Top Stories -   

1

Two chickenpox shots are better than one, docs say

Vaccine generic Vaccine generic
Vaccine generic

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (23) Facebook   

Date: Tuesday Sep. 6, 2011 11:27 AM ET

All children should receive two shots of the chickenpox vaccine, to ensure they are protected from the illness for a lifetime, Canada's pediatricians recommend in a new position statement.

Since 1999, the Canadian Paediatric Society has recommended that all young children be vaccinated at least once against chickenpox. Most provinces and territories have routine immunization programs in place for varicella, the clinical name for chickenpox.

Most kids get their first dose between 12 and 18 months of age.

Before a vaccine was available, there were about 5,000 chickenpox-related hospitalizations a year in Canada. But surveillance programs show that the number of hospitalizations for kids has decreased by up to 84 per cent in some provinces since the vaccine was introduced.

Now, new evidence suggests that two shots offer better lifelong protection against the illness, the CPS said in its position statement Tuesday. So the pediatricians recommend kids get a booster dose when they are between 4 and 6 years old.

Teens who have never had chickenpox should also get two shots, at least four weeks apart, the CPS recommends.

They say there's evidence that without that second vaccine dose, some children will lose immunity as they get older, making them susceptible to the illness as adults -- a time when chickenpox can be more serious.

"Adults who get chickenpox have more serious illness, are more likely to get pneumonia and to be admitted to hospital. They also have a higher death rate from the disease," explained statement author Dr. Marina Salvadori, in a news release.

No vaccine offers 100 per cent protection, but the CPS says two doses should improve immune response in those who get the vaccine.

Chickenpox is marked by a whole body rash of red spots that sometimes develop into fluid-filled blisters. The illness usually also brings fever, headache, a dry cough and fatigue.

Chickenpox usually develops two to three weeks after either physical contact with an infected person, or by breathing nthe virus. The illness then becomes most contagious about 24 hours before the rash appears, making it easy for infected people to spread the virus without realizing it.

Those who have actually become ill with chickenpox won't need the vaccine, though if they do get a dose, it's unlikely to cause any harm.

The statement puts the CPS in step with Canada's National Advisory Committee on Immunization, which already recommends a two-dose schedule for chickenpox, and has for a year.

The American Academy of Pediatrics has recommended two immunizations since 2007.

CPS also wants to see public funding for the chickenpox booster vaccine. Some provinces, such as Ontario, pay for the second dose, but not all provinces do. The position statement is urging all provinces and territories to cover both shots.

In statements made to The Canadian Press, Salvadori explained that one of the reasons the CPS issued this position statement is to put pressure on provinces to publicly fund it.

"What we're really hoping is the provinces all pick this up, and it becomes introduced in the next year or two in all Canadian provinces for all Canadian children," she said.

Certain people should not get the chickenpox vaccine, including:

  • people who have a prior history of severe allergic reaction to the vaccine, or other components of the vaccine
  • people with weak immune systems, unless under the supervision of a specialist in infectious diseases
  • pregnant women or those who are trying to get pregnant
  • babies less than one year old

Comments are now closed for this story

Pete
said
0 0

The point of the immunization innoculations is to create anti-bodies in a much safer, controlled manner than actually contrating the live pathogen. By having these antibodies and having memory B cells aware of this pathogen, it makes for a significantly decreased chance of full blown infection if exposed without prior to the immunization. Nowhere is it saying that people MUST get this, but it is strictly RECOMMENDED. I dont know about the rest of the country, but in Ontario these immunizations can be obtained at the local public health units, or physician's office at no cost to patients. I just thought I'd point out these useful bits of information which are FACTS and not strictly opinions..............


Mark
said
0 0

I believe in basic and minimal vaccines e.g Polio, mumps, measles Tetanus, Hep A and B etc, but things have gone too far. A very young immune system can be overwhelmed by this stuff and there are legitimate studies to prove this. This is huge business and a trillion dollar industry folks, To preserve most of these vaccines they are laced with chemicals such as formaldehyde, aluminum and mercury including dangerous(Thimersol) based products. Just look at the ingredients on the Pharma websites or product monograph. Then many of the vaccines are of an adjuvant nature, which rapidly increases the immune response, but are more likely to have serious side effects. The Hep B shot and swine flu gave me severe body wide itching that lasted for close to a year in each instance. Turns out I am very allergic to Thimersol and the adjuvant nature of these shots. As far as chickenpox goes our own doctor told us no way would he give our son the shot because the efficacy of it long term is unproven. As for shingles, yes it is extremely painful, but if you recognize the symptoms of it in the first 11-18 hours there are anti-viral meds that will limit the severity of it e.g Zovirax . Bottom line educate yourselves, I am very careful before I put anything into my body and make sure exactly what is going into it chemical and immune response wise.


Lucy
said
0 0

nhs.ukThe chickenpox vaccine is not part of the UK childhood vaccination programme, because experts think that introducing a chickenpox vaccination for children could increase the risk of shingles in older people. It is used to protect people who are most at risk of a serious chickenpox infection.Chickenpox is usually a mild illness, particularly in children. The condition is so common in childhood that 90% of adults who grow up in the UK are immune to the chickenpox virus because they have had it before.


Lucy
said
0 0

thinktwice.comDr.S. I am wondering what percentage of children die or are extremely ill due to not having the chicken pox vaccine; vs the percentage of children who die or are extremely ill due to HAVING the chicken pox vaccine?


LorraineH
said
0 0

@cOmmonSense : I hope you never develop Shingles - while mine was not so severe as I was able to get on antibiotics within 3 days my mother had a full blown case of shingles and was in extreme pain for a long period of time.

If you are not diagnosed and get the pills within 3 days, there is not much that can be done for shingles.

I say again, better a needle now than shingles later.


Phil Ottawa
said
0 0

Just as it doesn't seem clear how the vaccine works to many commentors, when you are immunized with a vaccine, you are actually injected with a partial viral strain or genome without it's virulence. The basic concept on a vaccine, is to expose someone to the antigen (think of it as the organism's national flag that they wave around) and your body then produces anti- bodies against that marker (the flag). Whether you're infected by the organism (say chicken pox) or exposed to it's antigen via a vaccine (antigens are usually just a protein, but can be partial DNA) you develop anti-bodies. Sure you make more when infected, as to fend off an infection, but the retention rate over time is the same (Some people do get chicken pox twice!)


cOmmonSense
said
0 0

@AM You may be content to let the government and their special interest groups tell you when to get immunized, but for those of us with a brain who did contract chicken pox and survived back in the day, we're probably far better off physically than you. You don't get immunized, you develop anti-bodies, then you are better able to fight off that and many other illnesses that will likely go around. You who get a shot for everything, or take a pill for all ailments will have a harder time fighting the most innocuous of ailments because you let BigPharma do it for you....and antibiotics of all stripes are very liver unfriendly - but by all means - go get shot!!!


Rachael
said
0 0

A study conducted by Dr. Bernard Duval (Most Children With a Negative or Unknown Varicella History Are Immune, from Laval University in Quebec, and colleagues assessed the age-specific incidence of chicken pox among 2227 fourth grade students. A subset of children with negative or unknown chickenpox histories were tested for anti-varicella antibodies.

The study was performed to determine the proportion of children that would need to be vaccinated in a catch-up program. Contrary to widely held beliefs, most 10-year-old children with negative or unknown chicken pox histories are actually immune to varicella. Based on the varicella antibody tests, two thirds of these children would be vaccinated "needlessly," the report indicates. Testing before vaccination could identify children who are immune.


Dr. S
said
0 0

waiting for all the anti-vaccine nuts to come on here and start spreading their quackery and pseudo-science. Vaccines are the single best health measure modern medicine has ever come up with. Dollar for dollar they save our health care system more money and save more lives than any other sickness-prevention strategy. To those who say that chicken pox is harmless, come spend some time on my pediatrics ward with children extremely sick from illnesses that could have been prevented with a simple immunization. It is a tragedy to behold.


SaskieMom
said
0 0

My child had a rash that looked like chickenpox when she was five. Both public health and the pediatrician would not tell me if it was possible to get a mild case of chickenpox if the child was vaccinated. They explained the rash as allergy or another virus even though chicken pox was in my child's daycare. I have heard many parents tell me their children also had chickenpox after vaccination. Maybe the vaccine needs to be improved instead of just adding an extra dose and health care professionals should be educated that chickenpox is still possible after vaccination.


Al
said
0 0

Of course the pharmaceutical companies monitor the success of their vaccines. They, like any business, don't want to waste money on useless products. But look at the numbers. How many children today get mumps, measles, smallpox, rubella or chickenpox? Very few. Most have no idea what those diseases are. Vaccines work.@Pat. I think you may be mistaken about getting the chickenpox vaccine as a child. It wasn't developed until the late 1980s and wasn't available in North America until the 1990s. You would have received the smallpox vaccine as a child which left a nice scar on the arm.


Prairie Mom
said
0 0

Sorry Pat but your recollection is off as a chicken pox vaccine was not developed until the 80's and wasn't allowed into the States until 1995 and Canada in 1998. This means that you may have had chicken pox as a child then developed shingles at 60. This is the reason for the vaccine - if you don't get chicken pox you won't get shingles - at least that is the plan. We shall see if it works.


Jaid in Toronto
said
0 0

So instead of a naturally cheap solution that was proven to work ages ago, we move onto a controlled but costly process and also produces the same solution. In an economy that is barely growing, I have to ask, where is the funding for this?


LorraineH
said
0 0

I agree with Pat - I had shingles in my early 60's. I would urge all adults to get the shot - better a needle than the pain of shingles.





PM
said
0 0

@AM, what are you going on about? What is wrong with discussing concerns about the adjuvants used in vaccines or their efficacy? I firmly believe some vaccines have their place but I do find it strange that chicken pox is suddenly considered a virus that we really need to immunize against, especially considering that the efficacy of the vaccine really isn't all that great; i.e. you can still get and spread varicella to others after receiving the vaccine, the effectiveness of the shot wanes over time (hence this article), etc. Somehow previous generations managed to survive chicken pox. As a kid I remember getting chicken pox and, while it wasn't pleasant, I certainly wasn't scarred for life, mentally or physically; chicken pox was something you just got over, fairly quickly. I'm certainly not a conspiracy theorist and firmly believe in modern medicine and science but I also don't blindly follow recommendations without first weighing all factors. I don't see the necessity in a vaccine for chicken pox and history suggests we are doing just fine without it. It's sort of like getting the flu-shot each year. For example, neither I nor my wife get sick during flu season and with her being a teacher, she is constantly exposed to a variety of viruses. I know colleagues who get the flu-shot yet still get sick. I understand that is anecdotal evidence at best but it still makes me wonder how useful some of these vaccines really are. I'm sure someone will chime in about how we need to be vaccinated against everything or the world will end. The money the provinces might spend on chicken pox vaccination programs could be better directed at more life-threatening diseases and illnesses.


Mike
said
0 0

Chicken pox in most cases is as harmless a mild flu, there is no benefit to the chicken pox vaccine, and it will not prevent shingles in later years unless your child continues to get booster shots in their adult life, however a child who does get infected with the chicken pox virus will rarely develop shingles later on. Talk to your pediatricians ask them for the facts, most doctors are not all that big on vaccinating against chicken pox, they do it upon the parents request and cannot advise against it even though they disagree with it. But if you first ask questions they can and will give you all the facts and even sometimes an opinion.


Vancouver Mom
said
0 0

My daughter had only one shot at one-year-old and came down with chickenpox last winter when she was 8. Classic example of what they're talking about. She missed a month of school. I wish a protocol of the 2nd shot had been in place sooner. Chickenpox can be very serious and, having also had a terrible case myself as a child, I think the idea of chickenpox parties is insane. It's good that they're finally endorsing the 2nd shot since other jurisdictions have had this in place for some time.


Mel
said
0 0

Now I understand why I paid for the vaccine and my kid still got chickenpox.Makes sense. I think the government should have to pick up the tab for the whole thing!!


Pat
said
0 0

I was vaccinated as a child for chicken pox, and in my sixties I developed shingles ( same virus) which was extremely painful. I'd urge parents to get the 2nd shot. The after pain of shingles is not pleasant.


Kate, Toronto
said
0 0

I hope this will help. This summer my 4 year old son spend two weeks of his vacation at home because of chicken pox. At the same time my husband had also 2 weeks off work due to chicken pox . I have no idea where and how they got infected and I did'n know that 1 dose is not effective. It came to us as a surprise. Although the symptoms were mild staying at home cost us time, money, and some nerves.


Lucy
said
0 0

Thing is, we the average public have to rely on what certain doctors tell us. "Two needles are better than one." Next, will it be "three needles are better than two."?At age 68 I have read this study and that study and then find out the studies are paid for by a pharmacutical (sp?) company.In a nutshell, I do not believe everything I read, no matter who wrote it. The decisions will not be made by "us" - so what can we do anyway? I don't blame parents for not putting into their children's bodies more chemicals than absolutely necessary.


PVT
said
0 0

I wonder which big pharma entity paid for this study and press release....follow the money....


AM
said
0 0

Let the conspiracy theories begin! Its a secret plot for the government to control our children!Vaccines are bad for us - they cause autism and cancer and allergies & everything else!The sky is falling, the sky is falling!


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Subscribe!

MedNews Express newsletter

CTV MedNews Express

Sign up for our weekly medical newsletter, delivered for free to your inbox.

CTV.ca Blogs

Dr. Marla Shapiro

Health Blog

Check out what our guest medical experts and CTV health reporters are writing about.

Twitter

Avis Favaro Twitter

Follow us on Twitter

Follow CTV medical specialist Avis Favaro on Twitter.

Facebook

Like us on Facebook!

Like us on Facebook

Stay connected to the latest health news while you're on Facebook with CTV MedNews

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Raitt urges MPs to support 'expedited' back-to-work bill

More   51 Comments 51    7 Video(s) 7

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students to resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1