News Sections
Informing clinic patients was left to Ottawa public health
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTVNews.ca Staff
Date: Tue. Oct. 18 2011 8:46 AM ET
Ottawa's Medical Officer of Health says his department took on the role of informing patients that they had put at risk of infection of HIV or hepatitis by a local endoscopic clinic, after realizing that no one else would.
Dr. Isra Levy told CTV's Canada AM from Ottawa Tuesday morning that his department learned of the poor sterilization practices at the private endoscopic clinic operated by gastroenterologist Dr. Christiane Farazli in July.
That was about two months after inspectors with the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario discovered the problems.
"When we learned of this, obviously we were concerned that the patients themselves would be notified," Levy said.
"And it wasn't clear whether anybody was going to do that. So certainly, we pushed for that and ultimately decided that we would do it, if no one else would."
Levy explained that the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario's role was to ensure the unsafe practices were put to an end. But it was up to others to inform the patients.
The college notified the Ontario Ministry of Health of the problems, which then notified the Ottawa public health unit in July.
After an investigation, Levy said, it was determined that there were about 6,800 patients who had used the clinic between April 2002 and June 2011. All needed to be told there was a chance they may have put at risk of infection with HIV or hepatitis B or C.
The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario issued a statement Monday noting that it was only because of changes to provincial legislation in 2010 that they were able to conduct the inspection that discovered the violations at Dr. Farazli's clinic.
Until that point, private clinics were not subject to the same provincial standards that compel physicians to follow proper infection-control practices.
The May inspection found that equipment used to conduct gastroscopies and colonoscopies of Farazli's clinic "was not always appropriately cleaned between tests," the college said. That put as many patients at risk of infection.
Most of those patients are expected to begin receiving letters as early as today from Ottawa public health officials. The letters will warn them they may have been exposed to hepatitis B, hepatitis C or HIV and should consider getting blood tests.
Dr. Farazli no longer performs endoscopic procedures at her clinic, though the clinic otherwise remains in operation.
On Monday, she issued an apology through an Ottawa Public Health news release.
"I remain committed to the safety and well-being of my patients and am co-operating fully with OPH in providing patients with this notification," Farazli said in the statement.
"I sincerely regret that the issues that were identified in my facility occurred and I apologize for any inconvenience or anxiety that patients may experience upon receiving this notification. I would also like to reassure patients that the issues that led to this notification have been addressed and that I will be available to support them through this process."
Health officials say there is a very low risk that any of the patients were exposed to any viruses during their procedures.
There is less than a one-in-three-billion chance that someone was infected with HIV, less than a one-in-50 million chance of infection with hepatitis C and less than a one-in-one million chance of hepatitis B infection, according to health officials.
There is no evidence yet that anyone has been infected.
Ottawa Public Health has opened a dedicated information hotline for patients who think they may have been affected. The number is 613-580-2888.
User Tools
Related Stories
Subscribe!
CTV.ca Blogs
Like us on Facebook
Stay connected to the latest health news while you're on Facebook with CTV MedNews
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
If 5000 jobs can be so vital to the nation's economy, they should get what they ask for in bargaining. Simple.
Email



Comments are now closed for this story
Pat S.
0
said
0
mir
0
said
0
"I sincerely regret that the issues that were identified in my facility occurred and I apologize for any inconvenience or anxiety that patients may experience upon receiving this notification. I would also like to reassure patients that the issues that led to this notification have been addressed and that I will be available to support them through this process."
--> support ! REALLY !!! it was your duty to ensure you had a sterile clinic.
peter west
0
said
0
LP
0
said
0
Firstly I am sympathetic of anyone who had a procedure done at this clinic and encourage them to get tested ASAP.
I know it's easy to blame the doctor in cases like this... But think about it, they have absolutely nothing to do with sterilization of instruments. In every hospital in Canada the instruments come wrapped in sterile fashion, are used, and sent back to the decontamination unit for processing. Doctors aren't involved in the cleaning process. Now if she had missed a polyp etc etc while doing the scope then she should be to blame.
D.R.
0
said
0
reener
0
said
0
More concerned about the lack of understanding around what a private clinic in Ontario is, and why stricter enforcement in these in-office clinics wasn't the norm before 2010. We're in a third world health care system sometimes. Only wish it was legal to have private health care in this province. What a joke.
Mumphies
0
said
0
Louise Marchand
0
said
0
2 more people where I live just got their letter.
Louise
concerned
0
said
0
reidjr
0
said
0
What i find amazing is some feel white collar crime should get far more jail time then so called serious crime.
Bill - Cambridge ON
0
said
0
conductor274
0
said
0
jen
0
said
0
Greyg
0
said
0
So why are the internationally educated doctors with more than 10 years of experience still not acceptable by the Medical council in Canada?
Who cares for the common Joe right??? They get only ripped off with the compulsory taxes, and our govt give it to incompetent doctors and the medical council in Canada seems to protect the incompetent doctors by the tax payer’s money.
Now how much the govt will give as compensation to the affected people with the tax payer’s money?? And then increase the taxes again right??
Finally the burden is on the tax payers.
Jacob
0
said
0
Hepatitis B: Ten thousand endoscopic treatments.
Hepatitis C: Five hundred thousand endoscopic treatments.
HIV: Thirty million endoscopic treatments.
That's for the period between April 2002 and June 2011. In that period there were 3348 business days. This means that in order to have a one percent chance of contracting Hepatitis B from this clinic (the most probable of the aforementioned infections), you would need to have an average of 2.68 endoscopic treatments every hour of every business day for that entire period.
Looking at the less probable numbers, to get that one percent chance of having contracted HIV, you would need to have such a treatment every 3.21 seconds on those days.
You are more likely to contract HIV by stubbing your toe on a dirty syringe in a public place.
Prof. Pye Chartt
0
said
0
Mumphies
0
said
0
scared
0
said
0
Anne
0
said
0
mary elle
0
said
0
Raj
0
said
0
Pat Prachter
0
said
0
Mary
0
said
0
Trust your health professional
0
said
0
drd
0
said
0
Healthy
0
said
0
Canada Post
0
said
0
TJ
0
said
0
Mike R.
0
said
0