Top Stories -   

1
The door name and number for Dr. Christian Farazli's clinic in the Parkdale Medical Tower is shown in Ottawa on Monday, October 17, 2011. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Ottawa infection clinic Ottawa infection clinic

Informing clinic patients was left to Ottawa public health

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Ottawa: Patients to receive letter warnings
Anxiety is high as 6,800 patients are expected to receive letters warning of an infection risk. There is a chance the patients could have contracted viruses due to poor sterilization.
Canada AM: Investigation launched into scare
Dr. Isra Levy, Ottawa's chief medical officer of health, says local public health is not involved in checking clinics, and explains how an investigation was launched as soon as a problem was identified.
CTV National News: Ottawa doctor investigated
An Ottawa doctor is under investigation for methods that may have exposed patients to hepatitis and HIV. CTV's Roger Smith reports.
CTV Ottawa Extended: Dr. Isra Levy on the lapse
Ottawa's chief medical officer Dr. Isra Levy says Ottawa Public Health has been investigating reports of an infection control lapse at a local non-hospital facility, and that patients of the clinic who may be affected will be informed on Monday.
CTV Ottawa Extended: Dr. Isra Levy answers questions
Ottawa's chief medical officer Dr. Isra Levy speaks to the media about the notification of patients that may be exposed to an infection at an Ottawa clinic, and why more details on the investigation can't be released.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (29) Facebook   

The door name and number for Dr. Christian Farazli's clinic in the Parkdale Medical Tower is shown in Ottawa on Monday, October 17, 2011. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Ottawa infection clinic Ottawa infection clinic

Photos

The door name and number for Dr. Christian Farazli's clinic in the Parkdale Medical Tower is shown in Ottawa on Monday, October 17, 2011. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

Date: Tue. Oct. 18 2011 8:46 AM ET

Ottawa's Medical Officer of Health says his department took on the role of informing patients that they had put at risk of infection of HIV or hepatitis by a local endoscopic clinic, after realizing that no one else would.

Dr. Isra Levy told CTV's Canada AM from Ottawa Tuesday morning that his department learned of the poor sterilization practices at the private endoscopic clinic operated by gastroenterologist Dr. Christiane Farazli in July.

That was about two months after inspectors with the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario discovered the problems.

"When we learned of this, obviously we were concerned that the patients themselves would be notified," Levy said.

"And it wasn't clear whether anybody was going to do that. So certainly, we pushed for that and ultimately decided that we would do it, if no one else would."

Levy explained that the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario's role was to ensure the unsafe practices were put to an end. But it was up to others to inform the patients.

The college notified the Ontario Ministry of Health of the problems, which then notified the Ottawa public health unit in July.

After an investigation, Levy said, it was determined that there were about 6,800 patients who had used the clinic between April 2002 and June 2011. All needed to be told there was a chance they may have put at risk of infection with HIV or hepatitis B or C.

The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario issued a statement Monday noting that it was only because of changes to provincial legislation in 2010 that they were able to conduct the inspection that discovered the violations at Dr. Farazli's clinic.

Until that point, private clinics were not subject to the same provincial standards that compel physicians to follow proper infection-control practices.

The May inspection found that equipment used to conduct gastroscopies and colonoscopies of Farazli's clinic "was not always appropriately cleaned between tests," the college said. That put as many patients at risk of infection.

Most of those patients are expected to begin receiving letters as early as today from Ottawa public health officials. The letters will warn them they may have been exposed to hepatitis B, hepatitis C or HIV and should consider getting blood tests.

Dr. Farazli no longer performs endoscopic procedures at her clinic, though the clinic otherwise remains in operation.

On Monday, she issued an apology through an Ottawa Public Health news release.

"I remain committed to the safety and well-being of my patients and am co-operating fully with OPH in providing patients with this notification," Farazli said in the statement.

"I sincerely regret that the issues that were identified in my facility occurred and I apologize for any inconvenience or anxiety that patients may experience upon receiving this notification. I would also like to reassure patients that the issues that led to this notification have been addressed and that I will be available to support them through this process."

Health officials say there is a very low risk that any of the patients were exposed to any viruses during their procedures.

There is less than a one-in-three-billion chance that someone was infected with HIV, less than a one-in-50 million chance of infection with hepatitis C and less than a one-in-one million chance of hepatitis B infection, according to health officials.

There is no evidence yet that anyone has been infected.

Ottawa Public Health has opened a dedicated information hotline for patients who think they may have been affected. The number is 613-580-2888.

Comments are now closed for this story

Pat S.
said
0 0

Ok, so the inspection was conducted last May... and the public is finding out about this now, in October? Why the time lag? (very disturbing)


mir
said
0 0

Dr Farzali : i think it is only fair that you are asked to relinquish your Medical Practioners License.

"I sincerely regret that the issues that were identified in my facility occurred and I apologize for any inconvenience or anxiety that patients may experience upon receiving this notification. I would also like to reassure patients that the issues that led to this notification have been addressed and that I will be available to support them through this process."

--> support ! REALLY !!! it was your duty to ensure you had a sterile clinic.


peter west
said
0 0

The cost of informing the public about this problem belongs to Dr Christiane Farazli along with any other costs that my be incurred


LP
said
0 0

Just want to add my two cents as someone in the healthcare industry.

Firstly I am sympathetic of anyone who had a procedure done at this clinic and encourage them to get tested ASAP.

I know it's easy to blame the doctor in cases like this... But think about it, they have absolutely nothing to do with sterilization of instruments. In every hospital in Canada the instruments come wrapped in sterile fashion, are used, and sent back to the decontamination unit for processing. Doctors aren't involved in the cleaning process. Now if she had missed a polyp etc etc while doing the scope then she should be to blame.


D.R.
said
0 0

I have been a patient of Dr. Farazli for a number of years, I find her very rough during her procedures, now I have to go for further assessments due to her incompetence. She should have her license revoked immediately.


reener
said
0 0

I called the public health nurse last night to verify that I am on the list. Personally not that concerned since I had my Hep A/B shot in 2005 and my procedure was in 2008. She said they aren't encouraging blood work since the risk is so small, but the req will be in the package I receive. I will be getting it done, though, you never know.

More concerned about the lack of understanding around what a private clinic in Ontario is, and why stricter enforcement in these in-office clinics wasn't the norm before 2010. We're in a third world health care system sometimes. Only wish it was legal to have private health care in this province. What a joke.


Mumphies
said
0 0

To Bill - Cambridge ON: to clear up a misconception that you obviously have, while this might have been technically classified as a private clinic because it's run by a doctor and not a hospital, this is in fact an OHIP (taxpayer) funded clinic. Our son ended up there because he was referred to Christiane by his family doctor. He wasn't jumping any queues and in fact waited quite a long time for his colonoscopies. She is one of the few specialists for Crohn's disease in Ottawa. This should not have been a game of chance. He has suffered a serious liver and spleen illness and almost died at the age of 33 this last July. While we can't prove that her procedures made him sick, the many specialists who couldn't identify his illness felt that it was probably caused by a foreign bacteria, and he hadn't travelled anywhere ---only to her clinic. It's unforgiveable that the College of Physicians knew of her filthy practices months ago and did nothing to stop her. How many more people did she sicken? After our son's first visit there, he was turned off by her dirty office and bad bedside manner and sought a different specialist, which took months. In the meantime, he required a second emergency scope, again performed by her since he had no choice. So before you blame the patients, make sure you know the facts.


Louise Marchand
said
0 0

I just got my letter. I made a complaint about this doctor to the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario. The entire complaint process took over a year and in the end they informed me that they would give her an "in person caution" and this they told me many others had also complained about her, and she'd had an oral "caution" before. Cautions are not listed on the College's website so if you do a search on any doctor's name, you get the illusion with no "disciplinary" record, all is well and the doctor has a good reputation. NOT SO.

2 more people where I live just got their letter.

Louise


concerned
said
0 0

I'm only amazed that an incident such as this has not been detected or reported in the dental field. In many dental offices the newest employee or the lowest paid is often given the job of cleaning and sterilizing the dental instruments - without any formal training or certification.


reidjr
said
0 0

Raj
What i find amazing is some feel white collar crime should get far more jail time then so called serious crime.



Bill - Cambridge ON
said
0 0

This is what happens to people who want to jump the queue. You pays your money, and you take you chances. The same goes for any game of chance.


conductor274
said
0 0

Once again the public system will have to pick up the tab for the misconduct of the private for profit medicare system that Harper wants to impose on all of us. All those tests needed to determine id 7000 people got infected will be done by doctors who get paid by our medical system.Just like when the private banks screwed up the economy in the US, the public taxpayers had to pick up the tab to bail them out. Just like when private oil corporations cause huge oil spills it's left to the taxpayer to fund the clean up despite the fact the corporations are making billions in profits.Harper and his privatization plans are going to bankrupt Canada.


jen
said
0 0

I am 1 of the 6800 people waiting for my registered letter to arrive today. I feel frustrated, angry, disgusted and many other emotions right now. I was not happy with the way Dr. Levy danced around the questions while being interviewed on Canada AM this morning. I want answers. I want disciplinary action taken against Dr. Farazli. I feel sick over this whole ordeal.


Greyg
said
0 0

This is not a surprise for the Canadian medical education.

So why are the internationally educated doctors with more than 10 years of experience still not acceptable by the Medical council in Canada?

Who cares for the common Joe right??? They get only ripped off with the compulsory taxes, and our govt give it to incompetent doctors and the medical council in Canada seems to protect the incompetent doctors by the tax payer’s money.

Now how much the govt will give as compensation to the affected people with the tax payer’s money?? And then increase the taxes again right??

Finally the burden is on the tax payers.



Jacob
said
0 0

I understand people being upset about this, but let's put it in perspective and look at how many times you'd need to have received an endoscopic treatment from this clinic in order to have a one percent chance of catching the infections mentioned:

Hepatitis B: Ten thousand endoscopic treatments.
Hepatitis C: Five hundred thousand endoscopic treatments.
HIV: Thirty million endoscopic treatments.

That's for the period between April 2002 and June 2011. In that period there were 3348 business days. This means that in order to have a one percent chance of contracting Hepatitis B from this clinic (the most probable of the aforementioned infections), you would need to have an average of 2.68 endoscopic treatments every hour of every business day for that entire period.

Looking at the less probable numbers, to get that one percent chance of having contracted HIV, you would need to have such a treatment every 3.21 seconds on those days.

You are more likely to contract HIV by stubbing your toe on a dirty syringe in a public place.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said
0 0

@ Pat Prachter: From this story: "The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario issued a statement Monday noting that it was only because of changes to provincial legislation in 2010 that they were able to conduct the inspection that discovered the violations at Dr. Farazli's clinic." I do not think, therefore, that it is a given that our governments are moving away from monitoring and regulation, as you suggest. With regard to private-sector participation in our universal healthcare system (which is growing -- by absolute necessity, according to experts), it is estimated that the province of Ontario (via OHIP) will this year fork out in the neighborhood of $180M for "cross-border care" funding arrangements with selected American hospitals, imaging clinics, and treatment centers. Over the past several years, owing to its own inherent failings, Ontario has become a major contract-purchaser of American healthcare services. Healthcare "brokerage" has now evolved into a legitimate industry, helping to secure American medical care for the Ontario government ("preferred-provider" contracts) and those Ontario residents willing to pay out-of-pocket for superior or expedited service. Owing to the demographic tide, fiscal issues, and taxation limits, private-sector involvement is certainly here to stay. Dumping more, and more, and more money into our struggling universal healthcare system isn't a realistic option (again, according to experts). Don't bother shooting the messenger, my friend.


Mumphies
said
0 0

Our son almost died in July from a mysterious illness that affected his liver and spleen. The doctors kept asking him if he'd done any foreign travel recently. He hadn't. He had, however, received two colonoscopies from Christiane Farazli. Now we know where he probably picked up his mysterious illness but that won't bring his health back and I'm sure there's no way to sue her or receive any compensation. She gets off by just giving an apology--- that's not right!


scared
said
0 0

A 1 in whatever means a chance your are infected to an average person. A couple of years ago I gave blood and it was refused, they said I had the infection. A few years before that I had the procedure in her office. Before that I was clean. Minutes ago I received the letter from public health...


Anne
said
0 0

Inconvenience or anxiety?? Typical medical brush-off - and the problem is the College of Physicians and Surgeons disciplining their own - anyone who has EVER tried to log a complaint against a physician knows it is a brick wall of joined forces that prevents anything happening to the offending physician - except maybe "a letter on their file" big deal. Face it, we are at the mercy of these people with no recourse at all.


mary elle
said
0 0

@Canada Post - I'm surprised you would say this: "Why are letters being mailed? Shouldn't these people have been personally contacted by phone?" I assume you work at Canada Post, as do I. Letters being mailed is always a good thing.


Raj
said
0 0

(link removed) Perhaps CPSO and Ministry of Health should look here first. Complaints go back to 2007....Doctors are untouchables in Canada as with other business heads. Heavily protected by CMPA with tax payer dollars. Disgusting. The sad thing is she will continue to practice. Perhaps she can be prosecuted in the US if she crosses the border. Conrad Black would still be out in the open if he didn't step into the US soil and the crime was committed in Canada!!Law only applies to an average Joe here.


Pat Prachter
said
0 0

The area of health care is of massive importance in our country. Every hospital and clinic must observe and be made to observe strict guidelines. Stop cutting services to our medical care and hire more people to regulate procedures. Privatization and de-regulation will find us seeing more and more of these cases, as for-profit companies keep their focus on money and cost-cutting. This is a dangerous slope and I hope enough Canadians have the sense to demand sound medical practices that benefit all of us.


Mary
said
0 0

Both my parents were patients of hers and had procedures done there. My Mom has since passed away (cancer), but my Dad is not that concerned. The chances are so slim. However, I would like to know EXACTLY what was done wrong and why. I wonder how many other clinics make mistakes or are careless?? There is nothing wrong with letters being mailed to notify patients. I would rather get a letter than a phone call because then I would have all the info written down in front of me.


Trust your health professional
said
0 0

They are handling the advising of victims with the same carlesness they operate their facility. Sending letters out snail mail, and worse by registrered mail. If no one answers the door, they do not receive the letter. After panicking the entire city, at least some one told them to identify which clinic had infected the victims.


drd
said
0 0

Let me just said that there has been mistakes made in healthcare before. For example, mammograms were misread and people who had cancer were told they did not, pap tests were misread when they were abnormal. These mistakes were human errors/incompetence. The problem I really have was the way Public Health dealt with this. Why have a press conference to say people may have been infected (although exceedingly unlikely) and then not provide them with more info.This has only created undue panic. Dr. Levy needs to step down.


Healthy
said
0 0

Levy needs to fired.


Canada Post
said
0 0

Why are letters being mailed? Shouldn't these people have been personally contacted by phone?


TJ
said
0 0

Why is Dr. Farazli clinic still open and running? It should be closed down and his license suspended what is the HEALTH DEPT waiting for?


Mike R.
said
0 0

Nice. I had a procedure in that building last spring, but I don't know if it was the same clinic.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Subscribe!

MedNews Express newsletter

CTV MedNews Express

Sign up for our weekly medical newsletter, delivered for free to your inbox.

CTV.ca Blogs

Dr. Marla Shapiro

Health Blog

Check out what our guest medical experts and CTV health reporters are writing about.

Twitter

Avis Favaro Twitter

Follow us on Twitter

Follow CTV medical specialist Avis Favaro on Twitter.

Facebook

Like us on Facebook!

Like us on Facebook

Stay connected to the latest health news while you're on Facebook with CTV MedNews

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    7 Video(s) 7

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students to resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1