Top Stories -   

1
Interim auditor general John Wiersema holds a news conference on the report tabled in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Thursday June 9, 2011. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS) RCMP generic

RCMP struggles to provide services amid funding shortfalls

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News Channel: Auditor General John Wiersema
Interim auditor general John Wiersema discusses findings on RCMP services in his spring report. Wiersema says it has made unsatisfactory progress in addressing longstanding issues.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (35) Facebook   

Interim auditor general John Wiersema holds a news conference on the report tabled in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Thursday June 9, 2011. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS) RCMP generic

Photos

Interim auditor general John Wiersema holds a news conference on the report tabled in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Thursday June 9, 2011. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

Selected Comment

Interesting comments to say the least. For those who accuse Harper of dismantling the RCMP have to think again, all this is doing is giving the government an opportunity to restructure it into a fully functional and highly specialized federal law enforcement apparatus similar to the FBI or the DEA, in fact it has already started with the creation of the CBSA.

Jughead

RCMP struggles to provide services amid funding shortfalls

talking about
RCMP struggles to provide services amid funding shortfalls

Date: Thu. Jun. 9 2011 6:52 PM ET

OTTAWA — Delays in updating vital criminal record information have increased significantly because of mismanagement and funding shortfalls for national police services, says the federal spending watchdog.

In a report tabled Thursday, interim auditor general John Wiersema said the RCMP -- which administers a slate of crucial police services -- was scrambling to find enough money to keep them afloat.

Wiersema's audit focused on four areas: forensic laboratory services, the national DNA data bank, the federal criminal intelligence service, and a computerized system for running fingerprint and criminal record checks.

Despite a commitment to do so, the RCMP has not taken satisfactory steps to act on recommendations to improve police services in three previous audit reports dating from 2000, Wiersema concluded.

"We are concerned with the lack of progress in this area," he said in a statement. "The federal government, working with provincial, territorial and municipal partners, needs to decide which police services should be provided and how they should be delivered and funded."

Backlogs and delays in updating criminal record information had increased to 14 months for English updates and to 36 months for French updates from five months in 2000, he found.

Overall, the outstanding criminal record update backlog had jumped to 1.4 million from 186,000 in 2005-06.

In addition, technological updates to key national information systems have been delayed.

To make ends meet, the RCMP has trimmed some programs to help fund the national police services.

The shuffling increased available monies for the services but other RCMP programs, mainly federal policing, were cut back. In particular, the RCMP's federal international operations directorate -- which has responsibility for organized crime probes, border integrity, drug enforcement and money laundering -- had to slash its budget by almost $48 million, or eight per cent, in the last fiscal year.

"The RCMP finds that it is becoming increasingly difficult to continue funding the rising costs of providing national police services through internal reallocation," the report says.

The RCMP and the Public Safety Department, which oversees the police force, agreed with the auditor's recommendations.

The forensic laboratory services do biology casework and toxicology tests, examine trace evidence, identify fingerprints, and analyze firearms and ballistics samples. These services -- popularized by television shows such as the various Crime Scene Investigation (CSI) series -- have become more important for zeroing in on criminals as well as exonerating innocent people.

The Conservative government has launched a wide-ranging review of the RCMP's long-troubled DNA labs and other forensic services, opening the door to possible private-sector delivery.

Last year the Public Safety Department began seeking advice -- including a look at how things are done in other countries -- to help determine the best way forward in Canada.

However, Wiersema urged the government to look at all national police services to determine whether there are better, more cost-effective ways of doing things.

The government said an overall study of the 12 national services administered by the RCMP -- from the forensic labs to a national sex offenders registry -- would be completed by the end of next March.

Comments are now closed for this story

Jughead
said
0 0

Interesting comments to say the least. For those who accuse Harper of dismantling the RCMP have to think again, all this is doing is giving the government an opportunity to restructure it into a fully functional and highly specialized federal law enforcement apparatus similar to the FBI or the DEA, in fact it has already started with the creation of the CBSA.


Peter in MB
said
0 0

What does the RCMP expect when they waste time and money on a useless gun registry that only affects law abiding citizens and not the criminals? Also some of the tactical units are better armed and equipped then our militarily solders in Afghanistan. Why do cops need these fancy expensive military gadgets to stop burglars?


Calvin in SK
said
0 0

OK Get Real....tell all of us people with criminal records, which agency created, recommended (demanded), then spent the G8/G20 budget???? Come on tell us???? Oh it was the RCMP???


Eh Canadian Citizen
said
0 0

Hey Steve (Brian Mulroney ) Harper! Why do you hate the RCMP so intensely? Your propaganda to dismantle and disarm the once proud organization is working. Politician, the likes of the Conservatives have had a history of run ins with the police. You have ever so smartly turned most of the media and part of the public against a peace loving organization. Well done, for now. The next four years will show your corrupt purpose. Mr. Elliott continues to be one of your boys who cannot run the national police force. Brother Brian must be proud of ya. Just think if he had dismembered the RCMP as well as you have he never would have been investigated and exposed. Regimes manipulate the press and police, sadly you are headed in that direction.


Ken
said
0 0

Hey Get Real...you expect us to believe the RCMP foots the bill for "special events" like you mention Get serious!!! I was born in the dark, but not last night..


I have an idea.
said
0 0

Stop spending billions in Afghanistan, stop giving foreign aide to dictators in the hopes they will play nice, stop flushing money down the toilet in places like Haiti. We need a strong federal police presence to keep Mexican drug cartels and other foreign and domestic organized crime at bay. Canadians are notoriously cheap when it comes to paying for anything yet we gladly squander tens of billions in foreign countries on people who can't spell Canada or know where it is on a map. Maybe, just maybe, if the federal police service of this country is telling us they need more money or risk turning the country into war zone, we should close our mouths and listen instead of spewing forth with the typical cheapness rhetoric.


Get Real
said
0 0

To all bozos slamming the RCMP: No more money, no more services!!! The RCMP's salaries (increment) has been frozen fro three years, they have to foot the bill on Special events such as the G8 and G20, Harper does not give a surplus to the RCMP, cuts need to be made to fund security for major events. Before slamming a job lots of us would not dare do but can easily criticize, research what ever you are posting..


GO CANUCKS GO !
said
0 0

Everytime an article comes out about the RCMP, I am amazed how many people start the bashing. I'll bet the vast majority of the bashers have criminal records (because of their own stupidity) and now hate the police. Unless you walk a mile in their shoes...


Ken in SK
said
0 0

Hope you guys are getting the messaage!!! The people you serve have had enought of your waste. Do more with less. Prove to us you can!


Chris in Ottawa
said
0 0

Well done, Mr. Harper. That whole tough on crime plan really, really falls short (and looks more like just words than actions) if you don't properly fund your police forces, now, doesn't it.


DaveB
said
0 0

Archie: you may want to loosen up the chin strap on your tin foil hat. When it's too tight it restricts the circulation to the brain and you end up halluciating about plots to create private police forces.


Arby
said
0 0

66 million a year transferred by ending the useless long gun registry would help offset costs.A wage roll back would help as well.


The Big Cee
said
0 0

Legalize pot. Think of all the time and money that would free up! After 15 years of researching the issue I've concluded that the law against the use of marijuana is the most costly single issue funded by any government, anywhere, ever. As a conservative I've always grated against that expenditure, the biggest waste of money in history!


Julian
said
0 0

Oh great. You all know what this means.
Higher ticket quotas and more brilliant ideas like green light cameras.

Let the gouging begin.


Paul ~ Kitchener
said
0 0

Why is it, that every Police Department in this nation, always cry of "Shortage of Funds". There are no more funds gentlemen. Look inside your forces, & make whatever cuts are necessary, to balance the finanancial budget of your force. The rest of us are taxed to death while the Police salaries and benefits climb plus acquire more into the force. Our Federal Government is going to look at all Departments and reduce from 2 - 5% each year for the next 4 years. This may come as a schock to the Police and others "THEIR IS NO MORE MONEY FOR YOU" . I would recommend to the Commissioner of the R.C.M.P. to clean up the problems within the force first & then look to saving every dollar from every department within the group that they can ~ their is room to save a lot. Good Luck but, "NO MORE BUCKS" !


J.C.
said
0 0

Why do they have to do both English and French updates? There are computer programs that can convert language so I don't see the need for them to enter both. I am not so keen on having DNA etc. done by private companies either, unless they set up their shop inside the police labs, and use proper security methods etc. Maybe part of the problem is an overuse of formfilling etc. I am sure if they scrutinize carefully they will find there are many ways they could run far more efficiently and cost effectively. As far as comparing them to private security companies there is no comparison. Many security personnel work for minimum or slightly more than minimum wage, and very rarely have any benefits or pensions etc. Many also do not get a lunch time etc as they eat on the go or when they can and seldom have a backup for safety either. Nor do they carry weapons in this country. Their powers are limited to the property they are assigned to and the client's requirements.


Bill in AB
said
0 0

Perhaps if they are not able to manage their own budget maybe it is high time the government put someone in there who can do it for them! I for one am tired of police agencies crying not enough money in budget yet they approve all expenditures. Lets start showing some agressive leadership and work within existing budget for a change.


spaz
said
0 0

Once the government gets back to business the long gun registry will be one of the first to die a long overdue death.How would a couple of billions help the bottom line ????.....there is nothing that stops a criminal faster than that piece of paper in his wallet that says he has a gun......all locked up at home.......OH WAIT A MINUTE.......criminals do not register their guns


robin hood
said
0 0

Backlogs; missing paperwork; police policing police; disrespect of parliament; government takes no question on accountability; changing rules as they go along; photo ops; too many homeless; first nation atrocities; wars, rumours of war; company cutbacks; insane corporate profit margins; increase of deadly force on streets; controversy over action; captive majority of Canadian minds turned to mush parroting one another while our rights get flushed. Help!


just wondering
said
0 0

How much money would be saved if they stopped"suspending the officer with pay" until the investigations of wrong doing are completed? And the swept under the carpet of course.


Archie
said
0 0

Here we go. The privateering has commenced under the Harper government. For those readers unaware of privateering it can be summed up as: "a special case of privatization in which the capacity of government to carry out critical moral missions (in this case: protection of the citizens) is systematically destroyed from within the government itself, while public funds are used to provide the capital for private corporations to take over those critical functions of government and charge the public a great deal for doing so, while avoiding all accountability". Privateering is a ploy used by small c conservative governments such as the Bush administration in the U.S. and is a threat to democracy. The U.S. used privateering in the military and created a massive private army called Blackwater.The first step in privateering the RCMP was the G8/G20 summits when the Harper government misused the police in a manner that would alter public opinion against police in general by making them look like oppressors thereby turning the public against the police to make it easier for the public to accept the demise of their services. What the RCMP could lose, the taxpayer will ultimately pay more for via the private sector.


Allan K, Vancouver, BC
said
0 0

RE the argument for downloading responsibilities... I'm not sure how well that will work. Surrey, BC investigated somewhat recently about getting their own police department but decided to stay with the old one after finding out it cost less to do so. Maybe the RCMP can hike up the rates a little for local policing but that hike may cut into the cities' money supplies that could be used in libraries, transport, parks and rec, water, etc. and also neglects the fact that some areas are just too rural to get completely cost-efficient policing. I guess maybe in those areas we can gather like volunteer patrol officers akin to volunteer firemen, but I'm not sure how fast the response would be.... Anyway, I agree that some sort of reform may be necessary to trim the budget of the RCMP (or maybe even a simple extra funding injection will do) but at the same time we should ensure that the alternatives of downloading responsibilities or relying on the private sector do not lead to unintended side-effects like profiteering, budget deficits, extra bureaucracy, etc.


Chris in Campbelton NB
said
0 0

Police? Oh.. those are the guys that are always sitting at Tim Hortons instead of actually doing some work. Unfortunately, it would be 10 times easier to rob a bank than it would be to rob a Tim Hortons.Therefore, when they actually DO work, then they pull old ladys over and give them tickets because they have to keep their quota up. In the meantime, REAL CRIME flourishes.


Trevor in the Hat
said
0 0

@ Jeremy I find it difficult to believe they are doing it for free on their own time. The local police here charge MADD (Mothers Against Driving Drunk) overtime wages for the local police to do checkstops on their time off.


BobFar
said
0 0

Blah blah blah blah blah - maybe fewer bullets fewer tasers -? Are we then safer?


Dorian
said
0 0

Police need to better prioritize their time and resources. Have the 911 call takers better screen non emergency calls so that the police are not required to attend every pocket dial from a cell, suspicious persons, alarms without permits and pr's. The amount of driving around for menial crap is a waste of resources in the extreme. The public needs to not call the police unless of EMERGENCY!


Ray, Mississauga
said
0 0

How much of the spending is a consequence of unnecessary legislation such as the "war on drugs"? How much of the spending is a consequence of crime-fighting and how much is a consequence of toadying to bureaucrats and politicians? If our "public" law enforcement people are doing such a good job, why is private security such a large and growing business? Could it have something to do with private security being focussed and public security being . . .?


Jack in Ottawa
said
0 0

Seems there is no money in the world to do anything. The problem is greed on the parts of union and corporation CEO's and their corporate office worker types. They make huge amounts of money, drive expensive cars and get a new one a the drop of a hat. Then there are the poeple who work for the company and make the corporate types rich, but can't afford to live, eat, pay rent and drive old cars because there is no money to buy a new one.I am by no means a socialist or communist, but there is something wrong when corporations who make millions of dollars a year profit have CEO's making hundreds of thaousands of dollars, or more, a year but the people working for the company don't make enought to live. I bet if the purchace price of everything, and I mean absolutly everything, in the world was dropped by 30% everybody would be rich. Even the CEO's and corprate cronies would still be able to drive nice cars, but might have to keep it an extra month or two befor buying a newer one or another one.


weyoutwest
said
0 0

Perhaps we should buy a couple more ( Cadilac ) stealth fighters with no engines, so we can take part in another war someplace on the other side of the ocean. Or perhaps we could provide proper funding for our national police force, infrastructure, universal medicare, eliminate a defiect etc. etc. etc!!!! You gave them a majority folks, now you are going to get know them. Most of you wil be denying you ever voted Conservative 4 years from now, .....enjoy!!


Jeremy
said
0 0

Actually Jonathon, mounties at those sporting events are there on their own time and are not collecting any form of overtime.


Bill in AB
said
0 0

@Bulldog you are not wrong! cost of policing at the local level is very very high.......If we had pure provincial policing the costs would be much lower. The RCMP love this though, as it bring in lots of "extra" money so they do not want to loose this part of the job. It keeps their numbers up when the seek funding for their annual budget RCMP should be Federal only.....


K in Canada
said
0 0

Not sure if the RCMP are the same way, but here if sporting events and other types of events want uniformed city police at their events, they do cover the costs to have them there. They are normally on days off and the events pays their wages in overtime. That way it does not interfier with normal policing in the city.


Mike
said
0 0

Canada Post has lots of money they can give them some


jonathan
said
0 0

If the RCMP is so short on money, how can they afford to have a Mountie or three standing at every sport or political event, to provide a nice photo op for some politician or celebrity. Is the RCMP able to bill this time to the event organizers?


Bulldog
said
0 0

It seems the time is right to restructure and reorganize the RCMP into strictly a federal policing role. The cost for the mounties to operate at all three levels of enforcement Federal, Provincial, Local, must be high. Maybe it would be more cost efficient to have the RCMP mirror the FBI and let the provinces look after the responsibilities of Provincial and Local law enforcement. Just a thought, I could be completely wrong.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Top Stories

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt appears on CTV's Power Play on Monday, May 28, 2012.

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    11 Video(s) 11

Dominic and Abby Maryk were found in Mexico four years after allegedly being abducted by their father.

Extradition sought in Winnipeg missing children case

More   4 Comments 4    3 Video(s) 3

Protesters opposing Quebec student tuition fee hikes demonstrate in Montreal, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (Graham Hughes / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Quebec, students resume talks on tuition hikes

More   26 Comments 26    1 Video(s) 1