Top Stories -   

1
One of the ads in the Fluid Salon campaign features a young woman sitting on a floral couch with a black eye. She has perfectly coiffed hair and is wearing high heels and a stylish dress. Salon owner Sarah Cameron told CTV Edmonton she stands by the ads, explaining that they were meant to strike a chord with people -- and they've done just that. One of the ads in the Fluid Salon campaign features a young woman sitting on a floral couch with a black eye. She has perfectly coiffed hair and is wearing high heels and a stylish dress.

Salon unapologetic over black eye in ad campaign

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Edmonton: Susan Amerongen on the outrage
A hair salon in Alberta is all the rage on social media sites Monday, but for the wrong reasons as an ad has stirred up controversy.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (39) Facebook   

One of the ads in the Fluid Salon campaign features a young woman sitting on a floral couch with a black eye. She has perfectly coiffed hair and is wearing high heels and a stylish dress. Salon owner Sarah Cameron told CTV Edmonton she stands by the ads, explaining that they were meant to strike a chord with people -- and they've done just that. One of the ads in the Fluid Salon campaign features a young woman sitting on a floral couch with a black eye. She has perfectly coiffed hair and is wearing high heels and a stylish dress.

Photos

One of the ads in the Fluid Salon campaign features a young woman sitting on a floral couch with a black eye. She has perfectly coiffed hair and is wearing high heels and a stylish dress.

View Larger Image

Date: Tue. Aug. 30 2011 4:52 PM ET

An Edmonton hair salon's controversial ad campaign featuring a woman with a black eye has triggered outrage and debate over the use of images of domestic violence in media.

But the owners of the salon are defending the campaign and suggesting people need to lighten up.

One of the ads in the Fluid Salon campaign features a young woman sitting on a floral couch with a black eye. She has perfectly coiffed hair and is wearing high heels and a stylish dress.

Behind her stands a well-dressed man holding what appears to be a diamond necklace.

The ad features the slogan: "Look good in all you do."

A New York City blogger called "copyranter," who focuses on media advertising, brought attention to the ad in a recent post.

"Well, she's about to get a shiny diamond necklace to match her shiner, so all's well that ends well? Edgy," states the blogger.

The comments section quickly came alive with discussion about the ad.

One poster going by the name Bock McMillan called the ad "absolutely sickening."

"How anyone can even consider this to be a 'cool' way to promote anything at all except spousal abuse is a sad statement on how men's violence against women is still viewed in many parts of society," McMillan wrote.

In another ad in the campaign, a stylish-looking young woman sits on a dirty mattress, smoking a cigarette in what appears to be an alley strewn with garbage, a broken bottle and what appears to be condoms.

The woman is wearing high heels, tights and a black bra with an unbuttoned vest.

The "Look good in all you do" slogan also accompanies the ad.

Salon owner Sarah Cameron told CTV Edmonton she stands by the ads, explaining that they were meant to strike a chord with people -- and they've done just that.

"We want people to talk about it. It's supposed to gear up some sort of discussion," Cameron said. "Look at her; she's not looking at him. Who's to say she's not getting ready to get up and walk away? It's how everybody perceives it."

The ads reportedly lived on the salon's Facebook page for two years before the New York blogger drew attention to the campaign.

With files from CTV Edmonton

Comments are now closed for this story

Anne
said
0 0

Chris.... free speach goes both ways, if they have a right to say this, people have a right to disagree with it!!


Living in Edmonton
said
0 0

I think the ad is repulsive. The best action to show disaproval is to stop using the services of this salon. If enough of this salon's customers stop using it's services, the owner of the salon will get the point that people find her form of advertising offensive. Let community standards prevail. I'm sure that glamourizing abuse is not part of the community standards of Edmonton let alone anywhere in Canada.


Gorg
said
0 0

If nothing else has been accomplished, we have drama in the both the article and the comments.


Shrewd in NB
said
0 0

And now the salon has millions of dollars of advertising. All for free. Good move on their part.


Loosen Up
said
0 0

Considering the amount of attention this salon has had - good or bad - it sure looks like a successful marketing campaign to me....


Gregory Wollf
said
0 0

Taking this in a slightly different direction, to quote Jen Reimer, who educates the public about domestic violence,"Domestic Violence hurts. It hurts women and it hurts children. It has a huge impact upon our society."She missed a huge amount of people who it also hurts, men. To assume the domestic violence is only done by men to women and children is simply inaccurate and sexist. There are many studies that show that women engage in domestic violence against men just as much if not more than men do. Men do not come forth because of shame, the public stigma against them, and a lack of help centers for males (institutionalized sexism) If we are going to actively fight against domestic violence then at least give accurate information about it and stop propagating this destructive and inaccurate view that women and children are the only victims!


BOOJ
said
0 0

The first thing that jumps out at me is how atrocious that hairstyle is. And this is an ad for a hair salon??? Just gross.


artfulpixie
said
0 0

To those saying it is just a photograph - remember how visual most people are. A photograph can be very impactful! If it wasn't - there would not be so many people from different walks of life upset about the imagery.


chel in the Peg
said
0 0

Just another transparent attempt to be controversial. Pretty common in the fashion industry.


Kyle in Edmonton
said
0 0

If you don't like the advertisment then simply don't go to the salon!! Many people interperet advertisments in many ways. The only thing this girl is a victim of is your nonsense remarks to abuse. Since when does getting your hair done associate yourself in anyway with domestic violence? What's next, a woman who has an apron on in a kitchen ad an absolute set back for womens rights? Get a grip you hypcocrits, or better yet, go get your hair done!!


charlie
said
0 0

Once upon a time, the most certain way to get tons of free publicity for a book, magazine or movie (or burlesque show) was to have it "Banned in Boston" which banning was then loudly trumpeted in all subsequent advertising. Remember this ad is almost two years old now and nothing was said until the professional agitators got into the act. All in all, much ado about nothing substantive (did they beat up the model before the photos? - thought not) - but the salon must be enjoying a quiet chuckle with all that publicity that came absolutely free of charge. As far as a successful boycott of the salon - lotsa luck!


Obvious
said
0 0

Maybe i could see with all the comments stating that she ran into a door, was beat by her lesbian lover...if the guy was not standing behind her and she was by herself. Crazy fight hair, black eye, man with necklace in hand...It's very difficult to see this some other way, other than she got beat and she is being rewarded thereafter for staying quite.


The Big BK
said
0 0

Belbows said"Sick, I guess the feminist movement has not progressed as far as we think it has."Actually, it has.I did a quick google of "Lesbian domestic violence" and the first hit quoting a university study shows that it's about equal in percentages to heterosexual domestic violence.So you are incorrect in your assumtion that the feminist monement has done nothing. Women now beat women just as much as men do.


T
said
0 0

So to all the over sensitive people.....where does it say anything to indicate that the man abused the woman?The picture leaves the perception up to the viewer. If spouse abuse is the first thing that pops into your mind every time you see a woman with a black eye it only means that you jump to conclusions. If the man had a black eye, would you think she beat him up or one of his buddies in a drunken bar fight? I know a few women that have had black eye's and none of them were from spouse abuse. There are more ways to get a black eye other then a man beating up a woman.


stargazer
said
0 0

Wow, this is the salon's idea of "perfectly coifed" hair? It looks like a backcombed mullet, are you kidding me?! If a salon did that to me I'd want my money back. Advertising FAIL.


Chris, Alberta
said
0 0

Free speech and expression is apparently inappropriate in Canada. Who knew? It makes people stop and think - that's probably the problem right there! How dare they !!


Mandosa
said
0 0

I find this whole debate rather meaningless anyway since our society has already jettisoned any sense of morality or moral framework. We parade our perversions in the streets and congratulate each other on our progress as self appointed 'rights activists'. So don't sweat it, dear CTV reader. Any horror you may (rightly) experience to this can easily be rationalized, justified and finally normalized by some soon to be released 'academic' study or maybe your new favourite reality TV show.


MAE in Ontario
said
0 0

A stupid ad that makes no sense and would only entice a few of the young who don't know any betterW hat gets me is perfectly coifed hair. Except for the top, the rest looks like a dogs breaklfast -- no -- It looks like the dogs breakfast after he threw it up


Tanya
said
0 0

I wouldn't waste my money going to this salon; not just because of the ad but because the hair on that model looks like an angry 4 year old did it.I wonder if her next ad will be of some greasy guy offering a nicely coiffed little kid candy out his opened car door with some catchy caption referring to a first date? Classy Cameron...really classy.


Paul
said
0 0

Maybe the bruising is from the plastic surgery from her/his gender reassignment surgery. Maybe she was beaten by her lesbian lover. Maybe she got banged up in a botched armoured car robbery. Maybe the cross fell over and bonked her at a KKK rally. Come on people get over it.


Salt and Vineger
said
0 0

It is just an ad, and just make up. But it does bring domestic violence into view, rather than being hidden away and not talked about.


Paul
said
0 0

Back fire and a public apology will soon be forthcoming. The model should think twice before acting in such bad taste as to allow herself to be victimized.


The Big BK
said
0 0

I agree with Steve H. I don't see bloody knuckles on the man so why exactly do we assume this is domestic violence? To the people saying the feminist movement... or it's not OK... Why is it OK for you to assume that she is a victim and not an assertive female athlete? I think people who see this and instantly "ASSUME" domestic violence are the real sexists posting here.


You Dont Know
said
0 0

Why are people so quick to jump to conclusions? Domestic violence? Maybe she walked into a door? You weren't there, were you? Images of people should be picture perfect? LIttle Betty can't be fat (sorry obese) because that gives the wrong message? Message from who? To Who? Maybe the model was in a car accident three days before the photo shoot, but really needed the gig? That's it, no more diamonds or hair do-s for my wife.


PEI Fella
said
0 0

To all those whining over or opposed to this ad. You are giving the salon exactly what they wanted. Thanks to you you've made it a successful campaign. Don't like the ad don't by the product. Personally I think it is silly, who says he hit her? Maybe she walked into a door and he's bought her a present to make her feel better.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said
0 0

The profession of "advertising" has devolved into basic attention seeking, in which any means to rattle some heads is both fair and desired. Little is off limits, and few rules exist. Depict whatever you want, get some sensitive folks upset, watch the media sniff its way to the piece, and sit back and smile. (You can pull the ad after the glorious attention has been gained, and pretend to be sensitive to public opinion and offending people.)


Edmontonian
said
0 0

I don't understand how anyone in their right mind can defend this ad. This woman is OBVIOUSLY being portrayed as a victim of abuse. There are too many cues in the add for anyone to rationally suggest an alternate plot line. It is what the owner intended and it is sick. A hair salon, run by a woman, is exploiting one of the ugliest aspects of our society to make a buck.


DD
said
0 0

If they wanted to portray a boxer, they could have put her in a ring, in gym clothes or even with a belt around her waist. If they wanted to portray a hockey player, they could have laid a stick across her lap. What they have portrayed is a woman looking pretty for her apology jewellery after a beating. I also agree with Ferdinand - what message are they trying to convey by giving a hairdo to a homeless person? Maybe they should have two women with nice hair in that picture - one who needs help and one who is giving it by offering food, shelter or a helping hand. Just so you know Ms. Cameron, the only chord you have struck with people is one of disgust. Good luck with that.


jerrycan42
said
0 0

The extra free advertising provided by news agencies was the intended effect. It worked! I wouldn't have notice this otherwise.


Gaila
said
0 0

The picture speeks for itself. Woman boxer? Come on! A woman boxer would not be portrayed that way. Very poor taste! But the most disconcerting about this picture is that a woman accepted that interpretation for $$$..an then we complain that we are treated as sexual objects...really?


BBB
said
0 0

These anals are so annoying!! They object to everything. I side with the salon and say to the idiots protesting "Get a life people!!!"


Penelope
said
0 0

Maybe she is a boxer .....woman are allowed to be boxers right? People need to get a grip.


KC
said
0 0

I am constantly amazed at how the heckles raise on people's neck over mundane matters. It is a picture people - let it speak to you... We get offended because more attention is not brought to spousal abuse; then we are offended because more attention is brought to spousal abuse. We are offended because royal is back in the military's name; we are offended because it was taken out. Well let me add to the list - I am offended that there are not more parking spots at the prostrate clinic. Most of you do not realize just how inconvenient and taxing that is for some of us.


Steve H
said
0 0

Why does everyone assume that this woman is a victim of domestic abuse? Could she be a female boxer? How about a field hockey player who took one for the team? Or maybe she is just clumsy and really did smack herself with a door.


Joe Canadian
said
0 0

Normally I tend to side with the corporate world on stuff like this - if they want to run an ad that's in poor taste.... let them AND let their customers take their business elsewhere. In this case though - REALLY? This is the best your marketing team could come up with? My suggestion is, pull the ad, give the marketing team each a punch in the eye and post their photos. The ad is in very poor taste.


Belbows
said
0 0

Sick, I guess the feminist movement has not progressed as far as we think it has.


Terry
said
0 0

So, every child that falls down and gets a bruise is child abuse ? Adults have accidents too ! Let's be concerned about abuse against anyone and take corrective action but let's not jump on the band wagon before checking to see if the wheels are functional.


Debbie
said
0 0

That is so sad to be so insensitive to a very real situation only to promote yourselves...I would quit that place in a heart beat!! Stop a minute, and think what message you are sending to our young girls. Shame on you.


ferdinand@gmail.com
said
0 0

Rather interesting that the media fixates on the domestic abuse angle in the advert when the second example focusing on prostitution and poverty does not warrant commentary.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt appears on CTV's Power Play on Monday, May 28, 2012.

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    12 Video(s) 12

Air Canada says it appears an engine part fell from the plane and crashed into the windshield of a car in Mississauga, Ont. on Monday, May 28, 2012.

Air Canada plane makes emergency landing in Toronto

More

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    4 Video(s) 4