Top Stories -   

1
In this undated family photo, Arron Dack, left, and his wife Abigail, right, are seen with their two children Carter and Olivia. (Courtesy of Abigail Carter) Arron Dack, left, fools around with his youngest child Carter. (Courtesy of Abigail Carter) In this undated family photo, Arron Dack, left, and his wife Abigail, right, are seen with their two children Carter and Olivia. (Courtesy of Abigail Carter)

Life after loss: Canadians transformed by 9-11

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Basnicki family on moving on
Maureen Basnicki talks to Canada AM about how her husband was killed on 9-11, and her children, Erica and Brennan, explain how they are moving on with their lives.
Canada AM: Abigail Carter on losing her husband
Since she lost her husband on 9-11, Abigail Carter has moved her family across the country to get away from the memories that changed her life.
Canada AM: Mario Tama, photographer
A Getty Images photographer who was at Ground Zero on 9-11 recounts the tragic events of that day, and discusses the incredible pictures he took as the buildings came down.
Canada AM: Hans Gerhardt on losing his son
A man who lost his son Ralph on 9-11 says despite the fact that ten years has passed, it still hurts to see images of the tragic day. He discusses the last time he spoke to his son, as Ralph called home as soon as the plane hit the north tower.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (10) Facebook   

In this undated family photo, Arron Dack, left, and his wife Abigail, right, are seen with their two children Carter and Olivia. (Courtesy of Abigail Carter) Arron Dack, left, fools around with his youngest child Carter. (Courtesy of Abigail Carter) In this undated family photo, Arron Dack, left, and his wife Abigail, right, are seen with their two children Carter and Olivia. (Courtesy of Abigail Carter)

Photos

In this undated family photo, Arron Dack, left, and his wife Abigail, right, are seen with their two children Carter and Olivia. (Courtesy of Abigail Carter)

View Larger Image

Date: Thu. Sep. 8 2011 5:31 PM ET

Static crackles across the phone line as Abigail Carter pauses to consider which parts of her life have been altered by the events of Sept. 11, 2001.

Half a minute passes. There is a sharp exhale. Then, at last, she breaks her silence.

"Everything," she says. "My life has changed in every single way possible."

Abigail doesn't mince words. When a pair of hijacked airliners decimated the World Trade Center a decade ago, her husband vanished with the life they built together. Thrust into a new normal, the Toronto-native has spent the last 10 years adjusting to her "unintentional life."

The 9-11 terrorist attacks have been labelled the most pivotal event of the 21st century -- an irrevocable act that shook the collective consciousness and changed the shape of foreign policy. Many who watched on television as the Twin Towers buckled into steel and smoke said the moment was surreal, a horrific stunt pulled by a macabre Houdini.

But what happens when an iconic event leaps off the evening newscast and collides with an ordinary life? In Abigail's case, "you're completely transformed."

Ten years ago, Abigail was a young mother of two living in Montclair, N.J. She and her husband Arron Dack, a towering jokester with a broad grin, had moved to the United States a few years after getting married in Toronto.

The young couple woke up around 6 a.m. on the morning Arron died. Arron, a software company executive, was attending a trade show at the World Trade Center that day and wasn't sure what to wear. In a rare move, he let Abigail choose his tie.

"I remember holding his hand just a little bit longer that morning, thinking ‘Don't go, just don't go,'" said Abigail from her new home in Seattle, W.A.

But he left, sporting the tie his wife chose. At 8:46 a.m., a hijacked passenger jet careened into the WTC's North Tower. While smoke rose through the building, Arron phoned Abigail and instructed her to dial 911.

"I thought he was being dramatic. I just said, ‘Okay, I'll dial 911.' I didn't even say I love you because I just assumed I'd talk to him again in 10 minutes," said Abigail.

The North Tower collapsed at 10:28 a.m. Arron, 39, was never seen again.

His daughter Olivia, then 6, would never eat Dad's special "Minnie Mouse" pancakes again. As time passed, his 2-year-old son Carter would barely remember what it was like to have Arron hoist him into the air like a free weight.

Haunted by memories in their New Jersey home, Abigail moved her family to Seattle to start anew. There, she wrote a book about her experience losing Arron. Abigail also continues to lead a "grief and loss" class at a nearby community centre.

On the phone from her Seattle home, Abigail says she hasn't made any big plans for the 10th anniversary of her husband's death.

"Going to public memorials for 9-11 always left me angry," she explains. "After a while, I realized it's because they weren't enough. I needed my own memorial for him."

Instead, Abigail erected a mosaic-tiled birdbath in the family's backyard, a playful nod to "Lemonbird" -- Arron's nickname for her. On the third anniversary of 9-11 she invited neighbours over to christen the bowl with champagne and silly straws.

"Remembering him in the little ways, that's what I prefer," said Abigail.

'It still doesn't make sense'

Over the last decade, there's been a yawning chasm in Stephan Gerhardt's life -- a gap that becomes more pronounced with every milestone.

A lot has happened since his "little brother" Ralph vanished into a smoke-choked office on the 105th floor of the WTC's burning North Tower 10 years ago. Time, like a brisk wind, whistles past the hole that 9-11 left.

"I've changed jobs, started my own business, got married, got a divorce," said Stephan. "These are moments you want to share and Ralph wasn't around for any of them."

On Sept. 11 2001, Ralph was working in Tower One as vice-president of the financial services firm Cantor Fitzgerald. He called his parents in Toronto shortly after the first hijacked airliner crashed a few floors beneath the company's main office.

"Something just happened at the World Trade Center," Ralph told his father Hans over the phone. "We either got hit by a bomb or a plane. I am okay. We are okay. I love you, but I have to go now. We are evacuating. Call you later."

Cantor Fitzgerald lost more than 600 employees on Sept. 11 2001. Though his body was never found, Ralph is presumed to be one of the dead. He was 34.

"I don't think I was ever really angry about it," said Stephan, enunciating slowly while on the phone from his home in Washington, D.C. "I just didn't understand why all these people were murdered. It didn't make sense. It still doesn't make sense.

Stephan said he tries not to dwell on his brother's death anymore. But, occasionally, time goes whistling past the chasm again and reminds him of Ralph.

"I've gotten a funny email and thought ‘Ralph would get a kick out of this,'" said Stephan. "I'm always remembering — from the big things to the little things, to everything in between."

This year, Stephan plans to travel to New York City for the 10th anniversary of his brother's death. It may sound odd, Stephan concedes, but there is a strange comfort in standing at Ground Zero.

"It's as close as I can be to where he is," he said.

'I'm a fighting widow'

In 2004, famed author Joan Didion wrote a memoir chronicling her experience with grief after her husband died of a cardiac arrest. The first lines in her book are: "Life changes fast. Life changes in the instant."

If anyone can vouch for those words, it's Maureen Basnicki.

Ten years ago, Maureen and her husband Ken had just finished building their "dream home" on a sprawling property near Blue Mountain, Ont.

Adding to their bliss, Ken had just been promoted as financial marketing director of the software company BEA Systems. On Sept. 11 2001, he was enjoying his new title at a company conference on the 106th floor of the World Trade Center's first tower.

That's when, for the Basnicki family, life changed fast. Life changed in the instant.

Ken was on the North Tower's 106th floor when the first hijacked American Airlines flight barrelled into the building. Nearly 900 people died on floors 101 through 107 that day, reported The New York Times. Ken was one of them.

The 48-year-old father of two never returned to his dream home. Ken's kids, Erica and Brennan, stepped into adulthood and eventually his wife moved into a different house altogether.

"The walls were screaming at me. I couldn't stay there," said Maureen, over the phone from her new home near Collingwood, Ont.

As incomprehensibly awful as 9-11 was, it gave Maureen a renewed sense of purpose. Five years after Ken's death, Maureen helped launch the Canadian Coalition Against Terror (C-CAT). The group lobbies for legislation that would let Canadians sue countries or groups that support terrorism.

She also regularly visits New York City to give tours of Ground Zero, where she plans to be on the 10th anniversary of her husband's death.

"It's occurred to me that [9-11] was an incredible day or terror and hate. Not just for my family but the entire world," said Maureen, in a soft but forceful voice.

"I try to work my way through that horrible, traumatic day because I don't want to be the grieving widow. I'm a fighting widow," she said.

Comments are now closed for this story

joe canada
said

I wonder how many innocent lives have been lost in Iraq and afghanistan since 911? I'm sure the world trade center (yes a tragedy) would pale in comparrison.


Jenni B
said

Just because we are discussing what happened ten years ago does not mean we haven't moved on. It is okay to talk about it and if you aren't the type of person to do that that stop commenting on this forum. You have no right to tell other people how to deal with their pain and memories of that tragic day. Show some respect for goodness sake!!


Mark in Newmarket
said

Well said Prof. Pye chart, very well said.


Robin
said

Put yourselves in these people's shoes...Their lives were changed in a few short hours with the world watching...I just couldn't imagine..show some compassion people!!!


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

It's quite interesting to witness how "political" people get when 9/11 is justly remembered. (Jack Layton was a career politician, so, it's understandable that the political effort to canonize him and glorify his death with a hyped "legacy" draws dissenting political commentary.) Painfully obvious is that any discussion of genuinely one of the most horrifically tragic events of our time gets certain types all uptight and annoyed. Some feel compelled to "educate" us by way of brainlessly irrelevant comparisons having to do with the number of people killed in Afghanistan, Vietnam, and/or WW2. The "mission" seems to be to minimize, or even trivialize, that awful day -- a few hours -- that took the lives of so many innocent people (not just Americans) on safe-and-secure soil. We typically hear idiotic mumblings about President George Bush, and how "terrorism" is really a fiction perpetrated by manipulative right-wingers with their destructive foreign policy motives. Worse, we hear the mind-numbing nonsense from the kooky conspiracy theorists who concoct bogus "facts" to forge the claim that, in their genius, they have it all figured out, and we're all too dumb to grasp the alleged game at play. Interesting, indeed. Instead of viewing 9/11 as a tragic loss that took people of various races, religions, ethnicities, nationalities, and political stripes, these petty fools see the remembrance as some sort of "gain" for others with, allegedly, an agenda. Real people, real lives, real families, real voids. Grow up, folks. The "politics" here is in your own silly head. Thanks.


big_papi
said

" I agree, time to move on"... when i read your comment, it shows to me your ignorance towards americans and Sept 11, it was a huge tragady that should NEVER be forgotton. the fact that it didnt happen in Canada is no excuse for tell people to get over it, we as Canadians have changed drasticly because of 9/11, we have lost over 150 amazing canadians in that crap hole over there fighting so you can have the freedom to write this stuff. "would you just let it go" if someone in your family was murdered because of where they are from?


Savvy
said

To everyone whos saying its time to move on, you're being very disrespectful. Everyone grieves in different ways. Some people want to move on, some people want to talk about it, some people want to remember. Let people who want to hear about it and dont want it to be buried, talk about it without adding in your rude comments.Goodness.


rick
said

911 has only served the right to grab more power and strip hard earned freedoms from the rest of the nation. All the efforts of veterans from earlier conflicts became worthless thanks to power hungry priveleged politicians and their appointees. What happened that day was bad, but what the governments have done since is worse.


Will
said

Ten years of angst over this tragedy is enough. It is time for the media to let people move on, the story has been flogged to death already.


T Murphy
said

I live in Waterloo, Ontario Canada.Honestly, I really think people should start moving on with all this.Think...Feel...and do Differently.People need to heal.....its’ about time you let it go. Enough is enough...


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

9-11: Ten Years Later

9-11 Ceremony

9-11 Ceremony

50 Pictures: A changed America marks a decade since the Sept. 11 terror attacks.

Before and After

Before and After 9-11

In Pictures: Dramatic before and after images of the 9-11 terror attacks.

9-11 friends

Lifelong Friends

Two men who survived the 9-11 attacks explain how they escaped the WTC.

Canada Reacts to the 9-11 Attacks

9-11 North of the Border

25 Pictures: Canadians watch attacks unfold and step up to help the U.S.

CTV News Channel Special: Ten Years Later

CTV News Channel Special

Watch: Part four in series: CTV reflects on 9-11 and its historic impact.

Haunting 9-11 Shots

Haunting Shots

In Pictures: An emotional look at the heart-wrenching moments etched in history.

Memories of 9-11

9-11 Memories

Memories of 9-11: A day that changed the next decade.

Skyscrapers

Skyscrapers safe?

Are today's skyscrapers safe from another 9-11?

Canadian Victims

Canadian Victims

List of the 24 Canadians lost their lives in the 9-11 terrorist attacks.

A New York City Honor Guard carries a flag found at ground zero during a memorial service commemorating the ninth anniversary of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center Saturday, Sept. 11, 2010 in New York. (AP Photo/Peter Foley, Pool)

9-11 Tributes

A list of events scheduled to mark the 10th anniversary of the terror attacks.

Sept. 11

9-11 Timeline of Events

Recalling the tragic events in chronological order.

9-11 Survivor's Perspective

Survivor's Perspective

In Pictures: Stunning black and white photos from a 9-11 survivor.

Ten years later, Chretien remembers 9-11

Chretien Remembers 9-11

Former prime minister Jean Chretien sits down for a one-on-one interview with CTV.

Thank You, Canada: A commemorative 9-11 photo exhibit.

Thank You, Canada

In Pictures: The U.S. Embassy in Ottawa releases 9-11 photo exhibit.

Conspiracy Culture

Conspiracy Culture

Alternative theories theories thrive 10 years after the 9-11 attacks.

DiscoveryChannel.ca

DiscoveryChannel.ca

In commemoration of the 10th anniversary, Discovery Channel remembers.

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Raitt urges MPs to support 'expedited' back-to-work bill

More   51 Comments 51    7 Video(s) 7

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students to resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1