Top Stories -   

1
Montreal mother Paola Ortiz is hoping a last-ditch efforts allows her to stay in Canada, the country her children were born in. Paola Ortiz is hoping a last-ditch efforts allows her to stay in Canada, the country her children were born in.

Judge orders Montreal mom deported to Mexico

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Genevieve Beauchemin
A Montreal judge ruled that a Mexican woman should be deported to her home country.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (22) Facebook   

Montreal mother Paola Ortiz is hoping a last-ditch efforts allows her to stay in Canada, the country her children were born in. Paola Ortiz is hoping a last-ditch efforts allows her to stay in Canada, the country her children were born in.

Photos

Montreal mother

View Larger Image

Date: Mon. Sep. 19 2011 8:03 PM ET

A 31-year-old Montreal mother who says she fled Mexico five years ago because of domestic violence will be forced to return to her native country, after a judge ruled that her deportation proceedings could move forward.

Paola Ortiz fled her homeland in 2006, after allegedly suffering abuse at the hands of a former partner. But a year after landing in Canada, the Immigration Review Board turned down her application for refugee status.

"They said that there is protection for women who are in danger in Mexico, which is just absolutely false," her lawyer, Stewart Istvanffy, told CTVNews.ca in a brief telephone interview on Monday morning.

"They said there's a legal presumption that Mexico is a functioning country and that she should have made complaints with the police there, which she did, of course. And they said that there is protection of the state in Mexico and nobody believes that."

Ortiz received a deportation notice on Thursday and Istvanffy filed for a judicial stay of removal the next day. But a judge ruled Monday evening that her deportation could proceed.

She spent five years fighting to stay in the country, getting married and giving birth to two children along the way.

She also made efforts to become a Canadian citizen.

"She's been sponsored by her husband and she's already received a Quebec selection certificate, so she's not that far from getting permanent residency," Istvanffy said.

Ortiz fears her two Canadian-born children -- one of whom is autistic, while the other requires surgery for ear infections -- will be put at risk if they accompany her back to Mexico.

"It's not safe for them in Mexico, but if they stay in Canada, they won't have their mother. I know what my children need," Ortiz told CTV Montreal on the weekend.

With a report from CTV Montreal's Kevin Gallagher

Comments are now closed for this story

Charles
said

I volunteered helping refugees at a local non-profit. I have compassion for people who suffer. However, domestic violence should not be allowed as a claim for refugee status. Refugee status is supposed apply to people who are being systematically persecuted by their governments i.e. political prisoners, religious sects etc.Domestic violence occurs in Canada too, and justice is not always served (I have friends who went through this).


Jacqueline
said

She isn't hurting anyone, she isn't leaning on our system. I agree with Louise. We should spend our enegry on bad people, not a mother asking for help.


Jackie Barrett
said

I thought that the Canadian Government has a mandate to unite immigrants and potential immigrants with the families, especially Paola Ortiz.If Paola is deported, then the Canadian Government is not fulfilling their mandate as her children will be separated from their mother, and that's wrong.Lessons learned, you're not in good hands with Stephen Harper as he is splitting families instead of uniting them. I'm glad I didn't vote for the Conservatives.


annette
said

Look we can't help all the needie in the world. we have Canadian here that is not getting the help they need. So send her back. Canadians should come first.


Hunky Dory
said

Why do we have laws if they are not enforced? I feel for her but there's way too much of this going on. And lawyers are making way too much money off taxpayers!!


JPC in SK
said

What a ridiculous claim - send her back...


ColinR
said

An unfortunate story, but rules are rules. She's an illegal. Its not up to Canada to solve the social issues of Mexico one person at a time. Let the kids stay. She can apply for citizenship the proper way.


Doug in Alberta
said

Its going to get very cold here soon over the next few months. If our judge lets her stay, can the gov. deport me instead for a few weeks to Mexico so I can enjoy the sun and sand. I could use a free flight there and then go in an whine and snival for a free flight home like many of our part time Canadians have done in the past.


MarkinTO
said

She's not a "Montreal mom" she just lives in Montreal, she's a Mexican national. I have compassion for refugees fleeing war and violence, but just because her husband ALLEGEDLY abused her in another country does not give her a golden ticket to Canadian citizenship.


Toni
said

Simple answer, send her back. She used Canada, married and had children with the hopes of staying here. She did jump the queue, and for that she needs to go and start again. As someone else said Mexico is a big place and not everywhere is bad. Too many like her using the country and we as tax payers have to foot the bill.


AC in NB
said

With all due respect, a lot of Canadian Citizens have sad stories too. Not to say this woman's problem isn't real. Most people applying for refuge status, are in the same boat or worse.It's like that commercial on tv; can't remember the company. "Sorry current, poor Canadian citizen, we can't help you and your family anymore, our refugees have NEWER problems".I don't think this is news. There are hundreds of thousands of Canadians in bad shape and we don't hear their stories on CTV.


Steve
said

When she arrived she was legally to notify authorities that she was claiming refugee status.Unfortunately for here and her new family, she broke the law and is not a Canadian citizen.I hope things work out but we can't overlook all of our immigration laws because some claims they had a bad time in their country.It's a shame, but it's the law.One woman is here in the news and millions of illegal Mexicans are in the US causing havoc there.


Louise
said

we need to deport the bad guys not the women who are no risk.


mike
said

It seems that everytime their is an excuse the media gets involved and somehow paints the picture that the country of origin is a bad place and they will not survive if they have to return.I suppose that all the individual women in Mexico should leave and come to Canada as there is no protection for them. That would leave no women and the men would have to fend for themselves.Canada has laws for protection as well but even with these laws it does not allows work out for the best.It is about time that we say no to these individuals and their lawyers who are of course making all the money through our tax dollars. I am sure she has not be footing the bill.She should have entered into Canada LEGALLY and then we would not have to spend these tax dollars on her lawyers.The reason she came was to jump the cue which should be reserved for the patient ones who waiting to come to Canada legally.


hollis macdonald
said

send her back this not our problem.this is been used by her to get into the country.


David
said

What a joke, I'm a Canadian living in Mexico. Unless your living in a border town , your fine. If they let her stay in Canada than every person can use the same story to become Canadian. I feel for her abusive relatationship, but that's her partner not Mexico. I guess if you can get on the news than you can be Canadian. I think her lawyer has done a good job getting her exposure , which will help her case.


Jonathan from Saskatoon
said

Wow. Talk about trying to stretch the definition of refugee way beyond reasonable. If we allowed "abusive husband" claims we open our borders to 2/3 of the planets female population plus their kids. 90% of whom would have no marketable skills. Not to mention all those from western nations who are dissatisfied with custodial agreements.


Some fed up guy in Canada
said

Here we go again..... Send her back and make her wait in line line everyone SHOULD!! How about equality for everyone to be given the same chance. Don't jump the line, go back in the queue lady!And she had 2 kids here illegally that we all have to pay taxes for..... Yippe!!! NOT!


Jean
said

I'm just throwing a question out. Why did she have to leave the entire country of Mexico? Couldn't she have simply left town? With millions of people in Mexico, couldn't she have just disappeared to another city? Given her situation, why did she choose to have children in Canada, knowing her stay here was uncertain? Did she get married in Canada or have 2 children out of wedlock? I have to question her decision making.


Jacko
said

I find it funny while waiting to be allowed to stay, this woman has 2 more children. Now she and her lawyer will use these very same children to be able to stay in Canada and in Quebec. Sorry if she has problems back home, but with no proof and no citizenship, she is playing the game for which we as taxpayers will have to pay. Way to go Harper Government. If after your 1st round in which we say no to staying -- No means no go home to the country from which you came. Stop having the rest of us pay your way.


DANIEL H
said

Canada is not resposible for solving all the social problems in other countries!


Bart
said

Send her back. She doesn't deserve to stay. She knew she was an illegal and went ahead & had children to help her cause to stay. Cancun is a great place to be this time of year... No problems there at all.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Raitt urges MPs to support 'expedited' back-to-work bill

More   51 Comments 51    7 Video(s) 7

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students to resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1