land for 100's of year..Right? So tell me again why their sustanance is suddenly our responsibility!


Mark
said

Aboriginal band leaders making hundreds of thousands of dollars in income, the secretive nature of their finances despite billions of dollars of federal spending...and it's amounted to what?Nothing.The First Nations politicians will complain that they only need more money. It is a never-ending cycle. The system is broken. The band leaders have overwhelmingly demonstrated that they are incapable of taking care of their people-only in spending Canadian TAX PAYER funds to enrich themselves.We should phase out reserves, drag them kicking and screaming if we have to to become educated and learn to take care of themselves. It's way past due and I for one am sick and tired of blockades, CALEDONIA, and the victim mentality.Time to grow a pair First Nations and stop sucking at the teat of the Canadian Tax payer.


Retired in Burlington
said

It is time to put an end to the Indian treaty system. this is 2011. They are not helpless and should be able to work and look after themselves. The federal gov. has given them $90m since 2006 and this is just one group. How much of taxpayers money goes out to all the other groups. This is our country we built it and made it what it is today and it is time we said enough of the handouts get a job and work like every other Canadian. what happened hundreds of years ago is history. We have catered to them far too long. Just because you are a decendant of the native people should not give you the right to a free ride. End the treaty system now and make them contribute to society like everyone else.


Fred, Ottawa
said

The first Nations call themselves NATIONS, yet they do not behave as nations do.Every nation knows that if you are to succeed in this global world you need to educate yourself. You need to build, strengthen and arm your citizens with the tools (education) so they can go out there and compete.First Nations have for too long taken from the federal government and by proxy us, and have failed their own people by not giving them those tools and moral standings that will ensure that future generations out perform their parent's.It is honorable and proper to remember from where you came from, but you cannot live in the past. You must prepare yourself for the future while remembering your heritage and use that heritage to help you succeed. First Nations have definitely a problem with this last part.


Craig
said

Truly, this is a MAJOR problem that as been going on for to long. The Conservative Federal party under the leadership of PM Harper must take action. Were are all these Federal funds going? There are to many aboriginal communities in Canada with severe poverty conditions.


isn't it obvious?
said

It's obvious First Nations aren't prepared to manage money. It's obvious they can't manage their communities. It's obvious they can't manage their educations. It's obvious they can't manage their health. When is it obvious that they can't self-govern?? When is it obvious the government needs to make a drastic and significant change to the way things are working??


plans need to change
said

This situation reminds me of my friend after graduating High School. He lazed around unmotivated to do anything in his mom's basement. She paid for everything. He was depressed and lacked direction. His room became a pig-sty because he did not care for it. He got fat and ate terribly. He started drinking heavily and smoking pot. He had no goals or dreams. Now he's 35, 2 strokes later and an internal defibrillator, his prospects for a normal life are slim.He needed some "tough love" at an early age. His mom should have kicked him out. Babying him didn't work because he never grew up and took responsibility for his life or respect for his surroundings. This should be a lesson for First Nations who are following the same path.


Fred, Ottawa
said

For decades the federal government has been dishing large amounts of money to aboriginal/native settlements and reserves with little if anything to show for. 90 million dollars in 5 years for a population of 1,800 out to be 50000 over 5 years or 10,000 per year for every person (not family)! Wouldn't we all working citizens want such gifts!This not by far the only aboriginal fiasco out there. the majority of norther settlements/reserves are nearly all in the same conditions.We should insist that each band chief be held accountable on a yearly basis for all use of federal funds received. In fact, I would go further, all federal funds given to first nations ought to be publicly published and audited to report how it is being used or in this specific case, misused.


Dianne
said

I think the funds that were obviously "misplaced" should be obviously given back.


Shocked
said

It's not surprising there was little to no accoutability the gov't can't just give out the money to a small group of people. It was shocking to see the conditions inthis day of age(3rd world was better)Instead of the NDP,Liberals blaming the gov'tthey should work with the gov't to Improve the community Immediatly.


Acorn127
said

Mohawk Warrior Brave
Reserves are poverty stricken becuase of people like you!!!! Chiefs and band councils are stealing the money. I know I used to work on a reserve and saw the living conditions of the chief and council members. Very different from the rest of the reserve!!! Get a job and get over the treaty thing it is long ago. All the TAXPAYERS money should be controlled by the government not the band. I want to know that my money is being spent correctly


roger watson
said

i like this site ,cbc,s site is censored so much the only sure way to get posted is to blame harper.


Just Saying - Ottawa
said

it is quite obvious that there is a problem on the Reserve and many of them...if $$$ is given out to help these people and nothing is getting done over the years..then it is time to show them how the money is used...no if's and's or but's...lead the way to whoever can go up and show the ones in charge what to do...no one can predict things that happen so get them on the right path if they will allow it. Obviously need direction.


Well, Yes
said

Isn`t normal that when money disbursed that someone checks up to make sure the money was spent on what it was to be used for. Gee seems strange giving away millions a dollars and no one has been accountable for the miss handling of the funds. Sad, it has to get to this point and all these years of mishandling of money . No watch dogs.


Brairrose
said

Things need to change! The parable of teaching a man to fish, needs to be applied. The first nations people need to learn "how to fish again". They have forgotten how their ancestors lived many years ago. They were self sufficient, they took care of their own, they were industrious, and they were resourceful. They must to go back to their old ways before the white man came. Their ancestors would be very dissapointed in the lives that their children live today! Teach them how to fish!


Echynoweth
said

The government of Canada is billions of dollars in debt. I think the Assembly of First Nations who represent most of the rightful owners of this land and its resources should force the PC government into 3rd party management.


Canadian
said

There's nothing from stopping them from moving. There's lots of places to live in the cities and towns across this country.


Chris
said

I really don't care about some long dead people signing treatise and not respecting them. those people haven't been around for hundreds of years. and considering the original natives didn't have houses or snow mobiles or trucks and planes or free handouts, they can continue to live like that or join the rest of Canada and pay taxes and receive benefits like the rest of us. this racist behavior needs to end. everyone is the same and should be treated as such. i'm fed up with being held responsible for all the world's problems because I'm a white male.


River
said

I wish "people" would stop thinking they come from a special God and deserve to be treated different from the rest. First Nations are known to have done slavery of their own. Read the BC history. Its time for the Government to treat all as equals. It would be interesting if National Geographic did a DNA testing to see where the First Nations people actually came from. China, Africa, Mongolia, Hawaii?


oddmelll
said

I would guess all the indian Band members will be running for cover now--some are already saying there is money there to help the people already in the bands bank ledgers--and the houses are better on reserves than most people live in the cities--take a hike fend for yourselves now


Thanks!
said

For all of you in questions like:"Harper said Attawapiskat got $90 million, where did it all go!?" OR "But $90 million could have built the community 360 brand new houses!!" OR"Fine, they got $5.8 million for housing, surely that is enough?" OR"The Feds are just handing that money over and the Band does whatever it wants with it!" and so on....read this....it explains the break down of it all. I thank Khodi Dill for breaking it down for people to read and get a better understanding!!! Type in "Khodi Dill sums it up nicely" on search.


Hey Porter
said

Elmer. First off, Nycole Turmel is a she, not a he. Secondly, she has gone there and visited the community this past week.After that, well, you are probably right. Lot's of who knows what is going on, and no responsibility or accountability! Obviously, this and prior governments' idea of throwing enough money at the problem and maybe it will go away doesn't work. Not to mention that those in charge on the receiving end hope that the trend will continue, and continue...


Evan in Athabasca
said

ENOUGH GIVING THE MONEY TO THE ABORIGINALS.... as much as it pains me to say this in some reserves we require a federal baby sitter...


Lynn
said

At the risk of sounding unsympathetic how many hundreds of years ago did the Europeans come to this continent? People need to get over that. Period. We can not continue to pay for what our ancestors did that long ago.Compensation for the more recent residential schools is different- those that suffered through that should be compensated - but only those that suffered through it. The reality is that being Native comes with all kinds of perks that the Canadians who pay for it are not entitled to. And the lack of accountability for this amount of money is absolutely unacceptable. The Government is partially to blame- who doles out that kind of money without monitoring it to ensure it is being spent on what it is suposed to be? But the people responsible for ensuring the money goes to where it needs to be and is used properly should be held legally responsible.


Mohawk Warrior Brave
said

The Government has to pay according to treaty rights. It is time for First Nations to take a stand against the atrocities occuring on reserves. I have adorned my eagle feather headress as well as tail feathers of the Great Rooster. The torn up Canadian flag shown around there world is an example how poverty stiken Natives are, and Canadian Government needs to fix that problem.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

As a country, we write an unending series of cheques to First Nations people and keep our head firmly turned the other way. Most of us know what goes on. Our federal government and its departmental bureaucrats certainly know what's going on. This collective "knowledge" spans a couple of decades, and all political parties, federally and provincially. Spare me the "Gosh, we had no idea how bad it was" crap. We're all guilty of sponsoring a failed (and monumentally costly) compensatory system. It fosters dependence, struggle, and misery. Only those who take advantage of the system, and many of the innocent souls within it, end up prospering. What in God's name are we doing?! We desperately need oversight. We desperately need across-the-board audits. Most of all, we need to finally figure out another system, because this one is completely and utterly flawed. (Fixing one of the broken legs on a three-legged chair is a foolish waste of time.)


rb
said

I agree with everything that’s been said….the government should have people in place to audit all the reserves…I've worked on reserves and seen how money is spent and some reserves have made companies go bankrupted because they didn't want to pay….the money always goes to the Chief's first than what ever is remaining the band council gets there is no accountability of how the money is spent …When everything is given to you, you have no respect for it, I've seen this with my own kids…I have nothing against natives, I have many friends that are native and work hard for what they earned…I am first generation Canadian….when my farther came to Canada he was given nothing he worked for everything he has, and that makes me proud of him…I hear about native pride…we'll step up and show it..


Len
said

After reading the editorial in this morning's Torstar have to agree with them that the blame game should be stopped, hopefully the overseer will have free reign in determining any blame but, more importantly, how to fix the problem. Too many lives are at stake here to blame one side over another or one party over another. Just get the job done and do it right this time - and fast enough that there will be less suffering in the cold months ahead.


Nancy
said

Is it obvious that the current system offirst nation reservations is not working?? Children have been neglected and abused foryears and will continue to be unless a completeoverhaul is done. In the 21st century we have not come very far.


Jill
said

Ya think? This has been going on for years on reserves. The money has always been squandered away and most of it illegally I would bet - by the leaders of these communities. The Gov'ts only fault is not monitoring how this money is being used. There is no accountability and when it is questioned, the racist card is played.


JS
said

let's hire Rob Ford to stop the gravy train in Attawapiskat! Come on....93million in less than 10 years for a community of 2000. Stop the bleeding!


Capt. Compromise
said

Hmm, I think we all know there's corruption on band councils, and Harper's recent plans to force members to divulge their salary and contracts are a great move. I can't help but feel this may be part of the Conservative pattern of publicly flailing anyone who embarrases them - remember the Stats Can guy, and the Atomic Energy lady, and all the others? How much of what we are being told is true, and how much is retribution and innuendo? Very hard to tell with this "Boy Who Cried Wolf" government.


Judy
said

I would like to know what the source of income is for this particular band, ie. what is their economic base comprised of? What kind of work does the population perform? Do they only rely on government handouts?


Raj
said

Well they spent money earmarked for something else on a Zamboni.They need an audit.Its the children I feel for.


Anne
said

Oh give over with the "before the europeans came blah blah blah"...generations ago, time to integrate with the rest of us Canadians. Reserves don't work. Corruption would appear to be rampant. Communities remain where there is absolutely nothing to sustain them or provide an interesting future for their children. Grow up already and build your own future like the rest of us.


flaemeonglass
said

Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan needs to visit this reserve & figure out a solution to this horrible problem.It's his bloody job!


bob
said

when you look at the 90 million spent over the past 5 or 6 years and compare it to the 50 million spent in clements riding in one summer well i think you get the picture


Jayme
said

What i would like to see is give each native say $2 million dollars and close all reserves.


Gerry from MB. but not NDP.
said

I want my tax $$$ that go to aboriginals and the C.B.C.to be autited.


MIke
said

After spending 1 Billion for 2 days on security for themselves, the cons should know that 90 million to house a remote northern community is just a drop in a very big bucket.


Elmer in BC
said

Maybe Nycole Turmel should go there himself never mind blaming Mr Harper. You can through a lot of money at some reserves but it will never go to where it needs to go to. As well it is not just a native issue it is people in general. People get control of money and greed takes over the "I" gets looked after first (new car trips ect) then the "relatives and friends" (new housing, new skidoo, ect) And the "other people, well they get the tents and sleeping bags. Then there are some people that get a new house given to them and in a year it is demolished.


RonPaul2012
said

The government needs to cut off the welfare and tell them to get jobs. The free ride is over. Sorry about what happened to your ancestors 400 years ago, but it's time to move forward.


Barry
said

The minister said this morning that in the last 5 years 34 new homes had been built. One of those homes has to be renovated to make it habitable for a family. I live in a home that is almost 60 years old. It has been maintained and is no where near unlivable. We see this on numerous First Nations, homes that are only a few years old sitting in disrepair and a new one being built right next to it. There has to be some common sense and accountability for this.


Suzie
said

It all comes down to accountability. When you receive money, you must provide a report. I want to see that report. NOW!


@shaun
said

Better off? They would still be living in teepees and long houses! Let them build these now to live in!


JB in Ontario
said

A short term plan is needed as well as a long term plan. There has to be accountability with money going to housing on the reservations. I'm sure most natives want accountability so they each have a warm and clean place to live and sleep. No one in Canada or Ontario should go without clean drinking water, proper sewage system, food and shelter. Surely we can hire someone to look after the natives and help the Chief run the reserve the right way financially.


Elder Wolf Yellowhead
said

Harper should NOT have hired a third party to take care of the funds. This has all been a misunderstanding, the few pictures by the media of shacks and a ripped up Canadian flag are not typical. They will see in the other section on the reserve there are nice homes and flags and cars. This inquiry should be stopped immediately and allow First Nations to Govern Ourselves according to treaty rights. There is much more funding that is required immediately to solve this problem.


GHW
said

Every single government funded organization should have to account for money received.


George V.
said

Bands receiving support payments from the Gov't should file quarterly audited reports showing how the money was spent who were the recipients, together with receipts. Gov't appointed auditors should be designated to all Indian reservations. Any miss- appropriation of funds would stop the next payment until unti the problem was rectified.


Said it in Muskoka
said

Funny how how it is that those of us who work for the money to buy/maintain our homes look after those properties (which we have to buy) because we can't whine to the government that we need a new roof.Interesting too that we never hear about them getting $90Million, but you sure here when they need more.Shows what kind of self-governance they would be capable of without the federal hand-holding.Why should I - or any other Canadian - be politically correct about this... everything about this is politically incorrect.


ohmygod
said

We just give to much money for nothing where is all the money they make from casinos Most of those bands are very rich but always looking for another government handout if they do not get any money they start crying to the media --I AM SO SICK and tired of them getting more than they need there are other people in worst shape than any reserve people--They are only showing the old old homes on TV get them to show the band council members home some are worth half a million dollars ---take care of your own people --quit going on holidays


shaun
said

@northernjeffAboriginal people were doing just fine before european people showed up, stole the land, the resources, brought disease, and signed treaties with the natives that they had no intention of fulfilling.If the government would live up to their end of the bargain, native communities would be far better off than they are now. It's just not in their interest to do so, and delivering 90 million to any community is a drop in the bucket compared to the billions of dollars the first nations are owed from unfulfilled treaties which Canada's founding fathers had promised.If you're sincere about seeing native communities help themselves, write your MP and urge them to finalise all treaties with all Canadian first nations.


lc
said

As someone who has worked in native communities I know corruption takes place.That is why there is suppose to be governmental oversight.Why did so many get angry with the libs and adscam yet seem willing to pass the buck here?At least the libs had the excuse it was a extraordinary situation and they were making decisions on the fly to prevent the breakup of Canada.This is just downright incompetence in overseeing how the tax payer money was being spent in routine operations.Cons need to quit blaming the victims who are not responsible for any of this and just would not like to freeze this winter!They sound like the Bushies during Katrina.


Barry Wynn
said

There is no need for a gun fight up there. Bob, and the lady from the NDP are doing that in the house. Yelling and screaming, tap dance and etc. What we need in the north is the military i.e. the engineering corp., they have the emergency money and can find more emergency money in less than 5 minutes. The Aboriginal Affairs Department does not have emergency money. The military can build prefabs in a few hours. That is the situation where those Medewiwins are living. The Government has no power to move them so don't try that to Timmins or Greenstone. They need sewage tanks which could be build for less than 10 thousand dollars excluding the backhoe. The military can help these people have a warm house and running water and working sewers in 1 week.


Mike K. Calgary
said

When my (our) tax dollars are handed out, the benafactor of this money should be held accountable as to where the money is spent. (This includes the CBC). You did not earn this money. I did. And the government took some of the money I made and gave it to you. So, where is the money, honey?


Vern
said

So what else is new. Seems to be the same old story on most reserves. Money is mis-spent, the chief and his buddies have all the goodies, and the rest go with out. There has to some accountability to the tax payer where the money went.


Gerald
said

It's the children that suffer the most in these cases. They don't know what they are getting into when they are born. Given the proper education and environment to grow up in, things could be totally different in the future for them. The money is given for development and should be used wisely, if not, we as shareholders in Canada should make sure that it is. This is unacceptable for a country like ours.


Central BC
said

Don't Stop At This Reserve! Dig deeper, you'll find the wasting of tax payer money on all reserves. They should have to report out and show their books, just as every other level of government and publicly owned company. They want to represent themselves - show us you can do an acceptable job. It's waste, mismanagement and the chiefs and their close relatives are the ones keeping the money.


It's called corruption
said

The people entrusted by the federal government with distributing federal monies have obviously stolen the money for themselves.Not the first time in recorded history this has happened. In fact it happens more often than not.


PVT
said

I like the response of our government. If it was the Liberals or NDP they would just throw more money at the natives and hope for the best. The Conservatives are trying to get to the root of the issue. That's leadership! Thank you Mr. Harper for handling this the right way.


Raymond Paskimin
said

Third Party managers, typically shut all services down, to just that of a receptionist, a cheque maker, education for kids, and social services for food. I don't believe the look on his face on National TV, that he is doing something, "ask him "is paying the deficit of the band more important first, then fixing the situation? I would ask him what is the bands "score as to performance overall, and why did they not step in at that time, and not after the fact", and is and does the Federal Government interested in assisting the band, if after scoring a low governance rating? That is where the questions should start from. Ray Paskimin


CD from AB
said

How typical that the accounting seems fuzzy at some of the first nations communities. There seems to be lots of money for certain band members (the councils and the chiefs) but the general populace get woefully little and live in poverty.I think the auditor general ought to start looking at more than the disbursements of cash. In fact a full audit of the uses of the cash should be done by a non-first nations audit.Research says that there are 2800 registered band members and 1293 actual residents of the reserve. $90 million in spending over 5 years is roughly $65000 from the government per actual resident per year. If someone game me $65,000 for each of my 2 kids plus myself per year I know I could live pretty nicely.Something is rotten in Denmark (or Attawapiskat).


Elyzabeth
said

The LEADER of the Official Opposition NYcole Turmel is correct, what needs to happen is Harper must go sleep ina tent on a floor and then give millions it takes to fix this native Indian housing problem. Houses cost a lot to build and it is up to Harper to pay for that since people should not be sleeping in sleeping bags.


Don from Mb.
said

Typical of all native reserves, the canadian government is to blame. They spend our tax dollars on a race of people who don't care about the lower half, and the government should control their spending, and make them accountable for where they spend the peoples tax dollar.


Joe
said

Why does a new home built in 2006 need renovating?


lorne harvey
said

check the chiefs bank acctand show his/her house.and this reserves needs moving off the flood plane.


Northern Jeff
said

When I couldn't find work I had to move to an area where I could. I didn't sit around and do nothing all day waiting for the Government to give me money. Not that they would as I'm not Native. I live in a town that has roughly 4 times the population this place has and our town has never received a penny, let alone $90 Million Dollars from the Government yet we aren't living in shacks. It comes down to taking care of yourself and not expecting someone else to support you. You want help?! Help yourself.


Mike
said

Corruption, i.e. mis-management of funding or outright redirection, is such a surprise here? Really? I'm not defending Harper but to blame him for this is ridiculous and political posturing at best. Regardless of which political party is in power, this mess would still have happened. $96 million since 2006 and the place looks like this? When will some poltician finally have the courage to save enough is enough and that is it. Enough with giving bands the funds to manage their reserves, that business model is ripe for corruption just like this. The government needs to end this and move to a realistic model that can be audited to prove where the funding has gone. Before anyone says my comments are predjudiced against natives, there's no racism but plenty of frustration with funding being 'redirected' and it just happens to benefit those that control the direction.Mike.


cis in Dulin Shore
said

What happened to the money?????????


Mq
said

What they will find no doubt is a dirty chief, or a corrupt on some level elder council. The money has been flowing for years, but to the wrong pockets. Come everyone knows the native cartel is the new mob in on the streets, well maybe not new. But certainly all of our tax dollars in support are not marking it to those they were intended for. Our success rate of raising the education levels of those on the reserves is dismal at best. Some make it out, I've worked with many successful Native Canadians over the years. And to my understanding, allot seem to have the same view. At some point you must stand up as a human being, demand better of yourself, for yourself, and do something about it yourself. The money is there, go to school. I know it's not what allot of people want to hear when they are down and out. With the basics not even being met. Get off the reserve, join me on an assembly line, or construction site. Were not all evil white men. Some of us just try to live our lives as good men.


J.C.
said

There is probably no housing policy in place because the band members wanted to self rule. In the meantime tax dollars are continuously flowing into those communities but there is no oversight to ensure the money is spent on infrastructure and housing etc. Self rule is good for those bands that can handle it but what about others such as Attawapiskat that can't seem to, or lack the knowledge of how to. There needs to be some kind of oversight in these places in particular until they can stand on their own with the funds. Currently this band is being used for partisan politics by their MP. He should instead be looking for solutions to this problem and not using the problem as a way to attack the ruling party. Demanding more money is not necessarily the right solution!!


John
said

Where are the first nations leaders and where is the grand council? There is obviously problems with misspent funds and unaccountability. Band chiefs and councils are misspending and the remaining band members are suffering as a result. It is rediculous for the NDP and Liberals to sit in their glass house and blame the ruling party for all the problems caused by unqualified or crooked leaders.


Sick and Tired
said

Shocking...now they should go and do an audit of all of the other reserves and find out if the money has been spent correctly. It might be surprising what they find.A family member once had an interview with a tribal council and was told that if all the money wasn't spent by year end then the staff got a "bonus". The government needs to wake up and start looking after the money they hand out. The reserves have proven they can't manage their money so it is about time that someone else does it for them!


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

In Pictures

Attawapiskat Reserve

Attawapiskat Reserve

A look at the struggling First Nations community of Attawapiskat.

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    7 Video(s) 7

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1