Top Stories -   

1
Sarah Benkirane has been barred from refereeing while wearing her hijab.

Quebec teen told she can't referee soccer with hijab on

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Montreal: Camille Ross on the decision
The Quebec Soccer Federation says the Lac St. Louis soccer association was right to ban a referee who wore the hijab.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (73) Facebook   

Sarah Benkirane has been barred from refereeing while wearing her hijab.

Photos

Sarah Benkirane has been barred from refereeing while wearing her hijab.

View Larger Image

Date: Wed. Jun. 22 2011 7:02 AM ET

MONTREAL — A Quebec teen who has been told she can no longer referee soccer while wearing her hijab says she's going to fight the red card.

Sarah Benkirane, 15, said her Montreal-area soccer association informed her she could no longer referee games wearing her traditional Muslim head scarf after someone filed a complaint with the league.

Benkirane, in her second season as a ref for the Lac-St-Louis Regional Soccer Association, was told religious symbols like hijabs may not be worn on the pitch.

But the teenager insists she's not going to give up on her summer job that easily.

"I was kind of frustrated, but right away I started to think, 'OK, this is my chance, if they want to rule (on) this then I'm going to fight it -- for sure,' " Benkirane said in an interview Tuesday.

"I grew up with friends from every different culture and nobody's ever discriminated against (me) because of religion."

Benkirane said she's contacted the Council on American-Islamic Relations CANADA and plans to put pressure on the Canadian Soccer Association to force Quebec's governing soccer body to overturn its decision.

The president of the Quebec Soccer Federation told reporters Tuesday it's simply applying FIFA's international rules, which stipulate referees and players may not wear religious symbols on the pitch.

"It's clearly stated that officials shall not display commercial, religious. . . or personal messages of any language," Dino Madonis told a news conference.

The Quebec federation also issued a statement Tuesday to defend its ruling.

"Therefore the situation is clear! Wearing a hijab is not permitted on Quebec's soccer fields, not any more than necklaces, earrings, rings and such, and won't be until FIFA gives directives to the contrary," the statement said.

Quebec, which was ground zero a few years ago for the debate on the "reasonable accommodation" of minorities, has also seen several disputes in recent years over hijabs worn during athletics.

In 2007, an 11-year-old Ottawa girl was ejected from a soccer game in Laval, Que., after she refused to remove her hijab, which violated FIFA's no-headgear rule.

That year, a taekwondo team of Muslim girls withdrew from a tournament in Longueuil, Que., after they were told they couldn't compete in their hijabs.

Still, Quebec isn't alone when it comes to the debate over hijabs and sports.

In 2007, a soccer player wearing a hijab was ejected from a game in Calgary over safety concerns, a decision that came just weeks after an 11-year-old girl left a Winnipeg judo tournament in tears when officials refused to let her fight in a head scarf.

Benkirane said she was well aware of previous controversies surrounding athletes who were banned from playing certain sports in hijabs due to security reasons.

But she thought her situation was different.

"Refs don't have any contact with the other players, so I figured that there's no danger," she said.

"They've changed what they're saying and now they start saying it's a religious symbol -- back then it was about safety."

Comments are now closed for this story

Ashera
said
0 0

The mind, not the clothes makes decisions on/in any arena. Therefore, if the individual is capable to conduct themselves in a proper and intellectual manner, she should be allow to coach.


PBW
said
0 0

Are we going to ban girls from christian sects that require head covering too? Think Mennonites, Hutterites and others. Are we going to deny children of any faith the right to play an organized sport just because of political correctness gone wild? What has happened to our tolerant society? If the girl concerned were playing football or rugby or hockey, I might have a concern, but reffing soccer? Give me a break! This particular FIFA rule comes directly from France, where their racist government first introduced the concept of banning any sort of religious apparel anywhere outside the home. I guess Canada is becoming just as racist as that nation, judging by the comments here. Rosa parks had it right; I hope this gal gets it right too.


Tom
said
0 0

Why should majority be suppressed by minority? Nowadays, it is politically incorrect to even put a Christmas tree in city hall, or use the word Merry Christmas. All because some individuals feel that their rights is larger than the majority? Respect is bi-directional.


Give it a rest!
said
0 0

Ridiculous! Blatant racism and religious intolerance and lack of respect. We should be celebrating our differences and the richness our immigrants bring to our country!


s
said
0 0

pssst....hey haters....canada is a mosaic not a melting pot.....all the comments that start with "when these people come to my country" - disgusting....this is a little 15 year old girl who is screwed either way.....either she's in trouble with her family or she doesn't get to play soccer. poor kid has to take on the world for nothing. guess what this isn't the world cup and if she isn't infringing on my rights or my way of life she should do as she pleases. maybe all of you intolerant close minded emabarassments of canadians should go back to wherever you or your ancestors came from!i don't think a 15 year old kid should have to take on the soccer league, her family and the worlds religions to play a game of soccer. good luck to her and i hope she gets to play.


poptart
said
0 0

Oh boo hoo. Take the thing off your head and play soccer. Leave it on, stand out, be demonised and begin the hate, In this day and age if you believe in anything supernatural, you are an immature kook.


Tony - Mtl
said
0 0

Our forefathers and foremothers fought for the rights of women not to be opressed, to be able to vote, to be equal to man. The hijab and the burka undermine the fight that our mothers and fathers fought for in this country. Many immigrants have come to this country to take advantage of these wonderful rewards that Canada has to offer. If you do not agree with the rules and customs that our foreparents fought for in this country your alternative is to go back to the country that is more in line with your political (yes political) and religious views.


D
said
0 0

This is Canada, not some muslim country. When in Canada, you do what the Canadians want you to do, or get out.


Gorg
said
0 0

After reading all the comments, I strongly agree that the rules are rules. Don't like it, too bad! I am one of many who are really getting sick of all the political correctness which is about the same as walking on eggshells everyday. There is absolutely no reason why the majority has to bend over backwards for a few vocal loud mouth minority groups that figure we owe them a life. I agree with a couple of comments where if I went to the country of Muslim origin, I would absolutely not be allowed to make my personal faith public in their former country. Hey folks, this is just the beginning. First it's their own rights, then it'll be their rights for me whether I like it or not. Just another "special interest" group. In conclusion if they don't like the "Canadian" way, go back home and while you're at it, get off my lawn!


Cindy - Edmonton, AB
said
0 0

This is Canada and we don't wear those garments here?? She very well could be Canadian just like the rest of us. A majority of this country originally comes from somewhere else with other customs that at one point were possibly frowned upon so leave the 'this is Canada' out of it. If you're born here, you're a Canadian and we have many cultures to represent here. We are not a melting pot and for a lot of Canadians that's something we're proud of. That being said, if FIFA has it posted that there are no religious symbols on the pitch then it should be across the board or not be applied to anyone. It may not be what she, or anyone else, wants but it's what it's set at now. It's no easier for someone to remove a Star of David, a crucifix or any other symbol but they too should be expected to do so. Anyone can fight this rule for their right to wear their religious symbol if they chose.


robin hood
said
0 0

Honestly, I don’t see a lot of difference between the hijab and driving a convertible wearing a kerchief back in the 50’s—maybe a little out-dated for the 21 century but hey each to their own—it sure doesn’t appear to be covering her face and here I thought that was the issue?


taylor
said
0 0

The ruling is suspect, if only because someone filed a complaint. If the rule was across the board, then it would have been implemented at the time of infraction, which according to the article was last season. So, what can be gathered is that the girl does her job and does it well enough to be brought back for another season. My guess, some parent did not like a call she made against their child so they went after the easiest mark on her. If the ruling is to be enforced then it should be enforced consistently, not at the whim of a hate-filled parent who hides their racism and contempt behind a rule most would rather forget about at the teenage level. Amateur football is not FIFA, it's for kids.


Mike
said
0 0

Poor girl doesn't even realize that the scarf isn't actually a religious symbol but a cultural one. She is going to fight it on religious grounds? This isn't some Muslim state, it's Canada. The rules are FIFA, international and are there for a reason. Deal with where you live, and what the rules are like the rest of us. You aren't anymore special than any other kid out on the pitch. So very sick of this PC crap. If you don't like it, your free to live somewhere else.


Wilson
said
0 0

It seems safe enough to me. These are kids.. we're not talking about pro soccer here..


Peter
said
0 0

I have lived in Dubai, Qatar and Lebanon (Muslim countries). I can give you addresses and names of places where you can buy bacon, Pork shops, alcohol. Example: SHWETRAM, Waitrose & Spinneys. And the best part is, no one had ever suggested asking any Canadian to leave their country if they did not find Pork shops or if the women are not wearing hijab!!!My wife, as for foreign women, DID NOT HAVE to wear hijab in these Muslim countries. On the contrary we enjoyed the beach everyday…. Finally in the Canadian Constitution of Canada, it is clearly written that Canadians have the freedom of believe and religion. I find the request to leave Canada is so contradictory to what true Canadians should believe.


Richard
said
0 0

Wow ! she must be proud of herself. This is ridiculous!


Layla
said
0 0

Wow, Everyone is talking about "tolerance" as long as it doesn't infringe on them, and following FIFA rules and don't come to this country and try to change things yada yada yada. Can I just point out that first of all, she is a TEENAGER, so this is not FIFA it is a kids soccer game. So the main objective should be for KIDS to have FUN. Second, she is just reffing, so how is that a safety issue. I agree with one commenter, leave this girl alone!!


Carol
said
0 0

@ Carl have you ever been to a Muslim country to know what is going on over there? Are we not(meaning Canadians) the one who are in Libya bombing up the place and it's not our affair? but b/c France started it then we must join b/c there is oil? And what about Afghanistan? What Muslim country came to Canada and started dropping bombs on our heads? This has nothing to do with complying in Canada. And what country forces the women to wear hijab? Do you even have a passport? I mean bush did until he became president. And you see how ignorance prevailed just from him being the head of America? Only close minded individuals like you would make the comment you did. what does bacon or pork chops have to do with this situation? if you that hungry go to the cooking channel and cook you up something. but refrain from commenting on something that you have NO knowledge of. Muslim have a right to fight for their rights just like how a gay person would do so if they were not hired somewhere or they were fired from a job b/c they were gay. And wore the gay flag colours on their shirt or wherever would FIFA then fire one? It's a war on Islam not terrorism and that is the sad thing history repeats itself, Canada is doing the same thing like Germany did to the communist and set things on fire to start a war. the cure to ignorance is knowledge..so seek some knowledge to understand muslims, or other minorities that you hate.


Matt Assadourian
said
0 0

Just curious, is it that she is wearing something over her head that has religious significance? What if she wore lets say, a baseball cap, would that be allowed? It is important to protect individuals religious freedoms in this country. I don't see how the head scarf is any kind of safety issue, so I don't understand the problem of it.


Daniel in Ottawa
said
0 0

If there are no 'safety' reasons, what other possible reason is there for banning this girl. Racism, nothing else. Seriously, who can deny it? Who cares if she wears a headdress? Why should that bother ANYONE? Don't referees in other sports wear caps? What's the difference? I'll tell you the difference - she's muslim, and muslims aren't very popular in the west these days, and in Quebec. A short while ago, it was a teacher who apparently couldn't allow a muslim to take a class test while wearing a veil. Because of course, as we all know, it's quite impossible to mark a student properly on a language exam if you can't see their face right? That was certainly worthy of trampling on rights. Then I see all the comments posted here about 'follow our rules' and 'this is Canada'. So, I guess in YOUR Canada, we impose arbitrary rules that target only minorities? That's OK right?But why stop there? Maybe we should give muslims their own toilets too, and make them sit at the back of the theatre so we don't have to see a hijab.I say some people need to grow up and learn a little tolerance. That little girl is right to fight this. I hope she wins. She deserves it.


mannybanany
said
0 0

my gawd. so many racist comments. for example, boy said: "Welcome to Canada! You want to stay here, obey our rules. Plain and simple.!.!.!"dean in abyy: So what? This is Canada. Last time I looked, we don't wear those garments. I am not a racist but this is my country. If you come here, be prepared to dress, act, behave like a Canadian and live by OUR values. If you don't want to, then go back where you came from. SHE IS CANADIAN!! and unless either of you are aboriginal, let's not talk about 'who's land this is and which rules/values we should observe.very well said Mark J.!!i understand if it was a safety issue, as it applies to players. but to a ref?? come on now people have an open mind. canada would be a horribly boring country if we all looked the same, talked the same and where as ignorant as some of you.


Peter
said
0 0

She is welcome to wear it in Yemen, Syria, Saudi Arabia, Tunisia, .... Lots of choices.


Tammy
said
0 0

To MartinTO and Carl, it's typical Canadians like you , who don't understand any law in Canada when it comes to human rights. Your very prejudice. And who says that they are not Canadian? How do you know her parents are NOT from here and she converted to Islam? Wow, well as you know history repeats itself. BTW, this is NOT our land/shore it's the native Indians. And since it was robbed from them and they are treated as foreigners with no rights I am not surprised people like you are doing the same to those who may not dress to you satisfaction or whatever. She is fighting for her rights to wear what she wants and NOT to get extra money from the tribunal. This is not her first time reffing she said that it is her second season. So how come NOW they have an issue? Quebec and it's people are always trying to find some way to oppress the muslims there. And then Harper wants to say that we have democracy? They are forcing people to do things that which is yes against their belief or at times that which they don't want. And by the way there are muslim countries that do sell pork as there are chrisitians who live there so please don't speak w/o knowledge. Stay off your tv channels and go travel and learn. Guaranteed neither one of you have been to a Muslim country but your statements are just from watching CNN and the likes. Your parents are NOT from here they immigrated from their country to Canada, so before you want to point fingers and judge look within yourself and see if you would be laid back if you were in her shoes.


Ron J.
said
0 0

Some people say a rule is a rule and should be followed. Tell that to Rosa Parks who refused to give up her seat on the bus to a white passenger. And how is it a "safety issue" when she's a REF. Look at it. It's basically a scarf. The same thing my white grandmother wore on a windy day to keep her hair from getting messed up. No one told my grandmother she couldn't wear it. Leave this girl alone.


Said it in Muskoka
said
0 0

Some people are just insitgators - and she's instigating. This issue just happens to center around the controversy of Muslim's and supposedly religious based garments, unfortunately (this type of garment can be proven to pre-date the actual religion and is more a show of subserviance than the claimed religious status that is commonly associated with it). That being said she openly admitted knowing there were controversies, and if she's as interested in soccer as she claims to be (by becoming a ref) she should have been aware of FIFA's position, and not surprised by the ruling.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said
0 0

As Canadians with unceasing anxiousness to fall all over themselves with the implementation of a politically correct deed, we've already happily and proudly "accommodated" Sikhs, for example, by allowing them to wear a turban as part of their official law enforcement uniform (ie. RCMP, Toronto Police Service, etc.). We gleefully opened the door many moons ago and, now, our goofy attempts to close it on occasion cause me to chuckle and shake my head. Close the door, or, open the door...but, keeping it halfway open/closed is intellectually inconsistent and culturally farcical. Too often Canadians act, and then think later. We deserve this girl's complaint. Our message is mixed, as we foolishly boast about the supposed blessed national glory of multiculturalism, yet, try to attach strings where possible. Nope; sorry.


Lorne
said
0 0

I agree with the decision. Rules are rules and laws are laws. If you can't abide by Canadian law or rules and regulations, too bad!!!!! She obviously got her 10 minutes of fame.


Matt in NB
said
0 0

This is a FIFA international rule that 'while in the pitch no ref shall display religious clothing or symbols.' Why is this so hard for her to understand... oh ya it's not.... "Okay, this is my chance, I am going to fight" she's not trying to be faithfully to her religion she just wants a fight and a cash grab.


island girl
said
0 0

Really? No kidding. If soccer is that important then start up your own league. Maybe pick another hobby. Really. Or find something else to cry about who doesn't have problems more important than yours. Good luck with that.


boy
said
0 0

Welcome to Canada! You want to stay here, obey our rules. Plain and simple.!.!.!


Steve J.
said
0 0

Girls are allowed to wear it when playing soccer here in Calgary. I guess Albertans are far more tolerant to other cultures than the people of Quebec. No surprise there.


Brad
said
0 0

We are so multi- cultural........As a Caucasian 7th generation, I cannot comment or say anything about anyone that may be considered offensive, however every other visible minority can cry foul on my dime! They can Protest, if I went to Queens Park and spoke out I would get arrested. They can tie up our systems, courts, shut down our streets and protests all on our dime Well Canada is it not time to stand up and serve notice? Is it not time to have a voice that heard, not muffled? Is it not time ............Welcome to Canada


Earl of canada
said
0 0

I think the rules are rules with no exception, we live in canada not a muslim state. Canada should and always make a point of the flag, and our religious beliefs not someone elses religous beliefs, they want to change our culture of being canadians, when in rome do what the romans do.


Jenna J.
said
0 0

She is not being oppressed. She chooses to wear it. Women have struggled for years for equal rights and for the right to choose. It seems many of you don't like that this girl chooses to wear it. YOU are the ones actually oppressing her.


Marjorie
said
0 0

I agree w/ Tomas & Carl's comments. I am sick of them trying to change our rules. It all began when they removed the Lords Prayer from schools, and it is not proper to wish " Merry Christmas". I have a very simple solution... If they cannot abide by our rules, go back.


steve
said
0 0

no religion to be mixed in with sports. what is so hard to understand about that. like our religion being removed from school to accomodate all non christians. NO RELIGIOUS SYMBOLS. GET THAT THROUGH YOUR THICK SKULLS.


Mark J.
said
0 0

In 1955, Rosa Parks refused to obey the rule that she give up her seat on the bus to a white passenger. Her act of defiance became an important symbol of the civil rights movement. According to this current news story, it sounds like a lot of posters here wished that Parks had just followed the bussing rule like a good little girl. Shame on you. Let this girl wear it. It looks fine and harms no one.


Paula
said
0 0

Religion is not the problem, its safety when it comes to sports. Especially when it can cause injury. Leave your headdress at home or leave the job. It's all about safety not your religious belief. No one is discriminating against this girl. They are obeying the rules and regulations which clearly state no religious statements on player, coach, referree....


mark
said
0 0

The Hijab is not a religious symbol, like a kirpan is. It's a cultural one. So essentially, this teen doesn't even know her own religion. Good luck with your court battle...


quebec
said
0 0

Quebec is a NOT CANADA! Go back to France and give us back our land!


Dean in Abyy
said
0 0

So what? This is Canada. Last time I looked, we don't wear those garments. I am not a racist but this is my country. If you come here, be prepared to dress, act, behave like a Canadian and live by OUR values. If you don't want to, then go back where you came from. We cannot allow ourselves to be everything to all people. This political correctness crap is destroying our country. Good for Quebec.


CSam
said
0 0

Not sure how this is a controversy? Someone is trying to go against the rules, and they're being told that they are not permitted. So what's the problem? Has there been a team of Muslim's in professional soccer running around with hijabs? I don't think so. And for those stating that Canada shouldn't be so strict. This isn't a Canadian rule...this is a FIFA rule. It just so happens that this teen deliberately went against the rules knowing full well the storm it would generate. Why do people want to change Canada? Millions of people play soccer under this same rule, yet this girl should be the exception? Why?


You can't have it both ways
said
0 0

Why is this discrimination? If I were to take my wife to a predominately muslim country she would have to cover her hair, we could not show affection in public etc to "satisfy" their beliefs not mine...I see this as the same thing...she is in a predominiately non muslim country (at least for the time being) so live by our beliefs and rules and if this does not satisfy your beliefs, move to where you can live your beklief system to the fullest. We can allow opthers to practice their belief system as long as it does not infringe upon mine. I agree with tolerance but not when this tolerance infringes on my belief system. If we say yes to her living her belief system against ours, where does it end? Do we allow polygamists to live their belief system freely? Do we allow for anyone who says it is part of their belief system to live it freely? What about those that believe in sacrificial ceremonies as part of their beliefs...is that OK now too? Think of it, are we just allowing this because this is a clothing issue but killings, and more than one wife now involves stronger morals? slippery slope we are on....


Rion J.
said
0 0

Look at it. It's basically a scarf. The same thing my white grandmother wore on a windy day to keep her hair from getting messed up. No one told my grandmother she couldn't wear it. Leave this girl alone.


moneygrabbers
said
0 0

When these people came over to this country they know there are different rules, so why should those rules not apply to them. This is ridiculous. I am not prejudice at all I have friends from all different cultures but they follow the rules and are not ignorant to the fact that there are different rules here in Canada. GO BACK HOME.....you come here for a better life, the suck it up!


Bob
said
0 0

When these people emmigrate to Canada they should be prepared to accept Western cultural values and leave their old country ideas behind them !They can wear whatever they like when they go to church, but in public they should make an effort to blend in with the rest of us.


SR in ON
said
0 0

"The president of the Quebec Soccer Federation told reporters Tuesday it's simply applying FIFA's international rules..."Just following orders eh? One word... "Nuremburg" look it up.


Christine
said
0 0

Really, people? Let the kid play soccer already! Why does it offend you what she wears on her head? It's not a weapon, sharp or dangerous. Who cares if she wants to wear a top hat for heavens sake! It used to be that when kids went to church and lived thier lives to a religious standard they were respected. I guess this is the "wrong" religion.


Marc
said
0 0

I'm sick and tired of Canadians having to bend over backwards to people from other countries. If they don't like the rules here they can go back to where they came from. It's getting pathetic in this country, having to cater to immigrants.


Chris in Ontario
said
0 0

Carl. The rules of Canada specifically permit freedom of religion. FIFA themselves have stated that it's up to national governing bodies to decide how to interpret FIFA rules so the quebec association claiming they're just following FIFA rules is a cop out.


Anne
said
0 0

The rule was no hijab. Don't like it? Find something else to do. I don't like the hijab (I detest the burqa), this is my country where women are not ruled over by men and imams. And I'd like to keep it that way.


Sinking
said
0 0

Here's an easy solution - what do 15 year old female soccer referees wear in Muslim countries? I just watched a news report on the Egyptian Womens Soccer team - none of the players wore the hajib.


Beth Brouse
said
0 0

Rules are rules...no hijab on the soccer field. Why can the muslims not confirm to laws in Canada. I do not like the words she chose" now is my chance"...sounds like she was just waiting for a chance to make an issue of this to get attention for her culture


A Canadian Canadian
said
0 0

I'll bet her family didn't 'seize the opportunity' to fight for the rights of women NOT to wear hijabs in whatever dysfunctional religious state they ran away from. Good on the soccer association! The girl needs to learn that religion does not dominate the lives of Canadians and thats why people move here.


Amber in Ontario
said
0 0

I think this decision should be reconsidered. While I understand the safety issues and do support players not wearing religious symbols, I think that perhaps the hijab should be an exception. This is not as extreme as a burqa and does not cover her face, and appears in this image to be safely tucked into her uniform. Also, This is not something the girls can take off therefore to ban the scarf means to ban every girl within that religious group from playing the sport which is unfair. Secondly I am really disappointed that they allowed her to play and ref up UNTIL one person filed a complaint. Is that what this country is coming to??? One person complains and then others lives and activities are impacted? Have some common sense not to mention some social justice here. p.s. to the commentator above - just because she's Muslim does not mean that she or her family were not born and raised here in the cultural mosaic of Canada. Open your mind a little.


Sherry
said
0 0

Look - if it were only one religion - but if NO religions can be shown then sorry - the Hajib does not take priority over all others. If a Sikh or a Christian or a Jewish person cannot show their religion - than neither can a Muslim. Fair is fair - it doesn't say she cannot do it - just that like all the other religions, she cannot show hers either. Why would we make one special over the others - to not "hurt their feelings" please....


RK
said
0 0

Hmmm… and during the gulf war a U.S service woman was beaten in Saudi Arabia by the religious police for wearing shorts while jogging. Who is the more ignorant? As the saying goes, when in Rome, do as the Romans. The agenda is not tolerance; it is to impose another set of beliefs. We need to follow Frances lead, and ban these head coverings completely.


Sam C
said
0 0

"If they dont really dont like the rules of Canada , then by all means Leave." Keeping in mind, of course, that we are all descended from immigrants who came to this country seeking freedom and acceptance. Intolerance is ugly.


jeff from Byron
said
0 0

These muslim countries are the least tolerant on the globe in regards to western culture, yet once these families they leave their native countries to join the greatest country on earth they feel offended that we wont show complete tolerance to every whim they demand....there must be a line..or sooner than later...at the reproduction rate of the muslim population Canada will look more like the middle east then it already does...Please make this stop........please


Paul
said
0 0

If you watch soccer world wide I have NEVER seen a player with a jihad or turban, so why should Canada allows it. No is no, welcome to your new country, we have rules here too.


Kevin
said
0 0

Whether it's this, or wanting to cover your face for a photo ID, or dictate that un-Islamic movies not be shown in theaters (as in some neighbourhoods of Rotterdam, I hear) you have to accept that here the rules are made by the majority, not a tiny but noisy minority. If not being allowed to be exempt from rules everyone else has to abide by means you're being persecuted, well at least it's not like being beheaded.


Gisabun
said
0 0

Wearing one to referee a game shouldn't be an issue. Wearing one while playing is an issue.


Congratulations CARL
said
0 0

You are a bigot. This is Canada. People here have the freedom to express their religious beliefs as they see fit. This isn't about denying rights to people based on what some bigot perceives would be denied to Canadians abroad. I shudder to think what people like you are like when they travel. "Mexico was nice but it was full of foreigners speaking Spanish." I'm actually embarrassed that this kind of nonsense goes on in Canada. We're known internationally as tolerant people who allow people here a great deal of freedom. It seems this born and raised in Canada teen is automatically deemed a subversive foreigner by every bigoted mushroom head in Canada simply because her parents raised her in Islam. Disgusting. CARL, I'm embarrassed for you. I'm embarrassed for all of Canada. Muslims have been in Canada since before Confederation as have Jews and Hindu's and Sikh's and Christians. It's time to stop pretending Canada is a Christian only country club. It's not. People like you make me gag.


howie
said
0 0

It's time that people start speaking out about this issue . . These people want the best of two worlds keep their own and also have ours. we are being too politically correct and it's time to start saying what we really think. If politicians said what they were really thinking about these issues they would be very popular amongst Canadian voters. `


chris
said
0 0

These rules are governed by FIFA not local canadian soccer associations. So if you want to complain, take it up with FIFA.


Laser
said
0 0

One way ticket !


GB
said
0 0

I don't know why Muslims always think we have to 'accomodate' them. They need a wake up call to remind them, they 'chose' to live in this country...then abide by this country's rules and laws. Imagine if I went to Saudi Arabia and demanded that I wanted to wear my cross openly on a soccer field....i would probably be stoned to death under Sharia law for offending Mohammed.


Tim
said
0 0

Ugh. This again? The soccer association (last I heard) lost the fight to stop a player from wearing the hijab while playing soccer, what makes them think they'll win when they don't even have the "safety concern" argument.


Vikkilo
said
0 0

Welcome to Canada! If Seiks can wear daggars to school, why can't this girl wear a headdress??


Christine
said
0 0

You know, I used to be proud that Canada was a nation that allowed people to express thier personal beliefs and still be Canadians. I don't know anymore. Here is a young woman who is active, responsible, involved in extracurricular activities and staying out of trouble. Soccer is not a contact sport and to not allow her to referee is ridiculous. Can't they judge theses things on a case by case basis? We should be encouraging young people like her, not preventing her from particitpating.


Tomas
said
0 0

Some groups will always have an agenda. This girl should not have been allowed to begin reffing until/unless she understood the rules. Simple. No Hijab on the Pitch.


MarkinTO
said
0 0

the key part of the story was when she said "this was her chance", don't be fooled, she's not wearing the hijab for any religious purposes. This is her chance to win some easy money from the human rights courts. This is her chance to change some part of Canadian law that has been around well before her and her family ever arrived on our shores. If this were any other person/group, the person would conform to the rules, but not muslims, no, they will never conform to our ways.


CARL
said
0 0

If a Canadian was in a muslim country , it would be next to impossible to find a restaurant that serves bacon or pork chops. & Foreign women over there HAVE to wear a hijab. Muslim countries are far less accomodating than western nations , & the "princess" in this story knows that.If they dont really dont like the rules of Canada , then by all means Leave.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt appears on CTV's Power Play on Monday, May 28, 2012.

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    12 Video(s) 12

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1